7 ms·
NHTSA: Car crashes cost Americans $340B
- rootusrootus 3y agoA little context would make this figure more meaningful. Like how much productivity resulted from having cars to begin with.
- alexfromapex 3y ago[flagged]
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoThis is the NHTSA. Not their job, and not their expertise even if it was.
- alexfromapex 3y agoEven the corruption within their purview is probably enormous.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoTheir total yearly funding just increased to $1.5 billion, or less than 0.5% of the $340 billion cost they are publishing here. https://www.nhtsa.gov/bipartisan-infrastructure-law https://www.nhtsa.gov/bipartisan-infrastructure-law
- afavour 3y agoWhataboutism at its finest
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago"Whataboutism" is overused, like most other dismissive criticisms. I don't see anyone accusing the GP, or GPs allies, of causing this $340 billion in costs, therefore redirecting from it is not "whataboutism". The GP was rightfully flagged, but their complaint seems to be that they either don't care about this cost in particular, and would prefer a focus on an analysis of costs due to government corruption, or just that they care about both, and want the government corruption analysis next.
- alexfromapex 3y agoDo you not see the irony in saying this?
- batter 3y agoHave a feeling that pushing security as priority is not trivial task. Even in cars: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=glmcMeTVIIQ&pp=ygUbdGhlIGZpZ2h0IGFnYWluc3Qgc2VhdGJlbHRz https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=glmcMeTVIIQ&pp=ygUbdGhlIGZpZ2h...
- rapatel0 3y agoMakes me wonder why I pay 2600/year in insurance
- lotsofpulp 3y agoWouldn’t that be part of “costing Americans”, even if it flows through insurance premiums? Also, my maxed out liability only insurance for 5k miles per year is ~$50 per month, $600 per year. For an extra $2k per year, I assume you have significantly more comprehensive/collision coverage, miles, and/or prior incidents on your driving record? For some savings, I always tell people to drop personal injury protection or reduce it to lowest legal amount if you have ACA compliant health insurance, since your healthcare costs would be covered by health insurance anyway.
- runjake 3y agoAs a point of reference, I pay around $140 a month for home insurance and comprehensive auto insurance. But I’m older and haven’t had a ticket in 15-20 years. Western US, if it matters.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI also have no tickets in 15+ years, and also western US in a suburb.
- sixothree 3y agoZip code plays a huge part in the cost of your insurance.
- throwaway22032 3y agoFrom what I read it sounds like Americans repair their cars more thoroughly than Europeans. Most people I know unless they have a particularly fancy car just leave the little scratches, dents, dings etc and do functional repairs only. Spending thousands on a paint job is car enthusiast territory.
- AnotherGoodName 3y agoI feel there's a huge amount of status put into cars in America too. Perhaps due to extremely effective marketing.
- thanksgiving 3y agoThere is just a lot of shaming going on even today. There's an Instagram story I just saw where some influencer was making fun of software developers showing how the apartments of typical software developers who make USD 100k, 200k, 300k, and 400k make and they were a. twin mattress on the floor, b. two twin mattresses side by side on the floor, c. full size mattress of the floor, d. full size mattress with fitted sheet on the floor. I mean ok, what's wrong with that? If someone has a mattress on the floor what does it hurt? It is made to look like organic "content" but I am positive it is boosted by some marketing firm somewhere if I saw it even though I don't follow the influencer. Point is, there are a lot of really smart people working really hard to separate Americans from their money. Full disclosure: I, too, had a mattress on the floor a few years back so maybe I am taking it too seriously.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoMy mattress is on the floor right now, but it has a fitted sheet.
- shortcake27 3y agoIt’s just typical consumerism. Most people in Western culture are brought up to believe you need to have stuff to be happy. Especially in America. You need to live in a big house with way more space than you need, then you need to fill that space with stuff. Then that stuff gets old so it needs to be replaced with new stuff every few years. The more this is perpetuated via mocking people who don’t have stuff, the better it is for companies who make stuff. A bed frame is the perfect example of stuff. The average western person believes this is a necessity even though it has no function. Especially the ones without storage. Yet if you sleep on the floor you will be mocked. People will scoff. “You’re an adult you need to buy a bed frame”. Why? Why would I spend money and consume resources on something that has absolutely zero benefit?
- megablast 3y agoEver year. Important part of headline is missing. > The total translates to $1,035 in extra costs incurred by each and every American due to increased medical and automotive insurance premiums for everyone, property damage, lost market productivity, and increased taxes to fund public services like first responders. The amount we have adopted cars is ridiculous. And there really is little need. I have lived all over with no car. Most cities used to have awesome tram networks that were dismantled to please drivers.
