3 ms·
Good question! We actually asked Apple exactly this when appealing the AppStore de-listing. How come others can require an account and we can't? What was it abo
by ryandrake 3y ago
Good question! We actually asked Apple exactly this when appealing the AppStore de-listing. How come others can require an account and we can't? What was it about our app that made us have to spend the engineering effort to add a guest login (this was a disingenuous argument that I advised against, since we deliberately spent engineering effort to require the login)?
Their response, not the exact wording since it was over a decade ago, was along the lines of: "1. We're reviewing your app, not theirs, so what they can do is irrelevant. 2. Your app core use case clearly functions without an account as evidenced by the previous versions having full functionality not requiring an account."
1. Is a standard Apple reply when you compare your app's treatment to others'. Everyone gets this when they bring another developer's app into the argument.
2. Called our bluff and is pretty hard to argue against unless we changed something core to our backend such that it now requires an account. Even if that was the case, I would expect Apple's response to be "change it back".
Throughout the whole exchange with Apple, I had to be Devil's Advocate, since I advised against the change to require an account from the start, being apparently the only person in the company who had actually read the AppStore guidelines. Nobody listened to me, of course.
- immibis 3y agoApple used COMMON SENSE? That's incredible. Google would never do that
- phreack 3y agoKeep in mind GP mentioned this was over a decade ago. Common sense is way less likely to exist at scale.
- floomk 3y ago> We're reviewing your app, not theirs, so what they can do is irrelevant rules for thee but not for me Apple has never been fair with its review, sadly. > I would expect Apple's response to be "change it back". Companies should not have to bend over to apple's whims just to get their software in end user hands. Hopefully upcoming EU regulation will reign apple's overreach in a bit.
- marvin 3y agoYou’re celebrating the possibility that EU regulation will remove Apple’s ability to enforce good user experience?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- codeguro 3y agoApple doesn't get to dictate what constitutes a good user experience. Especially for me - that is my prerogative and mine alone. So yes, I will be extremely happy with it. This opens doors to all kinds of software that can compete with one another, and if I don't like it, I can simply uninstall it myself.
- extragood 3y agoJust one more bit of anecdotal evidence to support your view. Our app was rejected after review until we updated an external support doc to which the app linked. The doc contained system requirements for both iOS and Android devices, and we were specifically rejected for even having mentioned the competing operating system.
- andrekandre 3y ago> The doc contained system requirements for both iOS and Android devices, and we were specifically rejected for even having mentioned the competing operating system. same, for us we just open all links in safari now, so if mentions of android show up its not "in the app"... an arguably worsened user experience for no good reason except to keep apple happy
- riwsky 3y agoIf open doors did a better job of UX than apple, then you would have been using Android instead of iOS in the first place
- jrumbut 3y ago> Nobody listened to me, of course. Being the voice of "this is never, ever going to be accepted into the AppStore, it is a perfect example of what you can't do" can be a very lonely journey.
- chii 3y agoas long as you aren't the person who will ultimately pay for said failure, it doesn't matter if nobody listened to you. You just need the cover-your-ass evidence that you presented this evidence to the stakeholder (who is ultimately responsible for said failure).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fennecfoxy 3y agoOne time Apple asked us why we needed bluetooth permission for an app that had the singular purpose of using bluetooth "iBeacons".