7 ms·
Yeah I drink a lot of Pepsi Max. I just love it especially in summer. I've drank it for decades. Would this make me worry a lot? Not really. I have worse healt
by wkat4242 3y ago
Yeah I drink a lot of Pepsi Max. I just love it especially in summer. I've drank it for decades.
Would this make me worry a lot? Not really. I have worse health risks like being overweight, pfas etc.
The "if it was that dangerous we'd see the effect" is a pretty decent argument IMO considering it's been heavily used for almost 40 years.
- peteradio 3y agoWhat effects from the last 40 years might be missing attribution?
- throwawaymaths 3y agoAtmospheric nuclear testing
- labster 3y agoNot in the last 40 years, it was all before then.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoradioactive fallout never has long-lasting effects on the places they fall.
- grecy 3y agoCancer rates are rising rapidly. Soon 50% of people will have cancer. I’d say something is going on
- stopping 3y agoCitation?
- hunson_abadeer 3y agoSomething is bound to get ya. As we get better at managing other diseases and risks, cancer - which is seldom truly curable - gets a larger share. The progress on other fronts really is staggering. Forget pre-industrial times: global child mortality is half of what it was in the 1980s. The same is true for vehicle deaths in the US.
- uejfiweun 3y agoWell, I'd also say that as society continues to get more complex we're exposed to more and more previously-unknown substances, chemicals, and compounds. Kids used to play in the DDT mist sprayed by trucks. How many DDTs are there right now that we don't know about? I'd guess a whole lot.
- rnk 3y agoUltra and highly processed foods are terrible for us. Consuming so much more sugar than in nature seems to be bad for glucose intolerance. I love bacon but I try to resist ever having any. Don't buy meats with nitrates. We do have way more cancers, a big reason we know about is our food choices. We don't even know the impact of hard things to measure yet, like the impact of all these things on our gut biology. It's not a new discovery that eating a lot of sugary foods leads to greatly increased diabetes, and now we are learning more about how artificial sugars have their own impact. So basically, it's increasingly obvious that artificial sugar drinks are not good for you too, maybe in different ways than "natural sugars".
- jorvi 3y ago> I love bacon but I try to resist ever having any. Don't buy meats with nitrates. That is no way to live. In general, you should think about risk management, not exclusion. Have your bacon as a bi-monthly treat, and splurge for some high quality bacon at the butcher. I remember seeing a video of a talk where the host asked who was managing their health by going partially or fully vegetarian. Lots of raised hands. Then he asked who was sitting or standing still for extended amounts of time. Even more raised hands, including almost all of the previous group. And that’s a higher cancer risk than meat eating :)
- willis936 3y agoDoes this correlate with life expectancy?
- indymike 3y agoFrom NIH's National Cancer institute: * Approximately 39.5% of men and women will be diagnosed with cancer at some point during their lifetimes (based on 2015–2017 data). This is no where near 50% of people "having cancer". * The rate of new cases of cancer (cancer incidence) is 442.4 per 100,000 men and women per year (based on 2013–2017 cases). (.442%) * The cancer death rate (cancer mortality) is 158.3 per 100,000 men and women per year (based on 2013–2017 deaths) (.158%). Regardless, these numbers are very scary.
- mvkel 3y agoThis just says we're living longer, not that cancer is suddenly becoming an epidemic. Live long enough and you will get cancer.
- copperx 3y agoThose numbers have been about the same in the last two decades. The numbers have always been that high.
- Nathanba 3y ago40% is definitely near 50%
- mtmickush 3y ago"will have" infers a future present though. 40% will have at some point in their life is substantively different than 50% having at a single moment in time
- XorNot 3y agoThose numbers are context-less. Cancer is what happens to you if something else doesn't kill you first.
- rootusrootus 3y agoExactly this. The prevalence of cancer in my family is pushing 100%. However, the onset is almost always in the mid/upper 80s to early 90s. So it's not really that cancer is a problem for my family as much as it seems like living long enough to get killed by it is.
- cheekibreeki2 3y agoAnd if sweeteners were at play (sucralose also has scary new research) I couldn't see why the food industry, the paid off gov regulators and insurance companies would cover this up and short the involved companies.
- copperx 3y agoThe latest figures point to 1/3 of people in the world will die due to cancer, and the statistics always have been close to that. Where are you getting the 50% figure from?
- robjan 3y agoWe're getting fatter and sitting in a chair all day. It's pretty well known that lack of exercise is a significant cancer risk.
- gonzo41 3y agoWe're better at seeing cancer now. Maybe people used to get small cancers that just went away. Which sounds insane I know! But you can be perfectly health, get a body scan, find a lump of something doing nothing and then you're on the big C train all of a sudden.
