21 ms·
Linguists have identified a new English dialect that’s emerging in South Florida
- alehlopeh 3y agoIt goes a lot deeper than this in Miami. A big chunk of suburban miami is populated by white Cuban exiles and their descendants. Growing up we spoke in Spanglish, which involves switching back and forth between English and Spanish, often multiple times within the same sentence. The switch between languages isn’t random, though. There are rules that govern which words you should say in which language, when to switch, etc. I’ve never heard anyone investigating how these rules work, but there are millions of Americans of Cuban descent in Miami for whom Spanglish is their true native language.
- pfannkuchen 3y ago> The switch between languages isn’t random, though We kind of do this already in mainline English, switching between Germanic, French, Latin and Greek based on some unwritten rules. Adding Spanish wouldn’t really change things that much considering its close relatives French and Latin are already so well represented. Though I’m sure the Spanish part is more dominant in this dialect than it would be eventually in the broader language.
- EduardoBautista 3y agoSpanglish is not necessarily using English words in Spanish or vice/versa. It's using "troca" ("trucka"?) instead of "camioneta" when referring to "truck". Another example is "parkear" instead of "estacionar" when referring to "parking". This is in the case of the Mexican dialect of Spanglish.
- idlewords 3y agoIt's extremely common in every situation like this, the grammar of the original language stays but the lexicon (nouns especially) gets rapidly switched out with borrowings and calques from the surrounding language.
- rrradical 3y agoOh interesting. Japanese is like this. Many years ago it absorbed Chinese nouns, but more recently it has absorbed many English nouns. Some Americans learning Japanese will regret this last part- wishing that the language stayed “pure”, as if it were ever actually pure, whatever that means.
- fknorangesite 3y ago> Japanese is like this. Every language is like this.
- semi-extrinsic 3y agoExcept Icelandic.
- arnsholt 3y agoOh, even Icelandic: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helvítis_fokking_fokk https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helvítis_fokking_fokk
- eru 3y agoDifferent languages embrace this to different degrees.
- WorldMaker 3y agoWith modern French the interesting one trying to fight this sort of natural evolution by defering a lot of language changes to their Academy and intentionally replacing calques and borrowings with "corrected" versions. Their Academy isn't always successful in getting French speakers to conform to their "corrected" words, but it is fascinating that they still try.
- biggoodwolf 3y agoSimilar happens in Spanish, I think just the attempt is valuable in and of itself, if for no other purpose that asking the question, "can we do better?". Otherwise one ends with English and its lowest-common denominator antics
- muststopmyths 3y agoparqueo and parquear are used widely in Central and South America so I am not sure it's fair to call them Spanglish. Provided the term is meant to apply to the Spanish spoken by immigrants and/or border area residents in the US.
- riffraff 3y agoParcheggio and parcheggiare are used in Italian too, I'm pretty sure they're not derived from English, but from "parco" (park), which has Indo-European roots.
- ftyers 3y agoIn Spain at least there is a difference between estacionar (to stop with the engine running) and aparcar (to stop and leave). In Mexico the two things are more or less merged, and if you say estacionar or parquear depends on how much English influence there is on your idiolect... Or how close to the border you are o/~ y sus troconas del año, que afuera tenian parqueadas o/~
- cfinnberg 3y agoActually "aparcar" and "estacionar" are synonyms (at least in Spain, but I think also in latin America [0]) Maybe you meant "parar" or "detener" (to stop), that don't clarify by them self if the engine has to be stopped or not (usually is the whole sentence what clarifies that) [0]: https://www.fundeu.es/recomendacion/aparcarestacionarparquear/ https://www.fundeu.es/recomendacion/aparcarestacionarparquea...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cool_dude85 3y agoYou don't switch between Greek and French while speaking English.
- babelfish 3y agoThe doctor performed the Hippocratic Oath on the terrace.
- asveikau 3y agoImported vocabulary is not code switching.
- IIAOPSW 3y agoIs this gatekeeping?
- zirgs 3y agoWhat's the difference?
- samtho 3y agoCode-switching (linguistically) requires the speaker to be multilingual and it describes the process and patterns used to determine when words are spoken in one language versus the other. Imported vocabulary/borrowed words simply describes loanwords that make it into the common lexicon of speakers of the receiving language but not necessarily speakers of the donor language.
