12 ms·
Right versus pragmatic
- afhof 15y agoMarco's posts are always short, sweet, and to the point. I wonder if anyone in a position to make these kinds of decisions will heed his advice.
- jarek 15y agoNo. The point has been made over and over and one more restating, however short, sweet, and to the point, will not materially change the situation.
- keithpeter 15y agoSadly, I'm with Max Planck on this one "A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."
- jtchang 15y agoGet one of these: http://toepener.com/ http://toepener.com/ Of course the people still might continue to throw paper towels on the floor. Changing a habit is difficult.
- karolist 15y agoA large bank in UK has all of it's office doors plated with metal near the bottom, also the doors open both ways making them really suitable for kicking, I don't know if the original intention was that.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- sek 15y agoOr when we build the next building, we make automatic doors with a corner so you can't see anything from the outside and nobody has to touch anything.
- julian37 15y agoAnother solution (albeit more costly) would be to re-hinge the door so it swings outwards, and make the springs easy enough so people can push it open using their shoes. That's not the gentleman's way of operating a door, but with the trashcan solution people also have to hold the door open somehow while disposing of the towel, unless it comes with springs that are adjusted just right so it stays open just long enough for people to sneak out in time. Making the door open outwards is the right thing to do anyway with regards to fire safety, as far as I understand. Of course, if you have the space to spare (without things getting too intimate) you can also just leave out the doors altogether, which is how many airports I've been to seem to handle the issue. (I'd say an automatic bathroom door is overkill and a bit creepy, too, which probably is why I've never seen one.)
- drewjoh 15y agoIt's dangerous to have doors swinging out into hallways (which is usually what you exit to in an office building).
- snprbob86 15y ago> Making the door open outwards is the right thing to do anyway with regards to fire safety You've got that backwards. You want the door to open inward, in case there is an obstruction. If it opens outward, there may be something on the ground blocking the path of the door. It may be too heavy (or hot!) to push away, but small enough to climb over or around. Furthermore, it's dangerous to open a door outward into the path of people walking. Think about the front door on your house or apartment, the door to your bedroom, your bathroom door, etc. They all open in to the room, away from the hallway.
- jsankey 15y agoIt seems obvious that the best long term strategy for media companies is to start addressing the demand. Indeed, over the long term, any other strategy will likely result in those companies being left behind. But if you're in charge of a media company today, and your bonus this year is tied to a cash cow you can keep alive for a few more years, would you be taking the risk and short term pain of making the transition? I don't think it's stubbornness or stupidity we're looking at, it's a classic case of misaligned incentives.
- abraxasz 15y agoI will have to disagree. Not that I think that the people in charge of the MPAA and co. are altruistic, nice people. But I don't think they act the way they act because they are looking for immediate profit, or rather this is not the principal reason. There was an excellent comment on HN a month or so ago (during the SOPA madness, I can't find it though) from a guy from the industry that explained that the main problem was "ignorance and misunderstanding". And this echos what the OP explained so well: the MPAA think they are right, and don't understand why people are downloading illegally (they most likely think it's just about money).
- jsankey 15y agoI think it's too easy to look at people in these positions and say they just don't get it. This is their industry, they're immersed in it every day. They may not have seen this coming, but it's been in their face for a while now, and even if a few can't see what's going on I simply can't believe that none of them do. At best I would say any "ignorance" could still be tied back to incentives: even if they know the truth, it's inconvenient and not worth acknowledging widely (or perhaps even to themselves). Better to keep on peddling the line that piracy is theft to preserve the status quo as long as possible.
- nirvdrum 15y agoI've mentioned something similarly here before (I think during the SOPA stuff): people simply do economically irrational things to take a principled stand. I've certainly done things that my friends and family thought were batshit crazy just so I could achieve perceived balance in the universe. My take is that's what we're seeing now and have been for a while. The media companies obviously want our money, but more than that, I think they just don't want you to have access to their content if you didn't pay for it, to break this overwhelming sense of entitlement many of us have. I don't condone the methods, but I don't disagree with the rationale either (providing that actually is the case).
