4 ms·
Bluesky: Building a Social Internet
- ggm 3y agoI've seen a line of reasoning here (hn) that threads has stolen mindshare and impetus, and bluesky will be seen as "reactive" rather than innovative respective of planned intent and outcome. Basically, marketing not technology will win. That, and instant signing on by uplift of the existing meta user base. Google+ lost out on drive and will to live. It was a nice experience. Nice guys, came second in the race. They lost impetus, and they lost c* backing. Bluesky at least won't have that problem, it's the core product not a nice-to-have.
- paulgb 3y agoAs I see it there are really two twitters: consumption twitter and conversation twitter. Consumption twitter is where people go to follow celebrities, athletes, news publications, brands, etc. Most twitter users don’t post, they belong to consumption twitter. Then there’s conversation twitter. It’s smaller but it was there from the beginning, even before the celebrities showed up in force. It seems to me that Threads will capture the consumption twitter market. I’m far from convinced that Threads will capture the conversation twitter market. So far, Bluesky feels to me the most like early twitter, community-wise.
- threeseed 3y ago> I’m far from convinced that Threads will capture the conversation twitter It really depends on what you're discussing and the tone you're looking for. Threads is already discouraging the type of brawling, political discussions you get on Twitter. But it's amazing if you're wanting to talk about entertainment, photography, sports etc as the tone is more fun and positive courtesy of all of the Instagram people and the assertive moderation.
- whyenot 3y ago> marketing not technology will win As it should. No matter how amazing the technology may be, a social network that almost nobody uses is a dud. IMO every day that Bsky stays in private beta it is losing more potential users. Marketing is more important than tech. Look at Threads, there is nothing particularly revolutionary about it’s tech, but in large part thanks to marketing and seeding the platform with well known users, it appears to be off to a great start.
- jitl 3y agoG+ felt pretty dead and lifeless when I joined during beta. It’s major innovation was “circles” - tools to share to a smaller percentage of your contacts. Bluesky does not feel dead or lifeless, it’s much more lively than Mastodon because it isn’t fragmented by default, and the user-designed feed algorithms are a cool way to discover new conversations.
- unmole 3y agoFor a brief period around 2012/2013, G+ was awesome. It was the best way of following people who shared your interests. If Facebook was for keeping in touch with people you went to highschool with, G+ was for keeping in touch with people you wished you went to highschool with.
- explorigin 3y ago> What all these technologies had in common is they allowed people to freely interact and create content, without a single intermediary. > Sign up for the Bluesky private beta. Anyone else see the irony here?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Confiks 3y agoThe wording could have been better (and the whole private beta thing as well). For what it's worth, the protocol and data model is open and designed for redistribution [1], and the event stream of messages is freely available without login [2]. It's quite similar to Secure Scuttlebutt (which has the most beautiful protocol guide itself [3]) including the disadvantages that come with radical publication – for example described in this 2018 pre-LLM Facebook v. Cambridge Analytica-era comment [4]. [1] https://atproto.com/specs/data-model https://atproto.com/specs/data-model [2] https://firesky.tv/ https://firesky.tv/ [3] https://ssbc.github.io/scuttlebutt-protocol-guide https://ssbc.github.io/scuttlebutt-protocol-guide [4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16877892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16877892
- unshavedyak 3y agoWell damn, that kinda interests me now. As i sit here and develop an app for ActivityPub.. i'm kinda puzzled at how ATP feels like it fell so far behind. Is there any hope for it now i wonder?
- enumjorge 3y agoI thought maybe they had opened up account creation, but it’s still behind a waitlist. I put my name down several weeks ago. Unless I missed the invite, they seem to be stingy about giving them out. If this is still mostly unavailable to the public why post it on HN again?
- pelagic_sky 3y agoBluesky is dead in the water. There was a point where people were talking about it and wanted in. No one (in my social sphere) is talking about it anymore. I even mentioned it at work (FAANG) the other day and most people haven’t even heard of it. I’d love for it to be a thing. But history dictates they missed the opportunity.
- paulgb 3y agoI’ve worked at two FAANGs and while I respect my former colleagues, I wouldn’t consider them harbingers of what’s cool.
- dleeftink 3y agoIf you/we/other folk want it to be a thing, shouldn't we at least try to not frame it as a 'dead in the water' piece of tech? Seeing how HN has a way of planting seeds in the minds of potential early adoptors, framing it as DOA may be the self-fulfilling prophecy we want to avoid if we want changes to unfold within our heavily centralised social media sphere.
- jsnell 3y agoMost people on HN don't have any vested interest in the success or failure of BlueSky. That's a good thing. It means we can actually give our honest opinions rather than equivocate in order to prop up a dead project in a kind of virtual recreation of Weekend at Bernie's. Honestly, even without Threads I would not bet on BlueSky to be the winner in this space or even to be viable. The team got really lucky having the right product at the right time, and failed completely to capitalize on it. Or actually worse, they seemed to not even try to capitalize on it. Even trying and failing would have been bette.r
- azakai 3y agoMy experience is exactly the opposite. Most of my social sphere has already moved to Bluesky. Also most of the top posters I used to follow on Twitter have either migrated or post on both. As a result I've been spending more time on Bluesky than Twitter recently. It's the future. But you are right that while it remains invite-only it is limited. The real test will happen when they open the floodgates.
- lexandstuff 3y agoI cannot believe that Bluesky still hasn't opened its doors. There was a huge window of opportunity for them that now seems firmly shut.