- bluGill 3y agoThe trams were dismantled before the car took over. They were mostly expensive and didn't provide the freedom that cars do. (They could provide it, but only with a much larger network)
- digdugdirk 3y agoUnfortunately, they were dismantled so the car could take over. Many city streetcar systems that were struggling in the great depression were purchased by a group of automakers (including General Motors) and chemical companies and then closed down. From my recollection, the goal was to remove the streetcar systems and increase adoption of buses and automobiles, thereby profiting on the sale of buses and tyres.
- bluGill 3y agoThe important point is they were already struggling first.
- bpodgursky 3y ago> I have lived all over with no car. You've actually only lived in a couple very small, very homogenous, places at the center of dense mass-transit networks.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoIt goes the other way too. Cities/states now tax cars to fund trains/trams. https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/bridge-toll-hike-18166429.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/bridge-toll-hik...
- version_five 3y agoHow much value do cars add to the economy? And what's the incremental cost of reducing the number of accidents? Without any context it's just alarmism.
- rolldat777 3y agoWhat are the additional costs of cars and their infrastructure when there are more efficient options for transportation?
- bluGill 3y agoIrrelevant, we don't have those other systems. Invest in them first. Places like NYC have a start, but they don't make good investments in more. Other cities are trying, but have a lot of work to go.
- doubled112 3y agoWhat happens when there is a bunch of investment and they still mess it up? https://www.tvo.org/article/ottawas-colossal-lrt-debacle-a-brief-ish-history https://www.tvo.org/article/ottawas-colossal-lrt-debacle-a-b... Many working people I know who used to take transit before bought cars after the LRT came in.
- bluGill 3y agoLots of places are like NYC and not making good investments. Which is why cars are likely to dominate for the foreseeable future.
- 13of40 3y agoThe bigcorp I used to work for provided every employee with a bottomless metro card that could get you a free bus or train ride anywhere in a 20 mile radius. I would guess that maybe 1 in 5 people ever used it. Give someone enough disposable income that they have a choice between a 20 minute ride with their favorite podcast on the stereo vs. a 40 minute ride lurching along with a bunch of strangers and people tend to pick the first one. Our VP, to her credit, did take the bus every day, though.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- czx4f4bd 3y agoI hate that this article doesn't link to the original report. I found it here: https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/traffic-crashes-cost-america-billions-2019 https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/traffic-crashes-cost-am...
- dang 3y agoThanks! We changed the URL to that from https://www.thecarconnection.com/news/1138400_nhtsa-car-crashes-cost-americans-340b-or-1-035-per-person https://www.thecarconnection.com/news/1138400_nhtsa-car-cras.... Submitters: "Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter." - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- kderbe 3y agoThis blog post is mostly a rephrasing of NHTSA's press release (from January 2023): https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/traffic-crashes-cost-america-billions-2019 https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/traffic-crashes-cost-am... The press release has a link to the full report.
- metaphor 3y agoRelevant data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners can be found here[1] as well. [1] https://content.naic.org/article/naic-releases-2019-2020-auto-insurance-database-report https://content.naic.org/article/naic-releases-2019-2020-aut...
- dang 3y agoThanks! changed now - more at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36463897 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36463897
- screye 3y agoThe economic percent loss of value due to car accidents, per capita is likely the same around the world. What stands out is the extraordinary rate of vehicular deaths and serious accidents in the US. [1] [2] Yes, everyone knows it's high. But, 5x the traffic accident and fatality rate of other comparable developed countries is unforgivable. Now high car crash numbers are bad enough, but their breakdown is even worse. It is the primary driver of child death [3]. Cars don't just kill other car-drivers. They kill every type of road user, while the others barely register, even when normalized per capita. [4] [5] Ironically, bigger and safer cars make both the driver and the roads a lot less safe as the prisoners dilemma means everyone loses. [6][7] And these are just the numbers. There are insidious cultural patterns that appear when cars are the only way to travel. The US has a shocking cultural acceptance of DUI. I don't blame them. If the only way to party is to go downtown 20 miles away, and an uber is 75$ each way, then people start making dumb decisions. No one follows the speed limit, frequently exceeding it by 100% in slow neighborhoods. [8] Stop signs are considered optional across the country and the assumption is always that 'might makes right'. I have learnt to never engage with a pick-up truck on a road, and never to trust a car to stop just because you have the right of way as a cyclist/pedestrian. Old people, sick people, the sleep-deprived, 15 year olds, and the soon-to-be-blind all drive in the US, no matter how suited for it. Because the other options are so much worse. Ofc they're out there running over people. What did you expect would happen? The article tries to quantify the damage done by cars with the least relevant metric : "$$". As bad as those numbers look, the economic damage is in fact the most charitable way to look at damage done by car culture in this country. [1] https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Fk7HavRaYAMRa_w?format=jpg&name=4096x4096 https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Fk7HavRaYAMRa_w?format=jpg&name=... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4igbmr3Qj30 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4igbmr3Qj30 [3] https://twitter.com/buttermilk1/status/1446513576559194118?cxt=HHwWjMC52eKbhpMoAAAA https://twitter.com/buttermilk1/status/1446513576559194118?c... [4] https://twitter.com/ETSC_EU/status/1461356632042979339?cxt=HHwWloCq8aeH5McoAAAA https://twitter.com/ETSC_EU/status/1461356632042979339?cxt=H... [5] https://twitter.com/fietsprofessor/status/1380048368085430274?cxt=HHwWhMC3ibqr9aYmAAAA https://twitter.com/fietsprofessor/status/138004836808543027... [6] https://twitter.com/emollick/status/1568797893888249858?cxt=HHwWhMC42ezXvsUrAAAA https://twitter.com/emollick/status/1568797893888249858?cxt=... [7] https://twitter.com/jdavey_2/status/1533865942731526146?cxt=HHwWhMComde8sckqAAAA https://twitter.com/jdavey_2/status/1533865942731526146?cxt=... [8] https://twitter.com/WarrenJWells/status/1501638281573777408?cxt=HHwWgICqpfSD8tYpAAAA https://twitter.com/WarrenJWells/status/1501638281573777408?... P.S: This is not arbitrary link spam. These are carefully curated links I have accumulated over years of this being my proverbial hobby horse. I am a broken record. I know that.
