16 ms·
Visual Studio '11' Announced
- ConstantineXVI 15y agoSince they're making such a big deal on the new styling; would anyone know the rationale they had for making VS2010 purple?
- bitwize 15y agoGray got boring.
- Derbasti 15y agoGray is the new Purple
- mattgreenrocks 15y agoI believe VS was always coupled to the Office look and feel...at least up until now. Frankly, I'm impressed. The constantly shifting Office look and feel seems motivated by the desire to create artificial distinctions between versions of a product that peaked in 2000, or earlier.
- brosephius 15y agoMaybe it's just me but I like the "Strong use of color" better. I find it hard to quickly find the tool button I want when they're all monochrome. I'm sure I'd get used to it, but I can't really say the colors in the GUI are my primary distraction when I'm coding...
- ax 15y agoQuote from the article: In VS 11 we have transitioned to glyph style iconography throughout the product. While we understand that opinions on this new style of iconography may vary, an icon recognition study conducted with 76 participants, 40 existing and 36 new VS users, showed no negative effect in icon recognition rates for either group due to the glyph style transition. In the case of the new VS users they were able to successfully identify the new VS 11 icons faster than the VS 2010 icons (i.e., given a command, users were faster at pointing to the icon representing that command). In this and subsequent studies more developers have expressed a preference for the glyph style icons over the former style, especially after having spent time getting used to the new glyph style icons.
- WayneDB 15y agoThat's great, except the test is not taking into account my personal preference. I don't use the icons very much to do things - I mostly use keyboard shortcuts. Now, I'm going to be stuck looking at that garbage all day. Furthermore...76 participants? That doesn't prove anything.
- Too 15y agoIf you know all the relevant keyboard shorcuts you can just hide the toolbars :)
- WayneDB 15y agoI like the toolbars though. I guess what I like and what I want didn't test well though...with that enormous sample size.
- bentlegen 15y agoNeither does your singular data point.
- WayneDB 15y agoHow about 200+ comments on the actual article mirroring my exact sentiment?
- ajross 15y agoSome of us grognards would argue that if you're having trouble finding buttons, they really shouldn't be on the screen at all. Seriously, why must IDEs look like this? Why is there screen space dedicated to documentation when I'm not reading docs? Why are there multiple horizontal bars at both the top and bottom of the full-screen display when the single most important activity in the app is scanning very long text files often dozens of times "higher" than the screen. Seriously, every line of text is precious, why must we steal them from the editor with a title bar and a menu bar and a tool bar (thankfully they now have only one toolbar) and a tab bar and a status bar. Why does anyone think this is a good design?
- dkersten 15y agowhy must IDEs look like this? Qt Creator is currently my favourite IDE to develop C++ in (even if it does not use Qt) and it doesn't look like this.
- ajross 15y agoI've used Qt Creator only once or twice, but my memory (and the handful of screenshots I see on google image search) is that it's pretty much the same. An editor rectangle embedded in a bunch of other crap with way too much vertical space above and below it dedicated to things that aren't very important. For reference, my emacs window has the gnome 3 panel and the window manager title bar as waste and that's it. And for years I ran a custom metacity theme which turned off the title bars entirely (haven't managed to port that to gnome shell yet).
- mkl 15y agoI think your recollection/search is incorrect. Qt Creator has a menu bar, navigation bar, and output selector etc. bar, all the height of a single line of text. There are no toolbars at all - none that can even be turned on. Much of the status and control interface is in a vertical bar on the left.
