9 ms·
Unfortunately, this falls short of respecting bodily autonomy. >Gov. Janet Mills, a Democrat, signed a bill into law this week that will eliminate penalties fo
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
Unfortunately, this falls short of respecting bodily autonomy.
>Gov. Janet Mills, a Democrat, signed a bill into law this week that will eliminate penalties for those who sell sex while leaving in place laws against the purchase of it.
- adrr 3y agoThat is so strange. Like legalizing drugs through allowing people to sell it but prosecuting the people who purchase it.
- lom 3y agoThat is not a fair comparison for so many reasons…
- adrr 3y agoHow so?
- serf 3y agowell, in the case of sex-trade it can be argued that the purchaser is ,generally speaking, in a better state-of-living than the seller. The reverse is, generally speaking, the case with regards to selling drugs. it's a matter of which party is thought to be more greatly victimized, in other words.
- yieldcrv 3y agothought to be is the primary achilles heel of these efforts they assume the sex workers have no agency and give them no voice in these proposals, opinions and legislation. “believe all women, except them”. many workers are saying “labor rights and harm reduction” and that thinly veiled eradication and weighing differences based on power dynamics does.not.help.
- 111111IIIIIII 3y ago[flagged]
- robbiep 3y agoThat’s a very puritanical view of the sex trade. In New South Wales prostitution has always been legal, including street crawlers, and for the protection of the sellers it is illegal to be a pimp. The view being the women have agency but pimping is predatory
- bruceb 3y ago"including street crawlers" Nothing says pro women than using a term like this.
- robbiep 3y agoWell, technically the term is used for the people who are looking to purchase services, so I’m not sure what sort of judgement you’re trying to apply, but thanks kindly for your 2c - the point being that you can buy sex off the street in NSW
- kortilla 3y agoBetter look up who it refers to before you whip out the indignation
- mock-possum 3y agoOoh ooh is it guys?
- kortilla 3y agoNo, it’s specifically the clients. Definitely predominantly men but it’s not a term for men specifically.
- adrr 3y agoStreet Crawler or Kerb crawler is the person looking to solicit prostitution. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerb_crawler https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerb_crawler
- perilunar 3y ago
- adrr 3y agoIs that true? Surveys show the top drugs as marijuana, cocaine(no crack), lsd, and ecstasy which are more party/social drugs. It’s not the “bad” drugs like crack, meth, heroin, or pcp. And there are plenty of victims in drug dealing. People get killed all the time and lots of children will never see their parents outside of visiting them in jail due to mandatory min sentencing. In terms of race for federal convictions for trafficking and dealing it’s mostly blacks and Hispanics that do all the time to feed America’s drug addiction. There’s the whole drug mule thing where cartels prey on people to be drug mules.
- vintermann 3y ago> Surveys show the top drugs as marijuana, cocaine(no crack), lsd, and ecstasy which are more party/social drugs. It’s not the “bad” drugs like crack, meth, heroin, or pcp. Surveys? As in asking people what they've used, and maybe how much? I can think of some reasons why prestigious/party drugs are well-represented there and gutter drugs aren't. It's safe to assume that most money in drugs is made on harmful use, if you define harmful use even remotely sensibly. This is the case for alcohol, tobacco and gambling, and although there is always going to be more uncertainty around illegal products, you can be pretty confident it's the case there too. This is why legalization isn't an easy fix. People running businesses that are harmful to their significant customers, know it. These industries will still attract gangsters in the sense of people that are OK with profiting from spreading misery, only instead of risking prison for it, they can openly build relationships to other powerful people, participate in lobbying etc.
- adrr 3y agoHow else would you determine drug usage in a country? You cant just randomly drug test a random cohort of the population. anecdotally, i have never had anyone try to sell me any “bad” drugs.
- gettodachoppa 3y ago>well, in the case of sex-trade it can be argued that the purchaser is ,generally speaking, in a better state-of-living than the seller. Maybe this applies to homeless street walkers. But the majority of prostitution I'm aware of (anecdotal, I know) is middle-class men who go to freelance call girls 10x wealthier than they are. The customer pays a several days' worth of his wages for 2h of fun. So I would say it can be argued that the purchaser is a bigger victim than the seller, considering the financial power dynamics.
- hammock 3y agoA bit like when usury used to be illegal. You can write a note (borrow money) but you can’t collect interest on notes from others
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 111111IIIIIII 3y ago[flagged]
- anjel 3y agoUS Usury laws were if not eliminated, substantially curtailed in th last 30 years. There used to be interest rate caps on consumer loans. Now we have Payday Loan Titans. In California, you can only charge a max of 10% interest if you want to seller-finance real estate. The way to charge more than 10% is to become a regulated bank which is non-trivial and capital-intense.