- hnav 3y agoNo doubt a good 5-10% of that goes to ambulance chasing lawyers and fake chiros blowing up fender benders to policy maximums.
- hnav 3y agoSeems that the issue is fairly pervasive and has struck a nerve with some who have contributed to it.
- TacticalCoder 3y agoFun one I read recently... In the U.S. an average of 11 our of 100 drivers having a car in their name have an at-fault accident on their record. Do you know what's the brand where, on average, the owners that have an at-fault accident is at the lowest for any brand, with only 8.62 out of 100 drivers having an at-fault accident? It's... Drumroll... Porsche.
- ftio 3y agoThis makes sense because Porsches aren't daily drivers for disproportionately large percentage of their owners. This needs to be normalized by miles driven to be meaningful.
- czx4f4bd 3y agoI found the source and the stat sorta accounts for that in a different way, because it reports any at-fault accident in the driver's history, regardless of whether or not it was with that particular car. Thus, even if the Porsche isn't a daily driver, the owner's past accidents would still count. That said, I'm not sure how I feel about this methodology overall. It's based on insurance applications submitted by the drivers themselves, and I'm not sure what they do to check applicants' actual history. Perhaps Porsche drivers are more inclined to lie about their accident histories? > To apply for car insurance, drivers input personal and vehicle information, including the make and model of the car they drive, their license plate number, and whether or not they have caused an accident in the past. To create the list below, the Insurify data science team compared the number of car owners with a prior at-fault accident against the total number of drivers for each make and model, determining the proportion of drivers with an at-fault accident on record. Source: https://insurify.com/insights/auto-brands-most-car-accidents/ https://insurify.com/insights/auto-brands-most-car-accidents...
- Freedom2 3y agoCould you explain how this is 'fun'? I think it more or less just makes sense as a fact.
- paxys 3y ago
- paulusthe 3y agoIf we had data on the median insurance cost per person - I know I pay a lot more than $1035/year - we could hypothetically have a rough estimate of how much the uninsured cost everyone else.
- kristopolous 3y agoI'd be more interested for insurance of total paid in - total paid out. I bet a few companies make out like bandits.
- giantrobot 3y agoWhat? Insurance companies are famous for their generous payouts and not at all using scummy tactics and wording to void claims! /s
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThey seem to have pretty low profit margins.
- kristopolous 3y agothat's not necessarily a good guide. Let's say you make a lot of money. You can pay your executives millions, have lush offices with swimming pools and tennis courts, company jets etc and report razor thin "profits". Not that they're doing that - but you can creative accounting your way out of reporting profits. For instance, the star wars movies, forrest gump, lord of the rings, men in black and harry potter are all still not technically "in profit": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting That's why money in - money out is a better barometer for insurance and people with star power negotiate different terms these days like percentage of "dollars in". I made a video a couple years ago with a writer friend who is now on strike about this. (I'm cutting out the first 5 minutes of chit-chat and it's processing on youtube, but if you see this after that happens, just go to the beginning) https://youtu.be/QZBqjZS3hZA?t=296 https://youtu.be/QZBqjZS3hZA?t=296
- mensetmanusman 3y agoWe only spend ~$50B annually on infrastructure. Things could be a lot safer if we spent more on infrastructure.
- mhb 3y agoThis is meaningless. If we spend x on y, things could be safer. So?
- DangitBobby 3y agoThe submission is pretty much about the current state of affairs and investigating what can be done about it. The comment you responded to has a suggestion!
