8 ms·
French tax officials use AI to spot 20k undeclared pools (2022)
- denhaus 3y agolegitimately the shittiest, most boring, and most unimaginatively dystopian use for AI I have ever seen.
- cinntaile 3y agoWhy do you think discovering illegal tax evasion is not good?
- stavros 3y agoBecause middle-to-lower-class people aren't the ones I want paying more taxes.
- cinntaile 3y agoHow did you arrive at your conclusion that the pools mentioned in the article belong to middle-to-lower class people? Did you do your own analysis and cross-checked it with their income statements? Myself I would expect the pools to disproportionally belong to well-off people. I don't quite get why you differentiate between classes, everybody has to pay taxes. I would prefer the tax agency to go after (illegally evaded) tax revenue where they get the most bang for their buck, this project paid itself back in less than a year so that seems to fit the bill.
- stavros 3y agoYes, everybody has to pay taxes. The more money you have/make, the more taxes you need to pay, but the case now is that the more money you have, the more you can avoid taxes. Sure, the agency can get more of the non-super-rich people who don't have an army of accountants optimizing their tax structure, but I don't think that's the most equitable thing to do.
- tasubotadas 3y agoMonitoring citizens using AI is China-like dystopia.
- skinnymuch 3y agoIn America we have a credit score which is quite dystopian. America has the most prisoners and slavery in prisons. The NSA among others monitor citizens.
- tasubotadas 3y agoSo?
- skinnymuch 3y agoYou made an offhand apolitical comment about China being dystopian in regards where America is arguably worse. I wake up every day in a right wing dystopia. Even worse, people like you lack the knowledge or solidarity with other workers while having too much nationalism and so on. I’m going to assume you wouldn’t be able to explain China’s politics nor explain why Taiwan is granted sovereignty but Palestine isn’t. Both places had people before each imperialist group of people conquered land where people already lived. When’s the last time any typical westerner has ever cared about the indigenous people of Taiwan. This doesn’t contradict anything. More of a case where I’m stating the obvious. Even if you happen to actually care about the indigenous people, you’re still going to arrogantly believe Taiwan is a Democratic good guy country. Let’s not even get into Taiwan being fascist for some time…
- pyrale 3y agoWhy? Taxes is what sends children to school, pays for hospitals and funds the infrastructure everyone uses. People love to hear about AI breakthroughs that could transform education or health, why should they not be happy about this? I have many doubts about the actual technical solution, but I wouldn't discard the work because it's for taxation purpose.
- im3w1l 3y agoThe power balance between state and individual is quite delicate and everything that changes it makes people uneasy. Most people want a situation where law and order is more or less upheld, but the state is otherwise unable to precisely know or control how people live.
- hkt 3y agoEnforcing property taxes is hardly a substantial change to that balance though, realistically.
- darkr 3y agoFrom my understanding they paid CapGemini €24M for this project in order to net €10M in taxes.
- TMWNN 3y agoMost of that will be fixed costs. It won't cost nearly so much the next time.
- Traubenfuchs 3y ago...when will the next 20.000 swimming pools be done?
- _Microft 3y agoAnother commenter pointed out that having a pool influences the property value and thereby tax, so they should be able to collect the tax yearly, not just once.
- andybak 3y agoIt's people that can afford pools on their property. They can afford to own property. I'm not shedding many tears here. If even a tiny amount of the money recovered improves the lot of the vulnerable then I find it hard to put this at the top of my "this year's dystopian" list. Your comment however might go on my own "most unimaginative definition of dystopian" list.
- wouldbecouldbe 3y agoIt costed more to create the AI with capgemini then they recoverd. One of the reason many of us hate taxes is because they always have a "punishment" mindset. They rather lose money and punish someone. Why tax swimming pools anyway?
- cinntaile 3y agoYou misunderstand, this is 10M euro extra tax revenue each year and it was only a pilot project covering a small part of France. The payback time is basically less than a year.
- wouldbecouldbe 3y agoRegardless 25 million of tax money to another consultancy is the problem. They are of one the biggest benificiaries of the modern western tax system. It's a complicated problem to solve, but not a 25 million kind of complicated problem. Also the bill isnt finished yet. 30% error rate, they are working on finetuning solving the issues.
- cinntaile 3y agoROI seems fine, I don't see the issue.
