7 ms·
Car quality is suffering as automakers shift focus to technology
- mupuff1234 3y agoI still don't get why our cities are populated with full sized cars and not 1-2 person cheap electric cars.
- api 3y agoKids. That’s usually two people plus (for young kids) a stroller, diaper bags, food, other gear, maybe toys… Then you want to be able to also take their friends… If you are young and hip and wonder why some aspect of the suburbs or transport is so absurdly oversized or badly designed, the answer is probably kids and you are not seeing it because you don’t have kids.
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago> you don’t have kids. Or rich enough to live in walkable neighborhoods.
- noelwelsh 3y agoWalkable does not imply expensive. If it does, that's a (local government) policy choice.
- ajmurmann 3y agoTo my constant dismay, that's the government choice in much of the US these days.
- api 3y agoIn the US walkable means either unsafe or very expensive or occasionally both. Changing this would be very challenging because we have also decided that real estate should be an investment. This means it should always go up, which orients urban planning toward making housing unaffordable. The primary role of the car is driving further away to escape rent extraction, which is sharply at odds with making cities walkable. The only way to have a walkable city that is affordable is to get those crime rates up. Maybe that’s what SF is trying to do. But even that doesn’t work if you have people like OpenAI locating there and making people work in the office and paying $300k+ entry level.
- noelwelsh 3y agoI'm eagerly awaiting the urban planning renaissance in Memphis, then :-) (Highest violent crime rate for a large city in the US.) Though violent crime is dropping over time, there was a resurgence following COVID. I couldn't find any statistics on whether that is sustained or has since started to decline.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoIn CA it is.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoI am not aware of a single walkable city or town in the US that is not expensive.
- indymike 3y agoI'd love to have a light, inexpensive electric (or even ICE) I can use to transport kids. It would save my family thousands of dollars per year. I don't need the tons of metal.
- eigenhombre 3y agoA lot depends on the size of your kids, and the layout of your neighborhood, and your local climate. In my neighborhood (south side of Chicago) a lot of people schlepp their kids around on the back of bikes (electric or otherwise), either long bikes with a[n extra] seat on the back, or with a trailer, or both. Not sure how that stands safety-wise, but it sure is a lot lower-impact than even my Prius hybrid. Anecdata, but I feel like I'm seeing more of these families lately. edit: add clarifying word
- dmbche 3y agoI mean why not get a used Corolla for something like 4k? Maybe 5k? I don't know how much you are spending, but an old Toyota will be reliable past 200 000 miles, easy and cheap to repair, and you can find one that was a one owner car, ideally a grandma or priest. You might be interested in the Suzuki Mirage as well. If you are stressed about reliability, don't worry. You need to do regular maintenance (oils, fluids, filters, tires) and you'll stay on the road longer than brand new cars. I had a Chevrolet Aveo that had the radiator blow up while leaving the dealer!
- ajmurmann 3y agoI understand this argument, but genuinely wonder how this works in European cities. Maybe it's because in cities most people just take the stroller on the subway?
- noelwelsh 3y agoThe transport infrastructure very much determines this. If you live in a city with good public transport you don't need a car. I have two kids and live in the UK. When the kids we born we got a car but didn't need it much as many places were accessible by light rail, in a place with ok (but not great) public transport. Then we moved to a place that was badly connected and had two cars. Now we've moved to somewhere with better transport and the kids are old enough they can cycle just about anywhere they're interested in going. Going to sell one of the cars soon.
- lm28469 3y ago> I want X, Y, Z and I can't live without A, B, C and also I really like 1, 2, 3 Well yeah sure... that's why we completely fucked up the world in less than 100 years. It doesn't really qualify as an answer though. Plenty of places, and times, where people had kids and no cars, you only """need""" a car now because we built everything around them.
- mozman 3y agoCars have a purpose - people get older, they are disabled, and they want to shop and not carry things. There is a lot of anti car sentiment here these days but many people depend on their cars and that won't change soon.
- nehal3m 3y agoThe default reply here would be that people depend on cars because we've built our world that way.