- maxharris 15y agoThere's a third option Marco forgot. Imagine that the problem is avoided because someone says, "it's right that we have a trash can by the door because people don't want to touch the door knob with their bare hands," and then follows through on that _correct_ theory by putting a garbage can there. So I say: if your theory is correct, it'll make sense as a theory (i.e., integrate with the rest of your existing knowledge) AND it'll work in practice. If what you're trying keeps failing, the solution is to go back, check your premises, and identify what's wrong with your theory. Often people do this automatically (and call it being "pragmatic"), but with bigger ideas, an explicit approach is required. To go for long without theory is to fly blind, and that's dangerous. Ideas and theory are what allow us to fly in the first place, as well as to change course before we hit the proverbial mountain hidden in the fog just ahead.
- Sivart13 15y agoMost importantly, I never knew why so many people at my office threw their paper towels on the ground next to the door (or in a trashcan located thereabouts, when available). Now I do. I still don't understand why people think the post-bathroom door is disgusting enough to merit hand protection. If anything, it's the door people are most likely to have touched AFTER washing their hands. Do these people bring another paper with them to open the door on the way in?
- whamill 15y agoWell the difference between the pre-bathroom door handle and the post-bathroom door handle (opposite sides of the same door, presumably) is that one of them is much more likely to have been touched by someone who may have just been to the toilet without washing their hands. You wouldn't be that worried about touching the door on the way in especially if you knew you were going to be washing your hands in a moment.
- karolist 15y agoIsn't that just a psychological thing? I mean, if people don't wash their hands after using the bathroom they might be less likely to wash their hands in general, but they're still using other doors, kitchen appliances, papers and (depending on culture) you shake hands with them in the morning. There's no way to avoid that while not looking socially awkward, just wash your own hands more. Also, don't you remove some of that bacteria left on the door handle by touching it yourself? The amount of bacteria on bathroom door handles should remain rather constant given that you take some away as you leave some of your own, also door handle not having favourable replication conditions for germs.
- whamill 15y agoWell I haven't done any studies on it but I'd assume that the number of people going to the toilet and then immediately touching the way-out door handle without washing their hands is probably higher than the number of people going to the toilet outside the bathroom and then touching the door handle on the way in... Not to mention that bathroom door handles are pretty good conditions for germs: warm (indoors), damp (from people who haven't dried properly), lots of new germs from people who haven't washed.
- vibrunazo 15y agoI'd rather have people understand there's no simplistic black or white right vs wrong. But only each ones personal interests. Than to come up with subjective excuses of why we shouldn't try to do the "right". Piracy isn't "wrong", it's in the best interest of some and not of others. The most healthy attitude, imo, is to objectively measure the pros vs cons and only then judge what should you do. Almost any decision you ever take will favor someone and not others. What we cannot let happen is let those of opposite interest convince us that our interest is "wrong", ignoring one of the sides of the issue. Intellectual monopoly privileges might be in the interest of a few select copyright holders. But maybe not in the best interest of users. No side is right our wrong, but just have different interests.
- sedev 15y agoOn a personal note, I had a workplace bathroom once that was worse than this, also in trash bins. The one you were supposed to throw paper towels into after washing your hands, had a spring-loaded lid that required at least two pounds of pressure to open - and that was the least of the design problems. More to the point, it fascinates me how the media companies' obduracy makes hackers in particular blindingly angry. It's interesting that from our side, they seem so insanely, self-destroyingly, offensively stupid that we just can't believe that they're really doing this. It's interesting on that cultural level as well as on the less abstract levels.
- tnuc 15y agoFor management to be right they should take away the paper towels and install a hot air hand dryer.
- Jarred 15y agoThe door should have metallic arm-slots where people can push the door open using just their arms. People usually don't pee/poop on their arms, so it'd be and appear clean, while removing the need to use paper towels to open the door.
- newbusox 15y agoThis article seems to imply that you can never change people's behavior by law (i.e. like posting a sign on a door saying not to throw towels on the floor) because people will always do whatever they want. I don't think I agree with that--I think the quesiton is to what extent are entities willing to impose penalties and enforce the law to sufficiently change people's behavior. For example, obviously if the company in the hypothetical hired a guy to sit in the bathroom to make sure that people threw paper towels in the trash can and then fired people who disobeyed, far fewer people who throw paper towels on the floor. So, the issue as related to piracy is not necessary that people would never change their behavior, its just that the cost of monitoring behavior and enforcing currently existing law/creating new law to effect such a behavioral change ("don't pirate stuff") is extraordinarily high. Right now, the strategy of the media industry appears to be to spend money under the presumption that the amount of money they spend enforcing/lobbying/trying to pass laws to prevent piracy makes economic sense: they will gain/save more money than they spend. This seems unlikely, but probably people have punched the numbers for these companies and concluded that this is the case. The radical alternative approach is to completely rethink the distribution and pricing scheme, and focus less on margins but more on quantity--distribute the content to as many people as possible, but make fewer $/product. To impose that would require either some fairly revolutionary thinking in companies that have repeatedly shown a hesitancy to innovate (and would require them to abandon a strategy now that still makes hefty profits), or to make media companies hurt to such an extent that they have no alternative (which, right now, does not appear to be happening).
