17 ms·
A child’s privacy is worth more than likes (2022)
- dazc 3y agoThis ship has already sailed, I am sorry to say. My mum used to have a physical album of family pictures, most of which were hugely embarrassing. But, at least, I had some control who could view these. Some came into my possession after she died and I did not hesitate to destroy each and every one of them.
- phneutral26 3y agoWhat would be SO EMBARRASSING that you burn heirlooms from a lost relative?
- loloquwowndueo 3y agoWhat’s so memorable or “heirloom” about a crappy or embarrassing picture of yourself taken by someone else? It’s not as if the relative lovingly painted it from scratch - it’s just a photograph.
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoI also inherited the family photoalbums and ended up burning MANY pictures. I learned from this the dishonest attempts at "making right" were exactly that: dishonest. My own mother had a streak for photographing nudes (myself included) and she "promised" that these had all been destroyed. They had not. They now are.
- dazc 3y agoSimply baby photos caught at the right moment that may appear funny to others. The world is no lesser place without them.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoOur family photos included one particular photo of me, a rear view holding a garden hose. And it was extremely embarrassing, but not because of its subject matter. It was embarrassing because, for decades, my mother used it as a weapon against me. It was one of those things to emasculate and humiliate me for being a boy and for having a natural body. It was a way to tease me and implemented as a source of shame. It was just another brick in the wall, of course, but unfortunately I didn't get proper access to burn it when I had the chance. It might still exist, for all I know. I may perhaps eventually get a golden opportunity for final satisfaction.
- AlexandrB 3y agoCalling something "embarrassing" leaves a lot of room for interpretation so I can't comment on your specific situation, but I have pictures my mom took of me as a baby naked, breastfeeding, etc and I would never consider destroying these. I also generally find it weird when adults consider something they did before the age of 5 or so embarrassing. Like you're a literal tiny child not responsible for your actions - nothing you do is embarrassing because very little is under your conscious control.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoMy wife is currently 9 months pregnant so my social feeds are essentially just baby content. I appreciate all the content new mothers put out, but I can’t shake the icky feeling I get from some channels that will place the spotlight on the child right from birth.
- sho_hn 3y agoOne thing I really dislike is the pressure it places on young parents to do certain things that are entirely optional and arguably misallocation of resources. Baby showers, gender reveal parties, pre-partum stays at "mom suites" in spas/hotels, all those Instagram moments that make people feel stressed and like they're not in the right income bracket to get into having a family. Save your money, folks. Spend it on high-quality toys, books, childhood travel. Save money so you have to work less and can spend time together. That's what your child will benefit from. We had a wonderful midwife who told us her secondary function was basically to reality-check parents on what gear, clothes, events, price points, etc. they actually need. Get the basics right, she would say, and deeply understand why they are basic and necessary, and otherwise save your time and money for stuff that matters long-term.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoI’ve started sharing whatever I want to buy with my 70 year old mother. Her response to everything is the same - “all of this is useless, kids aren’t that hard to raise”. Given that she’s raised four kids, I tend to believe her.
- rationalist 3y agoOne of my "Facebook Friends" posted details about his kid's medical issues. Who knows what will now be publicly-available when that kid becomes an adult.
- fn-mote 3y agoThis is a perfect example of how complex the situation is. On one hand there's a huge minus of the child's medical info available forever online. On the other hand, the parents can benefit in important ways. * They need support from their friends, so they post on FB. * They may need advice on choosing a course of treatment, finding a specialist, etc. Ideally you are already working with a competent doctor/team but that's not a given. One example immediately comes to mind that took two years of "working the system" before an actionable and effective diagnosis was produced. That's exactly the kind of thing finding the correct community on a social network really helps with. So I don't think it's always clear what to do.
- localghost3000 3y agoI really messed up on this early in my step daughters life back when Facebook was the dominant platform. Posted all kinds of stuff. Fortunately for both of us, she was self aware enough to express discomfort with the idea once she understood what it meant. I stopped posting stuff without her express consent after that but I still regret it. The point is, don't do this to your kids.
- detritus 3y agoUnfortunately for me my parents don't at all see the issue in sharing photos they take of my daughter on the social platforms they frequent and think my concerns are overwrought. She's young enough now that it isn't a major issue, but when she's older and her face is going to be more like the one she'll spend the rest of her life with, there's going to be a big argument about it.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThey almost certainly value seeing their grandaughter more than they value having facebook accounts, so you have a lot of leverage over them if you feel strongly about this. Threaten to cancel your future trips to visit with them if they don't knock it off. Explain your reasoning of course, it's not a response you want to take but your daughter's safety and privacy come first.
