18 ms·
The free soloist who fell to earth
- Invictus0 3y agoI can respect Honnold and Leclerc. While their pursuits are dangerous, they took great care in their craft and respected the mountains and the art. This guy just seems like a reckless fool, pursuing likes on Instagram out of some stubborn unwilligness to deal with his depression head on. Btw I have had a TBI, thankfully I made a full recovery, but I am not at all sympathetic to the TBI-justifies-deathwish this article hints at. The fact that the author writes these biographies, and seeks to add in his own lived experience, but has basically no bio of his own on his website is also a bit off-putting.
- BaseballPhysics 3y ago> While their pursuits are dangerous, they took great care in their craft and respected the mountains and the art. This guy just seems like a reckless fool, pursuing likes on Instagram out of some stubborn unwilligness to deal with his depression head on Bluntly, if you are willing to justify Honnold's behaviour but not Howell's, I think you're just rationalizing. At least Howell didn't have a kid.
- saiya-jin 3y agoHonnold has kid now, in the height of his fame curve when he did most dangerous stuff he had barely a girlfriend (with typical fanatic attitude of 'me any my passions first', and if there is sometimes anything left then others). He is still doing some soloing, and may very well die from some stupid accident outside of his control like random loose rock just falling on his head, but chances compared to before are much smaller.
- burkaman 3y agoI'm not really sure the chances are any smaller. Here's one example, he onsight soloed a 13 pitch 5.11a last year a few months after his kid was born: https://www.instagram.com/p/CfSIT0QuzXq/ https://www.instagram.com/p/CfSIT0QuzXq/ He does this kind of thing all the time (and usually doesn't post about it), and it's arguably more dangerous than what he's most famous for, which is soloing really big routes only after he's climbed them on a rope hundreds of times. It's like a retired Olympic marathon runner going for an easy jog every few days, but if they ever trip they'll die.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wcarron 3y agoI mean, 5.11a is really not that hard. Of course, there are levels to the game. 13 pitches changes the calculus a bit, but he regularly does 50+ pitch linkups. So, that's basically just a warmup for him (and others). Not without risk, but then again, neither is driving to the crag.
- fn-mote 3y agoTo me the article pretty clearly indicates that mental illness, and multiple traumatic injuries, play major role in Austin's addiction to free climbing. In the middle of the article is a point where his father tells him he's going to die if he keeps this up and he says he's "willing to take the consequences of his actions." He might be reckless but I don't think he can be called a fool. (Also: The author's credentials are in the article - depressed, took SSRIs, started getting high from free climbing. That's enough of a relation to the subject of the story for me. You're obviously closer to it.)
- krisoft 3y ago> I have had a TBI, thankfully I made a full recovery, but I am not at all sympathetic to the TBI-justifies-deathwish this article hints at. I have two problems with this sentence. You had TBI, that doesn’t mean you know everything about it though. Brains are complicated, and they can get injured in many different ways. I’m glad that you have recovered fully, maybe he was not so lucky? The other is that the article doesn’t say that his TBI “justifies” a deathwish. Rather than it explains his behaviour. It also clearly puts into context that this is disputed by the subject himself, but the explanation is supported by the mother. > This guy just seems like a reckless fool That is I think a valid observation. But one can always look one layer deeper. What made him a reckless fool? This is what I believe the article is about. > pursuing likes on Instagram out of some stubborn unwilligness to deal with his depression head on. What does “dealing with depression head on” mean to you? As far as I know there is no one-size-fit-all solution for depression. There are many who gets better following standard care, but also many who do not. It sounds he tried therapy and possibly many other things. Maybe free soloing was his way of dealing with his depression head on? Would you rather like him to be miserable but alive than feeling better but dead sooner than you think he should have died?
- BaseballPhysics 3y agoReally fantastic piece that explores the life of a free solo climber without straying too far into hero worship. I've long been troubled by other pieces on this corner of climbing as they always felt a little too approving, a little too encouraging of such a dangerous practice, but this one manages to avoid that trap.
- hotpotamus 3y agoIt reminded me of the story of a famous (within that community) Appalachian Trail through-hiker who went by the name "Baltimore Jack" (from the Springstein lyric, "had a wife and kids in Baltimore, Jack. I went out for a ride and I never went back.) that I read some time ago. He had abandoned his family to essentially live on the trail and eventually died there, seemingly of exposure. I googled it and it's from the same publication, so I'm sensing a theme.