- 111111IIIIIII 3y ago[flagged]
- anjel 3y ago[flagged]
- pyuser583 3y agoThis has been considered. You stop commerce by stopping demand, not supply.
- miley_cyrus 3y agoI have long advocated for this, and people always reject it out of hand!
- gizmo686 3y agoAre you intending to speak generally, because there are almost no markets where that is the way things work. I can't think of any other market that is restricted purely on the demand side, and the few markets I can think of with demand side enforcement as a major component, they do so because they are at the limit of what is practical on the supply side, not because they choose not to enforce supply side.
- michaelmrose 3y agoIt's true of illicit markets with a high ceiling for what buyers are willing to pay vs the requirements for sellers to engage in trade. People are willing to pay so much for drugs which are so cheap to produce that dealing with dealers does virtually nothing for consumption because rising prices inspire people to fill any gaps you poke in the supply chain. I would say sex is not dissimilar.
- roenxi 3y ago1) Generally the way commerce is stopped is first it is moved via a regulator, then the regulator squeezes it. See the medical market for example. 2) Sometimes we must refer to King Canute and the tide. The idea of "stopping demand" for prostitution seems like a long shot.
- lostlogin 3y agoHave you got an example of regulatory pressure working? Drugs, alcohol, sex, abortion. You make it illegal and you get the same behaviour with a whole load of bad add-ons.
- wiseowise 3y agoCould drugs be trafficked against their will and forced into modern life slavery? (Hint: you’re comparing people to objects)
- cwillu 3y agoIt's a great argument for a comprehensive set of workers' rights.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoIf you insist on framing it as "buying sex is consuming people", then sure.
- pasquinelli 3y agoi wonder what happens if both parties claim to be the prostitute?
- halJordan 3y agoIf they're both selling sex then they're both buying it.
- pasquinelli 3y agoi was imagining a dispute between the parties, with both claiming to be the seller and that the other is the buyer.
- smelendez 3y agoWould this come up that often? It seems like an easier defense would be for the buyer to say there was no payment involved and hope the seller does the same to avoid having to testify.
- yieldcrv 3y agoits ridiculous people still have a hard-on for the nordic model. they just think "how clever! we solved it ya'll!" any effort rooted in the prohibition of sex work will harm workers, and these efforts are based on enacting their discomfort with men having increased access to transactional sex as a normal option. this model simply exacerbates trafficking by removing one of the main ways exploitation is reported at all - by workers confiding in customers they've built rapport with! it has to be harmonized as a labor issue, rooted in harm reduction. edit: there it is >“The point of this whole thing is to decrease the demand for commercial sex,” said Maine state Rep. Lois Reckitt, D., who sponsored the bill,
- justrealist 3y agoTrafficking and abuse is still a big problem in Amsterdam. There's no magic solution.
- yieldcrv 3y agocorrect, a labor rights issue. just like labor trafficking is still a big problem .... everywhere. tackling this as a commercial sex issue debilitates avenues for addressing labor rights issues.
- 111111IIIIIII 3y ago[flagged]
- briantakita 3y ago> False. Human labor trafficking receives high praise from the global ruling class for its excellent profitability. It is also an effective tool to blackmail willing & unwilling lawmakers, corporate heads, & officials to control policy.
- 111111IIIIIII 3y agoFair point. It is a fabulous means for the pursuit of both profit and power.
- bitwize 3y agoThis is how you do it. The johns are the ones who create the market for prostitution. Prostitutes, many of whom were forced into it, should not be criminalized. Jurisdictions where voluntary prostitution is legal to provide or procure, have increased rates of illegal sex trafficking compared to jurisdictions where it is illegal. Criminalizing it from the demand side has much the same effect as a total ban, while also protecting vulnerable sex workers.
- DangitBobby 3y agoI just don't buy that paying for sex should be criminal. And it takes two sides to make a market.
- gostsamo 3y agoYes, but in many places the prostitute is not a side in the transaction. Google human trafficking.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoThis law will do nothing to combat human trafficking. The best ways to help human trafficking exist mainly in the places people are trafficked from, not to. Equal rights and access to education, suffrage and work for women is a good start. General societal development helps.
- gostsamo 3y agoGo implement them there. In the meantime, do not punish the victims here.