- mhb 3y agoOK. Here's a suggestion. Let's spend $20M to subsidize the replacement of gas cooking equipment. Was that also worth writing?
- DangitBobby 3y agoProbably not since it's not even remotely on topic and it just sounds like you have an axe to grind.
- mhb 3y agoOK. Here are more. Let's spend $10B on infrastructure to improve safety. Let's spend $20B on infrastructure to improve safety. Let's spend $100B on infrastructure to improve safety.
- koiz 3y agoShocker
- ksplicer 3y agoRoads in the US are a major part of the problem. They are incredibly wide and attempt to make drivers feel as safe as possible, lulling drivers into a false sense of security.
- pcurve 3y agoQuestion for economists here: "These losses include medical costs, lost productivity, legal and court costs, emergency service costs, insurance administration costs, congestion costs, property damage, and workplace losses. These figures include both police‐reported and unreported crashes. " So it costs $340 billion... but then that 'cost' also counts as GDP. It pays for insurance companies, cops, medical staff, repair shops, lawyers, etc. Right? So in a perverse way, there are people who care benefiting economically, and helps with flow of money. If traffic crashes were to go down to 0 and the cost goes down to $0, has anyone calculated what the total impact would be?
- bluGill 3y agothe ecconomy is not a zero sum game so you cannot calculate anything. We can however say with confidence that without that cost of money people would buy other things instead, and so would be better off.
- SapporoChris 3y agoI don't have a direct answer to your question but I believe the broken window fallacy applies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
- leguminous 3y agoI'm not an economist, but this sort of situation has been considered since the 1800's and is sometimes known as the broken window fallacy: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window Basically, society is better off using that money for something actually productive, rather than just repairing damage. > Whence we arrive at this unexpected conclusion: "Society loses the value of things which are uselessly destroyed;" and we must assent to a maxim which will make the hair of protectionists stand on end – To break, to spoil, to waste, is not to encourage national labour; or, more briefly, "destruction is not profit."
- akira2501 3y agoI buy groceries. I try to buy what I need so I have enough but I'm not wasting anything. Having enough is more important than not wasting anything. So, there is always a non zero amount of food I have to throw out as it didn't get eaten. I could optimize this to zero, but it would likely cost me _more_ to do that than the return would be _worth_. I suspect the same would be true here.
- RajT88 3y agoI have to wonder how much better off American society would be if we had cities designed to be walkable like other parts of the world. Better public health (fewer car accidents, more exercise), less of these costs related to car accidents, less public spending on roads (the constant yearly summer construction season).
- dionidium 3y agoWalkable cities are great and that's one way to reduce the impact of car accidents. Another way is to prevent the most catastrophic kinds of accidents from occurring in the first place by manufacturing the cars to be incapable of them. There's no reason, for example, that a car traveling on an urban street must dutifully obey the command of the buzzed teenager driving it to accelerate to 100 mph. We don't need to wait for full self-driving to make the cars more aware of their surroundings and incapable of doing things that are already illegal and absurdly dangerous. All new cars manufactured for use on public rights-of-way should immediately be throttled to the nation's highest speed limit on any road (85 mph in the U.S.). The most obvious kinds of awareness capabilities should shortly follow (e.g. am I on an Interstate Highway right now? No? Then I cannot travel at speeds that are only legal on Interstate Highways.) We don't manufacture any other product with buttons that invoke illegal functions and then spend millions on education and enforcement to persuade people never to press them. It is absurd to allow the manufacture of a product that is designed for breaking the law and that we know with great statistical certainty will used to do so.
- acchow 3y agoAt first glance, this seems like a drop in the bucket compared to USA's 23.32tn GDP. But if you look at savings, US savings rate is 3.4%. That's $792 billion. Suddenly blowing away $340B a year on car crashes doesn't seem so insignificant.
- opmelogy 3y agoThat's interesting. I wonder how much mass shootings or making abortion illegal costs.
- jodrellblank 3y agoSee the YouTube video by Not Just Bikes called “Why Cars Rarely Crash into Buildings in the Netherlands” for an interesting six minute talk about speed, road design and cultural expectations. https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ra_0DgnJ1uQ https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ra_0DgnJ1uQ
- tim333 3y agoThe interesting question for me is if self driving type tech will be able to fix this. I mean things along the lines of Tesla fsd are probably worse than humans at the moment but improving in an exponential manner year on year and if they get 50% better each year in terms of miles between accidents then within a decade they'll be much safer than humans. You wouldn't have to have self drive on but it could still break etc if you looked like hitting something. Probably also the tech will get cheaper and become widespread. It'll be interesting to see.
- tim333 3y agoComparing road deaths per person and per mile with the UK they are like 5x and 3x less. I'd say it's mostly road design and engineering. (Brit who drove in Austin TX recently, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-r...)