7 ms·
They had this debate in China recently and the problem was conflict of interest (lots of pricey snake oil for dying patients who can come up with the money). Th
by seanmcdirmid 3y ago
They had this debate in China recently and the problem was conflict of interest (lots of pricey snake oil for dying patients who can come up with the money). The market has to be regulated even for dying people, if only to prevent scams.
- warent 3y agoDid the Chinese government ultimately regulate the market to protect people and prevent this kind of corruption?
- DiscourseFan 3y agoThe regulation is approval by a governmental agency through clinical trials
- dspillett 3y agoIIRC it did, though the cynic in me would suggest that by “this kind of corruption” what it prevents is the kind of corruption that government officials don't benefit from. I trust the Chinese government less than I trust my own with regard to doing the right thing (just because it is the right thing or indeed at all), and that is a pretty low bar…
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThis wiki article is probably the best place to start: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Wei_Zexi https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Wei_Zexi Then there was some movement on the issue in 2019: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-12-10/cancer-treatment-china-mulls-looser-experimental-therapy-rules https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-12-10/cancer-tr... I’m not sure where they ended up due to COVID happening next.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoPerhaps the patients should be allowed to use experimental treatments only under the condition that it is offered for free; the upside for the company is that if it works, they get the evidence of efficacy.
- rafark 3y agoThis should be the solution. If they’re trials for an unproven solution, why should they pay anything at all. I’m any case, it should be the other way around; it’s the companies who should pay the person for subjecting them to something very likely to be dangerous and painful. In any case, I agree with the sentiment here. People should have the right to choose.
- Wowfunhappy 3y ago> the upside for the company is that if it works, they get the evidence of efficacy. They don't, though. They need a control group.
- londons_explore 3y agoAnd that is why you shouldn't be able to ask for the experimental treatment... You should be able to ask to be part of a trial of the experimental treatment. Remember that if 10 treatments are being tried at once, you can divide the pool of participants so that only a smallish percentage are part of the control group.
- Wowfunhappy 3y ago...I think that's basically how it works? If the company is running a trial, you can enroll in the trial. AFAIK being in a trial is free for participants. Of course, there are any number of reasons someone may be rejected from the trial. If that happens, the company isn't going to just freely give them the drug anyway, because it wouldn't provide scientifically valid data. Also, no one would enroll in a trial (which carries the potential of getting the placebo) if they could get the treatment outside the trial.
- starkparker 3y agoThe drug itself might be paid for, as well as tests under the scope of the study (which might be narrow), but services to administer the drug, and tests or treatment for effects not in the scope of the study, aren't always covered. Or, in the stupidest cases, approval gets bogged down by the drug company, patient, or administering clinic/practitioner trying to get the patient's insurance to cover whatever's not covered by the trial for so long that the patient no longer qualifies (or is dead) by the time insurance relents and agrees to pay.
- citizenpaul 3y agoI was going to make this point. People at EOL by default often have estates, investments, retirement accounts. In other words huge chunks of money/wealth that unscrupulous people may wish to get their hands on. Combine that with the desperation of a dying person and you have the perfect condition to create a very profitable scammer market for worthless treatments. This also harms eveyone because all the money pouring into a treatment that was a scam from day one is oppertunitu y lost.
- throwuwu 3y agoI think the argument is to loosen the regulation on human trials, not to drop all regulation on drug companies. They should still have to prove that they’re doing legitimate research and have had some success before opening it up to humans who are terminally ill. They should still be legally culpable for negligence and fraud.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoKeep in mind that it's not the pharma companies that are the only, or even most notorious, scammers that would benefit. Families of the dying one are a major risk factor. The difficult[0] truth is, plenty of families would accelerate the demise of a terminally ill or elderly[1] if it were possible. Like with euthanasia, any elective experimental treatment that carries increased risk of death, could become something the patients get pressured or manipulated into by their families. -- [0] - The situations can be ethically and emotionally complex, so I'm not passing any generalized judgement, other that this is something a person might be concerned about when contemplating the possibility of ending up in this situation in the future. [1] - Arguably the same thing, but that's another topic.
- civilitty 3y ago> This also harms eveyone because all the money pouring into a treatment that was a scam from day one is oppertunitu y lost. You guys remember Theranos? When Safeway announced their deal with Theranos in 2012, a bunch of companies working in blood diagnostics folded because they couldn’t raise money or because their investors clawed back entire rounds. A couple of friends had just raised a series B round to commercialize their surface plasmon resonance blood testing device, which would have actually done what Theranos promised with onsite blood testing (except with proper blood draw, not a finger prick). They were getting the product ready for golden standard testing with a CRO when investors decided it wasn’t worth trying to compete with a Theranos already in the pocket of major pharmacies and pulled the series B funding. Patents ended up getting sold to some patent troll shortly before the news broke that Theranos was a scam. The people who funded Theranos weren’t even desperate, just greedy. Imagine what fingers they’ll put on the scales when they’re actually staring death right in the face? It’ll be a disaster.
- short_throw 3y agoThere are tradeoffs here, but the current approach seems to protect people's inheritances better than people's lives. Selling straight up snake oil is still fraud, and letting money be thrown at overhyped but ineffective treatments is a smaller tragedy than forcing people to die when treatments exist.
- RobotToaster 3y agoWhich is why there needs to be a process to approve experimental drugs as at least scientifically plausible. There's a difference between something that works at least in a petri dish or mice, and something with no plausible mechanism of action like homoeopathy.
- varelse 3y ago[dead]
- nohuck13 3y agoIf they can come up with the money then who cares? It would be a much better case for regulating if there were some external payer.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoTheir parents and/or kids come up with money. It is basically theft. If you are ok with theft, fine, otherwise we shouldn’t exempt it just because of the false hope it provides.
- akira2501 3y agoThat seems like a claims and marketing issue, which is entirely separate from merely producing a drug and selling it when asked. I think it's fine that the FDA regulates advertising, I don't think it's fine that they act as gatekeepers to pharmaceutical products.
- sacrosancty 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aeternum 3y agoThis is a very weak excuse. If preventing scams is the main concern then old people should also be banned from purchasing real estate, timeshares, large donations, perhaps even giftcards in certain quantities. You can't have freedom without some chance of people making bad choices.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoDad asks me for a lot of money to help him buy a time share, I’ll feel ok saying no. Dad asks me for a lot of money for a snake oil cure that might prevent him from dying from bile duct cancer in a month or two…how am I going to say no to that?
- __pache__ 3y ago"No dad, it's a scam; there's no evidence, 100 people have taken it with no success, etc." I have a severely disabled dad and have had this convo.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoYou'll find out that when your dad has just a few weeks to live, those conversations will get harder.
- __pache__ 3y ago??? What? I don't think so? Literally experiencing this right now...
- jccalhoun 3y agoAhhh. This answers a question I've had: I'm in the USA and one of my senators has been banging the drum for allowing patients access to experimental drugs for a few years. I have wondered why this was an issue for him. Maybe I'm cynical but this and easy PR win for him seems like good reasons why.
- rajanaccros 3y agoI guess it would depend on the reason for denial to a patient. If it is solely because it isn't regulatory approved yet then that doesn't seem sufficient. If the drug was provided for free from the pharma company it would be a faster path to a human trial which would be a win/win for all involved with the only possible negative for a person who doesn't have anything to lose.