- tchaffee 3y agoYou're missing the point of how the vocabulary got imported. It was thanks to code switching.
- samtho 3y agoI don’t disagree with the idea that code-switchers introduce new vocabulary to the general public at all, in fact, the two terms describe a word or phrase at different phases of its journey to integration within a language. In other words, there exists a point in the history of the language or dialect, the use of word or phrase ceases to be code-switching and becomes widely accepted as imported vocabulary. There is a distinction, however, that not all words that are used via code-switching are going to become part of common enough vernacular that it would become accepted within a language, and likewise, there may be cases where loanwords do not enter a language via speakers that code-switch it into their daily vocabulary.
- hsush 3y agoI don't think you're referring to anything remotely approaching bilingual speech. Educated English speakers might use "a priori" or "in vino veritas" or some word in French here in there, but those are tiny changes compared to how spanglish is spoken in Florida and other parts.
- idlewords 3y agoThere's a less widespread but similar phenomenon with the older generation of Polish immigrants in Chicago, who use Polish grammar but an almost entirely English lexicon. I've met a few people who I straight up couldn't understand, and I'm bilingual in the two languages they fused together.
- kevinmchugh 3y agoIs that at all influenced by regional differences in the Poles that came to Chicago? I grew up with a lot of first-gen highlander Polish-Americans (in the Chicago suburbs). They apparently have some differences with earlier important groups, eg, my family friends who pronounce grandmother "Busia".
- andrewshadura 3y agoI'm a Belarusian, and Busia totally makes sense to me (as a simplification of babusia/babula), even though I probably wouldn't use it myself.
- kevinmchugh 3y ago"important" should be "immigrant" here
- idlewords 3y agoHighlanders have their own dialect, but it's intelligible the same way Londoners can understand Scots. What happens after long exposure to Chicago is that half the lexicon gets swapped out with English words pronounced with Polish phonetics. Those people in their youth spoke very easily understandable Polish, but what they speak today makes sense only to them.
- Pet_Ant 3y agoHighlanders = górale ?
- kevinmchugh 3y agoI think so? Google suggests that's what I mean? In English - the only language I know - they always said Highlanders. The only other distinguishing piece of information I have is that this was a common car window sticker: https://i.etsystatic.com/16056651/r/il/a2f7e1/2469515581/il_794xN.2469515581_7apx.jpg https://i.etsystatic.com/16056651/r/il/a2f7e1/2469515581/il_...
- sportslife 3y agoDo you have any guesses as to the contours of the rules followed? Maybe family v. friend v. work usage, or such? I've lived most my life in very multi-lingual cities and neighborhoods, and it always struck me how some English very expressive short phrases, eg. "Like, no way", were used in other language conversations. Always thought, it was the relative brevity and ubiquity, in the way "C'est la vie" was for awhile in English.
- zdragnar 3y agoWatching international versions of Taskmaster - originally a British show, which has now been done in many countries in Europe and elsewhere- it's always been amusing to hear random English phrases get blurted out. Brevity of phrase is part of it, but it doesn't seem to happen in conversational tones- usually either when someone is showing off or as an interjection of sorts.
- kadoban 3y agoWhat's your favorite versions? I've watched the UK and NZ ones (and I know the US one isn't worth it), but I haven't gotten into the non-English ones yet.
- zdragnar 3y agoOther than those two, the Australian and Norweigan (Kongen Befaller) are great, though early on in Norway's seasons there'll be a fair number of repeat tasks from the UK version. Same for Denmark (Stormester), perhaps more so. Portugal's is pretty decent, though the format runs two hours per episode. I also thought the Croation version (Direktor Svemira) was decent, though the individual cast members lean hard into their own stereotypes (Lidija as the personification of the male gaze, for example). Sweden's is really popular, but I personally didn't care for it at all. As with the US version, it's probably best to pretend that Spain and Belgium's didn't happen.
- kadoban 3y agoThanks! I did not even realize there were so many! I imagine it's a popular format due to how well it can go for comparatively little budget and planning. I'll have to track those down. Two hours per episode for Portugal's sounds _wild_, I'm interested to see how that goes.