- dkersten 15y agoA typical session looks like this [1]. With the documentation window open, it looks like this [2]. The GUI designer looks like this [3] (there's also a second "designer" for Qt Quick). The debugger looks like this [4]. With the compile log/error log/search results window open, it looks like this [5]. About 80% of the time, when I use Qt Creator, especially if I'm not developing a GUI application (in which case I also use the designer), my screen looks like [1]. On the other hand, to my eyes at least, most other IDE's look something like this [6], [7] or very very extreme cases [8]. That is, they lose a lot of vertical space to tool bars. When I'm developing on Linux and I'm not developing a Qt GUI application in C++, I use a mixture of text-mode vim, geany and gedit in a tiling window manager (that is, the "dock windows" in most IDEs are windows that I have tiled, or vim panels) with no window borders or decorations whatsoever [9]. [1] http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/4d/QtCreator-Linux-2.0.1.png http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/4d/QtCreator... [2] http://www.developer.nokia.com/Resources/Library/Porting_to_Qt/Porting%20WP%20to%20Qt/Screenshot-qtcreator-overview.png http://www.developer.nokia.com/Resources/Library/Porting_to_... [3] http://linux.leunen.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/qtcreator_designer.png http://linux.leunen.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/qtcreator... [4] http://lists.qt.nokia.com/pipermail/qt-creator/attachments/20090903/70c85ec2/attachment.png http://lists.qt.nokia.com/pipermail/qt-creator/attachments/2... [5] http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-teVIBJ45OEU/Twbi9_wQd_I/AAAAAAAAAYQ/eixJ2YLG-Pk/s1600/snapshot12.png http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-teVIBJ45OEU/Twbi9_wQd_I/AAAAAAAAAY... [6] http://www.eclipse.org/screenshots/images/SDK-RedFlag_Linux.png http://www.eclipse.org/screenshots/images/SDK-RedFlag_Linux.... [7] http://www.hanselman.com/blog/content/binary/WindowsLiveWriter/MultithreadedDebugginginVisualStudio2008_E599/Listing23-04_app%20(Debugging)%20-%20Microsoft%20Visual%20Studio%20(Administrator)%20(5).png http://www.hanselman.com/blog/content/binary/WindowsLiveWrit... [8] http://swtswing.sourceforge.net/screenshots/images/EclipseMetalL&F.png http://swtswing.sourceforge.net/screenshots/images/EclipseMe... [9] Not my screenshot, but similar: http://static.milkbox.net/ss/ss-2009-05-06.png http://static.milkbox.net/ss/ss-2009-05-06.png
- km3k 15y agoIt looks like a monochrome Visual Studio 6. I don't really see how this is an improvement.
- bitwize 15y agoI came shockingly close to projectile vomiting when I read the header "The New Developer Experience". My experience of developing is quite similar regardless of the tools I use. And I've been developing for years on a variety of toolkits including VS. A slick mobile UI styled facelift on their signature overweight IDE isn't going to radically change the developer's experience. (Also, who else looked at Metro and ICS's love affair with abstract geometric single-color icons and thought "OLPC"?)
- Spearchucker 15y agoI've been using Metro on a Samsung Series 7 Slate as my main PC/laptop/tablet for a couple of months now and don't quite see OLPC in there. But then, I've not used XO. FWIW I love Metro. The little UI touches like changing the volume or brightness make Windows 7 feel somehow... inadequate. As for VS - yup, 2010 was slow. I actually went back to 2008 because even the Express editions were too slow on my little Vaio P-Series.
- rkwz 15y ago>The little UI touches like changing the volume or brightness make Windows 7 feel somehow... inadequate. Can you elaborate on that?
- Spearchucker 15y agoWhen you swipe in from the right side of the screen (in both Metro and from the desktop) you get the search, share, start, devices and settings icons. Touch settings, and you get WiFi, volume, brightness, notifications, power and language icons, from which you can make changes without closing the current window/app or having to open a new one. Doing all of that in Windows 7 meant going to a whole herd of different places to do that sort of stuff. Metro is just so much easier than moving down to the system tray with a mouse, or having to right-click the desktop, or having to go to the start menu.
- rkwz 15y ago
- jamesaguilar 15y agoI like the new decolorized look. The colors don't seem to add much and are a bit noisy.
- MartinCron 15y agoI didn't think the old colors were noisy, but now when I open up VS2010, it's like a clown car in there.
- andypants 15y agoColours help to differentiate between icons. It's much easier to differentiate between and identify two differently coloured icons at a glance, than two monochrome icons.
- jamesaguilar 15y agoTo me it looks like they've put more effort into differentiating the shapes now that the icons aren't colored. Personally I think the increased contrast makes up for it -- the shapes in the monochrome icons are much more visible to me. I'd love to see their usability studies though. Perhaps you are right.
