9 ms·
FTC announces proposed rule banning fake reviews and testimonials
- jonahhorowitz 3y agoNow if they'd only ban "this review is based on a free product I got from the company in exchange for reviewing it" fake reviews.
- JimtheCoder 3y agoAs long as it is clearly indicated, is it really that big of a problem? I think they are focusing on getting rid of deception...
- russdill 3y agoYes, so long as when browsing products there's a checkbox to ignore all such reviews so I can sort by a rating that doesn't include such shenanigans.
- samtho 3y agoI’m personally conflicted about these. On one hand, having launched products before, it’s difficult to get those first reviews because even if the public perception of reviews is poor, they still hold a lot of weight in terms purchasing decisions. As such, it’s easy to send off a few free products and hope they will review them well. As a consumer, however, I’m always skeptical of products with less than 20 or so reviews that are all 5 stars and the text of the reviews have no real substance. There is an opportunity here (and I’m not sure what it looks like) to get products in the hands of people who will be incentivized to review honestly because the maker of the product actually wants to earn organic, positive reviews and will take the issues noted by reviewers seriously for improving upon the product.
- JohnFen 3y agoI think those sorts of reviews are fine (both ethically and legally) as long as that is disclosed so that everyone knows to discount the review.
- have_faith 3y agoThe scores are still being counted in aggregate scores though.
- fuzzythinker 3y agoLike others mentioned, disclosed is fine, it's the "you'll receive [$20 | free stuff] if you leave a 5 star review" that makes reviews untrustworthy.
- photonbeam 3y agoHow will amazon survive this
- justrealist 3y ago? Amazon would be absolutely thrilled if the FTC successfully cracked down on fake reviews.
- AbacusAvenger 3y agoAmazon would still be in charge of enforcement, they'd just be held liable for not doing so. Which is not a pleasant place to be, because blocking automation is not an easy problem, and it's difficult to measure success.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"Amazon would still be in charge of enforcement" Is this true? Based on my reading of the proposed rules, it would be the product owner who would be responsible, not the platform. I don't think Amazon Basics or any of their other brands are participating in this sort of behaviour. I could be wrong, though...
- meragrin_ 3y ago> Is this true? Based on my reading of the proposed rules, it would be the product owner who would be responsible, not the platform. From my reading, Amazon is only responsible for whatever they knowingly participate in. If sellers and manufacturers participate in it without Amazon's knowledge, Amazon has no required enforcement.
- jkaplowitz 3y ago> blocking automation is not an easy problem Amazon is very much willing and able to tackle difficult problems, as repeatedly demonstrated throughout their history. Admittedly they prefer to choose which difficult problems they tackle, but still.
- lallysingh 3y agoThis needed to happen 10 years ago.
- jlsfiew38 3y agoI would estimate more like 20.
- EA-3167 3y agoHonestly, that's a pretty standard "tape delay" for this sort of thing. It's really hard to make good, widely agreed-upon rules before the problem becomes widespread. Once it is, and there's popular support, rules and regulations become obvious. And that's how government tends to work.
- DangitBobby 3y agoBut fraud is already illegal.
- ranting-moth 3y agoAmazon reviews were decent 10 years ago. Now they're worse than useless. My Amazon shopping has followed the curve. I'm pretty sure Amazon knows best of all what's going on, but stays quiet because they're generating insane profits.
- fmajid 3y agoThey’ve been broken for a lot longer than a decade.
- ranting-moth 3y agoOh yes, but now fake reviews are on a an industrial scale.
- fmajid 3y ago
- m463 3y agoIt is sort of amazing how many of the scenarios listed on this page we have all seen, probably on a daily basis. Wonder how many of these will survive to the end? I guess one good thing is that the participants are not something like ISPs vs the public, more like business vs business.
- geraldwhen 3y agoMost fake reviews come from India and the buyers are using non-US payment systems. I don’t know how this would impact the existing market.