- msla 3y agoThat's called code-switching https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code-switching https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code-switching > In linguistics, code-switching or language alternation occurs when a speaker alternates between two or more languages, or language varieties, in the context of a single conversation or situation. Code-switching is different from plurilingualism in that plurilingualism refers to the ability of an individual to use multiple languages,[1] while code-switching is the act of using multiple languages together. The whole rest of the article is the result of linguists studying it.
- Fellshard 3y agoThat is an entirely different phenomenon.
- msla 3y agoOK, what makes it different?
- Fellshard 3y agoHmm, looking further. It seems the linguistic phenomenon of code-switching is one accurate name for this, but there's also a sociological phenomenon of code-switching that is related but very different - intentional shifting based on social context or group that you're addressing. Elsewhere in this same thread, someone was assuming the sociological cause for Spanglish, instead of the more organic linguistic cause that happens anywhere you have two cultures and languages in close contact. I suspect this blurred definition makes talking about this more complicated now, since sociological code-switching has become part of America's racialized sociology discussion. If I had my druthers I'd split those two very different phenomena into separate terms, because they don't even produce the same kinds of linguistic patterns. (Thanks for asking me to justify, my assumption was quite wrong regarding the scope of the term.)
- denton-scratch 3y ago> intentional shifting based on social context or group that you're addressing. Isn't that register-switching? It gets confusing in English, because the classier registers in English involves the use of more words of French, Latin or Greek origin, the less-classy registers rely more on anglo-saxon words.
- lynguist 3y agoLike Surzhyk in Ukraine! Mixed Ukrainian/Russian that is the true mother tongue for many Ukrainians! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surzhyk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surzhyk
- type0 3y agoNot quite, English and Spanish are just too dissimilar. Surzhyk is like Portuñol and it's different in different places https://multilingual.com/articles/portunol-blending-spanish-and-portuguese/ https://multilingual.com/articles/portunol-blending-spanish-...
- zvmaz 3y agoI grew up with French and Kabyle [1] and to this day we speak a mixture of both. And it comes very naturally. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kabyle_language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kabyle_language
- fathyb 3y agoMy favorite Algerian loanword is "mickeyettes" for "cartoons" which comes from Mickey Mouse.
- auxym 3y agoSounds similar to the "frenglish" that is often heard in Montreal.
- fathyb 3y agoI like that english idioms translated literally make sense in Québec, such as "ça fait du sens" for "it makes sense". I realized this specific one is a bit controversial while searching for it, here is something I found on the website of the Government of Canada about it: https://www.noslangues-ourlanguages.gc.ca/fr/chroniques-de-langue/mots-de-tete-faire-du-sens https://www.noslangues-ourlanguages.gc.ca/fr/chroniques-de-l...
- kcplate 3y agoWhat I find really interesting perhaps more than even Spanglish or this new dialect, is that back in 2006-2007 I did a lot of business trips to Miami and found it wild that many non-Spanish speakers (only English speakers) spoke English with a detectable Spanish accent. I think it makes perfect sense on reflection, but was eyebrow raising for me.
- Arn_Thor 3y agoThere was a video I saw of an American with a burger shop in Tokyo. He had adopted something of a vaguely Japanese-sounding accent. I think it just happens to some people
- yurishimo 3y agoI’ve seen that one as well! Interesting video for sure. I was also surprised to hear him say he did not speak Japanese despite living there for 20 years and being married to a Japanese woman.
- tjpnz 3y agoI've always wondered how that happens. Having lived in Japan for eight years my accent has become more neutral, but that's about it.
- mabbo 3y agoMy sister, a Canadian, has lived in England a decade now. The locals can't hear it, but I can hear her accent and how she generally speaks has changed quite a bit. She can hear it and knows it but can't help it at all.
- BoxOfRain 3y agoI've lived in England all my life aside from several years in Wales and it's interesting how contrived the accent a lot of foreigners associate with us actually is. There's a lot of natural variation in our accents (they can change from town to town over the course of a dozen miles in extreme cases) but RP, 'posh English' or 'BBC English' was a product of 20th century radio broadcasting based on the natural accent of the south-eastern upper classes and somewhat controversially declared to be the standard pronunciation for British English. The result of this is that a few of my friends and I have very similar sounding accents despite our families being from other ends of the country and having very different 'default' accents; it's entirely down to our respective mothers telling us to 'speak properly' every time we'd drop our Ts or show other 'common' habits of speech as kids!