- ajmurmann 3y agoThe parent was wondering why we don't have smaller cars, not why we have cars at all. Especially for older people whose kids are out of the house, a car for 1-2 people would make a lot more sense. My answer would be that if you only have one car, you buy what accommodates the likely maximum use case. So you buy a car that is sufficient when you have out-of-town visitors to chauffeur or buy something bulky. If car rental was more seamless and common outside of travel elsewhere we might be able to shrink cars. Another factor is feeling safe. I'd love to commute in a single-seater like the Toyota iRoad, but would be terrified between massive pickup trucks.
- adhesive_wombat 3y ago> If car rental was more seamless and common Just not eye-wateringly expensive would be a start. Though, having met people, I can see why renting cars to people can't be a cheap business to be in.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoand, as was pointed out to me here on HN a few months back, it is extremely hard to rent a vehicle under terms that allow you to tow anything, so if you haul that camper/5th-wheel or the yard trailer just once or twice a year, you pretty much have to own a vehicle that can do that, rather than the small car that would be a better fit for the vast majority of the time.
- lm28469 3y ago
- pixl97 3y agoBecause the average American house is huge.
- indymike 3y agoRegulation requires mass for survivability in crash tests.
- sottol 3y agoI _think_ this was sarcasm, but... Not as far as I know. Full-size SUVs used to be classed as trucks and (were?) exempt from many safety tests and standards. They used to have the worst safety ratings, actually, despite mass. Modern engineering and production with multi-material crash zones also means the mass is not necessary. Plus, smaller cars don't kill everyone involved in the accident outside of your car. People are just like "my car is bigger than yours", aka super-size me.
- jjoonathan 3y agoSurvivability in crashes requires mass. It's a race to the bottom (top) unless we figure out how to head it off with better regulation.
- one_level_deep 3y agoI think we are in a loop. All the cars are big, so the only way to feel safe when driving is to have a big car. Just look at Ford trucks. The current Ranger is as big as the old F-150. Everything is a quad cab, 20 years ago those were rare.
- tcfhgj 3y agoRegulations are less restrictive for SUVs because they are supposed to be used for work stuff
- dmbche 3y agoLot of people are outside the city, and lots of countries are very, very large - the US is a good example. Americans drive double what europeans drive in a year!
- Maschinees 3y agoFor me it's simple: my company ev car came only in SUV version for longer range and I use it only on the weekend for longer trips. Unfortunately getting into my car is much nicer than in small cars. A critical factor when you are getting older
- nforgerit 3y agoCan't find it anymore but I've watched a documentary claiming that Henry Ford and other car makers, oil companies and tire manufacturers in US and Europe lobbied city mayors over 100ys ago to get rid of perfectly fine public transport in favor of private cars. It felt ridiculous that we're still falling for that propaganda.
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoEven Jeremy Clarkson knows rear seats are hardly ever used: https://youtube.com/watch?v=wjnxDSMjh5I https://youtube.com/watch?v=wjnxDSMjh5I Though I imagine most journeys with children in the back aren't made on motorways.
- layer8 3y agoRelated discussion two days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36441054 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36441054
- nonethewiser 3y agoCars are trending towards a consumer electronics lifecycle.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lttlrck 3y agoFor that to be true reliability needs to trend upwards and the price needs to trend downward. Over time the former is true. The latter seems to be out of control, the lower cost segment is vanishing.
- LapsangGuzzler 3y agoCar touchscreen UX still feels 15 years behind in a lot of cases. I was driving in my brand new Subaru the other day when a full screen message pops up that I have a message from the manufacturer and a disabled button that says something like “stop the vehicle to see the message”. I had been navigating with Google maps and CarPlay and this pop up completely obstructed my map. I pull over to read the message and it’s a bleeping reminder that I need to schedule my maintenance appointment. It so half-baked, totally could’ve been an email.
- jjoonathan 3y agoI can't wait until this happens for an ad.
- qbrass 3y agoIt was technically an ad for their service centers.
- jjoonathan 3y agoShit, you're right. I've become too desensitized. This sucks.