- silisili 3y agoOn Amazon at least, they aren't. There are giant networks of companies seeking out American reviewers, basically giving free products in exchange for reviews. I was invited to one after leaving a good review on some product I'd bought, and did some digging. From what I can tell, Chinese companies hire companies in India and Bangladesh to boost reviews. They then act like middlemen, seeking out pay for play reviewers in other countries. It's funny because they pretend to be Chinese women in their profiles. After chatting one lady 'Eve' up, basically saying I knew they weren't Chinese by the way they wrote English, he admitted to being a young man from Bangladesh, though I forgot his name. I thanked him for his honesty. I was sent a spreadsheet of multiple items to choose from. Clicked on a few, and saw a couple 'Top 10 Reviewer' labeled folks making reviews on these unheard of products. So the 'all stars' of Amazon are all in on it. All this is separate from the multitude of companies who put little cards in their packaging offering a rebate for a good review. Garbage all the way down...
- tough 3y agoWhere does one start working as a paid reviewer anyways?
- refulgentis 3y ago> On Amazon....There are giant networks of companies seeking out American reviewers...I was invited to one after leaving a good review on some product I'd bought > From what I can tell, Chinese companies hire companies in India and Bangladesh to boost reviews. They then act like middlemen, seeking out pay for play reviewers in other countries.
- geraldwhen 3y agoSites like mturk. Some of the work seems legit, but it’s all manipulation of organic web traffic. I made a lot of money in fake reviews in a past life.
- loeg 3y agoKind of amazed this needs any kind of new rule. Isn't this FTC bread and butter? Still, if it leads anywhere, I'm happy to see the FTC do more work in this direction.
- DangitBobby 3y agoMe too. I'm over here wondering how fake reviews aren't already fraud and why it isn't being actively prosecuted for obvious consumer harm.
- sergiomattei 3y agoThis week I got locked out of my car. I left the keys in the trunk of a 2022 Toyota Camry. A car that happens to have strong anti-theft features. In a state of desperation, I looked for locksmiths in my area. First Google ad that popped up for “Locksmith Redmond” seemed like a reputable website. To confirm their credibility, I looked up their Google reviews: 400 five star reviews. I requested the service, and twenty minutes later some dude turns up in a Ford Escape. He proceeds to “open the car” and quotes me $299 on the spot for simply opening the door. If you’ve dealt with anti theft on these Toyotas, you know this solves nothing. You can’t get into the trunk without disabling it. I refused immediately: are you insane? He started getting aggressive with me. It’s me and this dude, alone in a parking lot at 10 PM. Dude’s twice my size, I was terrified. Long story short, he didn’t get the money. It was a scam, a bait and switch. In my state of nerves, I fell for the reviews. I took a look at the reviews after the situation was resolved. Clearly fake reviews: same writing style, similar names. Only two or three people who actually exposed the scam. I’m a very tech savvy guy. I got screwed by fake reviews and Google ads this week. I have a feeling this measure won’t stop them.
- walrus01 3y agoLocksmiths, plumbing, electricians and other services in any major city are plagued by people whose actual business model is setting up a website, CRM system and pipeline to sell "hot leads" to shady trunk slammer type contractors. It's trivially easy to have a phone number that looks like it belongs to the area code for (your city here) but goes to a call center offshore. It's a whole well documented phenomenon.
- LordShredda 3y ago> Businesses would be prohibited from creating or controlling a website that claims to provide independent opinions about a category of products or services that includes its own products or services. This is literally designed to kill vpn review websites. All the major ones are owned by a couple of vpn mills
- gigglesupstairs 3y agoAnd the sundry video editing tools, pdf editors, random file converters etc. So many just mask their promotion strategies in the form of review blogs.
- JimtheCoder 3y agoIt will be interesting to see what "controlling" means. Can they "Sponsor" a site, and put a little tiny disclaimer on the bottom of the page, where no one ever looks, indicating this is sponsored content?
- dylan604 3y agoHell, they could put "Sponsored Content" above the article just like in news readers, and people will think it is legit news
- jvanderbot 3y agoI dont think it's designed to kill vpn review websites specifically. it'll sure catch those though.