- barista 15y agoThe blog is by UX designer guy. So obviously he's focusing on the UI changes. Hope there are more substantial changes in this release other than just a change in color scheme and iconography.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- baconner 15y agoSomeone over there has clearly been reading tufte although I think in some cases (the new all gray icons) they've gone overboard. Overall the strategy of moving the interface into the background and the content you're building into the foreground is great. I want my eyes drawn to what I'm building not 50 other ui elements. The metro style icons IMO are a bit hard to distinguish from eachother but anything I used regularly I'd have a keyboard shortcut for anyway and the new command search handles the rest. I think they're on the right track.They're minimizing any mental activity that's taking focus away from actually coding and that's a good thing.
- thom 15y agoFor those annoyed that this just focuses on colours, here's some C++ features of VS2011: http://herbsutter.com/2012/02/23/vc11-beta-on-feb-29 http://herbsutter.com/2012/02/23/vc11-beta-on-feb-29
- CedarMadness 15y agoAll that C++ support and they still don't support C99...
- SamReidHughes 15y agoAnything to avoid tgmath.h.
- cygx 15y agoC11 added generic selections - tgmath.h is no longer magical...
- lambda 15y agoThey have explicitly stated that they have no interest in supporting C99, because they don't believe their users are asking for it, or their users would rather have new C++ features than new C features.
- xpaulbettsx 15y agoA lot of the C99 features like array initialization got sucked into C++11, and since the C "compiler" in MSVC is the C++ compiler, I think you'll probably get most of C99 for free.
- cygx 15y agoIf only that were true - however, some of the more interesting C99 and C11 features aren't part of C++11 as there are already C++ specific alternatives. Also, MS doesn't really have a good track record of backporting C++ features to C (mixing code and declarations, anyone?). If you want to write portable C code that works on at least *nix and Windows, either ignore MSVC (GCC works just fine on Windows via MinGW or Cygwin cross-compiler, as does Clang once you get it set up), or restrict yourself to the common subset of C99 and C++98...
- bwarp 15y agoSure it looks all pretty, but have they made it faster and more reliable? VS2010 is just damn slow and falls over on me at least 2-3 times a day which is not acceptable. When you pay for 25 VS2010 premium licenses with MSDN on top of your gold partner allowance, you expect it to work.
- MartinCron 15y agoVS2010 is just damn slow and falls over on me at least 2-3 times a day which is not acceptable. Non-aggressive suggestion: think you've got something screwy with your system, I've had VS Fall over on my 2-3 times in the last several years of heavy use. It doesn't have to be that unstable. Also, with an SSD and enough RAM, I don't feel like I'm ever waiting on VS anymore.
- elemeno 15y agoI'd second that. In the past five years (or at least since VS 2008), I can remember VS crashing on me maybe half a dozen times. That's with spending most of my time working on pretty large multi language projects. For context, I don't use any extensions other than (sometimes) ReSharper and Tortoise svn/git/hg.
- brunomlopes 15y agoMine doesn't crash on Web projects, but can't work for a couple of hours on a Windows Phone 7 project without it going boom. I think most of it works fine and dandy, but some parts can be quite sensitive.
- MartinCron 15y agoFair enough, I haven't worked on any Windows Phone 7 stuff yet, so it may be fatally brittle there.
- bwarp 15y agoI've dumped all extensions - I had R# and VisualSVN. The solution does have about 80,000 files though.
- pkamb 15y agoDo new tabs still open to the left of the current tab? Drives me absolutely insane.
- kprobst 15y agoTools -> Options -> Documents Check "Insert documents to the right of existing tabs".
- pkamb 15y agoBut why is it the default? Why not match the existing tab behavior of every web browser?
- kprobst 15y agoActually both IE and Firefox now (I think) insert tabs to the left. I don't know why it became a 'thing' at some point, I dislike it enormously as well.
- joshuacc 15y agoI just tested this, and both IE9 and FF10 insert new tabs to the right in Windows 7.
- recoiledsnake 15y agoI like it that way. It allows me to think of the tabs like a stack. In any case, you can easily change the default, it's not like you use a new machine every week that needs to be configured again.
- michael_miller 15y agoIt's interesting that Microsoft chose to adopt monochrome icons after Mac OS X / iTunes adopted monochrome icons. I'd be curious if Apple's design was a major influence on Microsoft's designers, or if the idea for monochrome icons came primarily from independent research/user testing.
