6 ms·
> Coinbase, as with most crypto platforms, has decided it wants to simultaneously operate as an exchange, broker-dealer, and clearing agency. These three functi
by crazygringo 3y ago
> Coinbase, as with most crypto platforms, has decided it wants to simultaneously operate as an exchange, broker-dealer, and clearing agency. These three functions — bringing together securities orders for buyers and sellers, trading securities on behalf of others, and intermediating trades — are typically required to be separate due to conflicts of interest that emerge when one entity controls all of them. Coinbase would need to fundamentally change its business model in order to separate these functions, and thus far seems unwilling to do so. “[Crypto intermediary compliance is] not just a matter of ‘paying lip service to [the] desire to comply with applicable laws’ or seeking a bunch of meetings with the SEC during which you’re unwilling to make the changes needed to comply with the securities laws,” said Gensler in a speech a few days ago.
Can someone knowledgeable here clarify if this really is the crux of the problem?
The previous HN thread seemed to mainly be of the opinion that Coinbase wasn't registering the non-Bitcoin crypto, but that the problem was the SEC wasn't giving clear guidance on whether they needed to be.
But I don't understand what ramifications that has. Why didn't Coinbase just register everything non-Bitcoin? Would that have limited/destroyed its business model in the way the quote above suggests?
Edit: thank you so much to all the replies so far! This is incredibly helpful.
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoThe problem is that issuers of crypto don't file S-1's and the like. They apparently claim it's because the investment involved in crypto is technology-enforced scarcity and not any interest in an actual business. They might propose instead publishing a white paper about how their technology works. Since there's no satisfactory registration, there's no legitimate industry. The Coinbase situation is a follow-on consequence.
- unyttigfjelltol 3y agoWhich, when you think about it makes sense. Why would consumer protection folks waive consumer protections simply because the would-be issuer confirmed there was no intrinsic value in the offering?
- wmf 3y agoSome people have suggested that coins with no utility or claim on future revenue should be regulated as gambling.
- Doxin 3y agoI can see that being a good argument. Just because you run a casino that never cashes out doesn't mean it shouldn't be regulated as a casino.
- smeagull 3y agoThus far video games are free from casino regulations.
- Retric 3y agoMostly, there’s serious concerns over paid loot boxes with many countries including Japan banning them or treating them as pure gambling. Little outdated (2020) but: https://screenrant.com/lootbox-gambling-microtransactions-illegal-japan-china-belgium-netherlands/ https://screenrant.com/lootbox-gambling-microtransactions-il...
- vermote 3y agoNot in Belgium, where lootboxes have been banned.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoIf you can't cash out it's just entertainment. That's why you don't have to be 18 to play pinball. [actually the history of pinball and other arcade games is fraught with legal action, there were a few iterations of payout before we got to the harmless, kid-friendly machines of today, really good podcast about it, interviewing the guy who heads the Pacific Pinball Museum: https://art19.com/shows/the-madecast/episodes/6753c3e6-e12d-4523-b19c-83e2589d0b48 https://art19.com/shows/the-madecast/episodes/6753c3e6-e12d-...]
- yieldcrv 3y ago> Why didn't Coinbase just register everything non-Bitcoin? The organizations that created the assets have to register them as securities, Coinbase didn't create the assets. A broker-dealer (a securities exchange) can only trade registered securities, broker-dealers have to register to exist. So even if Coinbase went through the process of registering as a broker dealer (to be a securities exchange), they could not trade unregistered crypto securities, and cannot unilaterally register things they didn't create as securities. Registered crypto securities are a mixture of non-existent, or not the things people want to trade. There are zero popular registered crypto securities. Those organizations with those "unregistered securities" quote on quote, also don't believe they are creating securities at all, just digital products, cryptoassets. A distinct asset class. This should be possible to do compliantly, but it is also not clear how to do so or where the line is. Regardless, those organizations have not been approached by the SEC saying "hey you created unregistered securities and sold them, we're suing you". The SEC has indeed tried a couple of those cases against different crypto assets and their creators and had mixed results, the well funded ones are dragging the SEC through court for half a decade now, for a single case. While the number of crypto assets continues to balloon every single day. So the SEC changed its strategy recently and started suing exchanges using circular logic, claiming assets that they never said were securities to be securities and saying "these are unregistered securities and you are trading them in violation of Federal Securities laws", having never proved in court that these were securities.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 3y ago> So the SEC changed its strategy recently and started suing exchanges using circular logic, claiming assets that they never said were securities to be securities and saying "these are unregistered securities and you are trading them in violation of Federal Securities laws", having never proved in court that these were securities. You're describing the procedure of proving in court that they're securities. The SEC claims they are, sues someone over it, and they fight it out with them in court. The court decides who proved what.
