6 ms·
I will never understand HDR. A friend has tried to explain it many times to me, but I always fail to get it. A display just has so much dynamic range (from full
by stavros 3y ago
I will never understand HDR. A friend has tried to explain it many times to me, but I always fail to get it. A display just has so much dynamic range (from full light off to full light on). HDR can't give you more range, so what does it actually do?
The only thing I've seen it do is override my brightness setting to make my screen go to full brightness when I've set it lower.
- LeoPanthera 3y agoHDR increases the granularity of available brightness levels, from 0-255 to some higher level. (1023, usually.) It then defines the "old" 100% level to be some value less than the new maximum. It is usually combined with new display technologies that can emit unusually high brightness levels. On a traditional display there is obviously no point.
- stavros 3y agoAh, this kind of makes sense, but then why wouldn't they map the old 100% to the new maximum? I can understand the increased granularity, if you're making monitors that go much brighter, then you get more light levels, but why define the old maximum to be less than the new maximum?
- krackers 3y agoSo there is always headroom to show HDR content.
- stavros 3y agoSo the innovation of HDR is that it always makes my screen dimmer so it can sometimes drive it to full brightness and say "look, magic"?
- krackers 3y agoYes that's essentially how I understand it: hardware-wise HDR is basically "a really bright screen" coupled with good black levels. To ensure that you always get the HDR effect at any brightness, you need to reserve some headroom. It should be noted that you probably could not sustain this peak brightness for long anyhow due to thermal issues. You might be interested in reading https://prolost.com/blog/edr https://prolost.com/blog/edr which explains in more detail.
- pizza 3y agoBasically your eyes can see much more than SDR. There are lots of colors that are smooshed together on an SDR monitor that would be distinct on an HDR monitor. Sometimes this means more vivid colors, or sometimes this means much more subtle gradients, or sometimes darker darks that don't get killed by neighboring brights. Whether the effect is significant depends on a lot of stuff; how the display is built, how the codec works, your viewing conditions, and not least of all, whether the content "looks better" artistically with that much more range. Just like the compression audio effect clips the range of music and how some pieces of music sound more expressive when the range in amplitudes is used well for artistic effect.
- stavros 3y agoBut this only tells me that some monitors can show more colors than others. If you made a monitor that can show more colors, does it matter what you call it? SDR or HDR, it can still show more colors than other monitors.
- davrosthedalek 3y agoThe idea is that "full red" should always be about the same brightness (user controlled, so "same"). Not "red" on an SDR screen and "iris burning bright red" on a HDR screen. Essentially, you want to extend your color parameter space to give the iris-burning range new names so that SDR and HDR images can both be displayed sensibly.
- benabbottnz 3y agohttps://webkit.org/blog-files/color-gamut/ https://webkit.org/blog-files/color-gamut/ Look at the second example ( red images) and click the Display P3 option. Do you see the symbol inside? No? Well then your display / monitor isn’t capable of showing a colour range higher than sRGB. HDR is similar in respect to brightness and contrast. If your device supports HDR, then there’s more steps in the brightness scale that your monitor can display.
- stavros 3y agoIs higher granularity all HDR is, then? Other commenters mention that the HDR brightness max is more than what the SDR brightness max is defined as, which seems odd to me. It's as if you're crippling the display for SDR permanently.
- skavi 3y agoRec.709 actually defines a peak luma of 100 nits. sRGB has it defined as 80 nits. These numbers are really only for mastering, but as you push further from the standard you start to see artifacts, namely banding in gradients. HDR standards require higher bit depth and define higher peak brightness. In addition, and this is probably technically the toughest bit, they define dynamic metadata formats which define tone mapping as the content changes [0]. One thing you may be missing about the particular effect we see on this website is that it disappears as you turn your device brightness up. So you can still get that brightness with SDR content. [0]: https://www.avforums.com/articles/what-is-4k-hdr-dynamic-metadata.13402/ https://www.avforums.com/articles/what-is-4k-hdr-dynamic-met...