- TorbjornLunde 15y agoI find it much more likely that it is an result of Microsoft’s Metro design language. It’s something that is happening across many of their products. Apple might still me a influence, but I don’t think it’s minor.
- georgemcbay 15y agoThis looks more like an extension of the UI style they started adopting with the Expression tools back in 2008, which itself was more directly influenced by Adobe tools like Photoshop Elements and Lightroom than iTunes or Mac OS. If you really want to tie Apple into it, then the anchor would be Aperture (which obviously influenced Adobe), not really iTunes or recent releases of Mac OS.
- sixothree 15y agoA la iTunes 9 -> 10.
- contextfree 15y agoFWIW, I first noticed the "use monochrome icons to reduce distraction" approach in Windows 7, when it was applied to the default system tray icons. I think that predates the Apple trend (but I don't follow Apple closely enough to know). I suspect these kinds of things tend to just be general "design" trends though - I bet the people designing these interfaces probably talk to each other, subscribe to the same magazines, read the same articles, follow the same non-software industrial designers and artists etc.
- darrenkopp 15y agoAll of this came from Expression Blend and Metro
- DanI-S 15y agoI don't know the when we arrived in this new world, where thoughtful design is king, but I am glad to be here.
- blackhole 15y agoI'm sorry, but I use color to locate things. This, to me, is a disaster. If this isn't a problem for other people, fine, but it's a problem to me. A better solution would have been to use less color and desaturated tones rather than simply going to full on black and white, which serves only to rob the IDE of potential visual cues. This is like using a cannon to kill a bird. Just because they overcolorized VS2010 for no apparent reason doesn't mean they need to overcompensate in the opposite direction. I can't use this until someone comes up with color-based icons for it.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- WayneDB 15y agoSo...you're wrong on most accounts. VS 2010 is plenty fast and plenty of people build plenty of cross platform apps and web apps using Visual Studio. Honestly, I think you should really just consider checking your attitude and your politics at the door because hating Microsoft and all that "ghastly" proprietary software is just so passe. It's boring and nobody cares that you think proprietary software is evil.
- AutoCorrect 15y agofast is a relative term. If we're talking about VS 2010, then it's fast versus building an IDE with ed on your own. Honestly, I think you should really just consider checking your attitude and your politics at the door because loving Microsoft and all that proprietary software is just so old-school. It's boring and nobody cares that you think free software is evil.
- WayneDB 15y agoRight, except nothing that I said conveyed any sort of gushing "love" for Microsoft or proprietary versus any other software. Listing "it's proprietary" immediately before "it's slow" OTOH? Yeah, it's pretty telling where that comment is coming from. If you don't like it, why come out of your way to make a negative comment about it unless you're just being a hater?
- oleganza 15y agoInteresting thing about VS and Xcode is that they do not really try to compete with somebody or fight for attention. Both Windows and Mac/iOS developers would use less useful tools if they still let them make products for the popular platforms. JetBrains, Borland and others are fighting for attention and developers' love. They must try really-really hard to make people choose an alternative to the official tools. So both MS and Apple teams may focus on what is "right" and avoid feature bloat in UI, avoid quick and dirty solutions etc. Yes, they must include some features quickly and efficiently to allow support for some new APIs in the new products. But the overall design and fit and finish is free to define however they want. They can spend time making it right and redoing it how they please. They have resources and expertise for that and they don't need be in a stressing "competition" mood. I'm really disappointed by what Microsoft did with Visual Studio. They have great technology - great language, great compiler support and integration with editors. But the way it is all presented and organized is all boring mess of panels and tons of icons. They even understand all the icons are heavy for eyes, but instead of rethinking the design, they simply ask "40 existing and 36 new VS users" how do they like monochrome versions. Apple's Xcode 3 was also a messy window/panel cluttered tool like many others. Many still considered it lighter than any other complex IDE, but it was fairly cluttered on its own. Next version, Xcode 4 was not designed by "asking developers". Developers want a pink pony and all the features in one click. Xcode 4 was designed. They made priorities and straightened UI so much it is now Plain Straight. One window, three panes, 7 buttons on toolbar. Just by learning a single screenshot with both sidebars opened, you already know how to navigate 80% of the time. It is crucial. You don't have to read huge manual to learn more and more useful things. They all are discoverable over time. Most important things are more visible, others are discovered over time. Apple and Microsoft are rarely in position to throw old stuff out and replace it with brand new in their actual products that make money. Windows, Mac, iOS all have its legacy which must be dealt with. But UI for developer tools are different and Microsoft has no excuse not to make it interesting. Unless, of course, they don't want to maintain their own engineering culture.
