6 ms·
ASUS Chromebox 5
- jeffbee 3y agoPretty nice. I wonder why ChromeOS Flex is not certified on any Intel NUC newer than the NUC 8.
- Namidairo 3y agoProbably the same reason why only newer than 8000 series Intel CPUs are officially supported for Windows 11. It's the "easiest" way to ensure TPM 2.0 compatibility, at a CPU family level of granularity. (Yes, there are 7000 series with TPM 2.0 support, but I believe that may have been the exception to the rule) Edit: I took a look at the certified list and noticed that I indeed, cannot read.
- notyourday 3y agoI've tried ChromeOS Flex on all kinds of gear. It just works.
- blackhaz 3y agoAnd in the best traditions of modern product sites - what this thing actually is? It is a generic computer to run Windows? A media player? Google Chrome device? Can it run Linux? It seems I have been let to know everything about this device, including the model of the security chip inside and its military certificate code, but I can't seem to understand what this box is actually for.
- iand 3y agoIt's a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chromebox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chromebox which is a class of small computer that run ChromeOS
- sofixa 3y agoIt's kind of in the name, which is why they probably thought they don't need to say it. It's a Chromebox, meaning, a computer running ChromeOS. Usually those can run Linux with some tweaks.
- jeffbee 3y agoEvery Chromebox runs Linux.
- mobilio 3y agoAnd Android too...
- bdcravens 3y agoIt's semantics, but I think it's useful to reserve the name "Linux" for devices that are the unrestricted version of the OS, otherwise the name starts to become as generic as the term "smart".
- jeffbee 3y agoDescribe a way in which the Linux implementation of ChromeOS is “restricted”.
- cbm-vic-20 3y agoAre we talking "Linux, the kernel", or "Linux, the typical user experience"?
- jeffbee 3y ago
- xd1936 3y agoMy higher education institution has bought every generation of these for Digital Signage since 2014. We use an open-source (abandonware?) Ruby project called Concerto[1] to generate webpages, and the Chrome OS Kiosk Mode[2] feature to boot these things straight to chrome-less full-screen web browsers that load Concerto webpages. It's a nice setup, but I do worry about the future support of both of those pillars. 1. https://github.com/concerto/concerto https://github.com/concerto/concerto 2. https://chromeenterprise.google/os/kiosk-and-digital-signage/ https://chromeenterprise.google/os/kiosk-and-digital-signage...
- soylentcola 3y agoWe used AOpen Chromeboxes for a while, but they stopped getting updates after several years. That part is somewhat understandable, but given that they were full ChromeOS devices, it was less than ideal. Ended up replacing them with Brightsign (which I believe is just Roku for signage) boxes and the campus started subscribing to Appspace for hosting content. It's been...ok.
- binkHN 3y agoI think I have an AOpen Chromebox 2; still getting updates.
- soylentcola 3y agoOurs were purchased before that second gen was available. They're perfectly capable of connecting to a remote service to download and display slides, but without security and other updates, they were no longer reliable for our uses. A simpler (and cheaper) device made more sense for as little as we needed them for. I kept one of them to fiddle with at home though.
- xd1936 3y agoYup. We're just now (as in the last year) starting to see bugs with our first-generation Chromeboxes (Asus CN60) that reached end-of-life in 2019 and stopped getting updates. Some server-side change has been intermittently causing them to fail to boot into the Kiosk Mode Chrome app lately. It sucks that we're looking at replacing perfectly good hardware just because of Google's unwillingness to continue providing updates.
- jlund-molfese 3y agoThe wireless charger is kind of weird. Those things generate a decent amount of heat and seem like something you’d want to buy separately and upgrade every few years rather than being stuck in a desktop. But obviously I’m not in the target audience, because that feature has received positive press.
- bdcravens 3y agoTarget market appears to be the high-density enterprise.
- leokennis 3y agoMy wife works at a “Chromebox workplace”. I’d say they are mostly meant for organizations who naturally are not IT-heavy (schools, healthcare) who are looking for cheap computers that are easily maintained (as everything happens in the browser) and that work for employees who don’t like or lack the expertise to babysit a computer. These are likely the same people that would never even think about upgrading a charger. Until now they just borrowed their coworkers $3 charger and now they can just put their phone on top of their computer.
- 8zah6q7 3y agoThat's probably there so that users don't plug their phones into the PCs. Also saves desk space.
