9 ms·
US vendor accused of violating GDPR by reputation-scoring EU citizens
- johnea 3y agoAh yes, "reputation scoring", where have I heard of that before?
- amindeed 3y agoChina, I guess.
- LightBug1 3y ago-10 for mentioning China and/or reputation-scoring in a relatively negative fashion. Your credit score has decreased accordingly. Have a lovey day, citizen, and do better tomorrow!
- FooBarWidget 3y agoThis tongue-in-cheeck dig on China may actually mean something if it weren't for the fact that the social credit system, as depicted by the media, doesn't actually exist. It's wholly an invention of the media to project our own fears on. This article goes in-depth about what the actual situation is: https://www.spectator.co.uk/podcast/social-credit-system/ https://www.spectator.co.uk/podcast/social-credit-system/ The bigger story is why people are so receptive to such stories, and why the media keep writing them, even though they're false.
- newacct3 3y agoThe author of that article grew up in China and likely has familial ties there, one could argue that those factors discourage them from honest criticism
- FooBarWidget 3y agoThere are more accounts that corroborate that the social credit system as depicted by the media is a myth, like Vincent Brussee who is German: https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/09/15/china-social-credit-system-authoritarian/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/09/15/china-social-credit-sys...
- LightBug1 3y agoIt was actually a tongue-in-cheek dig at a near future ... and one that is likely here already. While you dismiss the stories, I think they point to exactly how insidious it is. The 'social credit system' is not one overarching system. Which leads to you and the Spectator to dismiss it, it will be the analysis of accumulated data that, in effect, amount to the same thing. Your comment that the social credit system 'doesn't actually exist' is woefully naive. No disrespect. You did caveat that by saying 'as depicted by the media'. And, in general, you would be right. But, in this case, the stories that are pedalled by the media (99% unintentional, I'm sure) serve as a useful metaphor for the wider public that don't scratch the surface of these topics. That's a horrible way to communicate, but in the absence of any other education, I'll take it. Citizens should rightly be very cautious of anything resembling, or amounting to (in aggregate), a social credit system. My gut says you'd agree.
- FooBarWidget 3y agoYour response reads to me as that which I already pointed out: the "Chinese social credit" myth is appealing not because it's factually true but because it's something we use to project our fears on. You dread the prospects of the myth coming true in your home country. Okay, fair. But you are also saying that that dread justifies making false, exaggerated or distorted assertions about China because the end (combating the myth from becoming true) justifies such means. That I disagree with. I am Chinese. China has been demonized enough in this cold war already. China shouldn't be collatoral damage in your fight against the myth from becoming true. Such myths have real consequences for Asian people even living outside China. Anti-Asian violence is at an all-time high because the public is fed daily with the narrative that China is some evil empire that's out to get all of us. This creates an environment of paranoia in which real people get hurt. Chinese scientists abroad are being harassed because they "could have links to the CCP" or other bullshit like that. Sure, protest against the prospects of the myths, that's fine. But that's no excuse for misrepresenting China. One can, and should, protest against the prospects of social credit while also acknowledging that the story about China is largely false.
- LightBug1 3y ago
- Ekaros 3y agoCredit score?
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoSo USA is giving me a social credit? Nice.
- inetknght 3y agoUS is all about the credit. But it's not the kind of credit that you usually want.
- pessimizer 3y agoSocial credit administered by private firms in the US for Europeans is the good kind of social credit. We'll rent it to European governments. edit: looks like this is identity unmasking, rather than social credit. Would work well in conjunction with social credit.
- 77pt77 3y agoJust like them, you don't get to choose. You're now forced to deal with coming mpanies you never entered in an agreement with. What a great system.
- raincom 3y agoPrivatize everything: surveillance, background checks, social credits, health scores, beauty scores, financial scores, work scores, etc. That's the best way to appear democratic, while blaming other autocratic, authoritarian regimes for how evil the latter are.
- opmelogy 3y agoI'm surprised speeding tickets haven't been privatized yet. Get a device installed in your car that monitors the speeds of cars around you. If someone violates the speed limit your car reports them to the authorities and then you get a "cut" of the ticket. Great way to make some extra cash while ignoring the fact that everyone is getting pitted against each other as a way to stay distracted from all the crap the ruling class does...
- raincom 3y ago
- McDyver 3y agoLink to noyb's site, with a template to request whether your number is processed by TeleSign: https://noyb.eu/en/telesign-profiles-half-worlds-phone-users https://noyb.eu/en/telesign-profiles-half-worlds-phone-users
- popcalc 3y agoWhat goes in the client number field?
- the_mitsuhiko 3y agoI assume it’s the customer account number on the invoice with your phone provider since you need to attach it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoAt this point, the EU and UK are doing a better job of fighting for my constitutional rights in the US than the US is.
- LightBug1 3y agoLess of the UK, thanks ... we're sliding down the slippery chain. Don't join us.
- gadders 3y ago[flagged]
- LightBug1 3y agoWhat? I wasn't even referring to Brexit. I think this is one of those look in the mirror moments for you.
- starttoaster 3y ago> I think this is one of those look in the mirror moments for you. Unfortunately, self-reflection isn't the strong suit of most people, and especially so for their alter ego internet personas.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dghlsakjg 3y agoWhat constitutional right do you think this violates? Constitutional rights generally refer to what the government can and cannot do to a person. In this case it was a private company that broke no US laws as far as I can tell. Why would the constitution apply?
- simion314 3y ago>Constitutional rights generally refer to what the government can and cannot do to a person. So the constitution only protects your human rights(life, privacy, no discrimination) from the government? in USA you need other laws to protect your rights from other people and companies ?
