9 ms·
US approves chicken made from cultivated cells
- vintagedave 3y agoThis is very exciting. Has anyone heard of this being affordably commercially available? (Asking from the EU, but a Yes answer for anywhere in the world would be huge progress.)
- jaclaz 3y agoAccording to Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upside_Foods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Upside_Foods the goal was to sell at 60 Euro/kg (by 2020). Not exactly competitive, pricewise.
- t1mmen 3y agoI don’t think it’s available anywhere in-stores, but (a?) restaurant serves lab grown in Singapore — https://www.bbc.com/news/business-65784505 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-65784505 To sibling comment on price, we’ve come a long way in a decade; > Ever since the first lab-grown burger - which cost a mere $330,000 (£263,400) to create - was unveiled in London in 2013, dozens of companies around the world have joined the race to bring affordable cultivated meat to the market.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoI imagine it's not yet saving-the-world effective yet. The lab environment likely costs more environmentally than a chicken farm would.
- urfullofsht 3y ago[dead]
- dimal 3y agoI think there have been studies that show that you’re correct. My question is how much room is there improve that efficiency as production scales and improves. But even now, there’s the benefit of producing less suffering. No need to breed animals that can’t even support their own weight and spend their entire short lives suffering in darkness, crowded in cages with other suffering beings, awaiting death.
- throwaway462910 3y agoCan't resist: there's already no need, even if we want animal products
- xdennis 3y ago> My question is how much room is there improve that efficiency as production scales and improves. I'm no expert on the matter, but it will likely never be competitive with real meat in either taste or price: - You need a lot of expensive equipment and chemicals to grow fake meat. A chicken just needs food and water. - You need extreme cleanliness to grow fake meat or else you're just growing bacteria. Animals have an immune system and can deal with minor threats. - Cells don't exist in a vacuum. You need to deliver nutrients and remove waste. Animals have lungs, blood vessels, kidneys, and all the other organs needed to maintain the entire biological system which has been optimized over millions of years. - Meat isn't just muscle cells, it's a very complicated structure. Growing separate cells and mushing them together will never give you the same taste. The only real equivalent would be if you could grow a chicken without a brain. > No need to breed animals that can’t even support their own weight and spend their entire short lives suffering in darkness, crowded in cages with other suffering beings, awaiting death. If that bothers you, there are always more expensive ways to eat real meat.
- dimal 3y ago> If that bothers you, there are always more expensive ways to eat real meat I’ve been buying free-range chicken and eggs for a while, but recent reports have said that there is basically no actual free-range chicken or eggs on the market. There’s no oversight, so almost everything labeled as free-range isn’t really free-range, so it’s just more expensive, with no benefit.
- EatingWithForks 3y agoI actually doubt this, but you have to be very particular. You can't just go to the grocery store and pick up a free-range label. But e.g. my local farmer's market has a guy who is definitely pasture-raised chickens with the $$$ to match.
- koolba 3y agoAny information on the labeling requirements for synth meat?
- ch4s3 3y agoI'm not sure synthetic is the right word for cells cultivated in a mold until they naturally adhere via cell adhesion.
- collegeburner 3y agosynthetic: something resulting from synthesis rather than occurring naturally seems like the ideal word. the meat is synthesized from cells rather than being grown
- ch4s3 3y agoBut it’s growing from the cells.
- lumb63 3y agoHopefully there is some requirement. The idea of unwittingly eating “chicken” doesn’t sit well with me.
- aendruk 3y agoThe FDA and USDA have been handling this question on a case-by-case basis. The approvals announced today are both for the label “cell-cultivated chicken”.
- cbm-vic-20 3y agoInteresting. Does all of this "chicken" have the same DNA? Is there a Genesis chicken from which all of this meat is derived?
- swader999 3y agoNo, it evolved.
