7 ms·
Apple Vision Pro – Potential hardware issues
- dijit 3y agoWhat a lengthy article that is entirely assumption. Sorry, until the hardware is available I am not willing to sit down and read/listen about how terrible it is. I have been wrong about Apple’s ability to execute before.
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoAgree, but having the battery on a long umbilical cord that gets in your way, instead of strapped to the back of the headset to equalize weight distribution and remove the long cord, feels like a huge oversight. Mounting an external battery pack to the back strap of the Quest headsets has always been a common mod and it feels bizarre for Apple to ship theirs with an external battery on an umbilical cord that you have to manage as a user, as it's an extra hassle that ruins immersion and portability, especially that since I live in a warm climate, my pairs of underwear and shorts I wear in my house have no pockets as I don't need to carry my wallet, phone or keys in my house. What then? Do I hold the battery pack with my teeth or between my ass cheeks while I slice cubs in beat saber? It feels like they prioritized some superficial design goals for the sake of looks, and didn't really think this through enough in terms of ergonomics by actually dogfooding this in users homes, just like their sleek good looking but uncomfortable and stupid wireless mouse that's the only one I know with the charging port on the bottom instead of at the front so you can't use it while charging like every other rechargeable mouse because of Apple's bizarre design choices. I wish I were a fly on the wall in the boardrooms when such design decisions are green lit. Is it the product designers that have the final call? Is it the engineers? Is it a vote by committee or is it one person who has the decision power?
- digitalengineer 3y ago“I want a 3.5K Apple Vision Pro but I can’t wear it naked” is something Apple didn’t think through? Maybe they can sell you an Apple Fanny pack to place the the battery in.
- ChuckNorris89 3y ago>“I want a 3.5K Apple Vision Pro but I can’t wear it naked” is something Apple didn’t think through? Well yes, they obviously didn't think through apparently, because, and this might come as a shock to Apple designers in Cupertino, but not all of us are Californians sitting in our air conditioned homes wearing long jeans pants and Patagonia jackets indoor in high summer because our home AC is set to a frosty 20C (68F). In my part of Europe, July and August are unbearable and there's no residential AC in apartments here, so sitting naked at home or in underwear is the only way to make it through these torrid summer months.
- throwaway675309 3y agoNot to be snarky, but you have $3500 of disposable income to blow on a pair of fancy VR goggles... but not enough money to afford a window AC unit?
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoEuropean windows don't slide up like Americana ones to support cubic window mounted AC units, and many offices in the old town don't have AC and everyone is peak summer sweating bullets in t-shirts instead of wearing 2 layers and a jacket like in US offices. Also, I wasn't being snaky at all, Apple is not the only Bay Are corporation to designing consumer products around the climate and lifestyle of the people working for them, omitting the other global demographics that face different climate challenges and lifestyles of those in California. How much are you willing to bet, that the second gen will feature a better battery support as the first gen will get criticized for this?
- StrictDabbler 3y agoImagine walking in to your boss and saying "boss, the battery pack works, but some sweaty Europeans may be forced to sit naked in their uncooled apartments without a belt to hang it on. I think we should delay the launch." This is a very odd take. Southeast Asians and Louisianans work in conditions that are technically considered "uninhabitable" by OSHA. The response isn't working naked. It is not a use case that any company would consider primary. Also, you know, you can always put on a belt without clothing.
- dmak 3y agoHave you tried the Vision Pro?
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoCan't I voice a personal opinion otherwise based on my own usage of other VR headsets in my home?
- prawn 3y agoHave you tried their shorts? Future of computing! :) I don’t think the demo was pushing fitness games. I reckon Apple are comfortable leaving the $500 end of this opportunity for Meta and co. I bet they included the power brick as a last resort and after thoroughly testing the weight of other mounted options. Insane to think otherwise.
- ElFitz 3y agoI’d say it probably makes sense for the intended use cases; the ones they have shown in their videos. Mostly sitting on a couch, or leisurely strolling in your huge, mostly empty, living room while discussing with your colleagues or family. Instead of, say, wildly moving your arms around to slice a cube in beat saber, or shoot down a face hugger in Alyx. The other big difference being the supposed ability to clearly see your environnement. But then, this is all suppositions. And they have screwed up more than a few times. Wait and see, I guess.
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoThen I guess, I'm not a target customer and Apple doesn't want my money. Fair enough, more money for me for other things. Yay!