- sandworm101 3y agoQuick solution: Pull over on the highway shoulder. Get rear-ended by a truck. Get injured. Sue the car company on the basis that their distracting in-car, while-driving, notice system contributed to the accident. Whether you win or lose, that will be the end of such popups.
- dgfitz 3y ago“Quick” and lawyers/court are antonyms.
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoOnly if the cost of provably caused-by-touchscreen accidents that the company can't blame the user for ("users should only use the car systems in accordance with local laws") exceeds the savings they think they're making by doing everything in software plus the data and affiliations like Spotify integrations they think they can monetise.
- sandworm101 3y agoCar quality is suffering because people treat their cars like junk. Too many people lease. Too many people are driving cars they don't actually own. Too many people see cars as temporary. A growing number see them as "necessary evils" and treat them like a bad habit that we all should kick asap. That attitude means people don't care about their vehicles. Cars are no longer partners that you trust year after year. People once grew attached to their cars. People remembered important life events based on which car they were using at the time. When you don't care about something you aren't going to take pride in it. You aren't going to maintain it yourself. You aren't going to demand proper engineering or design. Cars are now just a commodity, something to be used and tossed aside. Current design reflects that attitude.
- api 3y agoSounds like enshittification comes for cars. It’s a death spiral too. Cars get less reliable -> people lease and don’t care about cars -> cars get less reliable.
- Covzire 3y agoI think the kinds of quality issues people are taking issue with are primarily with the power-trains. No doubt some other features have seen disappointments especially the infotainment systems like you said though. Toyota only recently introduced a brand new Truck engine which replaced their previous 5.7L naturally aspirated V8. Presumably because they sell a lot of smaller cars they were able to keep the 5.7 for so long, it got worst-in-class gas mileage. But their clients loved that engine and there's only one reason you completely ditch a SKU the vast majority likes, emission standards. It's all being driven by emission standards. I'm not saying that's a totally bad thing either, I'm hoping to one day walk down a busy street and not have to breath in toxic fumes. But I think we all should know what the actual cause is that's helping drive car prices up and predictability/dependability down.
- lttlrck 3y agoIt's a good point. Where a larger normally aspirated engine would have sufficed manufacturers have shifted to smaller turbocharged engines that are significantly more complicated, more mechanical strain on the core engine, more mechanical parts, more cooling, more hoses, valves and electronics to control it all. Due to emissions. And hybridization on top of that. ICE is at the end of the road. Consumers and manufacturers are between two stools - a huge course correction. It'll take at least another decade, probably two before it's completed.
- programmertote 3y agoOwner of a CRV 2022. On my recent 200-miles trip, the tire pressure sensor lighted up. I pulled over to a station and filled the air (and before I filled the air, I measured the pressure on each tire and it was fine). It didn't go away. Had anxiety the whole trip about whether there was a leak in any of the four tires. After the trip, went to the dealership's workshop (btw, if you live in FL, NEVER EVER buy from Rick Case; they are scammy as hell in terms of pricing the cars as well as the maintenance fees). They said the pressure sensor sometimes got triggered and it needs the electronic reset to make it go away. I think these electronification of cars is going too far and I'm really afraid in the future, I'd have to go to the dealership's workshop to get any minor glitch fix.
- sandworm101 3y agoDon't go to a dealer. Go to a tire shop. They will know more about the problem and will be far more willing to tell you what is actually wrong. You may just need a new sensor battery.
- programmertote 3y agoYep. I went to Rick Case for annual check up to have a feel. I signed up online for a regular oil change (I have 6K miles on the car because we don't drive a lot) and tire rotation. The online quote was $90. When I arrived, the guy (expert consultant or whatever they call them) said he recommends me to do wheel alignment (and the quote was $110 without tax and other fees). I pushed back and said I only want tire rotation and oil change. Then he started looking a bit displeased (as if I dare challenge his authority). So I decided to go for it (in case he put a secret note on the paper to let the guys in the workshop know to do/not do something to my car). Then I swore myself I'll never go back to Rick Case again for regular maintenance (I'm going to have to find a good mechanic though, which is kind of tricky, but I'll do it out of my hatred of Rick Case). I had a horrible buying experience with them too (their finance guy trying to sell me $2600 'umbrella' insurance package, which when I pressed him, didn't specify anything it covers. I didn't end up taking it and the finance guy looked pissed (but I didn't care because the amount of money, $2600, is non-negligible).
