8 ms·
Wage slave? Or slave to the wage?
- hexis 15y agoYou could also start a business and not hire employees. It's not right for every business idea, but if you can manage it, it's pretty amazing.
- einhverfr 15y agoGuilds and cooperatives may work where employees are required.
- benjaminwootton 15y agoIndeed. I have no interest in building a company with employees, but owning and running your own one man product business sounds amazing.
- siavosh 15y agoMy concern with this has always been that you can never really have any time off if you're supporting a product, i.e. always having to check your email making sure customer questions are being answered and your servers aren't on fire.
- ahoyhere 15y agoYour concerns are mistaken on multiple levels: 1. It's not really that hard to take time away from your business. It's a common fear but not based in actual experience, and therefore irrational. When you have an established group of customers, yes, if you ignore support entirely for a while, you will likely lose a few. But if you have a largish group, losing a few won't matter. It's all about leverage. When you have a few customers, each one matters very much. When you have several hundred or several thousand, each one matters only a little. You have the leverage, instead of them. That is why running a product biz is not "wage slavery" -- assuming you set it up right, which brings us to 2. If you want to be able to take lots of time off, design your business around it. Yes, if you create a mission-critical infrastructure service, you will either have to have support people in place. But you don't HAVE to create that kind of business. You can do something that's less mission-critical and with customers who are more laid-back. 3. There is a huge gulf between "totally ignoring your business" and "putting it on pause for a while." My husband and I recently took a month-long trip to NZ and we hired a very part-time support person to run interference while we were gone. She was able to answer basic questions, gather details about bugs, etc., and tell customers with harder issues that we would be back soon. I worked about an hour a day average (2-3 hours at a stretch, not every day). It worked great. Unusually, we had 1 server issue with our 2nd product. My husband took a bit of time to restart and contact our freelance sys admin, and that was that. In the scheme of things, people will cancel for all kinds of reasons, many of which you cannot possibly control, and it's not a big deal. Commerce is a business relationship, and people end business relationships when they do not feel like they're getting a return of value for their money, and that's that. I know some folks would consider it a deep moral failing to not do everything in one's power to deliver the world's best customer service. That kind of attitude will not make your customers any happier, but it will make you more miserable.
- patio11 15y agoFirst, what Amy says. Second, http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/03/20/running-a-software-business-on-5-hours-a-week/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/03/20/running-a-software-busin... I run two software businesses. One of them is fairly critical. I'm taking off ~2.5 months this year for my wedding. (I.e. I anticipate less than 10 minutes a day of work during that... assuming I can't hire anyone to do it for me.) I've previously sustained that level of work for weeks or months. It really is doable.
- einhverfr 15y agoOne of the most interesting books I read was "The Servile State" by Hilaire Belloc. Belloc suggests that in fact most people when desperate will gladly trade freedom for subsistence. He suggests the natural evolution of class warfare is from unrestrained capitalism to a welfare state, to one which legally compels workers to labor for the benefit of someone else. And indeed that's the system we have in the US, if you listen to folks like Cornell West and look into the prison industrial complex. The way out, as both Belloc and his contemporary Chesterton (Note: I am NOT a Catholic. I am NOT even a Christian. I am not endorsing Chesterton's religious writings) thought was to try to push for an economy of the self-employed. This idea may seem less welcome on a VC site.... But the basic idea is that if labor and capital fight, both get to declare victory, but really Capital wins. The way to win if you are on the labor side is no to play the game, and go into business for yourself as an independent agent, freed from worker protections but also in a relative position of power and freedom compared to where you would be as an employee. Time was when almost everyone was self-employed. The only reason it isn't for everyone is we make it so darn hard in the US. I say that as one who has been in Indonesia and Malaysia for the past six months and I can say that no third world country makes it as hard to be self-employed as we do in the US. Indeed no developed nation does either.....
- tomg 15y agoAs a chronically self-employed person, I'm curious why you believe it is so difficult to be self employed in the US. The World Bank lists the US as #4 on the Ease of Doing Business list [1]. Anecdotally, I've found it very easy to do the proper paperwork to become officially self-employed. For under a thousand bucks you can even have someone else do it for you if you're so inclined. Another personal example is how a man I met from Italy could not believe that I owned my own one-man business, as such a thing would be nearly impossible in his own country. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ease_of_Doing_Business_Index http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ease_of_Doing_Business_Index
- SageRaven 15y agoThere's paperwork? I was independent pulling in random 1099 work for 5 years and the only extra paperwork I did was "Schedule C". I assume that owning a business proper would require a ton of forms and licensing. But just doing odd jobs for oneself? I didn't think anything special was required.