- eru 3y agoInteresting! Post-Norman-invasion English more-or-less came from a such a hybrid that switched multiple times per sentence between bastardised French and older English.
- imbnwa 3y agoIsn't it more like Old Norse and Old English, re: the number of basic English words that come from Old Norse[0]? The Norman influence appears to largely influence abstract domains like law, governance, and academia with the exception of the well-known culinary distinctions. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_English_words_of_Old_Norse_origin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_English_words_of_Old_N...
- masklinn 3y agoAt its largest extent the Danelaw covered only about half of england, and it lasted around a century before the Kingdom of Wessex conquered first the other remaining Anglo-saxon kingdoms, then retook the Danelaw, and created a unified Kingdom of England.
- ycombinete 3y agoNo, the Norse influence is small relative to Norman. Something like 30% of modern English is Norman-French derived, with thousands of direct cognates. History is rarely simple though! The Normans themselves were a hybrid of Viking settlers and locals. So it's likely that quite a few of those French words we absorbed into English have Old Norse roots.
- OnlyMortal 3y agoThere’s plenty of old Norse in use for places in Yorkshire. The dialect has words too such as, “ta” (thanks). It’s similar to the Danish word, “tak”.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 3y agoBased on the fact that some analysis of this appeared in my undergrad Spanish courses I feel confident saying that there must be a good amount of academic literature exploring these and many other topics with Spanglish.
- ambyra 3y agoYe I was just thinking this new dialect sounds like Spanglish transliterated into English.
- IIAOPSW 3y agoSounds like a standard Creole language. I know that phenomena related to merging languages of populations in contact are well studied, but don't know enough to link to any relevant lit. sorry.
- 4gotunameagain 3y agoI think Creole is different, in the sense that there is emergent grammar as well. While spanglish uses a combination of English & Spanish grammar, and is more close to a mixed language
- afiori 3y agoEDIT: This comment has significant inaccuracies. Creole languages are more about "20 people speaking 20 different languages create a new common merged language", spanglish sound more like "20k bilinguals with varying preference between the 2 languages mix and match the 2 languages for convenience". This assuming that most spanglish speakers could hold a conversation in either languages.
- hervature 3y ago> "20 people speaking 20 different languages create a new common merged language" If you can provide an example of such a diverse set of languages becoming a new language, that would be interesting. Creole has nothing to do with the number of languages. Creole is what you get when two groups of people with no bilingual speakers are forced to interact and develop a new language. Normally, it starts as a pidgin to facilitate trade but then develops into a full fledged language. The main difference with Spanglish being that the speakers often know both languages to a modest degree but probably would not be considered native by other native speakers. Also, there are almost 1M Dominicans alone in NYC. 20k makes it sound like some cute phenomena happening in Little Havana in Miami.
- afiori 3y ago> Creole has nothing to do with the number of languages. I agree, I was misremembering. After a quick refresher I agree that spanglish fits the Creole definition much better than I initially considered. > there are almost 1M Dominicans alone in NYC Not all 1M people interact with each other, I was talking about the overlapping sets of social circles areound people, not the total count.
- throwaway81523 3y ago> There are rules that govern which words you should say in which language, when to switch, etc. I’ve never heard anyone investigating how these rules work, That phenomenon in general is well studied: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code-switching https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Code-switching
- OJFord 3y agoCode-switching is not the same as 'Spanglish', 'Hinglish', etc. - the latter could be something you code-switch to with certain people (young peers say). GP means rules, a grammar of sorts, for which words are English and which words are Spanish in the same sentence. Switching without pause, talking to the same person in the same setting.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoI think "translanguaging" might be the better place to start reading about this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Translanguaging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Translanguaging
- travisjungroth 3y agoThe linked article is exactly what you’re describing. It’s linguistic code switching and covers Spanglish. It predates the more modern, broader use of the term, like having a work accent and home accent.
- wrp 3y agoNeed to clarify the difference between "pidgin" and "creole" here. A pidgin is a (relatively simple) language that develops for communication between two or more speech communities. A pidgin is considered to have become a creole when it has become the mother tongue of a new generation of children. I don't think the blended languages like Spanglish and Hinglish are considered pidgins or creoles within linguistics, but I could see room for argument on that.