- afavour 3y agoI’d be surprised if VPN providers were an area of prime focus. …but wouldn’t this description also include Amazon, with Prime brands at least? It sort of implies a separate site which would mean Amazon is fine, but it doesn’t say it outright.
- dcormier 3y agoMattress review sites, too.
- lolinder 3y agoFrom the proposed rule text [0]: > It is an unfair or deceptive act or practice and a violation of this Rule for a business to represent, expressly or by implication, that a website, organization, or entity that it controls, owns, or operates provides independent reviews or opinions about a category of businesses, products, or services including the business or one or more of its products or services. As I read it, the 5-star review systems on Amazon.com and Walmart.com would be categorized as unfair under this rule, since both companies sell their own products in addition to having a rating system on their website. I'm not sure whether that's intentional or not (and I could be misreading it, IANAL). [0] https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/r311003consumerreviewsandtestimonials_nprm.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/r311003consumer...
- scottshamus 3y agoI interpret that more as banning all of the shadier situations like the mattress companies that own “independent” mattress review sites.
- tough 3y agoI was thinking this but how the same 2-3 vpn providers own all the vpn review websites
- hrdwdmrbl 3y agoI suppose they would be required to work with an independent 3rd party that would manage the reviews. A little bit similar to the Credit Rating companies. IMHO it could be a good, kind of, separation of responsibility.
- crazygringo 3y agoNo, I don't think that's correct, either by the text or spirit. This isn't about user reviews, it's about editorial reviews where it is the website/organization itself that is doing the reviews. Think Wirecutter, Consumer Reports, and so forth (although those are fine). Basically when you search Google for reviews on e.g. an air purifier, you'll find a bunch of sites called things like "air-purifier-reviews.com" that seem to be a legitimate review site/blog at first glance (like Wirecutter), but are just a fake site created by the company whose products are recommended. Amazon and Walmart with their product listings and user reviews aren't anything like this. User reviews even for Amazon-branded products would continue just fine, although another rule indicates that Amazon couldn't selectively remove negative reviews for their own products (not that there's evidence they have, since there are plenty of terribly-rated ones alongside the good ones). It's also clear that Amazon wouldn't be able to e.g. create its own Wirecutter or Consumer Reports equivalent as long as it continued its own brands. And it probably means that Amazon wouldn't be able to continue its "Amazon editorial recommendations" which is a row that used to pop up in search results, but that they removed a couple of months ago [1]. [1] https://www.modernretail.co/technology/amazon-has-quietly-removed-editorial-recommendations-from-search-results/ https://www.modernretail.co/technology/amazon-has-quietly-re...
- eschaton 3y agoThis should already be prosecutable as wire fraud. Does an FTC rule make enforcement easier?
- jjtheblunt 3y agoi thought the same, then realized phone spammers are out of control still in the US, and they're not slowing down. What would actually work to shut these crooks down?
- janalsncm 3y agoHow about caning. It might seem foreign and extreme, but it works. A fine is just a cost of doing business. Even prison time would usually be spent at a minimum security prison perhaps even with work release. Barely a punishment. Those are just slaps on the wrist. You know what’s not a slap on the wrist? Caning. Caning would force these scammers to rethink their lives. It is used in Singapore as a punishment, a country widely seen as one of the least corrupt on the planet.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoOh, yes, good idea. Just track down wherever in the world the scammer lives, like Russia or Myanmar or Venezuela or something. Then you fly in a team of Navy Seals in a black helicopter to land at night on the roof of their tenement under cover of darkness. They storm in, restrain the scammer, and cane 'em real good with 39 whacks. Then they beat feet out of there before they can be detected or caught. You could GoPro all of this and then post it to a special "Cane of Shame" website. Exciting!
- jjtheblunt 3y agoCould skip all the actual action, and computer generate the same with "AI" and still run the Cane of Shame website.