- davidw 15y agoSounds like the "E-Myth revisited" situation where the business was something that was not separate from her. A "real business" is one that does not make you a slave to it: it's something that you own, rather than something you must be intimately involved in for it to continue functioning. You make money when you are sleeping. Not sure where the downvotes are from on this, it's not exactly some horrible thing to say about someone: many businesses "are" their owners. But unless you recognize that, you'll never fix it.
- mseebach 15y agoThe term "wage slave" annoys me greatly. You're a "slave" to whatever arrangements you can make to exchange your work for food and shelter. If you're a freelancer, you're a "slave" to finding clients and chasing payments, if you're a start-up founder, you're a "slave" to building and selling a product, if you're a subsistence farmer, you're a "slave" to cultivating the ground. The usage of the word "slave" masks the fact that "wage slaves" enjoy unprecedented freedom in choosing their "master". Yes, there are unhelpful patterns in consumerism in which people more or less consciously reduce the options available to them, but I don't think talking about wage slavery is very meaningful in that situation, either: If you have trouble moderating your personal consumption, the uncertainty of self-employment is most certainly not for you.
- calibraxis 15y agoThere is a relation of order-giver and order-taker. If you are a wage slave, you obey someone called a boss. Though I agree that wage slavery is better than chattel slavery.
- AndrewDucker 15y agoAnd if you're a startup-owner then you obey a bunch of people called "customers". There is nobody who is free of all relationships.
- _delirium 15y agoThat's the general point of the discussion, I think: trying to get yourself into a position where you have the most personal freedom, even if there is no such thing as perfect freedom. I agree "slave" is being a bit overdramatic in most cases, though. I'd only really apply the metaphor to desperate people who really have no choice but to work a shitty job with no alternatives or prospects of escape (the quasi-indentured-servitude 19th-century working conditions that led to the term "wage slavery" being coined, and today applying to some migrant farm laborers and similar). But I saw the post using it mostly as a half-joking counterpoint to the "quit your wage-slave job and start a startup!" sentiment that gets passed around a lot.
- maeon3 15y agoUsing the phrase "wage slave" to refer to a business owner who must make payroll even when profits are down is a bit of a stretch. A slave can't choose to stop working, but a business owner can cut payroll to zero by liquidating everyone and everything and taking a year long vacation.
- ars 15y agoA year long vacation? With what money? And by that logic a wage slave can stop by quitting his job and taking a year long vacation. Do you suffer from the belief that if you own a business you must be rich?
- maeon3 15y agoIf you own a business and have a big payroll to make say more than 5 people at some salary between min wage and 100k/year then I would think they have far more freedom to extract themselves from the rat race than someone living hand to mouth working minimum wage. You are right, a business owner could be a slave to others if they are not profitable and he has debts to other entities. Still, I reserve "slave" for those people lower on the food chain.
- ilaksh 15y agoGood point. A responsible and moral person will feel an obligation to his employees to maintain the business. Of course many business owners are disconnected enough that they don't rely on the income of a particular business and don't have qualms with cutting staff. However, I think its important to understand the historical context of the term "wage slave". Go back to serfdom. The lord owns the land, and in order to live there, a serf must provide service in the form of agricultural production or whatever else the lord wants him to do. Supposedly the lord or his king would provide "protection" by hiring knights and such. If the serf refuses to serve or pay up (by donating his harvest etc.) then he is removed from the land or killed. This is similar to the way that a Mafia operates. Fast forward to the "American System of Enter-prise". Prise: "something taken by force," late 14c., from O.Fr. prise "a taking, seizing, holding," prop. fem. pp. of prendre "to take, seize," from L. prendere, contraction of prehendere (see prehensile). Especially of ships captured at sea (1510s). pry (2) "raise by force," 1823 (originally also a noun, "an instrument for prying, a crowbar"), alteration of prize (as though it were a plural) in obsolete sense of "lever" (c.1300), from O.Fr. prise "a taking hold, grasp" (see prize (n.2)). What might one use a pry bar for? Manacles. In the American System of Enter-prise, capital (money) translates into land and business ownership and power. Rather than having land directly granted to the lords by the King, banks provide loans to those who can demonstrate a history of ownership (a parallel to the authentication of nobility). Rather than working the land directly for subsistence, workers are required to exchange wages for money to pay for food and the right to stay in their homes. A worker who does not please his boss or the ownership will be fired and no longer receive wages. Because of urbanization, few people have the land, skills or other requirements for producing their own food, and must purchase food with money earned through wages. Without wages, the worker cannot pay his rent/mortgage. Therefore, a man who has been fired by his boss will starve and lose his home if he cannot quickly find another boss (owner). Despite the introduction of money and new terminology, class structures and circumstances similar to those in feudal society occur in the contemporary system.