7 ms·
I applied to McDonald's and other fast food jobs but chatbots made it impossible
- AshamedCaptain 3y agoSurprisingly this is hardly new. The french national rail company has had a chatbot to handle customer complains for almost 5 years.
- version_five 3y agoAll the "ai fairness" bullshit it pretty rich when you consider how it's main use case is to abuse people who are desperate enough to put up with these automated interactions. All the talk about responsible AI and whatnot and how it affects various favored demographics is just a smoke screen for how it's really being used to treat people like crap.
- SonOfKyuss 3y agoI think a big part of it is execs at these companies jumping on the AI hype train looking to cut costs and stay up with the latest trends. They don’t realize and likely don’t care if the end user experience is awful as long as they can claim to be “using AI” in some way. Reminds me of the early days of outsourcing where there was a mad rush to outsource as much as possible to avoid being left out.
- srslack 3y agoYes, just like Yudkowsky and Altman are focusing on bullshit conceptual, theoretical and absurd risks as a smoke screen to what real risks and real harms will and are occurring right now, for regulatory capture and more funding for their bullshit non profit research orgs, so too do most AI ethics researchers. I'd say they're not even hiding how useless they are. Hell, one of the main criticisms of internal PaLM was that it was not progressive enough and didn't toe the Silicon Valley Democrat party line and thus was racist.
- cyanydeez 3y agoAI washing is the new hotness in class warfare
- mo_42 3y agoSometimes I ask myself when the first major companies won’t need any employees anymore. Basically, run by an AI that reports to investors and tries to buy robots on the markets to fulfill its goals. Seems like we’re not there yet at all.
- shortcake27 3y ago> The second application asked me to create a general profile and fill out other fields, including a video cover letter for the recruiting platform. This is tangential to the AI issue, but wow - absolutely horrible. How disillusioned are the execs who come up with these ideas? Do they really believe anyone _wants_ to work for them? I really feel for people who have no option other than to go through this garbage just to land a minimum wage job.
- version_five 3y agoVideos, including asymmetrical video interviews where the candidate has to record themselves answering questions, are becoming more common for professional jobs as well. It's probably a great screening tool for identifying candidates with no self respect and no other options that can be treated badly throughout employment. If not illegal, this practice should at least be made socially unacceptable. I'm a capitalist, but this kind of thing is definitely an argument against unrestricted capitalism.
- teclordphrack2 3y agoIt's going to be an HR and lawsuit issue in the future. There is a reason in the USA we don't have head shots on our resume.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lozenge 3y agoAh I wouldn't worry about it. The courts don't accept statistical evidence of discrimination, the rejected applicant would actually need to prove discrimination on an individual basis. Source - https://www.culawreview.org/journal/what-constitutes-discrimination-in-the-courts-proving-discriminatory-intent-and-systematic-racism-in-the-death-penalty https://www.culawreview.org/journal/what-constitutes-discrim...
- ChainOfFools 3y ago
- prepend 3y agoI have a teenager trying to get a job and is running into this. The local grocery store used to have a certain time each week to show up and interview. Now they have a web site. My kid filled out the web site multiple times and they’ve never called or emailed to follow up. Kid followed up in person and they just pointed to the web site. It’s frustrating because the stores are understaffed and always ask for applicants during checkout. Same for local fast food places. Their hiring process is so stupid.
- fineIllregister 3y ago> It’s frustrating because the stores are understaffed and always ask for applicants during checkout. If they wanted to hire more, they would. Understaffing is intentional.
- BizarroLand 3y agoHanlon's razor: Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity" Or in this case, incompetence.
- fineIllregister 3y agoGP said the person jumped through the hoops to submit the resume online. They have the candidate's information; they're actively choosing not to hire. The most likely explanation is that understaffing hasn't reduced revenue more than the additional staff would cost. That's not what I would call "incompetence".
- wrp 3y agoI lived through some really tight job markets as a youth, and it was the most aggressive of my classmates who got the jobs. I would advise printing out a short resume that could be scanned quickly, then handing it directly to the assistant manager with an explanation of the web-site problem and declaration of readiness to get right to work. If they don't hire you right off, I expect some will at least tell you how to get to the front of the line.
- akomtu 3y agoMcDonald's 2043: "We still employ humans! Yes, we do. Apply here." A small asterisk at the bottom adds in a microscopic font: "Applicants must bring a recent copy of the baseline test with a score of at least 740."
- expertentipp 3y ago"We are hiring*". * - no we aren't.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoMaybe when AI is added in, it will get really interesting. Imaging an AI hiring system, no human being involved. Then all you'll have to do is post a likely resume to the website, and use a chatbot to answer their AI interview. No human will ever have even set eyes on you before you walk in the door your first day! Rats. I have just given some HNer an idea for a startup.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Imaging an AI hiring system, no human being involved. I have imagined it. This is one of my nightmare scenarios.
- specproc 3y agoI had a quick play around with the Mcdonald's chatbot, in the hope that they might have hooked it up to GPT and it could be tricked into saying something funny. No dice, the thing is as dumb as a Beavis and Butthead Christmas special, and incredibly poorly built. I was being progressed to next questions after giving nonsense responses, there were also typos and zero context. I know giving it an LLM would have been a very bad idea, but it was striking a) how my expectations of a chat bot have shifted, b) how bad an interface chat is, and c) how a company that big could roll out such a transparently bad system for such an important function.