- detritus 3y agoWay ahead of you! Sadly I've already played out how that argument will go in my head a few times.
- xxr 3y agoHow will that argument go?
- em-bee 3y agoi raised you. you have no business telling me what i can or can't do. ok, hopefully most people have a better relationship with their parents, but i do think for many it does come down to either being able to explain to them the dangers of social media so that they get it, or accepting their parents actions, because threatening your parents that they can't see the kids of they don't stop is in most cases not a healthy move.
- aymar_99 3y agoI feel there are two kinds of people. The ones who derive happiness from posting online and the others who restrain from it. Baby isn't the provoking factor to exhibit the behaviour.
- jehb 3y agoI can't help but notice that I got an interruptive ad asking for my email address on a site that's supposed to be about privacy. I understand it's a Substack, but something about that just felt jarring given the subject matter.
- humanistbot 3y agoDid they require you to enter your email to read? Or did they just ask you for personal information, let you decline with a single click, and let you get to reading the article? Privacy is about giving people the freedom to choose how their personal information is distributed. Sounds like they are respecting your privacy.
- developer93 3y agoI signed up because it's a topic that interests me, and I can't recommend enough a service like anonaddy, which I now use religiously to create a personalised email for everything I sign up for which can be blocked with 1 click.
- jehb 3y ago> Privacy is about giving people the freedom to choose how their personal information is distributed. That's one take, and I won't argue that it's an unreasonable one. That said, if you asked me to describe the UX patterns I might expect to find on a privacy-respecting website, interrupting me to ask me for personal information probably wouldn't be on that list. I probably also wouldn't have expected to see the third-party tracking pixels from Cloudflare, Datadog, and Google, etc. That's okay. It's not egregious, it's just a bit odd, like if you were reading Apache documentation on a site served by IIS.
- fn-mote 3y ago> [...] I got an interruptive ad [...] Even on HN, theres's people complaining about things that happen to them because they are not running an adblocker. You want privacy? That's the place to start.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoSmall aside on a personal pet peeve. "dopamine hit" is not really a thing. Dopamine in the reward system tracks the difference between the reward we expect and the reward we get (i.e. the prediction error).
- HWR_14 3y agoThis is the first I'm hearing about that. Interesting!
- jonnycomputer 3y agohttps://www.cell.com/current-biology/pdf/S0960-9822(17)30266-X.pdf https://www.cell.com/current-biology/pdf/S0960-9822(17)30266...
- TaupeRanger 3y agoNo, that's just one of many "theories" about how this particular biochemical works, but it is not in any way a proven fact since we don't really know how the brain works in the first place, only what it looks like under certain conditions. "Dopamine hit" absolutely IS a thing though, because that term just refers to the fact that when dopamine producing areas of the brain light up in fMRI scans, people report feelings of pleasure. That's really all it means.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Hexigonz 3y agoI posted a short clip of my son dancing on Tik tok. It went viral very unexpectedly (I don’t make content about my personal life). With over 1 million views, I was riding high on that dopamine hit. However, someone reached out to me about the topic of not only my son’s privacy (he was only 2 at the time) and even worse, the fact that predators anywhere could now see the video. I don’t care if the next one would have gotten 10 million views. I deleted that video and immediately made a follow up explaining the situation to the thousands of people that had followed me from that one video. Your child’s safety and right to future privacy should always be the forefront, and I’m ashamed to say I even slipped up one time. Don’t post that stuff. Send it to your family and move on.
- duxup 3y ago>the fact that predators anywhere could now see the video I've seen this worry expressed before, but I don't understand it. Do you feel like your son is more likely to be a victim of a given predator that comes across the video because it went viral? Or some other consequence? That doesn't seem likely at all considering sexual assault or similar IIRC is usually done by someone you know already.
- Hexigonz 3y agoNo, meaning that any predator can save a video of my child for viewing any time they like. I don’t mean they’ll be preyed on, I mean they’ll be viewed outside of the context I wanted my children viewed in. It’s not always “oh look at this cute kid! That’s adorable!” It can become much darker than that.
- duxup 3y agoHow likely is that to occur? Is that harmful to someone?