- seydor 3y agoThe problem with unaffordable housing all over europe should be solved with massive amounts public housing. Pools should be taxed but that does not solve the problem. Everyone pretends they are not looking at the elephant in the room: draconian environmental regulations and lack of resources make the prices of housing go higher and higher. The governments have the money to solve that, instead of making it worse
- matsemann 3y agoAI making normal people lose their jobs, accumulating even more wealth at the top: Good AI making affluent people pay their share of taxes: Dystopian.
- beebeepka 3y agoThe way I see it, there are some really well off people on this site, so they sympathise with others like them. Off-putting but not unexpected
- Tade0 3y ago> As property taxes are based on the rental value of the property, improvements mean an increase in taxes. A typical pool of 30 sq metres would be taxed at about an extra €200 a year. Sounds like the tax authority just DDoSed itself with this, because processing all these changes is going to take some time.
- freddie_mercury 3y agoThe article is almost a year old and France had no issues processing this, so there was no Denial of Service at all.
- moonchrome 3y agoSend bills, disputes are easy to check, fake dispute -> full audit. Seems trivial, not like you can hide the pool once the inspection comes around.
- sjcsjc 3y agoWhat an exciting future lies ahead of us
- _Microft 3y ago„The spirits that I summoned…“ / “Die Geister, die ich rief“ came to mind. It is a well-known German phrase about losing control over something you started and unintentional consequences. It‘s adapted from the poem „The Sorcerer‘s Apprentice“. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sorcerer%27s_Apprentice https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sorcerer%27s_Apprentice
- mrfinn 3y agoWell "they" are being creative using AI, I say we follow suit...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- looofooo 3y agoNext;adversarial pool tiling to counter recognition.
- arthurfm 3y agoCould the pool owners simply stick a hot and cold tap at one end and claim it is a large bath and not a swimming pool to avoid paying the tax? :)
- gumballindie 3y agoNo need for tiles, a cover would suffice.
- ChatGTP 3y ago2022
- matsemann 3y agoShould be trivial to spot by just looking at their water bill, no?
- cm2187 3y agoI would assume watering a garden consumes more than a swimming pool.
- john_minsk 3y agoGardens must be taxed too then.
- orra 3y agoWatering plants with a watering can? Absolutely not. Watering a grass lawn to lush greenness, with a hosepipe? Agreed that uses a lot of water.
- motoxpro 3y agoMuch much more trivial to look at a map and see a big blue pool than try to parse water bill differences. Having had a pool, there isn't an obvious pattern as to when i had to fill it up, etc. Low hanging fruit are the ones that aren't covered.
- detaro 3y agopreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32652216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32652216
- ohgodplsno 3y ago"AI" Imagine being charged 24 million euros (https://www.01net.com/actualites/piscines-non-declarees-la-traque-par-intelligence-artificielle-a-rapporte-10-millions-deuros-et-sera-generalisee.html https://www.01net.com/actualites/piscines-non-declarees-la-t...) by Capgemini, known for having fucked up every single public -private partnership in France so they can just run OpenCV on satellite pictures, while being paid for a THIRTY PERCENT ERROR RATE
- nottorp 3y agoScheme to be extended across the country after trial in nine departments led to extra €10m in tax receipts So far it cost 2.5 times what it made. But tbh i don't think the 30% error rate is relevant. How many photos did it analyze and how many did it select for human review? Unless ... google being involved ... there was no human review.
- ohgodplsno 3y agoIt was ran in the nine departments where there's the biggest concentration and likelihood of pools. Additionally, these 10m in receipts include fines for not declaring the pools. The actual yearly returns are much lower. Looking for swimming pools in the Creuse is not going to bring in a lot of cash. The DGFiP is hit or miss with these projects, and they rarely hit well.
- BrandoElFollito 3y agoIt's not only Capgemini. Most of French digitalization is horrendous. We have a Social Security card (Carte Vitale) that you show when doing medical activities (so to speak). It could have been a great driver for centralized patient documentation (results, prescriptions, ...). What they did instead - a totally fucked up system nobody uses (including doctors and pharmacies) which was architected and coded by an intern with a liberal art diploma. Not only logging in is a shitshow but then you cannot add ANYTHING useful inside. Nothing. OK, this failed so now the govt decided to launch a new program (for the same thing) and nobody understands what this is is how it is supposed to work. At the same time, in Poland, I saw a perfectly well working system that centraizes everything (the public medical world sucks there but that's not the point). Why not reusing this instead of inventing a merdouille again? When COVID blew up, we had the luck to have a brand new exchange platform for schools. When I had to use it, my children said "oh, I did not know that word" when i started to yell on the screen. It is so bad that by just typing here I risk to break my keyboard. We have idiots in digitalization in France. I am sure other countries are the same but here this is a tradition since after the Minitel. If you can fuck it up, they will - with our taxes.