- fmajid 3y agoChina, most likely. Good luck sending Navy SEALs without starting WW3.
- jimmygrapes 3y agoI have been asked (even recently) many times by upper management in various private companies, NPOs, and public industries alike to boost local visibility by submitting positive reviews to Yelp, Google, Foursquare, etc. recommending it as a place to work or talking up products/services offered. Often offered a reward for it, in some form or another. Think of a clerk at your local EBT office submitting a 5 star Google review saying "Excellent customer service and low wait times, [your coworker here] was caring and compassionate, just make sure you schedule an appointment online to avoid the lines!" or "I've worked here for X years and I cannot say enough great things about how wonderful and caring everybody is! I love helping the undeserved in my community!" Maybe it's a car repair shop doing the same. Maybe it's a fast food franchisee. Maybe it's a boutique store. It's definitely more than just Amazon or TripAdvisor reviews. I intend to present this proposed rule to my current management and let them sweat, because just this week I was told it is "highly recommended to help offset the fake reviews". I understand the struggle, though. People leave shitty 1 star reviews for spiteful purposes all the time, and that can hurt a small business or encourage unnecessary community discontent. I don't think there is any good solution on the SEO aspect, but I'm all for banning the scummy practices of astroturfing.
- Morluche 3y agoI worked in a company a few years back where marketing people faked "trust-worthy" software like trust pilot reviews by using everyone phones, or with different IPs. Nowadays a 4.5 average review is not even that good for a product
- kahnclusions 3y agoTrustpilot also has paid subscriptions where the business can pay to send "review invitations". So a shitty business can get a high aggregate score because they've gamed when to ask for reviews.
- barbariangrunge 3y agoIs this going to tackle all paid fake reviews, aka ads?
- davidguetta 3y agoIs it all affiliates programs actually ?
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoIronically, my landlord has been bugging me for the past few months to review them publicly. This is how they do it: I log in to my tenant portal to check if my account is current, and a full-screen modal dialog blocks my way, promising that I could win a $100 Amazon gift card if only I'd review them on some site I don't know. (And I'd probably need to create an account and jump through all the associated hoops.) So yeah, dudes, I don't use Amazon. Most gift card offers at least provide a choice of two, in case you don't shop with the place. And the dialog is still in my way, months later. That dialog is the only update they've made to the portal in years. In fact it still doesn't support MFA at all. But reviews!
- 111111IIIIIII 3y ago$100 Amazon gift card + security deposit
- jewelry 3y agoSo... no more free iced tea for a 5 star review?
- kordlessagain 3y agoAnd meanwhile we let any governing official to tweet whatever they like to their followers.
- jgerrish 3y agoThis isn't a review of a FTC show. It's not really my genre. It's a review of that classic 90s sub-genre of FCC, Net Neutrality. This is Net Neutrality 2015: Nettier and Neutrier, with Michael O'Rielly. Esteemed Chair O'Rielly's performance was fantastic as always. After the entirely authentic acting in the fake-out heist classic between President Obama and Tom Wheeler in the 2014 installment, O'Rielly really steals the show here with his honest portrayal of concern for free speech. Four stars. A slamming success as always. I really can't wait for the upcoming FTC show of "Automated Robo-caller Deleters from Outer Space". It will be dealt with in a balanced and classy manner as the posters claim. An honest reflection on space PBX robots and what they experienced. Do you want a sarcastic parody world? Anyways, this gets us closer to authenticated users everywhere, so that's actually a good thing. Many lives will be saved that day.
- jgerrish 3y agoI really do understand the plight of victims of scams. I know of a couple. I also see people hurt who were chased from communities, or are drawn into these kinds of things right here instead of just working on what they love.
- gelartidam4 3y ago[dead]
- fmajid 3y agoRules are fine, but there needs to be a self-sustaining enforcement program.
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agoClaiming that millions of people are using a product or service needs to be supported by data. Bandwagon manipulation is worse than individual testimonials.
- gemmabrian 3y ago[dead]
- carlotte 3y ago[dead]