6 ms·
Formula E team caught using RFID scanner that got live tire data from other cars
- PeterStuer 3y agoAt first I was confused as I only ever saw Formula 1 races, where tires are replaced at every pit-stop, so info gained would be minimal, but it seems Formula E stipulates you can only use 1 set of tires for the entire race making the info strategic.
- tiernano 3y agoEven in f1, if the tyre changes, you could figure out the info based on ids and make a guess to which team you were reading the info from. Stuff like temps and pressures would be handy to know about from your competitors...
- notahacker 3y agoThink it'd be even more useful in F1, where timing of pit stops is all important, and the state of the tires is a strong indication of whether the other teams will be coming in very soon or holding on for a bit.
- joezydeco 3y agoWhat strategic information do you get from that, if the tire never changes? Like, what tire they chose for that particular race?
- gonehome 3y agoHow they’re driving will break down the tires at different rates. A driver may hold back to protect their tires to keep them in better shape in order to have more traction later when other people’s tires are shot. If you know the state of everyone else’s you could game this to be in a better position.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mabbo 3y agoThank you, that's exactly what I was confused by as well.
- PointyFluff 3y ago[dead]
- localplume 3y agoother cars should start using countermeasures. then maybe we can finally enter the electronic warfare era of formula racing which would be pretty interesting
- dgrin91 3y agoI'm surprised teams don't encrypt any of the data.
- pronoiac 3y agoDoes RFID allow for encryption? I'd thought they were too constrained re: power and cpu.
- bennettnate5 3y agoYour contactless credit card uses RFID; I sure hope it would use encryption :)
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoIt operates at a close distance to the reader and can collect more energy to run its electronics.
- bennettnate5 3y agoThis is a good point--my understanding is that it also takes a little longer to run than simple value-store RFID tags do (second(s) instead of milliseconds). Pressure sensors in tires might be far enough removed from the corresponding reader that encryption is not feasible for the RFID chip.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI thought contactless payment was less secure than chip. With a chip reader, the POS terminal powers the chip on the card to do encryption on the card. The POS terminal cannot access the private key on the card. Contactless is much lower power, and basically reads a one-time code for the transaction, and the card does not perform any encryption. Is that incorrect?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- asylteltine 3y agoProps for thinking outside of the box.
- entropie 3y agoHow does this work, RFID tags embedded in tyres? From https://www.tyrepress.com/2014/01/formula-e-tyres-to-feature-rfid/ https://www.tyrepress.com/2014/01/formula-e-tyres-to-feature... > “These RFID chips will be embedded in the tyres’ sidewalls to ensure their traceability, from their production right through to their return to the factory after use at the racetrack,” explains Serge Grisin, manager of Michelin Motorsport’s four-wheel programmes. “Traditionally, this information is collected using an optical bar code reader. These new electronic tags open up all sorts of possibilities in addition to simply identifying individual tyres. They will be able to collect data relating to running conditions including temperature and pressure sensors. It will be possible to record and access information covering the tyre’s entire lifecycle.” Identifying - sure. But how do they get temperature and pressure information? Is there a microcontroller embedded that writes stuff to the tag?
- w1nk 3y agoThis seems like (clearly?) bad journalism. RFID tags on their own are for sure not taking active sensor readings, that'd be left for something closer to TPMS style systems.
- ridgeguy 3y agoIt seems there are RFID tags that provide sensing functions. I didn't do a deep dive, here's the first thing I found. [1] They sense temperature, pressure, and other parameters. I wouldn't be surprised if something like this is used by tire makers. [1] https://www.atlasrfidstore.com/sensor-rfid-tags/ https://www.atlasrfidstore.com/sensor-rfid-tags/
- valianteffort 3y agoBut RFID are unique, read-only keys burned in to silicon at time of production. Perhaps the car is using Wi-Fi for TPMS.
- mh- 3y agoThey don't use Wi-Fi. There's a small battery-powered device mounted inside the tire, attached to the valve stem. In regular passenger vehicles, it's usually woken up regularly by a signal from the car. It takes sensor readings, and transmits them back to the car (using that region's unlicensed UHF bands). I imagine Formula teams may have need for greater frequency of sensor data, so there could be some variations here, but that's broadly how it works. In a passenger car, the battery outlives the tire. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_TPMS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_TPMS
- latchkey 3y agoThe tweet the article links to was deleted.