- l5870uoo9y 3y agoYou can without a doubt take this even further and train it to detect all sorts felonies. The felonies will mainly be simple ones that perpetrated by the lower and middle class. Builder working without a bill? Crosscheck income with an country wide average and their spending history. Nailed. Waitresses working without paying tax? Crosscheck size of establishment with formally employees. Nailed. Of course, this not only has privacy issues but also one of social justice. Illegal employment, or what is called "sort arbejde" in Danish or Schwarzarbeit in German if want a compounded word, allows builders en masse to make a decent wage and is widespread, in Denmark at least.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 3y agoA lot of this is already done (incl. IRS in the US) and you don't need "AI" for it, though it is the current buzzword I'll abstain from discussing the legal and societal aspects of such tighter enforcement though I might say every enforcement needs some kind of "wiggle room"
- kfrzcode 3y agoMmmmm strict bureaucracy....
- hkt 3y agoWorking class and even middle class people in France (and most of the world) definitely don't have swimming pools. No doubt you're right about the general case, though.
- dmw_ng 3y agoCost to build the system conspicuously absent This project https://www.gas.scigrid.de/ https://www.gas.scigrid.de/ used a similar approach to map gas pipelines
- seydor 3y agoI m not sure if the idea of going after pools is a good one though. Is the water shortages really that big that people are not allowed to even have blow-up tubs anymore? Pools are good for cooling down in the summer. Is it better if they use electricity and A/C instead? The worst thing is that other countries are copying this anti-pool thing because it's populist .
- TheFattestNinja 3y agoWater restrictions were common last summer over europe. True last year was particularly torrid and following a very dry winter. But this year seems likely to follow.
- ohgodplsno 3y agoBlow up tubs are not targeted by this, because they're not taxable. Pools only get taxed if they're dug in the ground (fully or partly), and are more than 10 square meters. It's not even going after pools in particular, it's just that pools raise the property tax. you're supposed to ask your city if you can build that pool, and your taxes will grow in consequence. Undeclared, no taxes. And yes, filling up pools is banned in most of the country right now because we're going through a year long drought.
- jylam 3y ago> Is the water shortages really that big that people are not allowed to even have blow-up tubs anymore? Yep > Pools are good for cooling down in the summer. Is it better if they use electricity and A/C instead? There is not much A/C in France/Europe. Go to a lake or a public pool instead, no need for A/C. > The worst thing is that other countries are copying this anti-pool thing because it's populist . It is necessary. Not populist, necessary. We can't afford to just scream "freedom" or "populism" every time the upper middle-class wants to enjoy an environment-destroying luxury. Think of the freedom to live of the others. Is a pool necessary ? Of fsking course not. Don't try to color this as a basic need. You don't need a pool to cool down in the summer. You also don't need a 2 tons car, you don't need to travel to the other side of the world for your holidays, and those things are very detrimental to everyone, you included.
- wouldbecouldbe 3y agoIn Amsterdam they've been using drones for this kind of things. An office of a client in worked in build a small wooden extension on the roof without requesting a permit (because that's so easy) A drone detected it and they had to break it down, not sure if they were also fined. France is a bit more spread out :)
- siva7 3y agoI'd rather become homeless than doing such shitty work.
- Symbiote 3y agoThe purpose and laws are clear, easily understood by all French citizens, and everyone knows whether they have skirted the tax or not. The tax law can be changed if enough people think it wrong. Working for Facebook or Google or Amazon is less ethical, in my view.
- prepend 3y agoI mean there are also anti-immigration laws in the US. Id rather not write the code that finds and deports families. I agree that working in adtech is more of a bummer though.
- hurril 3y agoSocial media is weird when it comes to taxation. Are you for taxes or not? Is it the poor that are buying these un-taxed pools?
