4 ms·
Of course it is unusual. But no less unusual than building a successful company to begin with. What's normal is failure.
by jacquesm 3y ago
Of course it is unusual. But no less unusual than building a successful company to begin with. What's normal is failure.
- adventured 3y agoFailure is definitely the commonality. The BLS reports typically that 1/2 of all new businesses (in the US) will formally fail within five years. One can safely guess that at least half of those remaining are something between zombies and hanging on by a thread. 1/4 or fewer will make it 15 years or more. And of course it varies by sector, restaurants notoriously have an exceptionally high failure rate. For all businesses the failure rate is around one in five in the first year [0]; for restaurants the failure rate is ~60% in the first year, and ~80% fail within five years. [0] And again, don't forget to assume the figures are even higher because the figures will never fully account for zombie businesses or quasi-zombies and the equivalent.
- Joeri 3y agoI’m wondering about the failure rate for technology companies. It may be higher or lower than restaurants, I have no intuitions.
- fbdab103 3y agoThere is somewhat fuzzy on where you even draw the line. Does someone moonlighting on their Wordpress side hustle count as a company? There are many of those which seem unlikely go bankrupt - the most frequent end state is the sole proprietor quits due to lack of work or interest.
- timparsa 3y ago90%+ for "tech startups," although it's very hard to find data that sorts through all the startups and separates them into tech and non-tech startups. Good source is https://www.failory.com/blog/y-combinator-failures#:~:text=Out%20of%20these%2C%20there%20are,to%20have%20shut%20down%20already https://www.failory.com/blog/y-combinator-failures#:~:text=O....
- marcosdumay 3y agoThose figures also do not account for selling all of the company's property with some profit and closing it down; the equivalent of an acquihire for small and medium companies is counted as failure. Running it successfully for a couple of years and changing your mind is counted as a failure too. I don't have a link on hand, but I've seen studies from people that counted how many business actually closed due to money problems. The actual rate of non-problem business after 5 years is close to 80%.
- jacquesm 3y agoI would expect it to be close to 100%. The difference between the 80% and the 100% is the ones that grow in spite of and sometimes because of their problems. Every business will run into trouble, sooner or later. In fact I don't recall a year in the past decade without some kind of crisis that needed fixing. Some self inflicted, some just circumstance and some outside malice. Never a dull moment if you run a small company.
- DeathArrow 3y ago>Every business will run into trouble, sooner or later. Even large businesses that have comfortable cushions and safety nets?
- jacquesm 3y agoYes. But they are better positioned to deal with it and will likely survive. But even the IBMs, HPs and Boeings of this world are not immune.
- Alex3917 3y ago> But no less unusual than building a successful company to begin with. Statistically, companies that raise venture capital are vastly less likely to succeed than those that are bootstrapped. Think about it this way: from the perspective of VCs, the most successful apps of the iOS era were Uber and AirBnB. But from the perspective of entrepreneurs, the most successful app of the iOS era was the Flashlight app. Which one do you think was easier to build?
- tptacek 3y agoI sort of don't doubt that VC-funded companies are less likely to succeed than bootstrapped companies, simply because bootstrapped companies can keep afloat with consulting and VC-funded companies can't. But vastly lower odds of product success sounds like something that'll need a citation. It seems likely that VC-funded app store pure plays without a recurring revenue SAAS component are much less likely to succeed than indie app store pure plays, but that's because VC is obviously the wrong model for one-and-done app store transactions. If you have a good idea for an app, don't raise for it (you'll have a hard time raising for it anyways).
- Alex3917 3y agoIIRC each time you raise a round, your chances of success go down by ~10x. Can't find a good cite offhand though.
- jacquesm 3y agoOnce you're in the VC cycle though not being able to raise another round when you need it is a 100% decrease in your chance of success. So I'm not sure if that follows for any but the first. Essentially you need to keep raising until you either reach profitability at scale, are acquired or IPO, and even the latter won't help you if you aren't eventually profitable.
- tptacek 3y agoEvery time you raise a round, the outcome you're shooting for is magnified. If you're raising an A round, you're not getting acquired after your seed; you're rolling the dice on getting a much better outcome. If you're raising a B round, you've got some facsimile of product-market fit, and you've decided to take the company to the point where the only "successful" outcomes are denominated in hundreds of millions of dollars, etc. So it's not surprising that there's a stat somewhere that says "committing to a 500MM sale decreases your odds of success over satisficing with a 50MM sale", right? Very few software companies of any provenance end up going public, but by the time you're raising a C, that's essentially what you're saying you're going to do.
- marcosdumay 3y agoSure, most initiatives fail. But successful ones are not so rare that you don't expect to see one. If you go all the way until you realistically start a company, you are more likely to succeed than to fail.