- dwaite 3y agoIndeed, taking over control of a market is more trouble than it is really worth. Apple wants alternatives. They're happy just taking the lion's share of profits.
- ChuckNorris89 3y ago>Mostly sitting on a couch, or leisurely strolling in your huge, mostly empty, living room while discussing with your colleagues or family. So, 3500$ for a VR Zoom call machine?
- ElFitz 3y ago… Yes? Considering some people’s use cases, the same could be said of a MacBook Pro or an iMac. I mean, have you seen their introduction video? [1] It’s basically watching movies on a huge screen and chatting with heads embedded in floating windows. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TX9qSaGXFyg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TX9qSaGXFyg
- Abroszka 3y agoI like the external battery. It's easy to replace and I don't have to strap a large and heavy battery to my head.
- adrian_b 3y agoWhether something strapped on your head is balanced or not matters much more for your comfort than its weight. In the past, but even today in some parts of the world, it was a common practice to carry great weights on the head for a long time, with the condition of them being well balanced (because it was more comfortable than carrying them in an unbalanced way, in the arms or on the back).
- rjh29 3y agoThat's a whole lot of words for something you can solve by buying a new pair of shorts...
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoAh, the classics Apple "you're holding it wrong", but now it's "your clothes are wrong". Brilliant! I don't want to have a battery pack in my pocket and dangling cable while I'm in VR. Oculus could solve this on a $350 device. Surely paying 10x more could also have this groundbreaking feature.
- rjh29 3y agoI agree with you! But it's a weird hill to die on. Assuming you really want an Apple headset, it can be solved in lots of ways including aftermarket straps or tools or just a roll of sticky tape. Or a shirt with a pocket... I will stick with my Oculus Quest and aftermarket rear battery pack though.
- ChuckNorris89 3y ago>Assuming you really want an Apple headset, it can be solved in lots of ways including aftermarket straps or tools or just a roll of sticky tape. Of course it can be solved with some ducktape, but for $3500 do you fell that's a great UX for your money? That's like buying a Mercedes S-Class and having to manually wind the windows.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ThalesX 3y ago> feels like a huge oversight Maybe I'm giving Apple a bit too much credit here, but it feels like they've given this some thought and decided to not go with that based on some sort of rationale, not oversight.
- ChuckNorris89 3y ago>but it feels like they've given this some thought and decided to not go with that based on some sort of rationale Was it the same rationale they used to ship the broken butterfly keyboard for 4 years straight, or for the uncomfortable bottom charging mouse that even hardcore Apple fans don't use? It's always funny to see people making excuses for the poor decisions of their favorite corporation as if Apple can do no wrong and it isn't capable of making stupid decisions just like any other big corporation subject to the same internal turf wars and power struggles.
- acdha 3y agoNobody is saying that they don’t make mistakes but the reason we remembered the butterfly keyboard is that it was a rare high-profile mistake. It seems reasonable to bet that this will be like one of the many thousands of decisions they’ve made well rather than the few memorable failures.
- programmarchy 3y agoDon’t batteries get hot? My Mac Air gets hot enough to be too uncomfortable to keep on my lap so there’s no way I’d want one sitting on my head. Seems like most consumers perceive a degree of danger associated with batteries, and don’t want them anywhere near their head.
- swader999 3y agoI ran a similar weight setup on my ebike for night lighting. Not more than a pound but it was pretty hard on my neck after a few months. Putting the battery not on the head is wise imo.
- DonHopkins 3y agoI'm looking forward to Kyle Machulis's third party high capacity butt plug battery and wireless charging seat cushion. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23094477 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23094477 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36377954 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36377954
- dfinninger 3y agoYes, but why not also sell an iClip that lets you attach the battery to the back of the headset for $99? I might wait for the Belkin one, personally.
- throwaway675309 3y agoI mean it's gonna take all of 10 seconds before third-party headband systems allow you to attach the battery to the back of the headset, so this feels like a non-issue to me. Both the Vive and oculus had lots of third-party support - I don't see that this is gonna be any different.
- clnq 3y ago> but having the battery on a long umbilical cord that gets in your way PC gamers have had to deal with umbilicals for a long time, and it isn’t that bad so long as you don’t move much. Of course, Apple would never say “it’s fine because PC gamers do it”. But it is probably fine.
