4 ms·
Note: I originally said Britain built 30k houses last year, which commenters have corrected. Thank you! I don't really understand all this. Surely the main rea
by robertlagrant 3y ago
Note: I originally said Britain built 30k houses last year, which commenters have corrected. Thank you!
I don't really understand all this. Surely the main reason for a lack of housing is the difference between house demand (e.g. Britain took in 606k people in net immigration last year) compared to house supply (Britain built I think around 200k houses last year).
The state shouldn't need to build houses (in fact it doesn't; it just uses your tax money to pay private companies to build houses). It should just make the building and zoning rules simple enough that it's possible to make money from building houses and selling them, and let people get on with it.
- blakblakarak 3y agoThe state does need to make houses to provide for lower paid people who do critical jobs.
- mordae 3y agoLower paid... critical jobs... State. Hahaha. Can't we just ditch capitalism altogether? It can't even pay and provide housing to people who perform critical jobs. Or are we discussing building barracks for slaves?
- notahacker 3y agoYep, and people who don't do critical jobs or earn much at all tend to want somewhere to live too (and subsidising their private sector housing costs in areas with housing shortages usually costs more in the long run) Not really discussing the slowdown of building and mass-selloff of council owned housing since 1979 is a curious omission from an otherwise detailed description of public policy on housing. Private sector housebuilders have different incentives from public authorities, and maximising the profit from a site need not mean maximising the number of available homes (especially not given Britons with purchasing power were the original suburbanites). Nor does it mean building on all the limited supply of local land suitable for development at once, when it can be released in tranches (homebuilders have several years worth of plots with planning permission for every home they build in a year)
- nradov 3y agoWhich jobs are critical? What would happen if those people decided to take higher paid but less "critical" jobs?
- Detrytus 3y agoThat doesn't make sense: if your job is indeed "critical" you have enough leverage to negotiate higher pay, don't you?
- spacebanana7 3y agoAgree about the supply/demand difference causing the difference but I think your numbers are off. The UK build around 200k new 'dwellings' last year (financial year ending March 2022) according to [1] but I don't know whether that accounts for demolitions. [1] https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/housing/articles/ukhousebuildingdata/financialyearendingmarch2022 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/housing/...
- blitzar 3y ago> Britain built I think around 30k houses last year The latest house building statistics show that in the financial year ending March 2022 there were 204,530 dwellings completed in the UK. https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/housing/articles/ukhousebuildingdata/financialyearendingmarch2022 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/housing/...
- 88 3y agoWhen you consider there are decades of under supply to make up for, this is still a paltry figure.
- hsjqllzlfkf 3y agoStill doesn't excuse quoting a wrong figure. I for one appreciate the correction.
- robertlagrant 3y agoOh - fair. I can't remember where I got that figure from. It might've been a quarterly average. I'll amend, but noting the change.
- mordae 3y agoNot really. It would also have to tax hoarding them to prevent driving rents higher. Which would hurt landlords sitting in the Parliament. All 100% of them.
- pydry 3y agoThe problem is land. Land is not a normal commodity. Nobody makes it - all land rights are derived ultimately through legal fiat and violence, not labor. Somebody who consumes a lot of high value land doesnt create the conditions for making more like somebody who, say, buys a lot of cars. They just create more profits for nearby land owners. Hoarding drives more hoarding and higher prices in a positive feedback loop unless arrested via a tax. The elites can accomodate their market dysfunction by building public housing. They can neuter this market dysfunction by applying a steep land value tax (or by increasing property taxes). Or they can sit back and profit, parasitically extracting ever higher land rents from the real economy.
- dauertewigkeit 3y agoLand is fixed, but only valuable because of the location it is situated in. And what happens as the location is not fixed. You cannot make more land, but you can alter the value of locations with incentives and taxes and government programs. Part of the solution could be governments shifting people and jobs around to secondary less popular cities.
- robertlagrant 3y agoAlmost every company doesn't employ people in incredibly high price locations. They can't afford to. And some of the ones that can will sometimes move, but they'll do it for bottom up reasons, not for political, state-led ones. Also, the big contributor is Zoom. If you can work from anywhere, as some jobs can because of Zoom, you can live anywhere.
- lucideer 3y ago> The state shouldn't need to build houses (in fact it doesn't; it just uses your tax money to pay private companies to build houses). It should just make the building and zoning rules simple enough that it's possible to make money from building houses and selling them, and let people get on with it. This is the modern wisdom in the west - it's the approach taken by many governments since the Reagan era (not just in the UK) and it's demonstrably unsuccessful in almost every metric except one: votes. Which is the only reason it continues. It panders to those who already hold assets, while doing very little to move the dial for those who need shelter. Migration is not a new phenomenon; citing it as an excuse for the utter failure of modern housing policy is disingenuous.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoI cannot comment on other countries, but this is clearly not practiced in the US. The US has not simplified building and zoning rules or made them more permissive. The US follows the third option: do nothing and hope it fixes itself.
