5 ms·
The headline/interpretation seems incorrect. Copying for "private study, scholarship, or research" specifically by libraries is permitted by §108 [1], while fa
by crazygringo 3y ago
The headline/interpretation seems incorrect.
Copying for "private study, scholarship, or research" specifically by libraries is permitted by §108 [1], while fair use is permitted by §107 [2]. These are separate concepts.
Libraries are not intended for photocopying of materials for all possible fair use cases; they're only intended for "private study, scholarship, or research" purposes.
So the sign correctly indicates what's allowed per library policy; it also correctly indicates you have additional rights per fair use policy and warns not to go beyond those.
(A good example is that a teacher can use a private/school photocopier to make 30 copies of material for classroom use according to fair use; but you're not allowed to use the library photocopier to make more than 1 copy of anything.)
[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/108 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/108
[2] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/107 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/107
- londons_explore 3y agoBut the notice attached to any library-produced copy should therefore presumably refer to the rights of the reader (ie. the member of the public), rather than the library.
- kayodelycaon 3y agoIt's basically a disclaimer limiting how you can use the library to make copies. You still have fair use, but the library won't copy documents for you outside of their own limitations.
- cvoss 3y agoThe user is welcome to investigate their own rights on their own time. The government has no interest in that here. The government has a different interest. The library is furnishing a powerful tool to users: the ability to make copies readily. The government's ability to police or regulate this tool so that it complies with copyright law is extremely limited. The government's options are to ban the tool outright, or to permit the tool while impressing a scary warning upon the user, hoping law-abiders will exercise self-control. "If you do something potentially illegal, then you are potentially liable for something illegal." It's a tautological warning, but it still has an effect. And the way they can force the library to communicate the scary warning to the end user is by conditioning the library's liability on the posting of the warning.
- mindslight 3y agoNo, the government does not have an interest in creating a chilling effect that goes far beyond the actual law. Rather, it's commercial copyright holders who have that interest, and they lobbied the government to include this scary warning.
- majormajor 3y agoThe library has an interest in Big Scary Warning because the US has an adversarial legal system which makes it easy for people to cost other people $$$$ on legal fees about stupid shit. You could get these signs with the following path with no lobbying at all: 1) Library puts out copier with no signage 2) Someone makes a bunch of copies of something and starts selling them to people they know 3) That person gets in trouble 4) That person gets angry and lawyers up "how was I supposed to know I couldn't do this, they let me use the machine, they need to indemnify me against this!!" 5) Library wastes money defending this and someone says "ugh let's just put up a stupid sign to deter the fools"
- omniglottal 3y agoThe people have an interest in teachers making copies for students. This is fair use. Most of my teachers didn't know this fact. Textbooks skyrocketted in price in recent decades, while critical thinking and reading level plummet. This is important.
- everforward 3y ago> The library has an interest in Big Scary Warning because the US has an adversarial legal system which makes it easy for people to cost other people $$$$ on legal fees about stupid shit. I think this is unlikely here. I would expect such a suit to get tossed out in the early, early phases because the plaintiff doesn't have standing. Per Manuel LUJAN, Jr., Secretary of the Interior, Petitioner v. DEFENDERS OF WILDLIFE, et al. the 3 part test for standing is: 1. The plaintiff must have suffered an "injury in fact," meaning that the injury is of a legally protected interest which is (a) concrete and particularized and (b) actual or imminent 2. There must be a causal connection between the injury and the conduct brought before the court 3. It must be likely, rather than speculative, that a favorable decision by the court will redress the injury They almost certainly fail the first test. Making bootleg copies of stuff to sell is not a "legally protected interest". They also likely fail the second test because having copiers available, even without signage, isn't causative of copyright infringement. The third is largely speculative, but I would bet a case like that fails that too. I don't even know what law someone would sue under for "they failed to tell me what the law is". Citizens are expected to know what the law is (whether that's reasonable or not is another question), as evidenced by the many laws that don't require mens rea. In all likelihood the way this goes is that person files a lawsuit against the library, the library files a motion for summary judgement, and the judge rules against the plaintiff before discovery even happens. The facts of the case are irrelevant, because even if we presume that everything the plaintiff says is true, the library wouldn't be liable.
- dang 3y agoOk, we've appended a question mark to the title, which is a trick we sometimes use to mitigate questionable titles (on otherwise interesting articles). Edit: ok, not.
- gridspy 3y ago> Does the U.S. Copyright Office require libraries to lie about fair use rights? The grammar is bothering me. Thanks for your moderation either way.
- dang 3y agoIf you 'hear' it out loud I think it sounds better?
- batshibstein 3y agoI'm Ron Burgundy?
- HWR_14 3y agoMight I suggest adding some other mark as well to indicate it was an addition to the title. When I read it, I first assumed the original source had the question mark. Maybe: [?] or *?*
- btilly 3y agoI would suggest removing the question mark. Per what I said at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36608891 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36608891, the article is completely correct.
- dang 3y agoOk, done.