- elif 3y agoThere was plenty of criticism that was qualified, and the assumptions had their limitations clearly explained... Overall the author did an incredible job providing context and caveats.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- traceroute66 3y ago> Sorry, until the hardware is available I am not willing to sit down and read/listen about how terrible it is. Agree 110%. Its not on sale yet. Only a tiny handful of Youtube influencers have been allowed to have a sneak-peak, and even they were not allowed to film it or go into too much detail. So clearly they were being shown late-stage prototype models and not the finished product. Its therefore clear anyone sensible should wait and see.
- scarface_74 3y agoThey were not allowed to film it, true. But Apple specifically told people who got the hands on demo that they were allowed to talk about anything that they saw or was discussed. This is according to John Gruber and Ben Thompson (Stratechery)
- lyu07282 3y agoIt feels like a waste of time reading it, this would be an amazing review, but they never have even seen the hardware in person its absurd. Obviously Apple might have just made a piece of garbage, I have no way of knowing, not a single credible person has ever said anything about it. This is Apple we are talking about, of course they are not just going to give review samples to any credible/non-journalist person outside its cult.
- andybak 3y agoIt's not entirely assumption, is it? It's carefully argued, based on published specs with clear caveats around the more speculative parts. It's worthy of engaging with on it's own terms.
- marcos100 3y agoUnless you really want it, it's usually better to skip v1 of anything, Apple or not.
- InTheArena 3y agoIf this were written about the general problems with VR, as they apply to the Apple headset and not just an attempt to troll bait Apple fans/haters with emotional statements like ¡Apple is is ignoring physics! I think I would find it more readable. This is some really interesting bits here, but the tone makes it off putting
- pavlov 3y ago> “ general problems with VR, as they apply to the Apple headset” IMO that’s exactly how the article approaches it: Here are some known issues where we can already see that Apple is taking a design approach that’s known to be problematic. I didn’t have much problem with the tone. You find harsher words and less qualified arguments in the typical “I don’t like this or that JS framework” programmer rant that makes it on HN.
- elif 3y agoInitially I thought 'oh I'm sure I can just turn off the fake eyes' assuming that unnecessary heat, battery usage, EM radiation, and social awkwardness were the only downside. I'm glad that this review explained more of the downfalls of this design choice before I plunked down the credit card.
- traceroute66 3y ago> unnecessary heat, battery usage, EM radiation, and social awkwardness were the only downside. Oh you are hilarious. First let's cover "unnecessary heat, battery usage". The headset is based around Apple Silicon. And as Apple has perfectly demonstrated with their Apple Silicon MacBook range they are very much the market-leaders in eliminating unnecessary heat and maximising battery usage. I suspect we will find the same with the headset, I doubt there will be a problem. > EM radiation Oh right. Because VR headsets (from ANY manufacturer) are so amazingly useful without Bluetooth or WiFi enabled ! if you're worried about EM radiation, then don't buy one ... oh and whilst your at it, throw away your cell phone, computers, laptops and build a faraday cage around your house. I'm sorry but I can't show sympathy for EM radiation concerns of VR headsets when you are clearly using 101 other devices in your every day life that emit EM. > social awkwardness That applies to anyone wearing a VR headset from ANY manufacturer on their head. Whether the front of the unit is Apple's eyes or Meta's plastic, it's the same thing .... a weird contraption siting yon your head.
- elif 3y ago[flagged]
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoI’m wondering what kinds of APIs will be available. It would be a hoot to see people write modifiers for the displayed eyes, to show things like cat pupils. As for the rest, we’ll have to see. There’s a long history of really difficult problems with 3D/VR/AR, but Apple has more money than some countries, so, if anyone can solve them, they can. I remember when the iPhone came out. I worked for a camera manufacturer, at the time. One of my employees brought one of them, and I looked it over. One of the things that immediately jumped out at me, was the built-in rear camera. It was pretty limited, with crappy resolution, poor light-gathering, weird depth-of-field, shaky image quality, and noticeable latency, but you could preview the image, live, on a fairly big screen. People may also remember, that, when the iPhone first shipped, there was no SDK, and the App $tore did not yet exist. No one could write any apps for the phone. The JS Web apps thing sucked (even though many folks now write iPhone apps in JavaScript). Even Steve Jobs couldn’t make developing for iPhone attractive. Nonetheless, using the device was incredibly convenient. I knew that if they could improve these issues, it would be a winner. I mentioned it to our marketing folks, and was laughed out of the room. A few years later, our entire consumer camera division, which had made us billions of dollars, was in the toilet. Even our pro camera division took some serious hits. A couple of major newspapers fired all their pro shooters, and told their reporters to use iPhones.