- danem 3y agoI'm confused... Are you arguing that zoning, red-tape, and generally anti-development politicians and voters aren't the fundamental problem here? How exactly do you envision a government housing program to side-step all of the above issues? Do you think voters who fight relentlessly to block development feel differently about public housing? How do you expect it to get funded even, when a single unit of "affordable housing" costs ~$1m to build in a place like San Francisco?
- lucideer 3y ago> Are you arguing that zoning, red-tape, and generally anti-development politicians and voters aren't the fundamental problem here? Minus the leading language (as I presume these so-called "anti-development" politicians don't self-define as such), yes, this is what I'm arguing. > Do you think voters who fight relentlessly to block development feel differently about public housing? I believe the tales of such voters are highly overstated, a really common red-herring used by advocates of private developer subsidy to deflect criticism. Do NIMBYs exist? Of course. But their impact is overstated, and overconflated with genuine concerns: there are valid reasons to object to new developments, though these have a tendency to be lumped in with less valid objectors for political gain/expediency. > How do you expect it to get funded even, when a single unit of "affordable housing" costs ~$1m to build in a place like San Francisco? Have you ever stopped to think about why it costs $1m to build such a unit in SF in 2023? About what system of incentives lead to the current status quo? I can assure you it wasn't decades of publicly-run projects.
- mavhc 3y agoAlso depends on the average number of people per house, and rate at which houses are destroyed. Why are we still building houses like it's 1800 though? Hand crafted houses built by local artisans are always going to be expensive
- nradov 3y agoConstruction costs are usually less then land acquisition costs. Housing developers are extremely efficient when they are allowed to build hundreds of identical units on a single large parcel. Most of the work can be done by unskilled laborers with artisans only doing the critical bits.
- Jochim 3y agoThere's a limited amount of space and a non-negligible portion of society are unable to afford market rates. When the state doesn't build accommodation, citizens end up transferring ludicrous amounts to private landlords to house foster children, asylum seekers, the poor, or the disabled. The UK experimented with selling off it's social housing in the 70s. It was a colossal failure that has lead to the country having some of the worst housing stock in Europe, with renters paying more for less. Private landlords have been enriched at the expense of the wider society. Without state intervention in housing regulation/supply we'd see shanty towns spring up fairly quickly, followed by violence. Refer to Champlain Towers, Grenfell Tower, or the collapsed luxury apartments in the Turkey earthquake to see what happens when the state does not do enough to ensure builders aren't building death traps.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> There's a limited amount of space and a non-negligible portion of society are unable to afford market rates. When the state doesn't build accommodation, citizens end up transferring ludicrous amounts to private landlords to house foster children, asylum seekers, the poor, or the disabled. Space is limited by regulation and zoning. 90% of the UK is rural. Market rates are high because of the supply not matching the demand, or being allowed to match it. Asulym seekers make up a small amount (3%?) of the people who we take in - e.g. in 2022 we took in 606k people, but under 20k of them were asulum seekers. > The UK experimented with selling off it's social housing in the 70s. It was a colossal failure that has lead to the country having some of the worst housing stock in Europe, with renters paying more for less. The same number of people would need housing, regardless of whether the houses were privately owned or state owned. > Without state intervention in housing regulation/supply we'd see shanty towns spring up fairly quickly, followed by violence. Refer to Champlain Towers, Grenfell Tower, or the collapsed luxury apartments in the Turkey earthquake to see what happens when the state does not do enough to ensure builders aren't building death traps. I don't understand this. I didn't say no regulation. But there's a huge gap between that and making it incredibly difficult to build. Citing some basic anti-zero regulation argument in response to what I said is disheartening.
- 3y ago
- bryanlarsen 3y agoFor comparison, Canada which has a population of 40M vs Britain's 86M built 286k homes in 2021. We took in 400K immigrants and 630K non-permanent residents in 2022. Not sure if those two numbers are additive, since I presume many non-permanent residents eventually become immigrants. The average price of a house in Canada is CAD716K vs £285K (=CAD480K) in the UK.
- Detrytus 3y agoyou made a typo, Britain's population is 68M, not 86.
- Arnt 3y agoI don't live in Britain and I don't know why too few houses are built there. I know something about the place where I live, which I'll not name because I don't think it's that special. Specifically, that houses are built if that seems profitable, or at the very least if the bank thinks the builder can earn enough to pay back the loan. The organisation that build/rebuilt/renovated the buildings across the street from me expected to earn that investment back in very roughly half a century. They considered it possible that they'd earn their investment back in 30 years, but unlikely. They managed to secure financing, though, and did the building. Not sure how they plan to pay the bank on time. You'll not be surprised to hear that this place too suffers from a lack of newly built housing.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> The state shouldn't need to build houses What is the basis for this belief? Every country that got people out of poverty, India, China and Singapore, has a massive state housing program. They work. We have results.