- mauvehaus 3y agoI met Baltimore Jack in the Smokies in 2010 and crossed paths with him a few more times between there and Hanover. I think it's a bit more complicated than that. With the limits that come of only seeing him a few times on the trail, I'd like to suggest that he clearly had an unhealthy relationship with alcohol and probably had some other demons. With that said, he was also a kind soul and the conscience of the hiker community. He was unafraid to say something to people acting in a way that was detrimental to the community at large. He encouraged other hikers and shared freely of what he had be that knowledge or food. Because of all of that, there was a certain amount of hero worship around him. He was a much loved character. But I get the sense that Baltimore Jack was a bit of a character, and assuming that role let him avoid some of the other things in his life that he might've lived longer had he addressed them.
- sneak 3y agoIs it a trap if the only danger is to the climber themselves? If our lives are not our own to use or risk as we choose, then to whom do they actually belong?
- animal_spirits 3y ago> That if you can’t find enough of the peace and mindfulness you need with a rope on, you’ll never find enough of it without it. An amazing piece of wisdom to take from the article.
- foobarbecue 3y ago"Howell’s belayer let go of the brake strand of the rope, a careless mistake." As a climber, I really dislike how this phrasing minimises the belayer's error. It's a sure sign of improper belaying technique. Bad belaying is life-threatening and quite common, and it makes me angry (having witnessed several such accidents). A belayer who actually knows how to belay never, ever, takes off their brake hand unless the rope is tied off. It's a bit like saying "the driver ran the red light going 20 miles per hour over the speed limit and hit a pedestrian, a careless mistake"
- BaseballPhysics 3y agoYeah, unfortunately belaying is one of those things where it's incredibly easy to lose focus, and when you do the consequences can be catastrophic. Unfortunately, climbing in general can be like this. Maybe you get reckless and space out your pro too far. Or you forget to tie a knot in the end of your belay line. The more competent you get, the easier it is to get too comfortable and to make a truly catastrophic mistake.
- foobarbecue 3y agoIndeed, complacency kills. But I think most of the "dropped by belayer" incidents are caused by belayers who were taught improper technique, or never taught at all. I've seen lots of youtube "how to belay" videos that involve switching hands and other dangerous practices which involve taking the brake hand off. Just slip slap slide, people.
- teolandon 3y agoAnother thing that bothers me is how people brush off improper belaying technique when the pro climbers do it. There are numerous videos of Adam Ondra, Dave Graham, etc just belaying with their hand off the brake strand, or their finger fully pushing on the cam of a GriGri while not paying out slack, and when people criticize them, other people just perform an appeal to authority and say "he climbs more than you, he knows what he's doing".
- 3y ago
- carabiner 3y agoReally engaging article. The "climbing as therapy" notion is a bit overhyped, in this article and elsewhere. IMO anything that promotes focus or mindfulness can chip away at a depressed state, and once in a while, pop you into happiness. It can be painting, mountain biking, playing piano, anything.
- sfink 3y agoI'm sure it's different for everyone, but I think climbing has a bit more reason to make a claim here. If you lose your focus, or fool yourself into thinking you're focused on the right thing when you're actually not, then you'll find out. You'll slip or you won't find a way up. With something like painting, it's easy to fool yourself. It's a bit like the difference between writing and programming. I like doing both, and can get deep into both, but a compiler is going to tell me I'm being a dumbass a lot quicker and more definitively than any eventual reader could.
- actionfromafar 3y agoTo me, programming is past that. But I easily fool myself what I program is worthwhile. Or am I?
- BaseballPhysics 3y ago> The "climbing as therapy" notion is a bit overhyped What I liked about the piece is it actually hits on exactly this point, and specifically that if you can't find peace off rope you won't find it chasing a high on rope.
- jfengel 3y agoAlso, climbing with protection can be very therapeutic. As can bouldering. It doesn't have to be deadly to really, really focus your attention. Your brain doesn't want to fall even if it's just a few feet. It's also a remarkably mental exercise. I love when they set new routes and you can watch the high level climbers gathered around, mentally rehearsing how to solve a problem.
- samtho 3y ago
- xigency 3y agoThis sport will never be for me. My fingers are sweating just from reading the article.
- bargle0 3y agoTry this climbing video: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Cyya23MPoAI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Cyya23MPoAI One legendary climber pressures an experienced climber in to a high danger situation. It’ll make you about as uncomfortable as a SFW video can.