- wrp 3y agoI struggle to imagine how this could be a controversial issue. It is just a clarification of the terminology used in linguistics, not a judgement of anyone's culture.
- foldr 3y ago>I’ve never heard anyone investigating how these rules work, There are studies of this. It's best to search in Google scholar to filter out (some of) the crap: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=Miami+%2Bspanglish+syntax+&btnG= https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=Miam... The majority of the work focuses on sociolinguistic aspects of Spanglish, but there are also grammatical investigations. Here's an example dissertation that cites some other studies along the same lines: https://digitalcommons.spu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1071&=&context=honorsprojects&=&sei-redir=1&referer=https%253A%252F%252Fscholar.google.com%252Fscholar%253Fstart%253D10%2526q%253DMiami%252B%25252Bspanglish%252Bsyntax%252B%2526hl%253Den%2526as_sdt%253D0%252C5#search=%22Miami%20%2Bspanglish%20syntax%22 https://digitalcommons.spu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1...
- HL33tibCe7 3y agoThis is called a creole (or actually perhaps in this case a mixed language is a more accurate description - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixed_language https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mixed_language)
- quotemstr 3y agoSee also the "great northern vowel shift": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inland_Northern_American_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inland_Northern_American_Engli... Fascinating phonetic rotation occuring in the north of the US. Also, regarding the Miami dialect: obviously fake. I don't see a single "coin" or "crypt" phoneme in the whole article. ;-)
- tgv 3y ago> This is exactly the sort of thing that’s been happening in Miami. The example quoted is exactly the sort of thing that's not going on. And where's the threshold for calling people bilingual? If you say "get down from the car," you're (likely) using that phrase only to people outside your environment. It's lack of fluency. > “Thanks God,” a type of loan translation from “gracias a Dios,” is common in Miami. In this case, speakers analogize the “s” sound at the end of “gracias” and apply it to the English form. That's just an assumption of the "mmm, let me think 2 seconds" kind. The writer also calls it Spanish, but e.g. beef is "ternera" in Spanish. It might be Cuban Spanish, which has a fairly large vocabulary that differs from other Spanish variants.
- bedobi 3y ago"Thanks God" from "Gracias a Dios" ^^^ this is kinda weird considering Cuban Spanish omits the S (and often half the rest of the letters in any given sentence, lol, at least to my lower intermediate Spanish ears), resulting in "Gracia Dio"
- rvense 3y agoYeah, thought that was a weird claim. I'd wager that the form "thanks" is more frequent than "thank" in most people's English, making it easy for an L2 speaker to hypercorrect.
- asveikau 3y agoOmitting the /s/ is an oversimplification. Classically what happens in accents like that is that /s/ is rendered as [h]. People do this aspiration to varying extents, sometimes omitting totally, sometimes not. Presence of a vowel following nearby can make a full formed [s] appear. The "a" in gracias a dios could easily make that into "gracias a dio". By the way I had a coworker who was a native Arabic speaker say "thanks God" a lot. I think "thank God" is a phrasing that throws off a lot of people learning English, from multiple language backgrounds.
- codeadict 3y agoIndeed, i'm Cuban and we might sound like "Graciah a Diò".
- j-bos 3y agoSpeaking of linguistics, I'd argue that "Linguists have declared a new English dialect that's emerging in South Florida"
- asylteltine 3y ago[dead]
- cool_dude85 3y agoNo mention of what I'd say is one of the more common cases of this "dialect", one I find myself using despite speaking only English: careful your head/hand/whatever.
- fknorangesite 3y ago> this "dialect" Why the scare quotes?
- cool_dude85 3y agoNot sure I buy it, never really heard any of the rest of the stuff they say in the article except maybe from old people who are second language English speakers. Careful your head though I heard quite a bit. That and the fact that it seems to mostly be a few set phrases make me suspicious.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> Careful your head Duck or grouse.
- avidphantasm 3y agoInteresting. There are similar unconventional grammars in use by English speakers of Cajun descent in Southern Louisiana (“put groceries up” instead of “put groceries away”).