- gumby 3y agoThis is so great -- I've been waiting for this for decades. I always felt the tofurky or "impossible burger" approach was a dead end. Also I have trouble getting enough protein with a plant-only diet. The big question of course is scale. Seems like the kind of thing that can develop an economy of scale better than the meat grown on the animal (farmers spend a lot of effort growing things that aren't salable, or are barely so, like bones and feathers). And the ultimate (scaled out) cost target is probably much better than the "traditional product" if the environmental impact gets priced into food costs.
- bobthepanda 3y agoBones are pretty sellable; they improve the flavor of meat and are an integral component of soups and stocks.
- throwway120385 3y agoSome kinds of feathers are as well. They're often used in soft goods like pillows as stuffing. Also they're dyed and used as decoration. The bones actually have most of the micronutrients, and people used to eat marrow like butter to avoid wasting it.
- bequanna 3y ago“Bone meal” and “feather meal” are commodity byproducts of the meat industry. You can find them used in animal feeds and even pet foods.
- adrian_b 3y agoMoreover, bone meal is also sold as a human nutritional supplement, but curiously under disguised names, e.g. "Calcium Hydroxyapatite" (while bone meal does indeed contain hydroxyapatite, it also contains other minerals and a large amount of proteins), presumably in order to not scare the vegans, who are the main people who need such a nutritional supplement. While I eat almost only vegan food, I make an exception and I add to some of my food small quantities of such bone meal. However, unlike most people, I read very carefully the small print, so I am aware that this supplement is in fact made from cattle bones, even if its label does not suggest this.
- mjfl 3y agoThe irony of synthetic meat is that it often requires FBS - fetal bovine serum, to grow, which is obtained from the blood of fetal calfs found when slaughtering pregnant cows.
- synetic 3y agoI’m know nothing about this stuff. Is it within the real of possibility that the technology can advance to the point that no animals die to produce synthetic meat? As it currently stands I imagine that far fewer animals are required to make x pounds of synthetic meat than it does to make x pounds the usual way. Is this correct?
- mjfl 3y agoThat's the goal, but I'm not sure it is reality at this point.
- aendruk 3y agoThe irony of electric vehicles is that they are often charged from non-renewable energy sources. Specifically regarding the two companies approved today, Good Meat is already approved to use serum-free media in Singapore and we can expect the same to happen in the US. [1] Upside Foods has both serum and serum-free processes [2] and is moving toward being 100% serum-free. [3] [1]: https://read.whatever.social/elliotswartz/status/1651566376635756547#m https://read.whatever.social/elliotswartz/status/16515663766... [2]: https://read.whatever.social/elliotswartz/status/1597231290318655488#m https://read.whatever.social/elliotswartz/status/15972312903... [3]: https://upsidefoods.com/progress https://upsidefoods.com/progress
- igtztorrero 3y agoI remmeber an old days hoax about KFC that they plant and harvest chickens, it look it's going to be real in the futuro !
- candiddevmike 3y agoI wonder if developing some kind of grotesque meat tree would be viable. I feel like mechanical support for biological systems is always deficient and costly, but somehow creating a self sustaining plant-like organism that passively produces a meat like thing seems impossible.
- aendruk 3y agoIt’s a stretch but semi-continuous harvesting is kind of like that, though in this case more of a houseplant than a tree: https://gfi.org/solutions/simultaneous-perfusion-and-stretch/ https://gfi.org/solutions/simultaneous-perfusion-and-stretch...
- joker_minmax 3y agoThe hoax I remember is that they were growing meat balls with no eyes or beaks. In which case we're already here
- Slava_Propanei 3y agoI use these amazing self-assembling chickens. They convert insects directly into edible protein too. It is the future!
- coding123 3y agoVery pleased that this is happening. Also very pleased to live the rest of my days to pay for ever increasing price of real animal meat.
- xdennis 3y agoWhy would real meat increase in price (other than normal stuff like inflation)?