- oleganza 15y agoExample of throwing away old cruft: Xcode 4 did not (and I guess still does not) support Interface Builder plugins. Meaning, you have to add third-party UI components in code rather than with mouse in a visual editor. But integrating IB into the rest of workflow was decided to be more important. Now, I'm not arguing it was right decision. My point is that both Apple and MS can afford making such decisions without effect on profits. If JetBrains throws away a feature, their sales drop. How much less Macs, Xboxes or Windows copies would have been sold if some convenience features were removed from or drastically changed in a developer tool?
- Too 15y agoThe quick launch feature alone is reason enough to upgrade. Every program should have this!
- bruceboughton 15y agoOn the Mac, they do: Command+Shift+?
- dav-id 15y agoIt looks like they are implementing the functionality from a lot of the plugins available for VS2010 and making them standard functionality. My biggest issue with VS2010 is the amount of memory it consumes. I hope they do something about that or some how let me disable functionality that I don’t need so I can reduce the footprint. Some of the icons in the screenshots do in my mind look to be an improvement whilst others are so totally different that I am sure will frustrate the hell out of me until I have adjusted. I know those screenshots are to show off as many widgets as possible but is it useful to show the tool with about 10% screen real estate dedicated to actual code.
- recoiledsnake 15y ago>My biggest issue with VS2010 is the amount of memory it consumes RAM is so cheap now that there is really no excuse for developers to skimp on it. I would rather hope that they work on improving the product in other areas than optimize it for 1GB. If there are leaks however, they need to be addressed.
- to3m 15y agoVS2010 is still a 32-bit app. This puts a limit on just how much RAM it can use. I for one might be a little less alarmed by (though probably no more happy about) its carefree attitude if it were a 64-bit app.
- kazing 15y agoI have not heard of a single VS instance taking over 4GB of RAM. The only time you'll get into trouble is with multiple VS instances - and there 40 bucks for another 4GB of RAM pay off instantly.
- silon3 15y agoI regularly get problems when reaching ~2GB ram on Windows Server 2008 32 bit (in vmware).
- 15y ago
- manuscreationis 15y agoThese are some nice concepts, but this is entirely overbaked (in my opinion). I don't find the colors of VS2k10 "distracting" me or making it "difficult" to find things at all. I am glad, however, they're removing a bunch of those useless buttons by default (of course you can always remove them yourself, but I digress). I can appreciate what they're attempting here, but why go this far without a road back? If you're going to completely overhaul the look and feel this much, and go so far as to let people choose between 2 different color schemes, why not at least give people the option of using the classic scheme, or allow for custom user developed schemes (which would invariably give rise to a few "classic" ones anyways). Maybe they mentioned this and I missed it... I hope thats the case. I've always felt the U/I got better with each iteration since the original VS, but this is the first time I'm not excited to get my hands on the next version based solely on the look and feel. Of course, I'll have to reserve final judgement for when I actually get my hands on it.
- lordlicorice 15y agoYou can already set (and share) color schemes for what really matters- the code editor. As long as I get to keep my editor colors, I'm sure it will be no big deal to get used to any changes to the chrome.
- manuscreationis 15y agoYea, but that's not really what I'm talking about. I mean purely the shell of the U/I - Although it would be good if both of those things were configurable in the same way, so you could truly share a completely customized and tuned color scheme
- tlianza 15y ago100% agree. If this is what they spent time on, as opposed to the fact that, say, 'find' is dog-slow and doesn't reliably cancel, or that copy/paste randomly stops working, or that it has a tendency to hang several times a day... well, I just don't understand the priorities.
- contextfree 15y ago
- AshleysBrain 15y agoDevelopers beware: Visual C++ 11 cannot compile executables that work on Windows XP at all: https://connect.microsoft.com/VisualStudio/feedback/details/690617/bug-apps-created-with-crt-and-mfc-vnext-11-cannot-be-used-on-windows-xp-sp3 https://connect.microsoft.com/VisualStudio/feedback/details/... C++ devs may want to skip this release and just go for Visual C++ 12 when it's out, since by then hopefully XP will be ignorable.