- blowski 3y agoWhen the Airpods first came out, I was convinced they'd never take off, and lots of social media seemed to agree with me. There was even science - SCIENCE! - used to explain why they were a bad idea. While I don't see myself buying the Vision Pro, I'll make no predictions about whether it will be popular.
- dmak 3y agoNever bet against Apple
- trabant00 3y agoThat is a common argument here. It is also a logical fallacy. Because heavier than air apparatus can fly, dropbox made money and so on does not mean anything in the future will be successful.
- blowski 3y agoAbsolutely. HN has an abysmal track record of predicting the success or failure of most innovations, because it tends to over-estimate the importance of the technology itself and under-estimate the power of marketing to overcoming challenges in adoption. This is why I make no prediction whatsoever at this early stage - we know very little about it.
- acdha 3y agoIt’s not just marketing but also confusing our preferences with the market as a whole. For example, AirPods are not as good as my over ear headphones … but they’re impressively close and the AR features are quite effective. Based on flat sales for traditional headphones and huge sales for AirPods, they clearly targeted the much larger group who don’t value audio quality more than everything else.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sebzim4500 3y agoUsing Apple's past track record to predict future success or failure is not a logical fallacy. And I have no idea why you are talking about dropbox and flying.
- pavlov 3y ago> “A related point that I plan to discuss in more detail in Part 3 is that there have been near-eye “glasses” for TVs (such as Sony Glasstron) and computer use for the last ~30 years. Yet, I have never seen one used on an airplane, train, or office in all these years. It is not that the displays didn’t work or were too expensive for an air traveler (who will spend $350 on noise-canceling earphones) and had a sufficient resolution for at least watching movies. But 100% of people decide to use a much smaller (effective) image; there must be a reason” It could be social conformance. Nobody wants to be the first person to do something conspicuously different in a constrained setting like an airplane. I remember when I got my first mobile phone sometime in the 1990s. It felt embarrassing to answer it in the middle of the street and carry a private conversation right there. Today there are essentially no boundaries to where you can use a phone. Apple can easily afford to spend billions on ad campaigns and influencer marketing to make headset use behavior look acceptable and get over the social conformance threshold. No guarantees that they can pull it off, but they have the resources to try. The external EyeSight display on the unit seems to be a big part of this.
- ukuuru 3y agoThey have pulled airpods as a "norm". In olden times leaving your earphones/headphones in you ear/head was a very rude thing to do, especially around people you know, in idle time; now it is almost norm. Especially it is marketed as a norm to the younger folk. They will try and there is no reason them to fail.
- ricardobeat 3y agoMostly presupposed hardware issues. Based on very thin assumptions, and some opinions that just seem wrong - for example, wearing a Quest 2 with the Elite strap is pretty comfortable, by far the largest issue is heat buildup and pressure around the eyes. The apple headset being lighter and with the much wider band looks to me it would actually be more comfortable. The failure of 3D movies is always used as a cautionary tale, but it was a pretty unique case that came down to artistic execution. Both Avatar movies are incredible in 3D and don’t generate any kind of discomfort, but the average “3D” title from other studios was a cardboard-cutout mess, usually a worse experience than it’s 2D counterpart. Not a technology adoption problem.
- agumonkey 3y agoAvatar seen on a CRT tv was more 3d than most 3d movie in 3d theater rooms. Cameron crew was really world class.
- AmericanChopper 3y agoThe problem with that 3D craze was that it was implemented entirely because James Cameron wanted it. All of the technical innovations and infrastructure costs were implemented for Avatar, and all of the subsequent movies and consumer facing products were just there to try and recoup some value from these (probably bad) investments that were made for just this one film. It lasted only as long as it took people to realise that general enthusiasm for 3D movies wasn’t very strong in the broader market of all people other than James Cameron.