- SanderNL 3y agoIt’s interesting they have time for this, but going after the big fish is too much. In the Netherlands we lack the capacity to go after tax evasion using non profits. Untold millions go to waste every year, but they have enough capacity to go after small fish and their “fraud”. (https://nl.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toeslagenaffaire https://nl.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toeslagenaffaire, this is a big one where thousands of families were sent into 30k-150k debt for a “mistake”. People’s children were taken from their families because this pushed them over the edge. I know this case is complex but it’s not hard to see who is at fault.) Tax evasion by the big fish is well known and clearly not in the spirit if the law: https://nos.nl/artikel/2440715-vermogenden-gebruiken-eigen-goede-doelen-als-belastingconstructie https://nos.nl/artikel/2440715-vermogenden-gebruiken-eigen-g... They set up non profits and get rid of their taxable assets. This is well known, in my opinion not hard to get into court, but nobody “cares”. Of course we all know what is holding them back. Color me unimpressed by fining some middle class people out of their pools.
- spoiler 3y agoProbably because most of the big fish are in politics or govt organisations, so they don't want to go after their own.
- doctor_eval 3y ago"Conservatism consists of exactly one proposition, to wit: There must be in-groups whom the law protects but does not bind, alongside out-groups whom the law binds but does not protect."
- arp242 3y agoAlso: how much did this system cost to build? There's a real chance it was more than the €10 million it brought up in revenue thus far, and total revenue is expected to be "up to €40 million" once it's rolled out nation-wide. Even without taking in to account the costs, €40 million is basically nothing considering total taxation revenue is in the hundreds of billions. At some point "fighting fraud" just becomes a cost-ineffective jihad rather than something meaningful.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoThe only interesting thing here is how this rule was simply not being enforced by anyone. Happens a lot with tax rules in many countries. Having rules is one thing, doing the leg work to enforce them is another thing. And tax systems tend to be extremely complicated. Of course, tax auditors could just open any popular online map for a particular area, look at satellite view and do a quick count and then look up the addresses for that area. Diff that with the list of properties that do pay their taxes and job done, Tedious work and AI speeds that up. But it's not hard and the revenue is probably worth it. Also, from an AI point of view pool detection this isn't exactly rocket science. And of course, a lot of these pools are actually mapped in open street map. I just checked this in a random part of France: 43.99847,4.92940 and compared with the satellite view in Google Maps. Lots of nice little pools that look like they are correctly mapped. An enterprising tax auditor might just export a list with a simple overpass query and them geocode them with nominatim to get the address.
- gniv 3y ago> The only interesting thing here is how this rule was simply not being enforced by anyone. Turns out that not even the notary, whose job is to check these things when a property changes hands, does it. I am in a local Facebook group and there are multiple folks saying they got a bill from the tax office for an undeclared pool. They bought the house recently and thought that everything was fine and now surprise. Even worse, some of them don't even have permits, so on top of the extra taxes they have to go through the town permitting process from scratch. It seems that the program mentioned in the article, which is from 2022, has now expanded nationwide. Would be nice if the French govt would publish some stats once they are done with it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- olivierduval 3y agoA big part of the "AI" trend is - be affraid of a big general AI that will destroy humanity like ChatGPT - recognize pools in garden from sat images Actually, if the title was only "French Tax service find 20k hidden taxable swimming pools in France, netting €10M", nobody would care... and it would be fair!!! There is no "Intelligence" in this...
- activiation 3y agoHow were they hidden?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- olivierduval 3y agoMost are in the garden in the back of the house... so hidden from the street but not really physically hidden. And house owner didn't declare that they build one (so hidden to the French Tax Service)
- zerr 3y agoThe reason they say is that it increases the property rent value. The pool tax seems odd/unfair, because the rent is already taxable and water bill is paid.
- zvr 3y ago"(2022)"
- Gys 3y ago> A typical pool of 30 sq metres would be taxed at about an extra €200 a year. I assume the average pool is less than 30 m2. I wonder how much effort people actually made to 'hide' their pool for not having to pay such rather small amount compared to pool building and maintenance. Plus there is the effort of building and maintaining this 'AI' system.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Solvency 3y agoImagine an AI that instead finds potential infrastructure problems riddled across the country. Buildings, bridges, roads, you name it. Then the AI priorities them into a queue and generates cost/resource estimates for repairs. Thereby helping the government improve the livelihood of its constituents! Or wait, imagine if the AI were finding all the rivers and lakes that corporations are dumping trash, chemicals, and other waste products into! Right? Right? Surely they'd do that with this great technology!