- RandallBrown 15y agoI'm afraid XP won't be ignorable for another 3 or 4 years at least.
- AshleysBrain 15y agoAccording to: http://gs.statcounter.com/#os-ww-monthly-201101-201201 http://gs.statcounter.com/#os-ww-monthly-201101-201201 XP dropped 14% in the last year, and is now on 34%. So a really dumb calculation says about 2 and a half years if that keeps up, but I guess there will be a longer tail of die-hard users... hard to tell, since it's pretty unprecedented for a particular version of a major OS to be so popular for so long.
- marshray 15y agoSo I guess in 2 or 3 years not supporting XP will only cost you 50 to 100 million potential users.
- dmethvin 15y agoMicrosoft stops providing XP security patches in April 2014. Any organization that wants to use XP after that will need to pay Microsoft to maintain support. Any organization that continues to use XP without support is irresponsible.
- yuhong 15y agoYea, it is called a Custom Support agreement. Costs $50,000 per quarter for first year and increases every year, BTW.
- nxn 15y agoBy removing all the borders/bars, and other useful grouping elements, they've made the application feel cluttered -- too many unrelated things share the same z-index. For example, the pinned panel titles, side panel buttons, inactive tabs, and toolbars are all on the same background. Considering how unrelated these things are in comparison to each other, I don't think they should share this same "zone". I'm not saying a design like that can't be done, but the only way I can think of making it work would involve much better use of the grid system and much better spacing than what they have in these pictures. Considering how limited they are for space though, I think they were just better off with the 2010 look.
- yarone 15y agoStill using a floppy disk to represent "save". Wondering when will this end...
- huhtenberg 15y agoBut what would you replace it with that is equally easy to recognize?
- cjensen 15y agoDoes anyone really use "save" so infrequently that they have not memorized the keyboard shortcut? There's a reason no apps on OS X have save icons...
- flomo 15y agoThey mentioned they dumped the clipboard buttons because nobody uses them. I would guess the need with Visual Studio isn't so much "Save" but "Save All", which also updates various project files. (I don't know the Save All shortcut off the top of my head - I almost always use the toolbar button.)
- lywald 15y agoSaveAll is Ctrl-Shift-S on most programs.
- marshray 15y agoHow about a picture of the inside of a magnetic media hard drive, complete with platters and heads. Or maybe just an icon of a bare 3.5" drive unit. http://www.ubuntu.com/tour/img/librewriter.jpg http://www.ubuntu.com/tour/img/librewriter.jpg Everyone should be able to relate to that, right? :-)
- riffic 15y agoan appropriate metaphor that represents checking your code in to your favored version control repository.
- huhtenberg 15y agoI might be an old fart (close to 20 years of Windows programming), but all I see is bloat. A compiler, a linker, a debugger. An editor with syntax highlighting, Ctrl-F and Ctrl-H. That's it, this is pretty much all that I ever use in VS. Even plausibly useful features like Intellisense and IDE macros end up being more of a hindrance than a help. What am I missing? What is there in the remaining 80% of VS that I am not using that is of practical value? Serious question.
- fryguy 15y agoGo to definition, Find all references, and variable rename are far superior to ctrl-f and ctrl-h because they operate on symbols rather than strings. When you highlight a variable and ctrl-f for it, you're going to find the 30 times the function is used (if it's even in the same file), whereas hitting f12 takes you right to the definition of it. Symbol renaming is much safer, since you don't have to worry about renaming "i" to "itemIndex" when a loop gets more complicated, and having misc things blow up in your face. Intellisense is really great when you're not entirely sure what order parameters go in, since it shows you what's important as you're typing. I've found them extremely valuable when working on large projects with multiple team members, since a lot of the times I won't have worked on the functions I'm calling to know them intimately.
- huhtenberg 15y agoThanks.