- Hexigonz 3y agoThere have been quite a few cases where content creators who have made their entire niche their children disabled downloading and follower counts dropped drastically. It may not harm my child directly, but I’d rather avoid making my kids someone else’s spankbank material. I don’t really see a case that it would be good for them to mass distribute videos of their formative years, even if it isn’t directly harmful.
- jamal-kumar 3y agoI've been telling people for over a decade that my reason for not wanting my photo taken is because a piece of your soul gets taken away into that photograph and if it's uploaded to the internet, it's lost in a virtual world forever. Yeah, it's a joke, but it seriously gets more acceptance and understanding, and less scoffing than telling people I really don't like my face in the corporate surveillance panopticon as much as I can avoid it. There just isn't any point in feeding that nonsense, on the other hand people are very quick to dismiss anything that sounds like paranoia from anyone. The logical solution I've found here is somewhere in the middle because apparently nobody dismisses people's spiritual beliefs. The result is that people respect my wishes to not be in photos.
- cempaka 3y ago> on the other hand people are very quick to dismiss anything that sounds like paranoia from anyone It takes willful blindness at this point not to comprehend how bad the panopticon is for us, and that's before even venturing into more conspiratorial analyses of the real purpose of all this infrastructure and what it's meant to be used for. I've noticed these dismissals will often take the form of a sort of learned helplessness/powerlessness, i.e. "they already know everything about me, so why wouldn't I just hand over my retinal scan, DNA, and images of my private moments?" It's just a method of coping with the subconscious recognition of how bad the situation has become.
- cheschire 3y agoIt's interesting how much it parallels the novel 1984. The members of the party lived under extreme surveillance and control for what? My analysis is that the outer party traded off those things effectively for a sense of safety, and the inner party traded off even more for pride. In total the party was only about 20% of the populace. At any point Winston could have left. The party had obviously created an oppressive wartime environment that made it scary to leave the safety of the party, but Winston had many opportunities to simply walk away. But he was invested. And I think that's the parallel I see in modern capitalist society. We're so invested that we cannot imagine walking away. Disposable gadgets, next-day shipping from the comfort of your couch, virtual social scores (either crowd sourced or provided by your ruling party). These things all feed into the sunk cost fallacy that starting over would be too hard. And maybe it is. Maybe that's why I keep marching with the herd.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoMy wife took a hard line early on—no pictures of the kids on social media. I thought she was being a little silly but went along with it. Really glad now.
- elforce002 3y agoSame here. Both decided against that. We only share pictures to our relatives and we specifically tell them not to share them.
- themitigating 3y agoWhy? I mean what event made you glad?
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoFacial recognition, and also just the general enshittification of social media and the internet at large.
- sendfoods 3y agoWhat was the timeline, if you don't mind me asking? When and why was your wife skeptical of social media, and when did you truly start understanding her concerns?
- KnobbleMcKnees 3y agoHow do you deal with family and friends wanting to post photos of your kids? The societal norm sadly seems to be that privacy invasion of this form is completely acceptable.
- klondike_klive 3y agoI keep an eye on it, if a photo of my kid pops up I get in touch with them and say do you mind not putting that up, we're not putting him on social media until he's old enough to choose for himself. It's been received well so far, people seem to understand our objections even though we don't offer any more explanation than that.
- elforce002 3y agoI don't understand why parents want to expose every facet of their children on instagram and TikTok. I have 2 children and I take pictures and record videos of them almost every day and I've never posted anything anywhere. In this day and age, privacy is almost a luxury and I want to protect theirs as much as I can. When they grow up, they'll decide how much exposure they want to have but that'd be their decision. My biggest fear is their photos/videos popping up in wrong places. Heck, with instagram being used basically as a "flesh" market for women, there are parents dressing their toddlers in outfits that are for grown ups that frankly make me wonder if the government ought to remove their children. There are some truly sick individuals out there and parents need to stay vigilant to avoid tragedies.
- flatline 3y agoI agree about the privacy concerns but I occasionally share funny or nice photos of the kids on Facebook - for the purpose of sharing those pictures with friends and family, and with discussion and consent from them. These are not public posts. Not everyone is seeking a dopamine hit, they are just exposing a part of their personal life to people in their circle. I only have like 150 friends on Facebook, all of whom I know or have known in person.