- icebraining 15y agoRight now, the strategy of the media industry appears to be to spend money under the presumption that the amount of money they spend enforcing/lobbying/trying to pass laws to prevent piracy makes economic sense: they will gain/save more money than they spend. This seems unlikely, but probably people have punched the numbers for these companies and concluded that this is the case. Of course it's the case: their endgame is to get governments to criminalize all copyright infringement and get the taxpayer to pay for all that. Of course, the balance for society as a whole is well in the red, but why should they care? But the worst is not the economic costs, but the (much more important IMHO) costs in terms of human rights, such as freedom from censorship, privacy, access to a indispensable medium, etc.
- paulovsk 15y agoReally nice piece.
- icebraining 15y agoThe single least-attractive attribute of many of the people who download content illegally is their smug sense of entitlement. … The world does not OWE you Season 1 of “Game Of Thrones” in the form you want it at the moment you want it at the price you want to pay for it. If it’s not available under 100% your terms, you have the free-and-clear option of not having it. This isn't any kind of counterargument. No, the world doesn't owe me¹ that, but I'm not forcibly taking it either.People are voluntarily sharing it with me. So what I'm owed is irrelevant. YCombinator doesn't owe me access to HN either, but I'm not a bad person for using it if they're offering it to me. ¹ completely hypothetically and for the sake of argument. For all you know I'm just playing devil's advocate, so let's keep the personal attacks to a minimum, please. EDIT: fixed typo.
- avree 15y agoAre you typing "own" instead of "owe"? Why? Also—"people offering" you something doesn't mean it wasn't "forcibly taken." All pirated material, movies, etc are forcibly taken by someone. They're ripped from DVDs, captured from telecasts, etc. Just because they're offering it to you doesn't mean that it's free. If I steal something from a store and then give it to you, the item's still stolen.
- dlitz 15y ago> All pirated material, movies, etc are forcibly taken by someone. Really? What force was used to take them?
- icebraining 15y agoAre you typing "own" instead of "owe"? Why? Typo, sorry. Also—"people offering" you something doesn't mean it wasn't "forcibly taken." All pirated material, movies, etc are forcibly taken by someone. They're ripped from DVDs, captured from telecasts, etc. Just because they're offering it to you doesn't mean that it's free. They did not forcibly took it: they bought the DVD, Blueray and/or access to the telecast. It's theirs. If I steal something from a store and then give it to you, the item's still stolen. Yes, but it's not what's happening here, so that's irrelevant.
- bsergean 15y agoPeople are sick. When I see people throwing a paper or anything on the floor it really drives me mad. This is the worst act of disrespect for janitors. There are not too many thing I like about Singapore but giving fines to people who throw garbage on the ground is something I like.
- superkinz 15y agoThis argument goes equally well for the war on drugs. Possibly even immigration.
- jd 15y agoPeople are so grossed out by a doorknob they refuse to touch it, only to immediately walk to their desk to type on their keyboard. A keyboard which is typically far dirtier than the bathroom they just avoided touching[1]. Oh, the irony. [1] http://abcnews.go.com/Health/Germs/story?id=4774746&page=1 http://abcnews.go.com/Health/Germs/story?id=4774746&page...
- robryan 15y agoI think it would really suck to go through life worrying about every surface I touched and the gems it contained.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoIt does. But it beats catching a cold or flu every couple of months. And it's not as if hand-washing is some kind of crazy placebo: In a research published by British Medical Journal on November 2007, physical barriers, such as regular handwashing and wearing masks, gloves and gowns, may be more effective than drugs to prevent the spread of respiratory viruses such as influenza and SARS... Handwashing and wearing masks, gloves and gowns were effective individually in preventing the spread of respiratory viruses, and were even more effective when combined... Another study, published in the Cochrane Library journal on 2007, finds handwashing with just soap and water to be a simple and effective way to curb the spread of respiratory viruses, from everyday cold viruses to deadly pandemic strains. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hand_washing_with_soap#Disease_prevention_in_handwashing_with_soap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hand_washing_with_soap#Disease...