- MandieD 3y agoCajun English sloshes over into East Texas and beyond, because I, daughter of an East Texan who grew up in Central Texas now living in Germany, often tell my bilingual toddler, “no, no, Mommy needs to put up the groceries first!”
- edgyquant 3y agoI’ve heard people say “put the x up” as far north as Illinois at least.
- elgrantomate 3y agoI would love to hear recorded audio of these examples...
- jrflowers 3y agoI found this bit of Floridian discussion from the beginning of the documentary This Place Rules to be fascinating. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4iYVSl09FVY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4iYVSl09FVY
- FearNotDaniel 3y ago"Meat or chicken" is also quite common in parts of UK South Asian culture, e.g. many lower-rent "Indian" (usually Bangladeshi or Pakistani) restaurants in England will offer a choice of chicken or meat curry, where "meat" could be lamb, mutton, goat or who knows what.
- sinkasapa 3y agoThe phrase "throw a photo" coming from "tirar una foto" is kind of interesting. It seems plausible that since "tirar" can be translated as "shoot" as well as "throw" that the Spanish phrase may have had an origin as a calque of English "shoot a photo". Now in Miami it is coming full circle but using a translation of a different meaning for "tirar". I wonder how the researchers determined that the 's' in "Thanks god" was from the 's' in "gracias" when we already had "Thanks" as a short form of "Thank you" in English. There is also the formula "Thanks be to god" that is common in religious writing.
- mjh2539 3y agoWhere I am from, it's common to hear someone say "take me a picture" or "take me a photo" because the Spanish is "tomame una foto" (as opposed to the more idiomatic "take a photo of me").
- denton-scratch 3y agoThat phrase "drew" my attention too. I don't speak Spanish; but in French, tirer is to pull as well as to shoot, as in pulling the trigger or drawing a bow. So I was surprised that Miamians choose to render it as "throw", the opposite of "pull". So I looked it up; "tirar" is also pull and shoot in Spanish. I wonder why it didn't turn out as "shoot a photo", which would be consistent with customary english English.
- Mizoguchi 3y agoSpanish itself "borrowed" many words from Arabic after 500 years of Muslim kings ruling Spain.
- iamacyborg 3y agoUnsurprising given Arabs were in Spain for a century.
- anthk 3y ago800. But for every Arabic loanwords you'll find a romance one almost in any case. Aceituna->Oliva. Alcoba->Habitación Alcancía->Hucha Except, of course, for universal stuff like alcohol, álgebra, azúcar, azafrán...
- sublinear 3y agoWell then doesn't every major metro area in the United States have its own dialect? How is this "emerging"? It's probably been like this for centuries. What's "emerging" here is that anyone in the media now wants to mention this particular dialect for political reasons. The title of the author is: "Race + Equity Editor". Why divide people over something so subtle? It's not that unusual. There is no such thing as a common American English for this to be distinct from.
- CyanBird 3y ago> It's probably been like this for centuries This is mentioned on the article linked
- afavour 3y agoIt hasn’t been like this for centuries, that’s the entire point. This migration pattern from Cuba to Miami is a relatively recent change (which happened for, you know, “political reasons”) and this is an effect of that change. All of this is fascinating and it’s intertwined with race. I don’t understand why we should be prohibited fromfrom talking about it.
- 29athrowaway 3y ago"Get down the car" sounds like a transliteration of "bajar del carro". "Bajar" has various connotations, one is to "get off" a car, another is to "descend". "I made the line to pay for groceries." sounds like a transliteration of "Hice la fila para pagar los abarrotes". "Carne" means meat but it often means beef specifically.
- liotier 3y agoIn French: "Descendre de la voiture" - in English, that would be "Step down from the car"... And that makes sense when considering that said vehicle was initially a horse-drawn carriage (-> "car"), which were typically high.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoInteresting. In Spanish, "bajar de la carreta" (step down from the wagon) was the pre-automobile version.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Simon_O_Rourke 3y agoI wonder if it's something related to the sense of isolation that might be felt in this group of Cubans in South Florida. My ex was from Miami, and both her and her family felt they were largely on their own, both nationally and internationally. Case in point, whenever she travelled overseas, and mentioned her Cuban heritage, there was usually something complementary said about the Cuban revolution or revolutionary leaders there - which upset her and her family and kind of led to them feeling like they were overlooked.
