5 ms·
UPS strike could devastate the economy, and could be eight weeks away
- deepsquirrelnet 3y agoThe American economy is both weak and strong — or so say articles like these that consistently try to convince us. Even the slightest mobilization of workers within a single company within a single sector can bring the greatest economy in the world TM instantly to its knees. I’m either getting sick of living in such a brittle system that is constantly at peril from people wanting to join or stay in the middle class, or I’m getting sick of these articles implying that this is the best we can do and there’s not better options. Too much cognitive dissonance to be believable.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_purpose_of_a_system_is_what_it_does https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_purpose_of_a_system_is_wha... Brittle systems were built because they enriched and benefited certain folks (paperclip maximizer but for profits). To build better systems, existing systems will have to be "refactored." With structural demographics constraining labor supply for the next decade, this is an opportune time for Labor to use the power that it has to reverse its 40 year power decline. https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2018/08/07/for-most-us-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2018/08/07/for-most-... https://www.barrons.com/articles/the-labor-market-bends-toward-scarcity-the-fed-cant-change-that-51670019273 https://www.barrons.com/articles/the-labor-market-bends-towa...
- nine_zeros 3y agoAmerican economy has become too concentrated to a handful of companies. That makes America a fragile economy. In a REAL capitalistic economy, a small shipping provider would have raised the capital immediately to capitalize on the strikes, advertised their services to UPSs customers and eaten the company away. This would have put pressure on the company execs to negotiate fast, give in to worker demands (which are reasonable) just to not lose out on future earnings. If the execs succeeded, UPS would continue to live. If execs failed, the competitor would replace them. That would have been capitalism but America is far too protective of large corporations.
- heavenlyblue 3y ago> In a REAL capitalistic economy, a small shipping provider would have raised the capital immediately to capitalize on the strikes, advertised their services to UPSs customers and eaten the company away. In a REAL capitalistic economy, a large shipping provider would intimidate their own employees by means of having their own army.
- EliRivers 3y agoAnd it would all work out, because the army would actually be composed of the striking workers, hired on short-contracts to intimidate themselves, and any strike-breakers would also be striking workers hired at greater pay; where else are you going to find people with exactly the right knowledge and experience, AND available suddenly? :)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- failuser 3y agoNot really. The army is the part of the workforce they actually take good care of. It might be contracted from a PMC, or even the state because under REAL capitalism the state exists to keep the capital happy.
- rightbyte 3y agoWasn't there a part of Catch 22, where the entrepreneur character outsourced the German bombing of some US air base to that very same US air base's bombers? Sounds about like that. In non-fiction there are just more steps in between to hide it.
- rocket_surgeron 3y ago>In a REAL capitalistic economy, a small shipping provider would have raised the capital immediately to capitalize on the strikes, advertised their services to UPSs customers and eaten the company away. In the real world it takes weeks if not months to purchase a delivery vehicle. There are no delivery van lots that you go to in order to browse a wide variety of Morgan Olson and Utilimaster vans and then plop down a million dollars for 20 of them, not that 20 of them would allow you to run a parcel shipping service. You need thousands. Which means a production run at a manufacturer who is already booked through next year. Hell, it would take weeks just to figure out WHERE to advertise much less actually inking deals, unless you like throwing money away. It doesn't matter if you apparate a trillion dollars, time is immovable. It took a decade of conceptualizing and two years of actualizing to start FedEx. If a rationally-acting rational actor rationalizes ten quadrillion dollars of gold into his pocket, it doesn't matter one fucking bit. They can't buy the facilities, systems, equipment, and experience needed to do shit. They can't use their iron capitalist will to pour concrete faster. This is one, of many, fundamental blind spot concerning reality that capitalists or pseudo-capitalists used to working in the fake online venture capitalist world have.
- ilyt 3y agoWhen government cares about corporation shareholders well-being more than their own people that happens.
- fundad 3y agoDo you measure strength in money or resilience?
- failuser 3y agoThose are metaphors. Hard, but brittle like over heat-treated steel might be a better metaphor. US makes it workers work very hard, but it will explode if too many workers will refuse to put up with the pressure.
- local_crmdgeon 3y agoOr, more reasonably, CNN is just a garbage news source.
- skinnymuch 3y agoThe economy is already devastated if it relies on a separate class of owners and workers. With the workers never protesting too much. Labor disputes and working with those things is a net positive for the economy and most people. Most people are not filthy rich.
- floxy 3y agoDid the 1997 UPS strike devastate the economy?