- torstenvl 3y agoI don't think I agree. What §108 allows libraries to do, and what §107 will shield individuals from liability for, are related but separate topics. Charitably, I could maybe see how the library's notice might cause confusion to someone who only skims it. However, upon close reading, it's very clear that they first talk about the conditions the library is bound by in order to use the authorization under §108, and then talk about individual liability if the individual exceeds fair use under §107. In my view, both their summary of §108 and their reference to §107 are cogent and neither is false. As a result, I believe it's incorrect to say that they are lying (and I believe the question mark should have remained). IAALBIANAIPL
- treeman79 3y agoMy wife’s a teacher. School Printer /Photocopier drama was such a stress point for her that her Christmas present was her own high end laser / copy machine.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y ago> A good example is that a teacher can use a private/school photocopier to make 30 copies of material for classroom use according to fair use I disbelieve that this is the case, for copyrighted material; this is not supported by your citations, and that behavior (30 copies in a classroom) seems like a flagrant violation, in fact, and although most teachers wouldn't generally get in trouble with it, most teachers also tend to steer clear of violations like this. A teacher either obtains permission, or uses public domain materials, or finds some other way to convey the information to their students. In fact I researched this when I was teaching a class, and I wanted to use some copyrighted handouts. I was able to obtain permission from a local blogger to use her article and distribute it to the whole class. In fact, she was very glad that I'd asked. I was less successful in contacting a publishing house overseas and obtaining permission for their stuff. So I didn't copy it.
- omniglottal 3y agoSeems like a flagrant violation - yet the actual law disagrees, and you have more rights than what the required library copyright warning implies, from which the majority of our population's learns of "fair use"... perhaps there's a correlation?
- bscphil 3y agoFair use is generally understood to be more flexible when it comes to educational purposes, but it doesn't extend as far as communicating a complete copy of a work. For example, you can't upload a PDF version of a textbook to your class's group website. I don't think this contradicts the parent to your comment. There are cases where a teacher can make 30 copies of a portion of a copyright work for distribution in the classroom, and the comment is about those cases.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y ago> There are cases where a teacher can make 30 copies of a portion of a copyright work for distribution in the classroom, and the comment is about those cases. False, the comment is not about "a portion" of a work, it's about the whole work. I would certainly agree that an educator could photocopy a few paragraphs of a novel, or a textbook, or anything basically, if that work was 300 pages long, and that educator would be within his rights to distribute it to 30 students. A few paragraphs of a 300-page work is a negligible portion when considering copyright. My personal examples were very definitely about reproducing the works in their entirety. The blog post was about a page and a half, so with permission, I had no trouble making it a handout. The other documents were of comparable length, and it would not have worked to use excerpts. I really wanted the work in its entirety for my students to understand the topic. If an educator copied a full page of a one-page handout and distributed it to 30 students, they would definitely be in violation, as that is a reproduction in full, and not fair use at all. Ask any news aggregator site how much of a news article they are allowed to quote. They can't scrape the entire article from a website, they need to selectively quote from it so that it is a minimal portion of the copyrighted work. Percentages matter here. The GP didn't even address that question.
- btilly 3y agoNo, you are misunderstanding it. 108 gives additional rights to libraries to make copies. But it does not take away the right of the library to offer copying for any existing purpose. Therefore, contrary to the posted notice, it is perfectly legal for the library to offer copying services for purposes OTHER than the extra permissions granted in 108. Which means that libraries are authorized under the law to produce copies for all the same purposes that Kinko's is allowed to produce copies. It is up to the library whether to do so. And it is incorrect for the sign to say that the library may NOT do so.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoI’m confused how one parses the required statement to mean fair use is prohibited. It states “a photocopy or reproduction for purposes in excess of ‘fair use’” (emphasis mine) generates liability, and that the library “reserves the right to refuse to accept a copying order,” not that it must. The entire article is premised on a red herring.
- btilly 3y agoThe notice says: Under certain conditions specified in the law, libraries and archives are authorized to furnish a photocopy or other reproduction. One of these specified conditions is that the photocopy or reproduction is not to be “used for any purpose other than private study, scholarship, or research.” This says that libraries and archives are ONLY authorized to furnish a photocopy IF the specified condition is met. In other words, they are not authorized to allow you to make a copy for any other purpose. Even if that other purpose is covered by fair use. But that isn't what the law says. The law says that, even if not otherwise authorized, the library or archive is ALLOWED to furnish a photocopy for those purposes. It is an additional permission, NOT a restriction. Elsewhere it correctly indicates when you, the user, will be sued. And it indicates when the library may legally refuse to make a way you a copy. But it is still worded in such a way to mislead the librarian into thinking that the library will violate the law if they let you make copies for the various purposes for which people legally make copies at Kinko's. And that is false.
- Supermancho 3y agoTrying to work through this... > Libraries are not intended for photocopying of materials for all possible fair use cases; they're only intended for "private study, scholarship, or research" purposes. "What Libraries are intended for" makes no sense here. Libraries are not intended for many things. Might I suggest a rephrasing? 108 is specifically to allow specific rights, mentioning nebulous "under specific conditions". > One of these specified conditions is that the photocopy or reproduction is not to be “used for any purpose other than private study, scholarship, or research.” Without an understanding that this is not a universally prohibitive condition, the poor phrasing makes it seem like it applies in all cases, despite the "Fair use" statement that follows. The US Copyright Office does not require libraries to lie about fair use rights.