- ahhwh71717 3y agoSo I read this and with the examples given are not new as I myself have heard people talking like this in South Texas, it’s called Tejano English or sometimes Chicano English, which has to be quite old at this point. They’re maybe some specifics to Miami that are unique but the examples given in the article are not. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texan_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texan_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicano_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicano_English
- jrockway 3y agoI think my takeaway is that English is very weird. You can ride a horse and you can ride in a car. You can get off a horse but you get out of a car. Many other languages use the same verb for dismounting a horse as alighting from a vehicle, it seems somewhat unusual that we specify whether or not the vehicle is enclosing you. But, not all vehicles. You get off a train and get off a bus, but even if you're in a convertible with no ceiling, you'd get out instead of off. I think the automobile broke English.
- selimthegrim 3y agoYou can still say get down from the train at least in Indian English
- defrost 3y agoThere's good reason for that though, where else is riding train roofs as common? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PdgZO7M4hgQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PdgZO7M4hgQ
- chrismorgan 3y agoThat’s probably because the train’s floor level is normally higher than the platform, so you are literally getting down from the train. In Indian English you can also detrain, which you certainly wouldn’t do in Australian English. In Australian English, you’d seldom get down from the train any more (unless it’s a piece of playground equipment), because the train floor and the platform are almost always level these days. You would instead get off the train, but you could also exit the train or even disembark (typically used as an intransitive verb). You don’t normally get out of the train, for some reason.
- TRiG_Ireland 3y agoDisembark is one of those words that appears only in certain contexts. Any official announcement is going to use disembark or alight preferentially to leave or get off, but almost no one would use them in normal speech. (Here in Ireland, anyway.)
- _fizz_buzz_ 3y agoIn German something similar developed through immigrants from Turkey or Russia. There is a German wikipedia article about it [1]. In particular a kind of distinct dialect developed in Berlin[2] [1]https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Migrantendeutsch https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Migrantendeutsch [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiezdeutsch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kiezdeutsch
- epolanski 3y ago> During this period, more than 10,000 loanwords from French entered the English language, mostly in domains where the aristocracy held sway: the arts, military, medicine, law and religion. One interesting aspect where this is very visible in the english language is meat-related language. Raw food and animals words, butchered by the common people have mostly germanic/saxon roots that have nothing in common with french words, e.g. lamb, chicken, pork, beef, etc. But cooked/processed meat has mostly french-derived words: sausage, charcuterie, cutlet, fillet, grill, sirloin, roast, stew..
- b3orn 3y agoI think you mixed up the words a little, pork and beef are of French origin, compare with modern French porc and bœuf, the germanic words are pig and cow.
- ntr-- 3y agoIt was once pointed out to me that French derived vocabulary is avoided in received pronunciation, compare: - Napkin / serviette - Lavatory or loo / toilet - Graveyard / cemetery see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U_and_non-U_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U_and_non-U_English
- TRiG_Ireland 3y agoThere are also some words derived from French but pronounced in a very non-French manner. The t in valet should be fully pronounced. Making the word sound French is a non-U hypercorrection.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> Making the word sound French is a non-U hypercorrection. I disagree that pronouncing it "VALLay" is hypercorrection. Proper French pronunciation would be "vallAY" (with the emphasis on the second syllable). At any rate, my language background is upper-middle-class English English, and nobody pronounced the word "valitt". That's an americanism, as far as I'm concerned. As a consequence, I've always struggled with the word when used to mean cleaning e.g. a car interior. FWIW, I understand that the "U and non-U" thing was meant as a joke, was horribly snobbish, and was anchored in a particular stratum of early 20th-C English society.