- ldoughty 3y agoThe goal of the bill is not about bodily autonomy... The article makes it clear that the goal is to stop penalizing people who are very often victims (of trafficking or circumstance). They are not trying to stop the trade, legalize the trade, etc... They are trying to make it so that those who sell their body are not 'locked' into the trade because they can't get a job, an apartment, etc. and escape the cycle of selling -> jail -> selling -> etc... Even if they get help, it's hard to continue your life if you can't find a job or sign a contract for a safe place to stay.
- rayiner 3y agoDecriminalizing selling sex is something social libertarians and sex-negative feminists can agree on. But the latter, unlike the former, don’t regard it as a half measure, or think about it in terms of “bodily autonomy.” They view the female prostitute as the victim of male aggression. It doesn’t make sense to punish the victim, but it does make sense to punish the perpetrator.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quickthrowman 3y agoYou’re responding to a poster called ‘ldoughty’, not Andrea Dworkin. Who said anything about sex-negative feminists (or social liberatians, for that matter)
- resolutebat 3y agoAs the GP points out, the fact that buying sex remains criminalized means that this is, indeed, a sex-negative approach.
- fdsio 3y agoThis approach is women-positive, not sex-negative. Here's an account of the awful reality of when prostitution is fully legalised: https://www.adoptnordicwa.org/uncategorized/insights-into-prostitution-by-former-receptionist-presents-harrowing-reality/ https://www.adoptnordicwa.org/uncategorized/insights-into-pr...
- rayiner 3y agoWhat is “bodily autonomy.”
- yes_really 3y agoThere is no principled reasoning from those politicians. The rule is basically "Sign any law that advantages women. Be neutral or against any law that advantages men." Ask these politicians how they are respecting men's body autonomy. They will look at you confused thinking "body autonomy" applies only to women or outright get angry and say you are arguing in bad faith.
- mola 3y agoYou just sent ppl to go argue in bad faith....
- Traubenfuchs 3y agoThis could create a weird dynamic where prostitutes are blackmailing their customers. Why are humans so weird about sex? What is the difference to a massage?
- wiseowise 3y agoSo you don’t see any difference between your wife giving a massage and having sex with someone?
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoCan’t speak for them, but mine is an adult and can make her own choices. I trust her judgement.
- wiseowise 3y agoYou didn’t answer my question. Would you react the same to both?
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoYes. I know some people are jealous types, or try to control what their partners do, but that’s not me. If she finds somebody else that she likes enough to have sex with I’m totally happy for her. More love is better.
- Traubenfuchs 3y agoThe wonders of non monogamy and separating sex, love and sex with love.
- bmacho 3y agoMarriage is about exclusive sex, you can't make an analogy with that. It wasn't me asked, but I personally wouldn't mind my exclusive masseur having sex with someone, but I would mind if he massaged someone else.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoHaha. That's pretty much identical to our "decriminalization" of drugs where we let people buy them, but leave the laws in place against those that sell.
- goolz 3y agoThis always cracks me up. The best part is, the same people who locked you up a few decades ago for bud are the ones making bankroll now on the “green rush” in all the medical marijuana states. My local dispensaries are run in the same manner the Walmart is, industrially. A fun exercise in futility is looking at the parent companies and looking at which billionaire or consulting exec is selling you 400% marked up crap. My point being: all it took were some good ol’ corporate profits to change that tune.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoThis doesn't really work. It's been tried for years now in Norway, and prostitutes, while no longer defined as criminals, still have to avoid the police because their customers getting arrested means they lose money. And they're prostitutes, so aside from a small minority, they really need the money they make. Very few people become prostitutes if they have other options. They also don't get the same legal rights that workers in fully legitimised businesses do.
- saurik 3y agoI mean it is certainly better though, right? Losing money is way better than going to jail. I'd say that is "working" even if there are even better things to do. Like, it would be strange to think "I guess it didn't work so no need to have bothered".
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoDepends on whether they have a pimp or not, and how sociopathic the pimp is. At least in Norway, going to jail is a lot better than being physically abused for not making enough money.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoExperience shows it doesn't work. So long as it's an illegal marketplace you get all the problems of an illegal marketplace. Whether you go after the sellers or the buyers doesn't change the illicit nature of the situation. If you want to actually improve the situation you make the transaction legal and aboveboard.
- saurik 3y agoThat doesn't mean it "doesn't work", that just means it doesn't solve all the problems you want to have solved. Insisting this change "doesn't work" and thereby, what... should not have happened? means that a ton of people I don't want in jail end up in jail. And like, that's what you are thereby arguing for: you are saying this somehow doesn't work to actually fully protect people... so you'd rather the status quo remain and these people be charged with a crime? How about instead of saying "doesn't work" you say "not enough" or "what's next"?