- robryan 15y agoI may just be lucky but I don't seem to get this, sure I catch some minor things but it is more like once a year. Your right if I was constantly catching things I would be more careful.
- Dylan16807 15y agoTheir own keyboard may be dirty but it's not transmitting any diseases.
- amanuel 15y agoThis reminds me of the story of the paving the walkways story http://sivers.org/walkways http://sivers.org/walkways
- bobbles 15y agoThe university I used to work at had walkways with at least 5 years with of dirt trails from being used as walkways across the grass.. When the administration had paths built.. they built them in completely different locations so that they matched the aesthetic of the other paths in the area when viewed from the top of the hill. Now they have great looking new paths (unused) AND the dirt trails across all of the grass..
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Qz 15y agoThe better solution is to use an open door design (often found in airports) and have hand dryers rather than paper towels. Less waste and associated mess, no garbage to change, no doorknobs to not touch.
- falcolas 15y agoBut it requires more floor space, which may not be available. Also, in the vein of the lesson being taught, that may be the "right" solution, but in an existing building, it's certainly more pragmatic to add a wastebin (versus, say, rebuilding the bathrooms).
- keithpeter 15y agoThe Dyson Airblade hand driers are really catching on in the UK in public building toilets. They are fun to use and actually work rather well. However the bottom of the opening where you put your hands gets some cruddy water/residue in it. http://www.dysonairblade.co.uk/ http://www.dysonairblade.co.uk/
- Illotus 15y agoTo my understanding hand driers are less hygienic. With paper towels you actually wipe off some the grime while with hand driers any left over stuff just dries on your hands.
- liedra 15y agoThe Dyson ones basically sluice the water off. They're excellent and so much quicker than traditional driers.
- crystalis 15y agoThe Dyson ones I've seen have only ever shot cold air on my hands and pushed my hands against both sides of the dryer. Maybe they've been horribly misconfigured at all 3+ places I've seen them at, but in my experience they've just been less effective and less sanitary than both traditional air dryers and paper towels.
- jeffool 15y agoI'm reminded of school, where the bathrooms had no doors. Yet they were designed in a way that you walked in, around one partition to get to the sink, and a second partition to use the bathroom. The sounds and smells of the bathroom never seemed to be an issue there.
- oz 15y ago"The signs never worked. Instead, they just annoyed and angered people. Some people even threw more paper towels on the floor because they didn’t like the condescending way they were being instructed." "This pattern is common. We often try to fight problems by yelling at them instead of accepting the reality of what people do, from controversial national legislation to passive-aggressive office signs. Such efforts usually fail, often with a lot of collateral damage, much like Prohibition and the ongoing “war” on “drugs”." This is something I've learned in when trying to convince people to do something that's for their own good. Often times, it all too easy to yell. But human nature is such that if you 'attack' a person's beliefs or actions, (rational or not) they will defend them, further entrenching them and encouraging the person to continue if even out of spite. Sure, sometimes an 'intervention' is necessary. But I've found that in most cases, it's more strategic to boil a person as a frog rather than a lobster.
- r00fus 15y agoThere's even a term for it: cognitive dissonance [1]. Fact is, the best way to make a point is to appeal to your audience. The appeal can be to authority, ethics, humor, aesthetics, etc. WIIFM applies here.[2] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance#The_Induced-Compliance_Paradigm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance#The_Induce... [2] http://www.websitemagazine.com/content/blogs/posts/archive/2010/09/16/business-writing-the-wiifm-principle.aspx http://www.websitemagazine.com/content/blogs/posts/archive/2...
- djrconcepts 15y agoYa know, the bathroom door swing problem has to do with the swing direction of the door + no one wants to touch a door knob. If the door gets replaced with one that swings in both directions by push... problem solved.