- samwillis 3y agoThere are some good questions asked in this, but I think there are some potential counter arguments missed. > Low Processing Lag Time and High Frame Rate are Necessary but not Sufficient to Solve Visual Issues I think I read somewhere that Apple are using the eye tracking to concentrate processing power and refresh rate on the area you are looking. Eventually a higher refresh rate in a smaller section of the display. > Poor location of main cameras relative to the user’s eye due to the Eyesight Display > The proper location of the cameras would be coaxial with the user’s two eyes. The eyes have two degrees of movement, the camera can't be "coaxial" with them at all times. The proximity of the cameras to the axial direction of your eyes is going to be more important for short distance than long as the effect of misalignment is going to be stronger. We tend to be looking somewhat down when working on things near to us, and in the case of the Vision Pro that's where the cameras are. You are almost exactly looking down through the axis of the cameras when working on something on a desk or table in front of you. This is better than if they were horizontally in front of your eyes. I don't doubt that Apple have considered all these issues in the design, and any trade offs they may have made. Once we get our hands on hardware we will be better informed how well they have addressed them.
- danpalmer 3y ago> > Low Processing Lag Time and High Frame Rate are Necessary but not Sufficient to Solve Visual Issues > I think I read somewhere that Apple are using the eye tracking to concentrate processing power and refresh rate on the area you are looking. Eventually a higher refresh rate in a smaller section of the display. That technique is Foveated Rendering, and my understanding is that it doesn’t change the frame rate. I think if it did you would get obvious visual tearing at the boundaries of the different areas. I believe it normally involves just rendering areas at a lower resolution and then applying a basic blur to it. Additionally, I’m not certain if that will be applied to the pass through video, the most important bit for these visual issues. Adding foveated rendering to that pipeline could even do more harm than good in terms of adding latency, and video processing is typically much faster than the rendering of new graphics from scratch, particularly given the M1’s dedicated video accelerators.
- 3y ago
- sergiosgc 3y agoThis is a lot of argumentation for such a thin knowledge base about the device. However, even if it is all true, it does not matter. The Apple Vision Pro is a developer kit only Apple could launch. Nobody knows what is possible with AR. There are lots of ideas, none tested in a large enough group of consumers. Enter Apple, which can attract both a sizeable group of developers and a relevant group of consumers. What we'll see now is the divergent part of software development for a new platform. Everyone trying new stuff, finding out what sticks, what gets market fit. It'll be fun. Then, a new device will refine the concept.
- avnigo 3y agoIf the author thought about all this in an essay, you can bet Apple did too in their many years working on this. Whether they managed to come up with proper solutions to these issues is another matter, but I'd be hard-pressed to think they've not been acutely aware of all of this and actively worked on it.
- jimmySixDOF 3y agoI look forward to the 3rd article in the series on Applications even though Karl's expertise is in hardware and I am surprised he was not asked to redteam Apple's design at various phases since it is what he does. But whereas Apple is, with notable exceptions like the EyeSight Lenticular screen which I love and cant wait to do in Jaguar mode one day, only assembling from the same shelf of product choices everyone else in AR/MR/VR is choosing from; it is their full control of the software stack and what they choose to do (or not do) with it that they have real opportunity. So I am much more interested in the VisionOS and Application landscape getting Karl's strengths and weaknesses approach.
- wsc981 3y agoIs it just me or does this feel like an ML generated response?
- sebzim4500 3y agoHonestly it feels like one of those old school RNNs. ChatGPT would be way more coherent.
- andybak 3y agoGenuinely surprised about the lack of keep-alive battery. I wonder if it's too late in the cycle to revise this? It seems like a real blunder.
- Tagbert 3y agoI think, for now, the answer to that is to plug in power through USB-C if you need more than 2 hours of continuous usage.
- andybak 3y agoI get that but I think it's a poor decision. Hopefully someone will release a battery pack that can handle hot swapping. But that doesn't solve "accidentally disconnecting the battery"
- skc 3y agoI learned a lot from this article. I don't think he is being critical, he is making very well reasoned arguments and is probably excited to get his hands on this device to see if they hold up.
- mirekrusin 3y agoHe could wait a bit so it's not assumptions and guesses only.
- urbandw311er 3y agoI know what you mean, but equally if people can’t apply the same principle re: hype and excitement then personally I think it’s nice to have a bit of a counterbalance.
- gsibble 3y agoSeriously.
- GeekyBear 3y agoMeanwhile, the usually very blunt Kara Swisher (who has experienced all the leading AR/VR hardware including Apple's) just posted a rave on her Pivot podcast. https://podcasts.voxmedia.com/show/pivot https://podcasts.voxmedia.com/show/pivot
- oezi 3y agoThanks for the link. Her review is almost entirely orthogonal to Karl's. She focuses on the efficacy of the experience. Apparently Apple is able to sidestep a lot of the issues that Karl is mentioning. For instance all the vergence issues seem to be non-existent in her usage. Likely because Apple isn't focusing on interacting with any real world objects.