- laserDinosaur 3y agoI always thought one particular line was interesting: Magnus: "I'm worried I might pass out, fall and die" Alex: "If passed out in your car on the highway here, you'd still be dead". Just an interesting perspective on danger. If we were to run the numbers, am I safer as Alex free climbing a wall as I am Regular Bob driving on a highway to work?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Vecr 3y agoNo, almost certainly not. For example, if you are in stop-and-go traffic on a highway, and as long as the visibility is good and the road has good traction, you could drive for literally hundreds of years straight before reaching 1 mean expected death from the driving. If you fall asleep in those conditions and are driving a modern car, the car is likely to be damaged but you probably won't die. I don't have numbers for free soloing, but if you pass out, you will die with a high confidence.
- untech 3y agoInsane video, thank you for sharing. It was way more psychological then I thought. Still not sure whether “the legend” is a hero or a villain here.
- xcskier56 3y ago
- sigabrter 3y agoClicked on this because a friend of mine from high school died while free soloing, and was shocked to see the article is about him! Good dude. Miss that guy. Still think about him often. It was really nice to get to learn about some parts of his life I hadn’t known about.
- Mistletoe 3y agoI feel uncomfortable watching free soloists. Like watching Roman gladiators, risking their life for our amusement. I found it interesting that Clif bar stopped sponsoring athletes that do it. Maybe that's the right decision and direction. They aren't just climbing for themselves usually. The eyes and likes are spurring them on to greater risk. On the other hand, I admire Alex Honnold and other climbers, it's a weird cognitive dissonance.
- dpc050505 3y agoClif stopped sponsoring every rock climber because free soloing is associated to it.
- actionfromafar 3y agoI don’t think it’s weird. We are savage but try better ourselves. This is what movies are for, to me. Death and violence can be had there, in a safe format.
- throwaway22032 3y agoThe thing that I fundamentally don't understand about free soloing is that it's only skill based to a point. You will eventually, as in the article, hit a loose hold and fall. When that happens you probably die and it wasn't due to anything you could have prevented.
- kdmccormick 3y agoIt takes extreme skill to maneuver yourself right and hold yourself on the walls he was climbing, even if every hold is sturdy (which they typically are). It also takes skill to look at rock and have an understanding of how likely it is to be safe to put your weight on. And it takes skill to repeatedly do climbs with a rope to get to the point where you're comfortable doing them unprptected. Finally, it takes skill to hold yourself on the wall with 1-3 of your other limbs in the event that one of the holds gives away or your hand slips (the latter of which does happen plenty often). If it weren't skill-based, you'd see random daredevil freaks freesoloing all the time. It just wouldn't be interesting. It'd be like, "Man climbs tall unsteady ladders regularly!" No, what these guys are doing is both insane but also insanely impressive.
- throwaway22032 3y agoI edited my post to clarify that I don't mean that there's zero skill involved, of course I didn't mean that. Just that when it goes wrong, you're just screwed.
- kdmccormick 3y agoYeah, I'm with you there, there's a big luck aspect it seems. I think those things soloists they do in order to lower the probability of freak events (choosing climbs smartly, not soloing when they're no in the right headspace, practicing, being good at recovering from mistakes, choosing good holds, etc) makes it very skill-based, but they can never lower that all the way to 0%.
- hutzlibu 3y agoNot necessarily. With experience you can tell what weight rocks will hold. And if you climb safe, you don't risk a jump towards a hold that might break (those guys did risk it). But accidents and misstakes happen. But they totally can happen when you use a rope as well! A rope can even give you a false sense of security (if you don't know what you are doing). When you climb free solo - you know everything is on you. One big misstake and it is over. It is a very intense experience, I used to do it in easy territory and I loved it. But now with kids, there is just too much risk. Because yes, it is way more dangerous. But it is only a certain path to death, if you push your luck.
- AlbertCory 3y ago> his “preflight checklist,” making sure he’d accounted and planned for all the variables that could go wrong. "Nothing can happen to me, because I've planned for all the risks." Hello, Black Swan.
- Vecr 3y agoNot even a Black Swan, in Taleb's original. It's a known unknown. Every time I write a checklist I know it's going to be somewhat wrong, even if I have other people go over it. I also know there are things I should have checklists for but don't, but I don't know what they are. Another known unknown. A real black swan is when thousands of dedicated people have thought about the issue and miss it. Thinking your checklists that no one or only a few other people looked at are perfect is just a major lack of intellectual humility.