- philwelch 15y agoThere are lots of examples of this. Moralistic thinking simply isn't productive in this context. If you build an economic system that depends on everyone voluntarily cooperating rather than acting self-interestedly, self-interested people will ruin it; if your public health strategy for HIV is to discourage people from extramarital sex, lots of people will have extramarital sex and get HIV; if your strategy to compete with BitTorrent is to try and make people feel guilty about using BitTorrent, people will tune you out and use BitTorrent. Of course, if you used those examples instead of a silly example about designing an office restroom, the HN thread gets derailed by people talking about economics or HIV. One could criticize the HN community for that kind of bikeshedding, but it's more pragmatic to just use a boring, contrived example to sell the point. Certainly, a HN thread won't end up filled with a side discussion about office restroom design.
- negw 15y agoWhat's funny is that the second comment down here is about office restroom design :-)
- ericwaller 15y agoI actually like the side discussion about restroom design a lot. The difficult part about these types of problems is that the guy who's picking up the paper towels doesn't have the authority to move the trash can.
- dsr_ 15y agoAuthority is a funny thing. In many situations, simply doing the right thing -- putting a trashcan in the right place, here -- is much, much easier than getting the notional authority to do it. Or as so many people have put it, forgiveness is often easier than permission.
- LaGrange 15y agoTo root this discussion solidly in hardware, moving the trash can might not be such an easy task — in many restrooms the paper towel baskets are actually embedded in walls. There you would to actually take the basket from elsewhere. To make the entire thing even more fun, I've actually worked in an office that had relatively strict sanitary requirements (the office contained some food testing labs), and opening the door with a paper tower was obligatory. Didn't stop the management from putting the basket on the other side of the bathroom. I may actually care about the described issue in restroom context more than in piracy context. But then again, my most common download is books.
- chj 15y agoAll these is in our gene, called Selfish.
- pbreit 15y agoWhere I thought Marco might have been going with this is all the web designers who try to solve their design deficiencies with help text.
- petercooper 15y agoBut some of them dislike it so much that they’ll take their paper towel over to the door, turn the knob with it, and throw it on the floor while exiting. OK, cool post, cool story, etc. But is it merely for rhetorical effect? I've used a lot of office and public bathrooms over the years and have never seen paper towels scattered around the doorway. Protip for the slovenly scatterers, though, this is what cuffs are handy for ;-)
- brown9-2 15y agoYes, I've seen similar things and almost-identical signs posted in office bathrooms before.
- ChristianMarks 15y agoBring rubber gloves to the bathroom. I remember the graffiti written on the seat cover dispenser in a bathroom stall at the NYNEX Science and Technology offices. The hand-written inscription provided a helpful arrow with the legend "ass gasket."
- rasper 15y agoThe article assumes it is wrong for the restroom user to discard his paper towel onto the floor. But why? A complete moral analysis would take into account the fact that he is a valuable employee and he doesn't want to pick up germs and thereby risk becoming ill. Just because his action imposes a small cost on somebody else _who is payed to tidy up_ that doesn't necessarily make it wrong. (Besides, picking up the towels takes a few seconds. Not much more time than picking up one towel, and far less time than cleaning the rest of the restroom.) It's a false christian morality which says that actions taken on behalf of oneself are always wrong and that actions taken on behalf of others are always right. There's a right use for a paper towel and there are right uses for various people's time. Morality is practical.
- ok_craig 15y agoThis really doesn't seem like he was saying at all. If you read the article, he actually doesn't have a problem with people throwing things on the ground, and is quite antagonistic towards the posted messages telling people to do otherwise. The only thing the article assumes is that it is desirable to have a bathroom that isn't persistently littered with paper towel on the floor. Is that something you disagree with? The solution provided was to adapt to what users were already doing, suggesting that the management, who implied the action of discarding paper towels on the ground was bad, was wrong, and that it was the management which had to change. He was not suggesting that the behavior of the paper towel litter-ers had to change. Especially the part about "false christian morality" is kind of weird. It's like you scanned through until you found one thing you think some philosophy you have applies to, so that you can comment on it, but you didn't understand or follow through with the rest of the article.
- rasper 15y agoHe thinks that throwing the towels on the floor is OK and that better still would be to install a new waste bin by the door. I agree with him. But he wants to reject moral language and label his approach 'pragmatic'. In reality he merely has a different opinion as to what is right in the first place. My concern is that if people do what they judge to be right but call it 'wrong' or 'pragmatic' or whatever then this can cause harmful confusion and guilt. And I think that the idea that 'Selfish == wrong; selfless == right' is the hangover of a puritanical strain of Christian thinking.
