5 ms·
Would love to see new builds factoring this in better too. i.e Grey water. Flushing toilets with flawless drinking water is insane
by Havoc 3y ago
Would love to see new builds factoring this in better too.
i.e Grey water.
Flushing toilets with flawless drinking water is insane
- erik_seaberg 3y agoOn one hand, we don't need potable water to flush a toilet. On the other hand, flushing a toilet with dirty water is going to leave your house smelling like whatever's in that water.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoAlready graywater is used in places like San Diego for watering public greenage, but I can’t detect any smell. Even if there is some very slight smell, sticking an ordinary deodorizer on your toilet bowl might be enough to suppress it entirely.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoIt doesn't have to be dirty / smelly, but it doesn't have to be fresh drinking water either. Filtered rain water is fine for example, plus bonus low mineral count to keep your pipes and toilet cleaner.
- throwaway290 3y agoYou should close the lid before flushing anyway... Stops bacteria spraying around
- throwaway290 3y agoI am guessing at least two people have issues with bathroom hygiene. Pro tip: you do not want fecal matter around.
- Faaak 3y agoI collect rainwater and flush my toilet + wash my clothes with it. It's not safe to drink, but it doesn't smell of anything and is nearly transparent.
- mnw21cam 3y agoI collect rainwater in water butts outside for watering the garden. They stink. What are you doing right that I'm doing wrong?
- EatingWithForks 3y agoHow often do you clean your rainwater collection receptacles? I clean mine out regularly.
- mnw21cam 3y agoI pressure washed them this spring, and bought new ones to add to them at the same time. How regularly?
- Faaak 3y agoNo direct sunlight + no direct heat. Of course, if the system is cycled frequently (i.e. the water doesn't stagnate for months), then it's even better
- marcosdumay 3y agoRainwater quality is a direct consequence of you local air pollution. You may not be doing anything wrong and still get a bad result, while somebody else in a different location may do a lot of things wrong and still get good results.
- goodcanadian 3y agoWhen I lived in Hawaii, we had rainwater catchment as our main/only water supply. We added some bleach to the (10000 gallon) catchment tank once per month and ran it through filters as it entered the house (the last filter was 5µm). Officially, it wasn't potable, but we installed an additional 0.5µm filter on a drinking water tap and never had a problem.
- atourgates 3y agoOur neighbor in rural Idaho has been drinking unfiltered rain water for decades without any (observed) ill effects. He did mention that he diverts the first few rainshowers of the year to flush out all the bird poop and debris that collect over the summer. I’m not sure I’d go that route, but it seems to work for him, and makes an area where wells don’t produce habitable.
- Havoc 3y ago>dirty water I meant more utility provided grey water. Meaning they still clean it up...just not all the way to drink quality. As with many things in life getting to those last few % to 100% are disproportionate and incrementally expensive/hard. So if you can flush toilets with 95% or whatever that's a win
- emmanuel_1234 3y agoHong Kong uses grey water for flushing toilets, and I never had a problem. Each building has its own tank (I believe, to pump the water and maintain a correct water pressure) that needs to be washed every now and then, but that's the same with fresh water.
- dirkf 3y agoIn my country it has been mandatory for at least a decade in any new construction or significant renovation to collect rain water and use it for at least flushing toilets. It's not that expensive to install at that time and saves a lot of potable water. Seems like a no-brainer to me to do this everywhere.
- sputter_token 3y agoIn some parts of America, collecting rainwater is illegal.
- sp332 3y agoRestrictions are mainly on commercial and especially agricultural use. It's not that bad for residential systems. https://www.worldwaterreserve.com/rainwater-harvesting/is-it-illegal-to-collect-rainwater/ https://www.worldwaterreserve.com/rainwater-harvesting/is-it... But in Georgia, you can only use the rainwater outdoors. So you can't legally flush your toilet with it.
- thsksbd 3y agoBecause, legally, you're stealing water from the basin and the basin's down stream users. You're also not paying for the sewer use if you flush with it (since sewer isn't metered)
- bombcar 3y agoSome municipalities have ways to handle the second (as you have homes that are on well water but city sewer). Usually it's a flat fee based on occupancy or square footage.
- freedude 3y agoThis is mostly a myth, but check your local ordinances. OR do like the rest of us Freedudes do. Just do it.
- wolverine876 3y agoWhere?
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoI live in a two-storey terraced house, it seems pretty simple to add a buffer tank to gravity feed the toilet cistern from the roof gutter. Presumably it's not cost effective or countries with nationalised water would be doing that already? Maybe they are?? Any good kits for this in the UK?
- viraptor 3y agoNot from the roof gutter, but check what Australia is doing. In new builds, I believe water collection tanks are mandatory now. You can use that for the garden, flushing, washing, etc. The usual system is described at https://www.yourhome.gov.au/water/rainwater https://www.yourhome.gov.au/water/rainwater but I'm sure you'll find many similar ones. Some could be adapted to use in the UK at small scale.
- james_pm 3y agoBC Place stadium in Vancouver, BC implemented a rainwater harvesting system on the 11 acre roof that collects and stores rainwater for use in cleaning, toilets, field irrigation and other non-potable uses. They estimate it saves 950,000L of drinking water per year. https://www.bcplace.com/blog/2021-04-22/how-bc-place-is-building-a-brighter-more-sustainable-future https://www.bcplace.com/blog/2021-04-22/how-bc-place-is-buil...
- paulcole 3y agoHow much pristine drinking water does BC Place use in a year (an important fact missing from the article)? If the answer is 2.5 million liters then I’m amazed. If the answer is 25 million liters, I’m much less impressed.
- lnsru 3y agoIt’s about amount needed for 40000 inhabitants for whole year. It’s impressive enough for me.
- paulcole 3y agoI'm not sure of your math here. Assuming Google is accurate and the average American is similar to the average Canadian. > The average American uses over 100 gallons of water per day 100 gallons/day * 365 days * 3.78 liters/gallon = 137,930 liters Isn't that just 8 or 9 people's drinking water? If you disagree with that, work backwards from your answer. 950,000 liters saved divided by 40,000 = 23.75 liters per year? That seems too low.
- andrewprock 3y agoThe 100 gallon average includes laundry, bathroom, home landscaping, golf courses and other things as well. Very little of that would be for drinking.
- paulcole 3y ago
- abwizz 3y agototally agree however, using greywater puts additional burden on the equipment in terms of maintenace (dirt layering on the walls and general externalities of unclean water) hence the economic incentives have to change before this will take on.
- thsksbd 3y agoAgreed, especially in water limited areas, but there's a reason it is used. potable water has very well defined properties. Its has a low salt concentration, pretty well known (and diminishing) chloride concentration, and known hardness. It wont give you any surprises when designing a water system. Grey water is whatever a human decided to put down certain drains. This could be very benign, but end users are... special. Will they out cooking grease down the drain? Will they pour industrial cleaners? How about if the end user is an artist who etches glass in the attic bathroom and rinse the HF in the sink? Will they pour "Jimmy"'s, the fish, bowl water and sand? Is shower water "grey"? How about those fellows (they exist) who poop in the shower and squish it down (one of the grossest things I learned on the internet)? And what about "Poochie", the pitbull, who loves to drink from the toilet bowl? What about "Max", the three year old toddler, who loves to wash his hands in the toilet bowl? Grey water should be used, extensively, but it is not a turn-key solution, and it certainly is way more expensive to build for.