- 3y ago
- kbos87 3y agoPersonally speaking I want my car quality and my car interior to be good enough, and the tech to be great. I have a year and a half old Tesla and despite all the complaining about build quality I hear, I haven’t had a single issue. The interior is simple, comfortable, and has fewer components that will eventually break. It’s good enough. Why I love the car is the tech. Self driving completely aside, the software is fantastic, thoughtful, and always getting better. Contrast that with the BMW SUV I recently rented while on vacation. BMW seems like it’s at the complete opposite end of the spectrum. It’s loaded with buttons and physical accoutrements that they charge for as premium upgrades. When it came to the tech, it was absolutely maddening and was the single reason why I’d never buy one. Just finding and connecting to CarPlay was nearly impossible, buried 10 pages deep in a buggy and unresponsive interface. This is representative of my experience with almost every traditional auto manufacturer and I rarely see any signs of progress. If “software is eating the world”, it’s barely begun in the auto industry.
- Maschinees 3y agoTesla gives you less for more because / through there ev risk and fast charger network. Bmw can't do that. They are bought because of everything you don't care for. I don't mind it either because even an not so we'll build Tesla is still much better what was build 30years ago. We solved the 'how to build a car's It's still shitty if you rip of the sun shield plastic holder when you use it. Which I did as a passenger.
- kbos87 3y agoThe downvoting without any context or feedback as to why is so predictable on any post that’s remotely positive about Tesla on HN :)
- h2odragon 3y agoI feel like automobile quality peaked around 1995-2005; probably on the earlier side of that range. They used to make little roller skate cars that got 50MPG, and expected to run for 200k+ miles. We have two small trucks from that era, 250k on the Dodge and approaching 400k on the Toyota. We're weird people who treat our cars as pets tho.
- dmbche 3y agoI've started watching Regular Car Reviews on youtube recently - he waxes poetic about those cars, it's just beautiful to hear. Really was a nice time.
- katbyte 3y agoNewer Toyotas still last forever and are not full of gimmicky tech, well at least some of them. I expect my tacoma to just keep going and going
- brandonmenc 3y agoI also have a Toyota from that era - 2000 4Runner with 200k miles. The fanciest things in it are power windows and locks. At least once a month I get approached asking if I want to sell it. Sometimes it's a note taped to the windshield, other times the potential buyer will walk right up to me. A couple weeks ago, a group of car enthusiasts driving their custom classic hot rods asked if I wanted to sell. Obviously car experts and mechanics. One guy in the group said he also had a 4Runner from the same era with 300k miles and marveled that they last forever. I'll never sell it. There's something very freeing about driving a completely untethered car that lacks all the modern bells and whistles.
- cvccvroomvroom 3y agoKeep it. It will last 500k-1M miles. Simplicity and reliability are king. The new ones have all plastic bumpers and grills that degrade in 10 years. The absolute worst are the new Lexuses.
- Brian_K_White 3y ago3rd gen 4runner ftw. '97 myself. Manual. I love it but I live in NJ so it's rusting out. So I've been thinking about a new one, but I dread trying to find a new vehicle that doesn't essentially have all the same things I think are terrible about a Tesla. I test drove a 2020 4runner a few years ago and hated it. By now all cars made by anyone seem to be software defined, with software you have no control over.
- dmbche 3y agoHow hard would it be for a company to start manufacturing small, barebones cars, compliant with safety and emissions, 4 seat, 4 door harchback and a 2 door version? Barebones meaning single/double din radio, hand crank windows, no cameras. Oh and if I may, no CVT, and made for easy access to parts. Oh and a transmission fluid dipstick. Oooh and a cheaper manual version. Selling something like that for..say 10k? Less maybe? I guess it won't work since it's competing with the second hand market..but people would like a new car, feels more reliable. Oh it'd be so nice. Edit: Oh and put the oil filter UNDER the engine, so when you remove it the engine isn't covered in oil.