- bipolarla 15y agoIn human history there are always problems. An individual or group needs to change it only happens when they decide to. If we want to stop HIV we need to decide if we want to make a smart choice to have safe sex. Young people want adventure and like risks. This is why there are so many overdoses and young people who get STD's. The smart ones decide they value life and don't drug or do other risky behaviors. My main suggestion for change is to create an exciting dialogue that might change the "coolness" of negative acts. Smoking is being done less due to the real negative media ads, people knowing about cancer deaths, and many talking about why smoking kills.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Hominem 15y agoOne of the VPs at my current company actually won $100 in a best suggestion contest in the office. His suggestion was "garbage cans next to the bathroom door". That is why the man is a VP.
- SG90 15y agoIt is totally correct that condescending people, more often than not tends to have a negative effect, but what about those people who do not care if their paper towel falls in the dustbin or outside it? A lot of people are out there who do the wrong thing, just for the kick of it, what can be done to influence such people. Same is the case with piracy, a lot of people share content because they get a feeling that by doing this they are getting back at the world
- jamesrcole 15y agoI agree with his point, but I dislike how he talks of it as right versus pragmatic. It should be moralising versus pragmatic. 'Right' means 'true', and the moralising stance he talks about is not the correct way to deal with the problem. It's not 'right', it's blinkered moralising. Calling such things 'right' muddles the notion of truth. We don't need more of this. Most of the people I come across seem to think there's no such thing as truth because it's all relative, and uses of 'right' like in this article serve to reinforce such beliefs.
- zerostar07 15y ago"Right" is a moral concept, not necessarily the (empirical) truth, it's the opposite of "wrong", not of "false".
- jamesrcole 15y agoHe says They just kept posting more signs, because they were convinced that they were right. They believed that the right way to solve the problem was for people to use the bin where it was located (that is, an empirical view as to what was the best solution, driven by a moralising attitude). His point is that their view was incorrect - false.
- zerostar07 15y agoValid points about piracy. People use whatever way is fastest to view content, but nobody gets paid that way. How about selling virtual "tickets" that allow you to download the movie from wherever you want as long as you have bought the ticket?
- xiaoma 15y agoI really don't understand where the author is coming from on this: --- "One of the floor’s tenants attempted to solve this problem by posting passive-aggressive notes on the paper-towel dispenser. (Image of a paper with "Please discard paper towels into wastebasket." written on it) The signs never worked. Instead, they just annoyed and angered people. Some people even threw more paper towels on the floor because they didn’t like the condescending way they were being instructed. --- That message is anything but passive-aggressive. It's direct, reasonable and courteous. It's also very ordinary and I've seen signs like it in various public restrooms, train stations, subway stations and other areas. If someone is actually angered by this kind of sign and decides to litter more as a response, they're probably not a very easy person to get along with. In many places, such as Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan, and much of east Asia, this problem is solved via fines. Over time the fines even change social norms about littering and the situation improves in areas without the fines. The analogy to copyright is pretty weak. Many places with more civilized norms in terms of litter really don't care about copyright infringement to the extent that English-speaking countries do. Copyright behavior has also been very resistant to being altered by fines.
- rue 15y agoIt's passive-aggressive, because it doesn't directly address the problem. A direct message would have been at the door and said: “Please stop throwing paper on the floor, there's a wastebasket on the other side of the room”. (I also suspect that the reaction would have been at least somewhat more positive.)
- xiaoma 15y agoI disagree. "Please discard paper towels into wastebasket" is direct and specifies exactly what kind of behavior is desired. Your example doesn't do that. It says there is a wastebasket, but the only request is not to throw paper on the floor. It could be satisfied by leaving the wet paper towels on the sink, leaving them draped on the door handle or slapping them on the wall. (How's that for passive-aggressive!) The original message is both shorter and clearer. It's both pro-active and respectful. Getting angry at the notice and littering to show you won't tolerate "condescension" is just being a dick.
- twfarland 15y agoThis is related to the concept of 'desire lines' used by architects.
- protomyth 15y agoIt is an interesting example, but I will bet that putting the trash can by the door didn't work either. I've worked in a place with a design that has the trash cans by the door and there is still paper on the ground. So, the next step would be to put a camera in the bathroom and review the tape to find all the people who didn't use the cans. Simple, quick, and only takes a couple of minutes after the cleaning staff says there is still towels on the ground. At some level, the people throwing stuff on the ground know that someone has to clean it up. They probably justify it, when they think about it at all, with some happy thought of keeping those people employed. After all, they are probably sure that is all the maintenance worker does (never mind all the things they need to do everyday). Pirating content and throwing towels on the floor both come down to placing a lack of value on the work of others and not caring about them.