- shagie 3y ago> Why didn't Coinbase just register everything non-Bitcoin? Would that have someone limited/destroyed its business model in the way the quote above suggests? Coinbase wouldn't be the one to register the security - the company offering the security would be the one registering it. Coinbase may have some securities of its own - but it is unlikely that it would be able to provide the necessary information for much of them or take on the necessary responsibilities for providing the auditing. https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-basics/glossary/registration-under-securities-act-1933 https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing/investing-ba... The registration forms a company files with the SEC provide significant information, including: A description of the company's properties and business; A description of the security to be offered for sale; Information about the management of the company; and Financial statements certified by independent accountants. https://www.americanbar.org/groups/business_law/resources/business-law-today/2017-april/what-constitutes-a-security-and-requirements-relating-to-the-off/ https://www.americanbar.org/groups/business_law/resources/bu... > In order to register a security under the Securities Act, a company must file a registration statement with the SEC. Typically the type of registration statement used for an initial public offering will be a Form S-1 Registration Statement (Form S-1). A Form S-1 includes two parts (Part I and Part II). Part I is the prospectus, the legal offering or “selling” document. In the prospectus, the “issuer” of the securities must describe in the prospectus important facts about its business operations, financial condition, results of operations, risk factors, and management. It must also include audited financial statements. The prospectus must be delivered to everyone who buys the securities, as well as anyone who is made an offer to purchase the securities. Part II contains additional information that an issuer does not have to deliver to investors but must file with the SEC, such as copies of material contracts, signatures of management and other representations. Most organizations providing cryptocurrency based securities are unable or unwilling to provide the required information.
- georgeecollins 3y agoRather that claim knowledge, I would suggest you read Matt Levine's newsletter on this. He is a former securities lawyer who is extremely knowledgeable. -- I mean very extremely, he wrote an entire Business Week magazine about it. Some key takeaways: For historical reasons as well as practical ones (who would you sue) BTC and ETH are probably considered commodities. Most of the rest are very similar to ICOs which were securities and rife with fraud. But you can't really go after the issuers very easily for a lot of reasons. But there are two parts to the SECs laws. One part is the issuance of secuirties, the second part is the brokers (or in this case exchanges). FTX, Binance, Coinbase, do things that would be illegal to do with securities (conflicts, lack of disclosure etc.). The SEC is just pointing out that most coins are securities and what they are doing is illegal under current law. https://news.bloomberglaw.com/mergers-and-acquisitions/matt-levines-money-stuff-the-sec-comes-for-crypto https://news.bloomberglaw.com/mergers-and-acquisitions/matt-...
- H8crilA 3y agoOn top of that it is very, very hard to not see staking as unregistered securities offering. It is so bad that many states issued an immediate cease and desist letters, as well as awarded fines per violation, that is per investor.
- lclc 3y agoFor ETH they can sue Vitalik Buterin, the rest of the Ethereum Co-Founders, and the Ethereum foundation. They are the issuers and majority of the ETH supply is there since the beginning.
- cliftonk 3y agovitalik and the ethereum foundation hold less than 0.5% of the eth supply.
- ceejayoz 3y ago"Your Honor, I didn't murder the victim today, just a few years ago. Surely that doesn't count?" They crowdfunded $18M and used that to develop and issue tokens. It was clearly under their control at the time.
- norswap 3y agoIt's important to note that event for the projects creating new tokens, there is NO WAY to register. It exists, in theory. Many people have tried, nothing has progressed even an inch. It's not even a matter of the SEC putting out a list of clear conditions that people deem unacceptable. Instead, the applications just seem to be mired in bureaucracy. As I understand, there is deliberate gaslighting from the SEC and Gary Gensler. Gary keeps telling the media "the law is clear" and "companies should come and register", but then never answer's even congress' own questions on what constitutes a security, and makes it impossible for crypto projects to register.
- cr__ 3y agoIf there’s no way to register, why did they proceed?
- gigatexal 3y agoGetting rich off of shit-coins in this wild west of digital currencies, that's why.
- agentgumshoe 3y agoNot sure why this is downvoted, it's absolutely true.
- criddell 3y agoMaybe they expected to still be profitable after paying the fines?
- danpalmer 3y agoBecause in the US a lack of explicit laws against something is typically interpreted as legal support. See pretty much any disruptive business mired in legal controversy. It's a cultural difference to many other countries where just because there isn't a law against something doesn't mean people will jump at the chance to exploit it at scale.
- jongjong 3y ago
- kerkeslager 3y ago> > These three functions — bringing together securities orders for buyers and sellers, trading securities on behalf of others, and intermediating trades — are typically required to be separate due to conflicts of interest that emerge when one entity controls all of them. and... > The previous HN thread seemed to mainly be of the opinion that Coinbase wasn't registering the non-Bitcoin crypto, but that the problem was the SEC wasn't giving clear guidance on whether they needed to be. See, this is why we need regulation. It's to deal with people like the HN crowd who will go up to the limit of the law with no consideration for ethics whatsoever. A normal, ethical person would never run into the problem Coinbase has here. They'd see that the differing parts of their business had conflicts of interest which were pitting them against their own customers, and they'd do the right thing by splitting them up so that their customers are served. The law never has to get involved, because good people don't need the law to tell them to do the right thing. But contrary to the end-stage capitalist beliefs of HN, corporations are not good people. Capitalism doesn't result in the best service for the lowest cost. If there's any way at all that corporations can make a profit by screwing over other people and getting away with it, they will, or someone else will. Without regulation to limit this, bad people bubble to the top. Coinbase has plenty of smart people who could have noticed the ethical problems here, but they didn't, because they didn't care. Coinbase has been successful monetarily because when they had a choice to do what's right or what's profitable, they chose to do what's profitable. And as is typical of HN, the top comment identifies with the bad guys. The problem, in your eyes, isn't that what Coinbase did caused conflicts of interest which harm consumers. The problem, in your eyes, is that regulation wasn't clear enough for Coinbase to know exactly which conflicts of interest they could get away with. Like Coinbase, you're unconcerned with ethics, instead blaming regulators for getting in the way of the only thing you care about: profits. This place has a serious problem.