- cm2012 3y agoYou realize is you ban this kind of service, fraud rates are going to multiply 10x in the EU, and new, very inconvenient barriers to fraud will be put in place. I'd like to see one (1) person harmed by any of the data sharing that TeleSign has done here in the history of the company.
- oxfordmale 3y agoThere will be multiple persons that didn't get the loan or mortgage they applied for, as their reputation score was deemed to low due to data quality issues.
- cm2012 3y agoThis "reputation score" means: Are you a bot or a human? It's not a credit score. And if it was, that kind of credit score improves access to credit.
- bckygldstn 3y agoOnly to the extent that the scores are perfect.
- 111111IIIIIII 3y agoAnd we can only reason that they are not. As parent correctly implies, the purpose is risk reduction. A well implemented system will accept false positives, as we saw with the recent Amazon doorbell debacle.
- ineedasername 3y agoNot necessarily: No Score = higher risk, higher interest. Incorrect low score = perceived higher risk, higher interest rate. Depending on how the risks of no/low score are weighted, and how wrong the inaccurate score is, a person may very well be more harmed by no score than by a low score. An inaccurate score might have to be massively off the mark to make a person worse off than no score at all. In the US for example, people with no credit history often get interest rates as high or higher than people with a relatively low credit score. Of course from a privacy & data protection standpoint this doesn't make silently and secretly profiling customers okay. The solution is probably something more like a transparent opt-in system that has easy access for the customer to review their data and decide which pieces of it are included. In the US, the balance is skewed a bit more towards secrecy, and it's not opt-in either. However you can with only modest difficulty check your credit score & information used to calculate it, and challenge parts of it that you think are inaccurate.
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agoDoes advertising exist anywhere in Europe? What a utopia!
- moffkalast 3y agoWell they are gradually banning billboards entirely in Poland: https://www.reddit.com/r/europe/comments/l0p31m/in_poland_we_are_slowly_getting_rid_of/ https://www.reddit.com/r/europe/comments/l0p31m/in_poland_we...
- littlestymaar 3y agoA city-wide billboard ban also happened in Grenoble (France) since 2014.
- 77pt77 3y agoBased!
- metaphor 3y ago> When BICS acquired TeleSign in 2017, it began to fall under the partial control of BICS' parent company, Belgian telecom giant Proximus. Proximus held a partial stake in BICS, which Proximus spun off from its own operations in 1997. > In 2021, Proximus bought out BICS' other shareholders, making it the sole owner of both the telecom interchange and TeleSign. Curious how the article's headline goes out of its way to emphasize "US vendor" when the puppet masters in the underlying corporate structure are entirely Belgian.
- aerio 3y agoIs Volvo a Swedish company or Chinese?
- DigiDigiorno 3y agoVolvo Group? Not Chinese Volvo Cars? Maybe Chinese, Chinese company owns a majority, but it is still publicly traded company with other shareholders
- dmix 3y agoThere's a ton of these anti-fraud data collection companies. That industry (plus marketing/credit card data) is probably the lowest hanging fruit to find privacy violations, much more so than the usual GDPR targets you often hear about. Maybe they can do the location tracking ones too that western police regularly buy.
- WheatMillington 3y agoAmericans: haha look at those dystopian Chinese and their social credit score. Also Americans: credit score, reputation score, every other ranking imaginable performed by non accountable corporations.
- Manuel_D 3y agoCredit score has a regulated scoring system. It's all based on your debts, and repayment of said debts. You're not going to lose credit score based on your vote.
- Mystery-Machine 3y agoSocial score is also not shot put someone's ass. It's calculated based on your criminal record and some other factors. Seems like, as per Wikipedia, it's mostly focused on company social credit scores. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Credit_System https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Credit_System
- Manuel_D 3y ago"...and some other factors." Nice handwaving. From your own link: > In addition to dishonest and fraudulent financial behavior, there has been proposals in some cities to officially list several behaviors as negative factors of credit ratings, including playing loud music or eating in rapid transits,[68] violating traffic rules such as jaywalking and red-light violations,[76][83] making reservations at restaurants or hotels, but not showing up,[86] failing to correctly sort personal waste,[96][97][81] I have no idea why you thought this link would help you make your case. Human rights organizations the world over criticize the social credit score: https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/the-human-rights-implications-of-chinas-social-credit-system/ https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/the-human-rights-implications-of-c...
- bllguo 3y agothe world over? you mean the US and UK? organizations with negligible representation from people who belong to non-Anglo cultures? the social credit myth has been busted plenty of times. it's a cursory search away.
- jgalt212 3y agoThe person (no name, no home address, personal id #) who controls phone number 555-1234 has a fraud score of X. It's amazing to me that this is a GDPR violation. What a poorly designed rule.
- poorlyknit 3y agoFor a regulatory body it is beyond trivial to assign a person to a phone number for a given time range.
- koiz 3y agoAhh GDPR the not enough answer to some of our data problems.
- msla 3y agoThe GDPR isn't global law. That's because most of the world, get this, isn't in Europe and isn't subject to EU regulations. It's very hard for some people to understand that Europe no longer has global empires.
- phendrenad2 3y agoThe problem with that logic is, because the EU was a good global citizen (at one point), everyone has reciprocal treaties to allow extradition and cross-border charges. And the GDPR actually applies to any website accessed by EU citizens so banning EU IP addresses still leaves you open to the case where an EU citizen residing in the US has a GDPR claim against you. Maddening, but that's the reality of this silly law.