- ghshephard 15y agoTo push the analogy to the limit - no, putting the trash can by the door doesn't stop 100% of the people, but for the 95% of the people who just don't want to touch the door with their hands, it does. Likewise, making content easy to purchase won't stop 100% of the pirates who can afford to pay for their shows, but for the 95% of us who can, and just want to watch Game of Thrones, and are more than happy to buy it from iTunes, it will capture our revenue.
- protomyth 15y agoIf I install the camera, I will catch 99.9% and know who is so unconcerned with our maintenance workers. In a pragmatic world that is an acceptable solution. It would probably be a good idea to find out who those people are so you know not to trust them with doing anything that is not convenient.
- skore 15y agoIt may be a solution, superficially, but only to the problem that you have outlined. If you make it your goal to eliminate "all paper thrown on the floor", why not go for 100% and get rid of the paper towels in the first place? The question is not how to get rid of people throwing paper on the ground, or how to guilt the remaining careless ones into throwing theirs in the bin. The question is actually - what is the most cost-effective solution to manage the problem: Having to spend energy on peoples carelessness. If putting a bin there catches 95% of the paper towels that were thrown on the ground before, that's as perfect as you could wish it to be. Those further 5% (or 4.99%) will cost you so much time, money and effort that once they do achieve your goal, you will surely ask yourself whether you would have been just as OK with 95%.
- hdalskfhkjlad 15y agothe problem starts when you want to sell the same show in us, UK and Thailand. in uk it would cost twice as much then us and ten times as much then Thailand, why? because people can pay more, and the industry wants to squeeze as much as they can. if they get rigid price, then in Tainan people may need a month pay for an episodes, and or the opposite, huge losses in uk. solve that, and you got the piracy problem solved.
- hdalskfhkjlad 15y agothe problem starts when you want to sell the same show in us, UK and Thailand. in uk it would cost twice as much then us and ten times as much then Thailand, why? because people can pay more, and the industry wants to squeeze as much as they can. if they get rigid price, then in Tainan people may need a month pay for an episodes, and or the opposite, huge losses in uk. solve that, and you got the piracy problem solved.
- Czarnian 15y agoI'll probably lose a bunch of karma over this, but here goes. This is my takeaway from the article: The pragmatic approach means that the company (media companies) should accommodate the folks who: 1) Are so emotionally damaged that they can't perform the simple act of opening a door without making a mess (pay a couple of bucks for content that they like.) 2) Are so ill-mannered that they have no respect for the people they share a space with (take content without the creator's permission.) 3) Are so poorly socialized that any attempt to correct their behavior causes them to act out like a 5 year old by making a bigger mess (downloading even more stuff that they don't even really want.) 4) Are so lazy that they can't be bothered to take the simple action of taking the towel back to their desk and putting it in their own trash can (using the distribution channels the creator asks them to use.) I find his argument unconvincing.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- orangecat 15y agoIt's understandable that you aren't happy with the state of the world and of human nature, but that's not an argument. Believing that it is, is in fact exactly the fallacy the article describes.
- drawkbox 15y agoI like the final line of the article. It is really basics, if you are making a product tailor it to the way the customer demands it. Path of least resistance, if there is an easier way it will be the way.
- zwischenzug 15y agoI spend a lot of my time at work telling junior designers: "That's a great idea - let's not do it!" "Why not?" "Because no-one behaves like that" "But if they only put the info A into the place B every time, their jobs will be much easier" "Yes. But they won't. We have to find a way to force them (which will annoy them), or work around it."
- Miky 15y agoThis article reminds me quite a bit of linguistic prescriptivism and descriptivism. Many people like to pretend that there's some platonic, right form of language. Splitting an infinitive is wrong, ending a clause with a preposition is wrong, using pronouns in the accusative case as a subject (“Me and her do this”) or a predicate nominative (“It's me”) is wrong. This attitude reflects the same stubborn insistence on being right instead of pragmatic. The reality is that language changes over time and is defined by usage, so Those arguing that a common usage is incorrect are wrong by definition.