- benjvi 3y agoThe perspective shared here seems to be very focused on fundamental difficulties with AR passthrough devices: - lag is lower than other devices, perhaps low in absolute terms, but is it low enough? Perhaps not for all use-cases - there are difficulties aligning virtual images (this part is very speculative as to how it relates to Apple’s headset design) - difficulties tracking saccades - not sure under what use-cases this would show up as a problem, this hasn’t been mentioned in reviewers’ first impressions - safety problems with obstruction of peripheral vision when moving around Pretty interesting, but I think it reflects well on Apple that these are the class of problems being discussed. None of these things sound like absolute deal-breakers for a Gen1 device. Will it be useful though? It doesn’t do games or “presence”, or indeed seem very focussed on any uniquely AR/VR experiences right now. It’s not as good a monitor as a proper monitor (this analysis of VAC and resolution is pretty convincing). But it is portable. Maybe that in itself is enough?
- oezi 3y ago> lag is lower than other devices Karl argues that the promised 12ms latency for video passthrough needs to be added on top of camera acquisition and display timing. This could lead to potential delay of up 3x 12ms in the worst case and 12ms in the best case based on 90Hz displays and 90Hz cameras. Time will tell.
- gsibble 3y agoYes, let's talk about a whole bunch of POTENTIAL shortcomings of a V1 product that is LIGHT YEARS ahead of the competition. This is why I tell everyone in my company not to complain about something unless they have a better solution. Does this guy offer any solutions or present better products? No. That's because with current technology, this is the best we can do. What a jerk.
- programmarchy 3y agoAs a likely buyer of AVP I thought it was informative. For example, the VAC issue does seem like a fundamental issue and now that I understand what it is, I’ll be able to better evaluate how Apple has solved (or not solved) the problem.
- kweingar 3y agoA product can be light years ahead of its competition and still not be worth buying. The best we can do with current technology might not be enough to make a good product. Not saying this is the case with the Apple Vision Pro.
- draw_down 3y ago[dead]
- iamleppert 3y agoI seriously can’t wait for Apple to be knocked off its pedestal. I can’t wait for the closure of Apple stores, layoffs in Cupertino, and seeing brand new MacBooks in the clearance bins. I’ve had enough of this pompous and arrogant company. This is going to be good.
- clnq 3y agoIt’s interesting that Apple isn’t using terms like AR, VR, MR, XR, and pancake lenses. It’s prob either that they want to package the tech as their own and give it fancy labels (like spatial computing). Or they are concerned about being compared to competitors. Or perhaps they want to do the “it just works” thing where you are not supposed to care about the specs, like system memory on iPhones. Maybe all three. But if they want to avoid being compared to competitors, that concerns me. As they use that strategy to deliver inferior products.
- lathiat 3y agoMKBHD: "Apple's Forbidden Words" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kvN5_GXlg2Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kvN5_GXlg2Y A good look at the topic, it's nothing new for them. They specifically love to both avoid marketing terms for some things and to give their own specific branding terms to others (think "Retina" instead of High Res, "ProMotion" instead of 120Hz, etc).
- acdha 3y ago> But if they want to avoid being compared to competitors, that concerns me. As they use that strategy to deliver inferior products. Based on the initial reviews, I think it’s more the opposite: they don’t want you assuming that their product has the same limitations which have characterized those acronyms so far. From what I’ve read they have gotten over a couple of key thresholds for resolution, response time, etc. which held back lower-spec products and don’t want people to think prior experience with e.g. Oculus devices is representative.
- clnq 3y agoI don’t think they’ve broken new ground in terms of resolution (compared to Pimax) and refresh rate (12ms is a bit less than 90Hz, which is equivalent to Quest Pro and worse than Quest 2 in dev mode). I think they might want to avoid these spec-to-spec comparisons because other aspects of implementation can give a better UX (like software in iOS compared to Android). Though, until we see the hardware, it will be difficult to say whether they can pull more out of current industry-leading specs than others.
- Reubend 3y agoThis is a great article with well supported points. I think a lot of people disagreeing are saying that since the hardware isn't out yet, this might not matter, but the takeaway for me here is that we don't yet have the technology to fix some of the issues for VR.