- TaupeRanger 3y agoYa the article seems to imply that the ONLY reason a parent would be doing this is to get a dopamine hit from "likes". That's just out of touch and asinine. It's perfectly fine to share photos of your children for friends and family to see on Facebook. Of course, using your children as content for your own public facing Instagram or TikTok is totally different. But everyone already knows that, and it wouldn't make for a great article that you could get reposted to the front page of Hacker News or whatever other site.
- chillbill 3y agoI agree with the spirit of the post, but: - You don’t need to be doing a PhD to realize that there’s something weird about sharing your intimate life stories online with strangers. Might be a bit crude, but you’d have to be pretty thick not to consider it. - This part: > Social media companies, these corporate giants that have so much influence in today’s culture and the way we connect with each other, are the ones normalizing oversharing and benefiting from it This is not exactly accurate. Social media companies are not the ones normalizing this behavior, bad parents are. They do benefit from it or even encourage it, but ultimately it’s the parent’s responsibility as they are doing it only for themselves. Bad parents are not the victim, they are the problem.
- elforce002 3y agoBoth are to be blamed but parents have 80% of the blame here.
- hunter-gatherer 3y agoI'm curious how you came up with that number.
- ajdude 3y agoI was reading recently the story of Christopher Robin, and how using his childhood stories in Winnie the Pooh haunted to him for the rest of his life and made him a subject of bullying. I can only imagine what it will be like for these kids once they're older with their whole story plastered all over Instagram.
- photonerd 3y agoIt’s more that his parents were completely emotionally absent & preferred to (as he put it) “step on [his] infant shoulders” than have any substantial relationship. The bullying definitely was real but his parents mental neglect probably contributed at least as much—if not more—to his trauma.
- Waterluvian 3y ago
- m3kw9 3y agoI’m not getting the arguments she is writing about. Predators: yes that is a risk, but it’s as much of a risk as walking outside. Child getting mad at parents for posting when they grow up: again everything has risk this is almost negligible risk because social media is so pervasive on society, they will likely understand why parents posted. What I find wrong is parents just showing off their kids for likes, a occasional bday pic is fine but every freaking meal or play day is just screams, I need likes today
- TaupeRanger 3y agoCorrect - but that wouldn't make for a shareable viral article about privacy, because that's what almost every normal adult in the developed world believes and is totally normal.
- duxup 3y ago>they are giving their children’s privacy away for something as trivial as likes. Generally speaking I'm sharing with friends and family ... there's more to it than likes when it comes to human social activity IMO. I feel like this post boils it down to too little. As for the consequences such as cyber bullying. Is the idea here is some bully at school one day might find some other child's photo and that spurs the bullying? That sounds like "hide your shameful pics someone might be mean" and IMO completely misses the whole bullying situation. That sounds like a horrible (and frankly childish) way to live life/ teach your kids. This whole topic is often so generalized (how much sharing are we even talking about), driven by fear, that it doesn't make any sense and the mysterious consequences a sorta boogie man.
- AlexandrB 3y agoIt's kind of funny that there's an old trope of people showing friends or strangers slides from their vacations or pictures of their kids from their wallet and the friends kind of awkwardly feigning interest. Not much has changed with social media. If I had to guess, many people that get pictures of kids shared with them like and comment out of politeness, not genuine interest. So I don't get why the collateral damage of also sharing those pictures with Mark Zuckerberg and various ad companies is worth it.
- duxup 3y agoI actually like seeing other people’s photos.
- averagepersonn 3y agoYou are the majority in my experience. People like other people. If you don’t care about your close friends’ lives, they aren’t your close friends.
- brewdad 3y agoI have many good friends and family members that I now live 1000+ miles away from. I might go years without meeting up with them face to face. Sharing photos and experiences helps to keep us closer than we might otherwise be. I also think there’s a huge difference between scrolling through a few dozen pictures on my terms vs being trapped in a slide show in someone’s home.
- hospitalJail 3y agoMy brother tried the whole 'don't share pictures of my kids online'. Lasted 2 weeks. They started by sending private snapchat messages to our family. My wife screenshotted the cute baby picture, google uploaded it automatically to their backup/photo storage. Game over. Heck, walk into walmart, your face and your family are all scanned and added into their security database. Its a fools errand. I can think of few uses for privacy, overthrowing a government, embarrassing fetish, a medical illness that would cause people to treat you differently, yet none of those are showing your kids being kids online.
- ampersandy 3y agoThere’s a difference between “I don’t want any photos of my kids in a server anywhere” and “please don’t share pictures of my kids to other people unless we do it privately”, which your wife immediately violated by screenshotting an obviously private message.