- hkt 3y agoThese are all things the state used to do without AI - people did it perfectly well. Regrettably it isn't a matter of technology that prevents this sort of thing. It is the hollowing out of the public sphere, the shrinking of state workforces, and the diminishing horizons of what is considered to be 'feasible' - where feasibility is often determined by consultants.
- zulban 3y agoWho is this "they" you're talking about? Lots of people and lots of groups are trying to use AI in different ways. So yes, obviously people are looking into that too. You seem cynical.
- alecco 3y agoNot OP, but let me try: career bureaucrats and democratically elected officials.
- motohagiography 3y agoI've said for years the main use case for AI is to dilute and launder accountability so that decisions can be seen as the expression of corporate entities and committees where no individual can be held responsible or accountable. AI is to bureaucracy what cryptocurrency is money laundering. Over a decade ago I was hired to do a privacy impact assessment for a government project that was going to "use AI to detect benefits fraud." Turned out under the architecture docs, the "AI" was a data repository managed by one of the big credit reporting companies, and their "AI" would flag back individuals to the govt benefits agency for further scrutiny. The company got to keep the data, there was no anonymization or de-identification, let alone any consideration of how the company would use the data after, or for re-linking the data to other data sets to make credit decisions about household members and other relations. The fact that the government was outsourcing their fraud detection to the very credit reporting and collection agencies who would be exploiting the data for credit decisions was also what nobody was supposed to say out loud or write down. The point is, so-called AI in this case was used as a proxy to hide a relationship between the government and a private company and as a way to absolve either of any accountability for marking someone as a suspect for benefits fraud. The govt didn't have to make or document a regulation mandating them to do fishing expeditions, or create a paper trail on how random their selection of someone was for scrutiny, nor did they have to disclose that their AI system was just the sleazy credit reporting company pretending to be an "AI." The problem with proxying decisions through so-called AI is that the bureaucracy only exists by its direct mandates, and the people in it are always trying to get around the constraints that imposes, so in these cases, AI is just a false-pretext generation machine. That any agency can act using "randomness," in any situation at all is a level of discretion that is very likely to be inconsistent with their actual mandates, imo.
- samstave 3y agoLook at these idiots using AI to find Tax Cheats, they should do like the USA IRS, and hire 80,000 new agents, arm them and get them to sign a document statingthey are willing to use deadly force (yes this actually happened here in the US this year)... -- Whats baffeling - is that the SEC should be all over this methodology - in fact - I am sure that there a re people out there right now building an AI to riffle through the Panama Papers and other "papers" scandals looking at shell companies for a way to blackmail those who are storing wealth in such. Or using ai to find chinks-in-the-armor for ways to exploit said shell companies and their 'anonymous' owners... I presonally used ChatGPT as well as AutoGPT to dive into Opensecrets.org and other online resources to look into the finances of congress - what their tenure is, age, salary, investments, committees served on and then major defense inititives, and the investments of congress into those contractors. What I am trying to do is build a table of acts/laws passed which benefitted defense contractors, and then the stated investments by congress just prior to said defense deals which should reveal insider trading pretty definitively...
- karaterobot 3y agoThe world depends on all the dumb little rules someone put in place for dumb little reasons not being adequately enforced. Imagine automatically getting a speeding ticket every single time you went over the speed limit by one mile an hour. Take a moment and mentally inventory all the code violations in your house right now. Look hard enough and everybody is breaking the rules every day, but we muddle through because it doesn't matter 99% of the time. If all these rules were actually enforced — let's even assume impartially and perfectly — we would be overwhelmed by them. Maybe the consequence would be that we would refine some of the dumb little rules, and remove others. But maybe we would just be overwhelmed.
- meling 3y agoIt wasn’t so clear from the article, but I assume they’re using images from Google. Don’t France have water usage meters? Seems like the main reason for taxation is to save water, and taxing actual water use seems more reasonable.
- pastage 3y agoFrance most probably have their own imaging as is the case with many countries; NOAA in the US, OS in GB etc.
- gumballindie 3y agoSuppose if the title was “use machine vision” it would have been boring?
- rurban 3y agoI programmed such a tool for my local city back in the nineties from 3d stereo overflies, exactly to detect undeclared extensions, verandas, garden houses and such. It just wasn't called AI then, just image detection and 3d reconstruction.