- bruce511 3y agoIts worth noting that we all die of something. When I see stats that rank cause of death, I'd love to see it adjusted for age. It would be interesting if death rates had a cut-off. Don't tell me that 50% die of heart disease, rather exclude everyone over 70, then tell me percentages. For most of my life the largest causes of death are accidents and suicide, but equally the age-group either the highest rate are over 75s. Sure there ways to improve both quantity, and quality, of life. Smoking pretty obviously reduces both - its a good habit to quit, or not start. Chugging DDT is bad for you. But linking foods to longevity, where there is unconvincing evidence, isn't helpful to me. Especially when that food has significant quality-of-life benefits. Ultimately we all die of something. A death "saved" here, is a death "gained" there.
- tptacek 3y agoAren't you a Google search away from seeing that this is the opposite of the truth? I'm asking because I didn't look very hard, but I'm on IARC's dataviz site right now looking at a graph of cancer rates --- all causes excluding non-melanoma skin cancer --- sharply down since the '50s (no surprise, tobacco), and also down since the 1990s. You can find cancer sites that break that trend, like bladder cancer, but (for instance) that's down in the period between the introduction of aspartame and the mid-2000s. Moreover, if you specialize on GI cancers, it looks like you see the opposite of what you'd expect if aspartame was a potent carcinogen: the rates are lower in places where Diet Coke is more prevalent. Maybe I'm looking at the wrong numbers, but I really think this is a result some people on message boards just want to see.
- kelipso 3y agoDo you want to post that link if you're on the site? I'm guessing you're looking at cancer mortality rates rather than cancer diagnosis rates. Because while the former has decreased since 1950 due to improvements in treatment, I'm pretty sure the latter has risen since 1950.
- tptacek 3y agoI closed the tab since last night, but if you Google "IARC dataviz" you're probably going to get it as the first Google search result. It's a site IARC runs itself, with historical data visualizations.
- kelipso 3y agoRight it was as I thought. Cancer incidence rate was increasing since 1960 https://nordcan.iarc.fr/en/dataviz/trends?mode=cancer&multiple_cancers=1&key=asr&types=0 https://nordcan.iarc.fr/en/dataviz/trends?mode=cancer&multip... while cancer mortality rate was decreasing since 1980 https://nordcan.iarc.fr/en/dataviz/trends?mode=cancer&multiple_cancers=1&key=asr&types=1 https://nordcan.iarc.fr/en/dataviz/trends?mode=cancer&multip...
- AnomalousBean 3y agoWell, aspartame has been shown more recently and by studies not funded by the food industry to impair glucose tolerance in obese people. And soda cans are lined with plastic, so there's your PFAS intake.
- checkyoursudo 3y agoHave you seen the maps that show where there is PFAS contamination in ground water and surface water? You would be doing reasonably well if soda cans were the primary source of your exposure to PFAS. Also, here in Germany, I can get my aspartame in glass bottles, fortunately.
- wkat4242 3y agoYeah I'm sure it's bad but all things are "bad for you" these days.. I just don't really care that much. I mainly drink my sodas from PET bottles by the way because cans cost twice as much per litre over here.
- cookiengineer 3y agoI don't think it's a decent argument. You are using the "I was at the train station and I was never mugged there, therefore mugging never happens at train stations" extrapolated argument. People still think that smoking doesn't cause cancer, even when they are in the hospital because of not being able to breathe. People still deny that climate change exists because of that one bought study in the 60s. People still drink chlorified water and governments still are too lazy to use a biological cleaning process all over the world, even though it is proven that this increases cancer rates 2x as much. As the devil's advocate I'd argue that people will only change their behaviour if a person within their personal influence radius dies because of it. If they just read about it, they don't care.
- valec 3y agook, but if 10,000 people go to the train station and 2 get mugged instead of 1 at the bus stop, is it not fair to say it's still pretty safe?
- freshpots 3y ago"People still drink chlorified water and governments still are too lazy to use a biological cleaning process all over the world..." What biological cleaning process are you referring to? How does it prevent bacterial growth in the water distribution system?
- tomcam 3y agoMicroscopic chloroforms. I’m pretty sure they’re related to midi-chlorians. </joke>
- freshpots 3y agoThank you for telling everyone that you are not even remotely involved in water treatment, especially for those that are. No matter the treatment method, absolutely purified water can encounter pathogens. The water treatment process uses various methods to make water safe for consumption but the distribution system requires a residual for any biological contaminants that can enter, or be harbored within, and low concentrations of free chlorine (<2 ppm) provide that while carrying very little risk. Especially compared to most risks in modern life, like being in a passenger vehicle. Safe drinking water, partially due to chlorination is the greatest public health achievement of humanity so far. You are spreading misinformation.