- hospitalJail 3y agoI wonder how many of these people have kids over the age of 10. By 4 years old, my kid was on social media, because he went to a birthday party and a stranger took a picture. Would be weird having everyone but the children go around the great grandparents when the great grandparents turn 100. When they are on a soccer team, they don't take a team photo? All because we are afraid a face is going to do what exactly? Reminds me of the whole 'don't put your last name on the internet'.
- AlexandrB 3y agoWhat's weird to me is posting any of this stuff to social media. It's great to have family photos with the great grandparents, but why does it have to go on Facebook?
- fn-mote 3y agoIt goes on Facebook because that's how people communicate with a wider circle of friends. They don't care about the whole internet, but they want the friends that they do not see every week to stay involved in their lives. FB absolutely maintains those connections over years of minimal personal involvement. You can debate whether that's a good idea. You can even debate whether you think the connection is real (but I think the feeling of a connection is enough to consider it "real"). You can certainly debate the use of these images in corporate machine-generated ads... but deal with the first paragraph: I think we understand why genuine people might still post on social media.
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoWe've forbidden most people to take pictures of our youngest because we don't want his pictures online without his consent. My parents are still very mad about it. We've posted or shared some limited photos but never ones that show his face.
- TaupeRanger 3y agoThat's silly. Straining your relationship with your parents over preventing anyone from simply looking at your child (which hundreds of people do when he/she is walking in public every year, and hundreds more will do by simply buying a yearbook when they are in school) is uncalled for. When you grew into adulthood did you demand your parents take down all of your baby pictures that they had hanging on their walls?
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoMy kid, my rules. If my parents can't respect that, they aren't entitled to be involved in our family. Why on earth would I associate with people who don't respect us?
- em-bee 3y agobecause they are your parents, and you should try to have a healthy relationship with them. (unless of course they mistreated you badly when you grew up, but then you probably would keep more distance than just disallowing them to take photos)
- ocdtrekkie 3y agoIs it a healthy relationship if they don't respect our boundaries? I think people may be projecting some very strange personal feelings about their parents on people they don't know.
- em-bee 3y agoIs it a healthy relationship if they don't respect our boundaries? it's not, but that doesn't mean it is a good idea to just refuse them. unless the relationship is seriously broken, it is always a good idea to to try to work on the relationship with your parents and avoid making it worse. if this is the only issue i'd have with my parents, it would be better to try to resolve the issue instead of rejecting them. I think people may be projecting some very strange personal feelings about their parents on people they don't know. possibly, but i get the same impression from your message too. you may have reasons for your choice that are not visible from your post, which is fine for your choice. but because i can't see those reasons (and it would be out of place to share them here) i have to interpret your message based on the context available.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoFor a while, I followed the Holderness family on YouTube. They are an amusing North Carolina family of four who had a breakout hit when they dressed in matching pajamas and sang a Christmas song. For a long time, their two young children were featured in all their videos, acting, engaging and interacting as a family. Perhaps a year ago, first their daughter and then their son vanished from the videos, without much explanation. And I think that it sort of dawned on them that people may have viewed it as exploitative or unwholesome that their children had become, essentially, employees without much of a choice in the matter. So while I miss their witty presence in the videos, I do commend the family on doing the right thing and letting their children be kids, off-camera, and perhaps when they come to adulthood, they can make a free choice to rejoin the comedy skits and music videos.
- tmoravec 3y agoFolks, can I ask about your opinion on one particular case of child photos on social media? Imagine a semi-pro photographer, focusing on childhood photography. The photos are of course not any candid moments, celebrating the kids birthdays or sharing their lives. It’s staged, often with professional lights, heavily Photoshopped, etc. Telling a “story” rather than showing the photographed person - they are basically actors. Clearly, FB et al. would be great for finding clients, or just sharing the work with people who enjoy this kind of art. Do you think it’s OK to post such images, provided the parents’ give their consent? Do you think it’s OK to post such images of the photographer’s own kids? EDIT: Should have mentioned that there's no reason to link the models' identity on social media. It's not captioned as "Picture of David Oberon, 6yo from Seattle" but rather "Picture of a little inventor, working on a cool new machine".
- natpalmer1776 3y agoIt’s a gray area imo, there is no way of obtaining meaningful consent from those children, even if they are your own, but in the same vein the photographs are presumably one-off and not strongly associated with their identity as they grow, causing the privacy aspect to almost become a non-issue in the long term.