- bdcravens 3y agoThe "high-end" configuration (12th-gen i5, 8GB RAM, 128GB SSD) is $675. https://shop.asus.com/us/90ms02n1-m002u0-asus-chromebox-5.html https://shop.asus.com/us/90ms02n1-m002u0-asus-chromebox-5.ht... edit: I originally read it as 4GB (listed as "4G DDR4 Memory x 2", not 8GB)
- smcleod 3y ago$1000AUD - What a rip off! For an extra 50% you could get a whole M2 MacBook Air.
- gymbeaux 3y agoTo me this is marketed towards enterprise, who wouldn’t flinch at paying even $2000 per computer. They would gladly pay it instead of the enterprise subscriptions to “antivirus turned bloatware” like Sophos or McAfee. The included wireless charger means they don’t have to buy a desk charger for all their employees (which they may feel the need to do if they give employees a company phone).
- jabroni_salad 3y agoWe are just really happy if employees stop plugging their phone into their computer to charge. We can give out USB condoms but we cant make people use them! As for the price, when you need to buy hundreds of units you start to value certain other services, like combined packaging. Last time I bought desktops they were just shrink wrapped to a pallet. When I buy chromebooks they come a dozen to a box. Best Buy isnt gonna do that.
- scintill76 3y ago> We can give out USB condoms but we cant make people use them! I don't work in BigCo IT, but shouldn't you just change the OS configuration to ignore the phone? Or is it also about training them to use safe charging practices for when your OS policies aren't there to force them?
- 3y ago
- nickcw 3y agoI'm a bit burnt by Chrome OS devices falling out of support. After the Auto Update Expiration (AUE) point don't expect any security updates. No security updates for something which is primarily web browser based makes it pretty useless. However this one is supported until June 2030 which is much better that I've seen before at 7 years. https://support.google.com/chrome/a/answer/6220366 https://support.google.com/chrome/a/answer/6220366
- notyourday 3y agoUse ChromeOS Flex - it works great. I'm running it on a ChromeBox that was out of support in 2018. Perfect video conference setup.
- rr808 3y agoYeah my child's Chromebook has this problem. Was a year-old model when bought, now is at AUE date after just 4 years. Still works really well so not sure if we should keep using or not.
- freeAgent 3y agoIs it getting security patches? That would be my primary concern since everything it does is web-based.
- rr808 3y agoNo security patches after expiration date. Not sure what problem is with lax security for schoolkids, maybe steal homework? https://support.google.com/chrome/a/answer/6220366?hl=en https://support.google.com/chrome/a/answer/6220366?hl=en
- e12e 3y agoSpear phishing for nudes/taking over the camera when your kid starts exploring porn? Ed: in general, for a box long enough out of support - just assume there's a zero-interaction exploit for full root - and consider if you want any family member to sit on front of an internet-enabled web cam, with sound, keylogger and screen capture?
- kgr 3y agoI worked at Google on a project called the Chrome App Builder which would let you create simple Kiosk apps which ran on these kind of devices. It wasn't uncommon for companies to buy these 5 thousand to 20 thousand at a time to run the displays in fast food restaurants, casinos, department stores, race tracks, etc.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoWhich looked like a really cool tool - until Google discontinued Chrome Apps...
- pzo 3y agoThis looks really nice. I hope ram is not soldered and can buy barebone without ram and ssd cheaper. This could be well adapted as media player, smart tv, smart speaker, router, local cloud, smart home gateway all in one - just plug usb 4g modem I always wondered why apple don’t try to more open up Apple TV and add some MagSafe like accessories that will transform it into smart speaker and router. Currently Apple TV can be bought for 150usd with remote, 4gb ram, 128gb memory, A15 bionic with 16x now, wifi 6, Bluetooth 5.0, thread for smart home, 1Gb Ethernet… … but just tvOS is so limited and ports are also very limited.
- crote 3y agoShame there is only one USB-C port. Peripherals are rapidly switching to USB-C, and adapters from C male to A male are a really bad idea. It would've been way better if they'd used 1xC + 1xA instead of 2xA on both the front and back.
- noisy_boy 3y agoDirect link to user manual: https://dlcdnets.asus.com/pub/ASUS/Desktop/Vivo_PC/CN67/E21339_CHROMEBOX_5_CN67_EM_WEB.pdf?model=CN67 https://dlcdnets.asus.com/pub/ASUS/Desktop/Vivo_PC/CN67/E213...