- Dylan16807 3y agoIdeal HDR goes up to 10000 nits or higher. It would be ridiculous to put SDR white anywhere near that level. And there is no need to cripple anything. Brightness adjustment can/should let you put SDR white all the way up to the max full-screen brightness. If a manufacturer cripples that it's not HDR's fault. But it's also important to note that "max full-screen brightness" is often a lot less than maximum spot brightness.
- grishka 3y agoThe way it is implemented on recent Apple devices is that the maximum brightness your display hardware is actually capable of is much higher than the color #FFFFFF at the maximum brightness available in settings. In other words, there's quite a lot of headroom that is only ever used for HDR content. This results in quite a strange sight of something (a QR code in this case) being much brighter than all of its surrounding UI.
- stavros 3y agoThat's odd, though, right? Why would they constantly cap the brightness of my screen, which I could really do with in bright light, just in case I watch some HDR content at some point?
- grishka 3y agoTheir idea is that you won't ever need your UI to be this bright, I guess? It's Apple, that's what they do — they build things that work optimally for most people. They aren't wrong about it in this particular case either. The MacBook Pro display does get bright enough for me as is to be readable in direct sunlight. But if you do want to "use the full potential of your hardware", there was some third-party app that used private APIs to set the screen brightness above that limit. I don't remember its name.
- jojobas 3y agoThis sounds incredibly stupid to me, giving some unspecified range of content providers access to things that users don't have access to. But that's Apple for you I guess.
- grishka 3y agoWhat do you mean by "some unspecified range of content providers"? You can edit your own HDR videos on it too. Affinity Photo also allows using the HDR mode for viewing raw photos. The APIs to sear user's retinas are there, they are public and available to all native apps, it's just that there's a very strict distinction between SDR and HDR content.
- Groxx 3y agosRGB defines these colors: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SRGB https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SRGB Every (compliant) screen will produce that range, when given numbers between the minimum and maximum. It's nowhere near every color we can see (the dark gray area), but it is a decent manufacturing target and it covers a very practical area of our vision. Screens could just produce their maximum range all the time... but then you'd get screwed up colors, with every display being different than the others (some redder, some greener, etc.). Hence standard color ranges, like sRGB, so bananas used for color scale always look the same shade of yellow. That triangle looks the same on my screen as it does on yours, assuming the manufacturer cared at all about consistency. (remember the stupidly red OLEDs when they were new? they looked awful, humans looked like oompah loompahs) So screens are capable of more than they normally display, sometimes by a pretty large margin. Somehow you have to tell the screen to go beyond its normal range, to show yellower yellows for super-bananas - that's HDR.
- MBCook 3y agoThere are generally TWO things going on, and we use one term. I think that’s because generally displays do both so it’s just easier. One is that HDR displays can usually get MUCH brighter. An iPhone 5 could do 500 nits. An iPhone 14 Pro can do 1,000 - 2,000 nits. That’s what’s used here. You get all the same colors as before, but max brightness is way brighter. The other thing is color gamut. The standard we had for a long time was 24-bit color, so ~16.7 million colors. Instead of having 8 bits per channel, screens may now have 10 or 12 bits per channel. I can’t find just how many a modern iPhone has. This means there are more shades between black and 100% bright red. There are more variations between blueish green and greenish blue. Gradients can be smoother. Objects that are mostly one color (yellow corn, a red apple, etc) now have more options the can use to provide definition and details. In a very dark scene, there are now more dark shades to show things with. When looking at bright clouds, they don’t have to be all white and washed out. And combined with the increased brightness a scene can show definition in both dark and bright areas without having to wash everything out.
- MBCook 3y agoBTW there are, or at least were, wide gamut only displays. I have one Dell made a few years ago. It supports the additional colors of P3 but isn’t any brighter than any other quality normal display of the time.