- tmoravec 3y agoCool, thanks for the response. Good catch about the privacy aspect becoming less of an issue long-term. I’ll be thinking about that.
- goolz 3y agoIMO it is not OK because there are long lasting implications (some creepy dude comes to mind, but I digress) that could impact their lives well past childhood. And as a child they cannot properly consent, and I do not trust parents to look out for their kids best interests. It would seem history has supported this theory with lots of anecdotes haha. Again, just my 2c.
- hammock 3y ago
- Engineering-MD 3y agoBeyond the actually privacy argument I think there is a social argument. If you don’t post photos on Instagram you will drive more (for want of a better word) ‘engagement’ in real life as your friends actually meet your baby/child in order to see what they look like. Hold of the digital snack and enjoy the much more wholesome reality.
- nelblu 3y agoI have no social media presence and i have no kids but I have an absolutely amazing dog who is the friendliest dog I have ever met. I used to wonder whether I should start a YouTube or social media handle to share the love. However I rejected the idea because it's so much stressful to get the perfect photo or video and it just ruins the whole experience of the interaction. I also realized I'm really doing it for myself so instead why not do something that will help the dog too - so now I'm training him to be a therapy dog and hoping he passes his test next month!
- oska 3y ago> it just ruins the whole experience of the interaction Hit it on the head there. Taking photos takes you outside the experience. It's the reason I take very few photos when I'm traveling. (I can understand ppl wanting to take them in that context, but it does make your travel different.)
- zirgs 3y agoThere are only 2 types of people who are interested in pictures of kids: 1. Their friends and relatives - it's easy to share those pictures with them privately. 2. All sorts of creeps.
- LAC-Tech 3y agoHad my first baby last year, and it struck me how often I saw this on social media. Especially on LinkedIn. (I can remember one example irritated me to no end, some CTO posted a pictures of his wife working from home with two babies trying to play with her. Really poor taste IMO). I can understand being proud and happy about the new arrival and wanting to shout it from the roof tops. But my logical side said "she's too young to decide if she wants her picture on the internet".
- klondike_klive 3y agoI was sorely tempted to put my son's artwork on Instagram because since he was about 6 months old he had spookily incredible pen control and a sort of uncanny skill in design and composition. I just couldnt shake a sort of icky feeling that I'd be getting a dopamine kick from people liking his drawings, and the converse, that I'd be feeling hard done by if one drawing didn't get enough attention. I really wrestled with it for ages because I was (and am) really proud and wanted to show off! (He's now less interested in drawing than in Lego so the moment has kind of passed.)
- tdeck 3y agoThe absolute worst is when parents play mean pranks on their kids and film it to put on the internet. I think it's a petty asshole move to tell your kid you ate all their Halloween candy, and that it's selfish and inconsiderate to mine your children for video content that will be online for their whole lives. Imagine how little self awareness a person needs to have to combine the two.
- jasonmp85 3y agoHey privacy is really important oh by the way subscribe to us, k?
- zagrebian 3y agoRelevant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ziltBdyFxDo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ziltBdyFxDo
- ddol 3y agoI wholeheartedly support the blog author. When my eldest was born I posted the following note on my Facebook wall: Today, I met you. My words cannot adequately express the hope and happiness you bring to your mother and I. After months of anticipation we are delighted that you are here and healthy, safe and sound. Like all parents we want to protect you and nourish your individuality. Today I'm making a promise: your identity is yours alone to express. In this digital era, we share more, more often. But that decision to share is not one we will make for you, we won't create an online presence for you. Only you can decide how you want to be seen by the world. I later realised that I had posed this on the day they were born, revealing their legal date of birth. I screen-shotted the original, deleted it and then reposted it, adding the following quote: I don’t share photos of my son online because he hasn’t consented to that sharing, and doesn’t understand what posting photos online means. I have seen friends post photos of their children on Facebook/Instagram while potty training and in the bath. Who knows how much those kids are going to get bullied in middle / high school when a classmate finds those photos, makes a meme out of them or prints them out and posts them around the school. All because their parents were chasing a dopamine high from a few likes. It's great to see kids like Gwyneth Paltrows' pushing back[0] against their parents oversharing very publicly, creating a great example for other kids, empowering them to stand up to their parents oversharing. [0] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-47722427 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-47722427