- neonate 3y agohttp://web.archive.org/web/20230624221112/https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/climbing/austin-howell-fallen-soloist/ http://web.archive.org/web/20230624221112/https://www.outsid... https://archive.ph/K763a https://archive.ph/K763a
- jrm4 3y agoObviously "it's a free country" and whatnot in terms of what you do and what you like to admire, but I can't seem to muster any respect or admiration for this sort of thing whatsoever. I see nothing here but potentially, literally, wasting your life.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ajhurliman 3y agoAgreed. It’s literally suicide with extra steps, I don’t understand folks’ permissive attitude about such an unnecessarily dangerous activity.
- samtho 3y agoThat’s a real disparaging view. It’s pretty clear that he intended to survive all of his climbs.
- jrm4 3y agoIt's not at all clear by definition of the inherent dangerousness involved.
- samtho 3y agoHe had a different risk tolerance and definition of safety. I would not agree that he made wise choice, but there is a difference between wanton recklessness and literally suicidal.
- jrm4 3y agoI agree with your assessment, but I also see no value in "respecting his choices?" Which is to say, if people like him think we're assholes for calling them something-like-if-not-exactly-suicidal, thats fine, I'll be an asshole. I still sleep better calling it out than being silent here.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aynyc 3y agoI positioned my right foot on the chip, took a breath, and reached around for a good side pull. As I grabbed it, the cobbles smooth beneath my fingers, I imagined, just for a second, what would happen if I released the tension in my core. That’s all it would take for my foot to wiggle a millimeter to the side and skate off that chip. I’d plummet more than a hundred feet to the ground. I cleared my head, pulled through the move, and stood up onto the face, now in more secure territory. I listened to my heartbeat. I calmed my breath. I closed my eyes. A few minutes later, I scampered over the top of the cliff. I know the author and Austin have their demons. I just want to point out as someone who has solo that route, and know quite a few people who have done that as well, none of us ever thought about that. I dislike the way social media portrait free soloing, because like twitter, it's impossible to describe Hemingway in 280 characters. Best wish for those who are suffering, and I hope they can find ways to survive and even heal before it's too late.
- asah 3y agoSo why do you solo? Honest question.
- aynyc 3y agoI didn't solo at my limit. The routes were easy, below my standard, and well known by me. The possibilities of so low that I just didn't think I would fall. I was good enough and confident enough that I want to experience freedom. During the solos, I didn't feel anything, it was mechanical, pure physical movements. I didn't have heightened sense or anything like that. In fact, it was less "arousal" than if I have rope and trying my absolute hardest on other routes. I also didn't have selfies or anything that would even prove I was there. But after the climbs, there was a sense of fulfillment, a quiet confidence and pride that simply make me happy. I didn't tell many people about my soloing because I did it for myself. Many of my partners/mentors have done bigger solos. All of the solos were done in quiet manner, and generally on less traffic routes or days. They weren't searching for meaning of life or next high. They simply want to climb quietly and competently and come home without any drama. I stopped soloing because I find it hard to take the next step, which is to solo harder and harder grades. I didn't like the way it made me feel. It became chasing glory rather than self expression.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoSome people have a death wish. I try not to get in their way or emulate their risky habits. There's no rational reason to climb without safety gear except to proclaim how much they DGAF about dying. Celebrating a death wish is canonizing dumb because the feels and drama makes it into a story. They're dead because of choices they made and that's nothing to celebrate.
- audiometry 3y agoThis long form writing style where the author has to inject his own story as a secondary/support narrative gets really tedious. You could edit all of it out and the story would be sustained.
- gerbilly 3y agoI don't climb, or at least not hard enough for my opinion on climbing to be relevant, but I came to realise for myself that my mountain biking was a form of counterphobia.¹ There is a famous trail builder who built super risky trails in the North Shore of Vancouver. Those trails involved riding along six inch wide logs which were all slimy and slippery way above the forest floor.² My bonafides: I've ridden everything on Fromme and most trails on Seymour too, back in the day before they cut down the most dangerous lines. Basically, I just wanted to say that from those riding experiences, that I get it. I know that feeling of being one with the trail, of fully accepting and merging with the fear. It brought me peace during the ride (it altered my perception till all I could see was the front tire and the line I was riding, everything else became bokeh) and the comedown after riding trails like that was also really nice. Driving home across the Lions Gate bridge with my bike in the back of my friends shitty pickup (the bike was likely worth more than the car) are probably some of the happiest memories I'll ever make. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counterphobic_attitude https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counterphobic_attitude 2. https://diggerknowfear.com/ https://diggerknowfear.com/ His logo includes the words 'Know Fear'