- joshu 3y agoi am assuming they are doing long range TPMS reading…
- pcdoodle 3y agoThis. Most TPMS can be read with an $29 SDR @ 433mhz. Not RFID, there's a little coin cell somewhere in the wheel.
- reportingsjr 3y agoRFID can still use batteries (called active vs passive RFID) for what it's worth.
- ris 3y agoIs there a rule against this? There shouldn't be - add an infosec element to Formula E!
- fluoridation 3y ago> the competitor had installed RFID scanning equipment in the pit lane entry this morning that was able to collect live data from all cars. Firstly, it is forbidden in general for competitors to install or place any equipment in the pit lane. Secondly, the collection of data by this method gives the competitor a lot of information, which is a huge and unfair advantage. I'm with you. To me, the second point is irrelevant. Something is either explicitly forbidden by the rules, or allowed by them. If doing this provides an unfair advantage then maybe there needs to be a new rule. To be honest, I think not making it a rule and letting everyone do it (as long as they can do it without breaking the rule on the first point) would make the game more interesting.
- brewdad 3y agoWell it was strictly forbidden. it is forbidden to install or place any equipment in the pit lane. Had they been reading this info from a device placed within their garage, it might have been a grayer area. I expect a full clarification and likely more explicit ban or such devices will be forthcoming.
- slater 3y agoIt's in the article: "it is forbidden in general for competitors to install or place any equipment in the pit lane"
- mabbo 3y agoTo those who wonder why this would even matter, it's worth considering how narrow the margins are in any racing sport. You're talking about a 80-100km race where winner is ahead by typically only a few seconds. If you can squeeze a 0.1% gain out of some key info, you'll do far better for it. Your driver is about to try to pass the driver ahead if him. How hard should he try? Pushing hard uses up your tires and energy. If you know the guy ahead has tires that are getting a bit worn, you know he won't fight very hard. That's a big advantage.
- voisin 3y agoWhy don’t they just make all the info fully transparent to all teams? Seems like it would make the competition even more interesting.
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoPoker wouldn't be too interesting if all players saw each others' cards. Same with racing. Keeping your opponent(s) constantly guessing is increasing the challenge and the fun of the sport.
- oatmeal1 3y ago> Your driver is about to try to pass the driver ahead if him. How hard should he try? Pushing hard uses up your tires and energy. If you know the guy ahead has tires that are getting a bit worn, you know he won't fight very hard. That's a big advantage. It's not totally clear, but it seems like this would only gather data when the opponent car entered the pit lane. In that case, the knowledge gained would just be knowledge about competitors' tires during practice, since during the race the tires aren't changed. That could be extrapolated to what the competitors' tire setup for the race, and performance of tires during the race are.
- exabrial 3y agoSo? This is way formula racing sucks. Too many stupid rules.
- theflyingkiwi42 3y agoThey didn't get live data, just the tire type. Shouldn't have had the device but it wasn't live data. Bad journalism as usual.
- zardo 3y agoThey should just mark the tires so you can tell at a glance. It's great fodder for the commentators to go on about the different tire choices each team made.
- ChuckNorris89 3y ago>They should just mark the tires so you can tell at a glance. They do. Pirelli F1 tires are color coded so anyone can tell at a glance what compound it is. Not sure why FE is different.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- brewdad 3y agoFE uses only one type of tire and it’s the same tire for everyone. They are probably closest to, but distinct from, the Inter tires used in damp conditions in F1.
- mvdtnz 3y agoNo surprise from Penske. They have a culture, across numerous categories, of pushing boundaries like this.
- theflyingelvis 3y agoIn auto racing, if you’re not cheating you’re not trying.
- activiation 3y agoHOWTO turn a disposable camera into an RFID-killer: https://boingboing.net/2006/01/27/howto-turn-a-disposa.html https://boingboing.net/2006/01/27/howto-turn-a-disposa.html