- jrm4 3y agoI like a lot of Google things, but buying something for its "general purpose OS" seems especially goofy. In my experience, it's just Linux minus the literal exact licensing and philosophy that, over time, made Linux good. In trade for that, you get a reasonably nice UI, a few more features, but most of all a very strong likelihood that Google drops support for you like a bad habit.
- _ea1k 3y agoTBH, a Linux box with a nice UI and all hardware well supported out of the box sounds like something we would have dreamed about 10 years ago. Chrome OS devices are seriously underrated.
- jrm4 3y agoMy first instinct was to reply "nah," because of how unfriendly to geeks they are compared to Linux -- but on the other hand, I must admit they are much better than Windows and much cheaper than Macs, so I suppose this is fair.
- _ea1k 3y agoHonestly, I've played with one quite a bit, and I wouldn't even say that are _that_ unfriendly to geeks. Root, vs code, npm, etc all run perfectly out of the box. It is more limiting if you want virtualization or even just containers, but that isn't always a requirement.
- seabrookmx 3y agoDocker runs fine under the ChromeOS Linux environment. Vanilla VM's are an issue because the Linux environment is itself a VM, and nested virtualization has lots of quirks.
- we_never_see_it 3y ago[flagged]
- ankurdhama 3y agoIf it doesn't make sense to continue it financially then it will be cancelled, just like any company would do.
- wvenable 3y agoGoogle domains is a license to print money. It's just not very sexy. It's not going to get anyone promoted.
- ralphc 3y agoAs an individual, especially a "hacker", I have no use for these things. But when I went to my state's Department of Driver Services (DMV) for my license renewal, there were a bunch of Chromeboxes running the check-in process and I saw the light. Single purpose, run the check-in web site, doesn't look like it's worth stealing, when they're obsolete just swap out the box and keep the monitor, mouse and keyboard. Makes perfect sense when you're buying hundreds or more at a time for your institution.
- jacquesm 3y agoYou can easily mod them to run stock Linux.
- seabrookmx 3y ago*some of them Not all of them run standard UEFI, and the ARM ones have all sorts of boot loader quirks ala smartphones.
- isawczuk 3y agoI'm baffled how black square box can be winner of RedDotDesign.
- swores 3y agoAm I super out of date, or is it surprising that non-dedicated GPU - Intel® Iris® Xe (i7/i5) - can run 4x 4k displays? Or will it struggle to do more than show non-moving stuff if using that many 4k screens? If the answer is that it can do that while keeping performance OK, then the moment I heard it's possible to install a proper Linux distro on it I'd buy one. Definitely not interested in a Google OS, though.
- aappleby 3y agoIntegrated GPUs have had sufficient fill rate to composite 4x4k pixels for a while now. 32 million pixels * 60 fps = 1.8 billion pixels per second, which is a lot but even integrated GPUs have compute measured in teraflops now. Memory bandwidth starts to become significant though - that 1.8Gpix/sec is 7.2Gbyte/s read, which is a big chunk of a DIMM's bandwidth if you have single-channel RAM.
- swores 3y agoThanks. I've never had a great understanding of GPUs though, maybe you could clarify for me - assuming decent RAM, how much could you do on those four 4k screens? Could you have a 4k video playing on each one? A game like CSGO that's more CPU heavy than GPU? More graphically intense games? Or is it more like it supports 4 monitors worth of business-type applications with maybe a single 4k video on one screen?
- aappleby 3y agoRough guess - CSGO on one monitor and web browsers on the other monitors would be OK, four 4k videos would probably not be ok. I looked up the specs for that GPU and they're roughly 1.5 teraflops compute and 20 gigapixels fill rate, so in theeeeory you could do a couple hundred FLOPSs and a dozen draws per 4kx4 pixel per frame, but in practice you're never going to get close to that.
- sliken 3y agoIndeed, definitely worth a second dimm. Careful some chromeboxes cheap out and offer only a single dimm. This is also why memory is often limited as 1x8GB or 2x4Gb. The second dimm is definitely worthwhile for improve GPU performance.
- jprd 3y agohttps://mrchromebox.tech/ https://mrchromebox.tech/
- ceving 3y agoDoes that case contain a fan?
- orloffm 3y agoCan someone recommend a cheap Chromeb\w* device reliably doing 4K@60? Some of them do that, but not with all displays. Some say they do, but have Intel UHD Graphics (as this Chromebox 5), which I find very suspicious.