- erikw 3y agoA lot of Japanese Kei cars fit that description, and they are available in every big market except the United States. I like to daydream about an alternative universe in which Suzuki was still operating in the US.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Ingon 3y agoI believe US requires you to have a backup camera, so probably won't be void of one (and its screen). But I would love to see a relatively small hatchback with manual, reliable and bare bones.
- Xenoamorphous 3y ago
- bilsbie 3y agoThere’s got to be a market for a “dumb” car. Bare minimum computers (and easily replaceable) for emissions and safety. And then nothing else. Just a 1980s UI, no connectivity, and easy to repair. I wish Tesla would make that actually. I’d bet they could shave 10k off the price?
- nunez 3y agoI think most OEMs still made base models that are super duper basic?
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI enjoy tech where it is a considerable improvement over the "non tech" version. But I despise tech that's just there because it's "cool" but doesn't add any considerable value, or actually makes the experience worse. Case in point, auto windshield wipers. I live in a place that gets a lot of "misty rain", and the wipers don't turn on in this situation until it's well too late, so I have to turn them on manually in any case. The options for my wipers are only "auto high" and "auto low" and "manual high" and "manual low", but there is no intermittent setting, which is what I want half the time. I basically don't understand the problem auto wipers are trying to solve in the first place. Who forgets to turn on their wipers if they can't see out their windshield? Is the tiniest tap to turn on the wipers really a burden that needs to be solved, never mind that I'm tapping that button way more with my auto-wipers than I ever did in older cars with normal intermittent wipers.
- pandaman 3y agoAuto wipers have two applications: for when you suddenly get water on the windshield, for example a splash from a puddle caused by another car, and for speed attenuation during a rain. Some people can panic when the visibility from the car suddenly goes to zero and might not be able to manually turn on wipers quickly, while still driving without seeing anything in front. The attenuation keeps driver from playing with the wiper speed control in an intermittent rain, thus not getting more distracted from driving.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> The attenuation keeps driver from playing with the wiper speed control in an intermittent rain, thus not getting more distracted from driving. Except, at least in my experience, this never works well for my car, especially in a light rain, causing me to have to get more distracted just turning my "auto" wipers on manually.
- pandaman 3y agoLooks like it's a problem with your car and not with the concept of auto-wipers?
- albertopv 3y agoDamn true from my experience. I own 16yo VW Golf 5 that is mechanically superior to a brand new Golf 8 with equal engine power, to get same rear suspensions system you have to buy a much more expensivemodel. My 235000 kms car still has original clutch. This just doesn't happen anymore, but prices went up by a lot even with cheaper solutions.
- dmbche 3y agoI read somewhere that since today cars are made with computer aided design, and parts can have their usage simulated for cheap, manufacturers make their cars to last just as long as necessary - and the average car owner keeps their car for 6 years (!!) before changing. So they get away with putting faulty parts in the cars because they are able to make them last juuust long enough for the original owner to be satisfied and them be a piece of doodoo on the used market. It's also touted as "less wasteful" since they treat the 6 year ownership as something enforced by the consumers (i.e. even if the cars lasted longer they wouldn't kee them longer than 6 years), it wouldn't make sense to make the cars to last longer. Like if we were building houses to last for 500 years instead of just 100, it'd be wasteful (?)...I guess?
- thayne 3y agoThat completely ignores the fact that most cars have multiple owners. If the average time to keep a car is 6 years, and the average car has at least 2 owners, that means it needs to last 12 years. But of course the carmaker doesn't have much of an incentive to car about people who buy it used. Maybe that needs to change somehow. Maybe some kind of requirement for much longer warranties?
- snapplebobapple 3y agoIts not just tech, its also the push for better gas mileage that caused a switch from metal to plastic parts, among of weight reduction for reliability trade offs.
- RickJWagner 3y agoDodge, Ram and Alfa Romeo are the top 3 brands in terms of quality? I double checked to make sure this wasn't an April 1st article.
- doubled112 3y agoI have a 2013 VW diesel, and if the quality trend continued from 2002 (last one I owned) until then, I can see why they're at the bottom. What junk!