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoNo, but package delivery is a much larger part of the economy today than it was 26 years ago. Many more businesses today depend upon UPS for delivery of parts.
- disposition2 3y agoI also wonder how much of ‘just in time’ / lean adoptions over the last 26 years might also play a part in potential negative effects.
- floxy 3y ago>package delivery is a much larger part of the economy today than it was 26 years ago In this "age of big data", is there a way to quantify it? Ideally, it would be interesting to see the inflation adjusted package carrier revenue per capita for the past 30 years or so in the U.S..
- jmpman 3y agoCan someone explain why Airline pilots are allowed to go on strike, pretty much at will, without government intervention, but railroad workers, who are paid a tiny fraction of pilots, are forced back to work? I expect the UPS drivers will be forced back to work just like the railroad workers.
- addisonl 3y agoYou want the government to force private employees to work? UPS is not USPS.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoNeither are railroads. Freight railroads, not just Amtrak.
- orwin 3y agoUS have four railway companies from what i understood a few month ago. Is one of them state-operated?
- ecopoesis 3y agoBecause we outlawed railroad strikes but didn't outlaw airline strikes. Doesn't really prevent a strike though: it just makes it cost more. Here in Massachusetts it's illegal for public school teachers to strike, yet it has happened a couple times in the last year. In one case the teacher's union was fined: https://www.bostonherald.com/2023/02/08/woburn-teachers-turn-to-community-support-for-hefty-strike-fines/ https://www.bostonherald.com/2023/02/08/woburn-teachers-turn...
- cool_dude85 3y agoRailroad strikes are not outlawed. They are probably more regulated than other strikes in some ways, as there are certain things they can't strike for, and certain times they can't strike. But when they do strike, they have more leeway too, like they can solidarity strike which is illegal under NLRA. The most recent attempt at a railroad strike was stopped by Congress imposing management's contract. But that's not a general prohibition against striking.
- mistrial9 3y agoUPS Management got one of the largest IPOs of the 90s, and have blundered and failed repeatedly at the promised international expansion. Meanwhile Amazon went ruthless, and other large package delivery companies were efficient. UPS is looking more like Detroit and less like New York City right now. Taking the difference out of the skins of workers is probably in line with the current strategy there.
- advisedwang 3y agoWhat a load of anti-worker propaganda. CNN would like you to think workers are obliged to work at wherever rate UPS offers because it's in the interest of "the economy". If UPS failed to reach a contract with any other key supplier they would be blasted by the press. UPS management has had plenty of time to negotiate. Management is playing a game pushing to the limit of a strike, and maybe into a strike, to get workers scared they'll lose a paycheck and accept a worse deal
- graypegg 3y agoThis has been strike busting 101 since time immemorial. *The whole point* of a strike is to prove how much of a company will fall apart with out labour. It makes management liable for the impending break down because the strikers/union will have made a very public list of demands and reasons for the strike, so it’s on management to figure something out. Resolving problems with concrete decisions is their job after all, like you said about contracts. However if management leaves it as long as possible so the public gets a taste of the breakdown, they can try and lean public sentiment towards them, painting the workers as “causing” the problem. It’s not their ineffectiveness in resolving a dispute that caused it, it’s those workers who don’t have any respect for the economy/consumers/YOU! CNN is reporting the news here, this WILL seriously affect things, but they’ve taken the angle that UPS corporate was hoping for.
- pempem 3y agoI think CNN knows this and is hard pressed to push the envelope further than they have. They note that the company is doing tremendously well at least three times. They also mention that even Deutsche Bank says the company can handle increasing wages. (the bank identifies it as due to inflation not profit, but I'll take my wins where I can) More than that, they have reported in the past on the record earnings from last year: https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/01/business/ups-earnings/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/01/business/ups-earnings/index.h...
- pasttense01 3y agoRemember that package delivery peaks in December before Christmas--yet the package industry can handle this peak. So let's say December volume is 100x units of which UPS handles 40x--leaving the rest of the industry handling 60x units. And normal August volume is 60x units. Thus the rest of industry can handle this (with overtime, part-time workers...). And business will do things like consolidate orders [ever order a half dozen things from Walmart and it comes in more than one package (from different distribution centers)].
- satisfice 3y agoWho writes “An UPS?” This is an affront to sub-vocalization!
- yesbut 3y agoObviously an young journalist does.
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agoCorporations can now win lawsuits against labor unions for economic damages. So, expect this propaganda to lead to the destruction of UPS's union following another lawsuit.