- bjg 15y agoVS Tips and tricks blog: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/zainnab/ http://blogs.msdn.com/b/zainnab/ Tips and Tricks session from two VS project managers at the Build conference: http://channel9.msdn.com/events/BUILD/BUILD2011/TOOL-830T http://channel9.msdn.com/events/BUILD/BUILD2011/TOOL-830T There are some pretty cool things in there. In my mind it's the same thing with vim/emacs. You only use what you know, it's not that the other pieces aren't useful.
- sixothree 15y agoBloat is the one thing the monochrome color scheme emphasizes the most.
- test83562 15y agoI still use VS 2008 on WinXP. VS 2010 is much slower because it's based on WPF. I hate having to wait 0.1-2 seconds for text editor to respond. Also VS 2010 IDE feels non-native.
- MartinCron 15y agoReading this article and the comments made me realize that I never ever use the toolbar buttons and I only sometimes use the menu. For all of the main things (build/debug/run, cut/copy/paste, save, close window, etc.) I either use the Visual Studio or ReSharper keyboard shortcuts. So I've turned the toolbars off and now have a few hundred more vertical pixels to work with. Nice.
- bjg 15y agoFYI if you want to get ride of the menu you can also have it hide. http://visualstudiogallery.msdn.microsoft.com/bdbcffca-32a6-4034-8e89-c31b86ad4813 http://visualstudiogallery.msdn.microsoft.com/bdbcffca-32a6-... It's nice, especially in full screen mode.
- dubya 15y agoI think it is hilarious that the 3.5" floppy disk is still an icon. What does a pair of them would mean? Copy disk? Commands you use every time you use a program don't really need an icon. Is there any overlap between the set of people who recognize the disk icon and the set of people who click in a toolbar to save a file?
- pilif 15y agoTangentially related: even in the redesign they manage to represent the save action using a floppy disk of all things. I wonder whether that is ever going to change as people forget what floppys were or whether this will just be the canonical icon for save even far into the future when nobody will really know that the icon does indeed have its roots in a long forgotten real-world object.
- sharjeel 15y agoI'm perfectly OK with it. Floppy has become the standard icon for "save" action. People have learnt it while using different applications and have got used to it. Changing it would need more learning and cognitive efforts by users.
- Shorel 15y agoWhat other icon do you propose? (hint: this is much harder than it looks) (hint 2: ask Susan Kare about it)
- georgieporgie 15y agoI like the new style. It makes me nostalgic for NeXT and AmigaOS 2.0 UI. I just hope it crashes less and is faster than VS2010. Also, it looks like yet another release that neglects C++ users.
- rbanffy 15y agoI'd gladly exchange color for more pixels most of the time.
- Maro 15y agoVisually, it almost looks like a step back.
- eblackburn 15y agoVS seems to be going the way of Office, only the 80% of features that nobody uses are also often inferior to alternatives. The bloat associated with VS is utterly unnecessary, I think it's an opportunity missed that VS hasn't been peeled right back to a glorified Notepad++ with the VS Gallery providing the mechanism to add / remove additional features from MS and from third parties.
- rbanffy 15y agoI must admit it looks much nicer. One of the things I observer when I moved back to Emacs a couple years ago was how the tools, buttons, borders, panels were distracting and one of their design goals was to make the code the more important visual element.
- nathanscott 15y agoThis is how I know this isn't genuinely a developer tool http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3628696 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3628696
- achanlon 15y agoI would point out that line numbers are an option in VS. Secondly, I believe we are getting to a point where giant monolithic files should be the exception rather than the rule. Lastly, the ability to right click on a symbol and go directly to it's definition, see a clickable list of all its uses, and the fact that all warnings/errors are clickable means that the line numbers are less-important frankly. I still have mine on always but I rarely use them.
- callumjones 15y agoI really don't understand the use of uppercase letters to denote sections, is this the Metro influence and have they taken it a bit to far? It really looks out of place surrounded by content that is Capitalized.
- mariusmg 15y agoThey still didn't get their priorities right. Nobody care about those shitty monochrome icons. MAKE THE DAMN THING FASTER !!!!!
- oliwer 15y agoFinally a black theme! I'm sold.
- mariusmg 15y agoVS2010 has a black theme......
- Lagged2Death 15y agoSo the ribbon UI will not be used in the next generation of what is arguably MS's most technical and deadly-serious product. They're sticking with old-fashioned menus and non-paging toolbars. I think that's really telling.