- DiscourseFan 3y agoI don't think this constitutes a dialect. It's not distinct enough from Standard English. Believe me, I've been to Miami plenty of times, and I've heard the typical "spanglish," it was fascinating to hear a group of friends rapidly and fluently switching between English and Spanish. But the English and Spanish were distinct. And the two languages are similar enough in their structure that when things get calqued there is often little to no loss of meaning. Hinglish, which is a language I've learned (well, I learned Hindi and I grew up speaking English) is a radically different dialect of English. Hindi, like Spanish, is also in a lot of ways very similar to English. But there are enough differences where the logic of the language, when used by Hindi speakers, changes enough that in order to understand the meaning of any given phrase one often needs to know both Hindi and English, even if all the words used are English. What one must understand is, all English words are part of the lexicon of Hindi (as are all Sanskrit, Persian, and Arabic words--in fact, alongside the major South Asian literary languages, any language spoken in the region where one is speaking Hindi is a language that loan-words are pulled from. Hindi is more a framework than anything else), such that you can speak Hindi only using English words, and its still basically Hindi. If you don't know Hindi, even if you know every word, you might not understand the meaning of the sentence. I understand the impetus but linguists for whatever reason are oftentimes politically motivated in this sort of social-justic-y, milquetoast liberal progressive way that stretches the limits of what can and should be rigorously defined as a dialect. AAVE is a real dialect, and there are many different registers of English in the world. I really don't think this rises to that level.
- comfypotato 3y agoYou differentiate between Spanglish and Hinglish because a native English speaker wouldn't understand the English parts of Hinglish (but they would understand the English parts of Hinglish)?
- DiscourseFan 3y agoSpanish is so far close to English in so many aspects, because English grammar is so heavily influenced by French (which is why French and Spanish are easier for English speakers to learn than German, even though German and English are technically both members of the same language family). If someone took a Spanish sentence and overlaid every single word with its English equivalent, 95% of the time it would be intelligible to a native English speaker. On the other hand, if one did the same thing for Hindi, it would almost certainly be unintelligible unless someone already knew the "framework" of the grammar of Hindi, in which case they'd interpret it properly. I never once been unable to communicate in Hindi, since I already know all the vocabulary I need.
- vintermann 3y agoOh, it's that old topic of grammatical borrowings from other languages! Long time no see.
- domatic1 3y agoSpanish is also changing, "te llamo para atrás" is used a lot, it means I will call you back.It translates word by word in Spanish, I will call you for behind, but it is now used a lot by the Spanish speaking population in the US.
- culebron21 3y agoCould a native English speaker, please, write correct versions of these phrases for non-natives? > “We got down from the car and went inside.” (I know Spanish, so this must be "Bajámos del coche y fuimos por dentro") "We got out of the car and came inside"? > “I made the line to pay for groceries.” (Hice fila para pagar...) "He took the line.."? > “He made a party to celebrate his son’s birthday.” This look like perfect English to me. o_0
- MrJohz 3y ago1. "We got out of the car and went inside." Possibly also "We got out of the car and came inside", but only if the speaker is still currently inside. 2. "I joined the line ...", although being British I'd be more likely to say "I joined the queue to pay for the shopping", so maybe get an American to double-check this one! 3. "He had a party ..." - I think "make" is used more rarely in English as an auxiliary verb than other languages, typically we "have" or "do" things.
- culebron21 3y agoOh, I thought I got this come/go distinction, but turns out not fully. Thanks!
- panda888888 3y agoI don't know Spanish. I would say: "We got out of the car and went inside" and "I got in line to pay for groceries" and "He hosted/held a party to celebrate his son's birthday."
- lazypenguin 3y ago“We got out of the car and went inside” “I stood in line to pay for groceries” “He hosted a party to celebrate his son’s birthday”
- leephillips 3y agoExcept in New York City, where it’s “stood on line”.
- odyssey7 3y agoThis is very cool, and I hope the dialect isn’t defeated by prescriptivism. Somehow — and I can’t trace exactly how — my public school education removed most of the dialect that I had when I started; I feel this is a shame since I’m fond of how my grandparents speak.
- koromak 3y agoTheres also a Miami accent. People born and raised in Miami, fluent in english, yet have a particular kind of spanish accent.
- Tainnor 3y agoThere's no standard definition of when something becomes a dialect or even its own language, so arguing about that is kind of moot. That said, I'm not terribly impressed that there seem to be some Spanish calques in certain Englishes. That seems rather expected and similar things happen all over the world (with different language pairs). I mean, this can still be fun to investigate, but the article makes it sound as if it's something totally out of the ordinary happening. If we had evidence of actual grammatical shifts, that would be more interesting, but that doesn't appear to be the case here.