- coding123 3y agoAt some point the fake meat is cheaper and more people buy that. This causes real meat to become more expensive because it becomes a luxury item - only wealthy people can pay for the intense farming practices that today every consumer is helping pay for.
- jjtheblunt 3y agoin the US, real meat is (heavily) subsidized by the federal government. https://www.usda.gov/meat https://www.usda.gov/meat
- jjtheblunt 3y agoafterthought, unrelated: does that mean heavy meat eating americans are being bought parts of their meals by vegetarians through federal taxes?
- coding123 3y agoI would assume it works like all other things taxes: people that walk are paying for car infrastructure.
- autoexec 3y agoWhy wouldn't fake meat also be heavily subsidized?
- 3y ago
- Quillbert182 3y agoThere needs to be some very strict labeling requirements for this. If I'm going to eat lab grown meat, I would like to know beforehand.
- moffkalast 3y agoYou'll know because it'll be 10x the price.
- jxramos 3y agome too, who knows what sort of chemical baths and other elements this material passes through to get to its final state and how much of that adulterates the end product. It sure ain't pristine organic regenerative grass fields etc with creatures output from it which our bodies have long adapted the consumption of.
- jareklupinski 3y agoas long as the end-to-end manufacture of the cells is done in a sterile environment... the lab-grown stuff will actually be _cleaner_ than anything made 'organically' cells don't poop (the same way), and aren't exposed to pathogens in a lab
- zdragnar 3y agoCells absolutely produce waste. That's why animals have things like kidneys and livers. Animals also have immune systems to survive mild infections. Cells grown in a lab are much more prone to any form of contamination at all. It's possible to deal with both things in a lab, but not inexpensively.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 29_29 3y agoknow your local butcher
- deleted 3y ago
- mc32 3y agoWhat is the carbon footprint for this food manufacture? Is it lighter than the natural alternative?
- autoexec 3y agoI'd be happy with an increased carbon footprint in exchange for a vast reduction in the amount of suffering we put animals though.
- darraghenright 3y agoThere's also the huge ecosystem impact of high-intensity farming; e.g: pollution of waterways, deforestation etc.
- jxramos 3y agoI can't imagine how the texture will be given that muscle bone and tendon are all mechanically responsive tissues that react to mechanical forces. Maybe something like the texture of liver or that cellular goop that congeals at the bottom of chicken drippings in a roaster.
- pdq 3y agoMy guess would be the first prototype is a substitute for chicken nuggets.
- aendruk 3y agoIf it helps your imagination, here’s a photo: https://cdn.bfldr.com/N0AMS98X/at/g4nb84kqfv2stbk635shx4/GMT_v3_Chicken_Close_Ups1665_1.jpg https://cdn.bfldr.com/N0AMS98X/at/g4nb84kqfv2stbk635shx4/GMT... (28 MB)
- yieldcrv 3y agohalf of the vegans I know only care about the cultivation practices of the food and would be fine with this and consuming this expanding restaurant menu choices by an order of magnitude when we go out I know of a half dozen other reasons different vegans have, not about them right now
- triyambakam 3y agoI prefer to just eat beans. In my pantry I have masoor dal, moong dal, cowpeas, chickpeas, French green lentils, rajma, pinto beans, turtle beans. Every day for every meal I eat some type of bean.
- TurkishPoptart 3y agoMy understanding is that these are lab-grown tumor growths that are going to be pumped full of antibiotics (because a tumor doesn't have its own immune system). I expect this will be far less nutritious than regular meat.
- JimtheCoder 3y agoI don't know if the HN community is a fan of the All In Podcast or not, but they did a piece about this a while back... https://youtu.be/3slYsEzJZoY?t=2873 https://youtu.be/3slYsEzJZoY?t=2873
- Sapere_Aude 3y agoNice! Now people can finally eat tumors with chicken texture. Thank God this stuff isn't econonically viable, nor is it in any way "sustainable". This is processed foods par excellence.