- lstamour 3y agoTechnically, then, that display is like OLED TVs pre-2018, which could only display about 70-85% of P3 wide gamut because they could not go bright enough across the entire display. They were amazingly bright if a small part of the panel needed to be lit, though, with excellent contrast ratios. By comparison, most LED panels that are wide gamut but don’t have dimming zones can only display a uniform brightness or dimness and often struggle to make colours pop against darker backdrops the way they do on MacBook screens (with dimming zones) or iPhones (with OLED screens). Point is, just because something is wide gamut doesn’t mean it can display the entire gamut nor does it mean it can display the entire gamut at the same time. Its quality can vary by image and lighting technology (since the quality and brightness of colours all rely on their lighting source, etc.) as well as the image content demanded to be displayed and the lighting of the room (since your eyes have to perceive the screen too, against whatever backdrop or lighting your room has).
- abhibeckert 3y ago> HDR can't give you more range, so what does it actually do? It does give you more range. A lot of modern screens literally can't run at their full dynamic range, they would draw too much power and/or get too hot (some professional displays I use at work have a power cable as thick as your thumb and radiate heat like an oven with the door open. They also require following warm-down procedures to prevent the electronics from failing if they cool down too quickly when you power them off). They can, however, run at full brightness for a small section of the display or brief periods of time. HDR videos are one way to instruct the screen to do that. (obviously, how much range it can give you depends what screen technology you have - Apple's software has supported this for a long time, but even some current model displays they sell can't really do HDR properly - though many that "cant" to HDR are able to make a best effort using complex software tricks)
- stavros 3y agoThank you, I hadn't thought of full screen vs spot brightness!
- geocar 3y ago> HDR can't give you more range, It gives you more range. > so what does it actually do? If you have done a little C programming, you will know (or can check) that a 32-bit `int` represents values from -2147483648 to 2147483647 while a 32-bit `float` goes from -340282346638528859811704183484516925440. to 340282346638528859811704183484516925440. - clearly more "range". This is almost exactly what is happening here. (If you haven't done a little C programming, you should!) > The only thing I've seen it do is override my brightness setting to make my screen go to full brightness when I've set it lower. That is too bad. My experience is very good: only the QR code becomes much more striking, while the rest of the display remains the same. Perhaps it is implemented by increasing the brightness on your display to compensate for the reduced range available due to your brightness setting, but if that's what is happening here, something else is also compensating the colours to make the non-HDR areas of my display darker so that I cannot notice.
- midasuni 3y agoA 32 bit float and only represent 2^32 numbers (maybe less), same as a 32 bit int. What’s happening here is using a short (16 bit) rather than a byte (8 bit), although not quite to the same extent, for each channel. HDR allows you to represent 2^6/12/18 times as many colors as SDR.
- geocar 3y agoHDR10 is 10-bits per component and there are plenty of 16-bit images that aren't HDR, for example: http://i.imgur.com/Wm2kSxd.png http://i.imgur.com/Wm2kSxd.png -- the main thing about using HDR is to increase the range of values, i.e. what the biggest and smallest values are, not merely how many distinct values you can represent.
- midasuni 3y agoWell that’s just the colour space, you’ve also got the gamma curve to consider when you look at the perception of how something looks
- zokier 3y agoLot of HDR tech is actually making sure that old conventional SDR sRGB looks "correct" (what people expect) on these newfangled displays. Lot of problems stem from lot of tech basically completely ignoring color management, even if wide-gamut displays were already a thing before HDR. Basically if srgb content was just naively stretched to rec2020 it'd look garish and oversaturated instead of what the designer/photo/videographer intended. If it was additionally stretched to HDR, it'd look garish and eye-searingly bright. Because the differences between HDR displays and SDR is so dramatic it is forcing everyone to scramble to do color management as the result would be pretty unusable otherwise.
- pokerface_86 3y ago[dead]