- unshavedyak 3y agoWhat’s the draw to BlueSky? I don’t get it. Just based on their invite behavior it feels very walled garden, so I focus on ActivityPub. Am I missing something?
- lexandstuff 3y agoLet's be honest: the draw was that it was Twitter minus Elon and the blue-check lunatics. Now Threads is that. Everyone I enjoyed following on Twitter is on Threads, so I don't need Twitter, and I certainly don't need Bluesky.
- maxverse 3y agoMost techy people I know are holding out for an invite code. I'd like to think Bluesky is trying to do it right and thinking in the long term.
- lexandstuff 3y agoI was holding out for an invite code. I wanted one because everyone I enjoyed following on Twitter was on Bluesky, singing its praise. Now they're all on Threads, so I'm no longer interested in the invite code.
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoThink of it as an opportunity to have dodged the eternal September that's moving over to Threads right now. There's nothing wrong with a soft launch and there's nothing wrong with a community growing deliberately rather than for the sake of growing, and suffering the inevitable watering down that follows.
- 3y ago
- COGlory 3y agoHas Bluesky addressed why not ActivityPub?
- Confiks 3y agohttps://atproto.com/guides/faq#why-not-use-activitypub https://atproto.com/guides/faq#why-not-use-activitypub
- unshavedyak 3y agoMan, I might get behind that if it felt more open. Instead I have to compare it to the thriving ecosystem on ActivityPub and I just don’t have interest in developing on ATP.
- housemusicfan 3y agoGetting people to come over to BlueSky is like trying to convince your normie friends to switch to Linux because it's built on software freedom. It isn't going to happen.
- soneca 3y agoThat is Mastodon for me. I saw a lot of people out of my tech bubble asking about and interested in joining BlueSky. Only that no one around me have invites. I signed to the waitlist the first I saw them on HN, still nothing.
- zhte415 3y agoCount me out of yet another cool clique where invites from friends get you a foot in the door of a social popularity pageant. And tracking, of course, we must know who knows who. Insepid, undemocratic, uninclusive. Deeply unsocial.
- soneca 3y agoI understand the sentiment, and I might be naive, but I really do think the restriction is due to technical reasons. It is a purposefully slow go to market plan because the engineering team is small, the tech new, and they are not ready to serve millions of users. It doesn’t look at all as something like Clubhouse was (which was exactly what you described). Some evidence is that a few people that I follow that got in say it looks empty (not “cool” or with everyone “that matters”), also the idea of customizable feed algorithm doesn’t align with the popularity contest strategy. And the rumors that Bluesky was having technical troubles after Twitter rate-limited users due to the high load.
- drewg123 3y agoEven my normie friends were begging for invite codes the last I checked. That might have died down since Threads launched though.
- jaylittle 3y agoI got three BlueSky invite codes, in case anybody wants em: Edit: All gone, thanks for playing!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mvkel 3y agoIf anyone has an invite, I'd love one!
- tapoxi 3y agoIf Threads follows through and implements ActivityPub, ATProto is dead in the water. ATProto may be superior in some ways (namely account portability) but ActivityPub is "good enough" and there's already a bunch of applications using it in a distributed fashion.
- threeseed 3y agoThey have the "threads.net" profile badge which suggests ActivityPub is definitely coming. Also I suspect it's a high priority for Meta as it blunts any anti-competitive attack from regulators. Complying with open, interoperable standards is usually far more important than whether or not you're a monopoly. And the EU in particular already has the mechanism to demand these companies comply. BlueSky could end up making a huge mistake by not adopting ActivityPub.
- tapoxi 3y agoI think you're right. It bypasses regulators and realistically it's going to capture the majority share of the fediverse anyway because it removes the complexity of picking a Mastodon instance.
- loteck 3y agoI wonder what the demographics of Bluesky are under their longish term strategy of invite-only, and I wonder what it says about the future of digital society. Given the history of invite-only societies, one or two particular outcomes seems highly likely. Is this the future of social?
- pessimizer 3y agoI hope so. We need more spaces where we can speak in private rather than more places where we can speak in public. Plenty of people are making a living from being public, though, so they will always need a public communication outlet. But maybe celebrities have been scared off by getting constantly cancelled and attacked, and would prefer that most people get news about them second-hand, through friendly intermediaries.
- ramesh31 3y ago(Invite only)
- pfist 3y agoI understand and even applaud their decision to grow carefully and deliberately. At the same time, I have been on the waitlist for a year or so and I am eager to try it out. Of all the Twitter competitors, I find Bluesky the most intriguing. I love the idea of managing my own feeds and connecting my own domain. There is a sense of control and privacy that I find appealing. It remains to be seen if Bluesky can deliver on its vision, but I look forward to experiencing it for myself.
- AustinDev 3y agoA year long waitlist is equivalent to dead in the water imo. They'll never win.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- romusha 3y agoBluesky: Building a failed app!
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoStep1: Generate some buzz, then don’t let people in.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoSomething new here?
- agentgumshoe 3y agoI think it's interesting that we expect each new social app to be 'the next big thing' and a failure if not replacing Twitter/Insta/Threads/Whatever by tomorrow. If they get decent user growth and remain profitable, having the right features and usability will make them a more appealing option as time goes on. It doesn't need to be overnight unless it's funded by VC cash that demands it be so... Personally, I don't want another Twitter. I'd be more than happy for Reddit to sort it's stupidity out and good old forums to continue to provide organised hangouts for interest groups.