6 ms·
Reddit were threatening to de-private the subs and replace the mods. When they can do, but will likely kill the community anyway for small communities. Perhaps
by pjc50 3y ago
Reddit were threatening to de-private the subs and replace the mods. When they can do, but will likely kill the community anyway for small communities. Perhaps big ones are anonymous enough for that to work.
- echelon 3y ago> Reddit were threatening to de-private the subs and replace the mods. Is there a link to this? That's crazy!
- 411111111111111 3y agoThey've done it before, shouldn't be a surprise at this point.
- iLoveOncall 3y agoWhy exactly would it be crazy? A few mods taking a community of half a billion hostages is not crazy? If I were spez I would simply disable the ability to make new subreddits private. This protest is not for the greater good, it's harming half a billion users for the benefit (actually, for no benefit since nothing will come out of it) of the 3% that want to not see ads and use the 3rd party apps.
- COGlory 3y agoYou are extremely naive if you think this stops at 3rd party apps.
- imauser 3y agoThe community (not all, I know) is supporting this.
- iLoveOncall 3y agoThe community is a massive majority of lurkers that don't comment, don't upvote and may not even have an account. It's not because a few terminally online Reddit addicts are vocally posing as the resistance that the majority of the community supports it.
- jitl 3y agoLurkers who never post are not participating in the community
- pjc50 3y ago.. but they do generate ad impressions. Everyone else is "the product", I guess.
- pixl97 3y agoI think this might be an extreme case of misunderstanding how internet communities work. Without comments, HN would be just a boring link aggregator and we'd get very little information if the article was BS or not. But because we have comments we get gems at times where 'the creator of X' discusses the merits of the article. That can be nearly priceless. Things like this draw people that don't upvote and don't comment, but they still get immense value from it. Posts are what makes Reddit, so much so that Reddit created hundreds of fraudulent profiles in their early days to fake popularity. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/06/reddit-founders-made-hundreds-of-fake-profiles-so-site-looked-popular/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2012/06/reddi... ---- Of course this interests me what the future looks like for social media. At one time in the past you needed users to generate and post content. Could we end up with social media sites with 'good enough' bots faking humans that draw in the masses, but few biological commenters and posters would exist?
- austhrow743 3y agoRunning a subreddit is an alternative to running your own forum. An alternative thats much easier to get up and running, so it's a very popular one. If Reddit does a mass replacement of mods, the illusion is broken. You're not running your own forum, you're doing free work for some website. So if you want to create a place to discuss X, then you dont think to make a subreddit for X, you go with something you actually control or far more likely just somewhere the illusion hasn't been broken; like create a discord server. That illusion is what has made Reddit basically the forum. It's the whole value of the site. Destroying the thing that makes your site valuable is crazy.
- iLoveOncall 3y agoHow many times do you get a Discord server in your Google results when searching for something? Reddit's value proposition is not the ego stroking of the 0.0000001% that are moderators, it's the discoverability and interoperability between unrelated niches. If little dictators don't get their kick from rulling lawlessly on a community anymore, I say good ridance.
- austhrow743 3y ago>How many times do you get a Discord server in your Google results when searching for something? What does this have to do with what I wrote? >the discoverability and interoperability between unrelated niches. Why are those niches on Reddit if Reddit isn't giving away faux forums? >If little dictators don't get their kick from rulling lawlessly on a community anymore, I say good ridance. Odd because I get the impression you prefer the communities those little dictators create to be on a google crawlable site over discord.
- iLoveOncall 3y ago> >How many times do you get a Discord server in your Google results when searching for something? > What does this have to do with what I wrote? You are suggesting that those users will go away from Reddit to form separate dedicated communities, and I am saying that they will try but fail to attract people. Reddit allows the vast majority of the subs that participate in the blackout to survive simply because they are a part of Reddit and benefit from its infrastructure and features. You really think a website dedicated to cute animals will attract 34M subscribers like /r/aww? And another one with the exact same theme will attract 4M subscribers (with a lot of overlap) like /r/Eyebleach? Those communities exist and strive because the barrier to entry is literally non-existent. It takes one input to create them and one click to join them. > Odd because I get the impression you prefer the communities those little dictators create to be on a google crawlable site over discord. I would prefer if there were no little dictators, with elections every 3 months, showing detailed stats of the moderators actions, and most of the moderation to be in the style of StackOverflow, so community driven.
- pjc50 3y agoThe problem is that people are (a) using the 3rd party apps for entirely genuine usability reasons beyond ads and (b) while the API users may only be a small percentage, they're the ones holding the site together. Few moderators use only Reddit official tooling. Some have built quite sophisticated tools to automate their work. /r/music mention of having their own server for some purpose: https://www.reddit.com/r/Music/comments/141tzgd/comment/jn2lclg/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3 https://www.reddit.com/r/Music/comments/141tzgd/comment/jn2l... The notorious Digg collapse was in part because of their fight with a big poster who was dominating the rankings and in the process supplying a lot of the content. They won against him, and the rest is history. Similar with Vine.
- DANmode 3y agoYou're talking about the 3%(?) that actually make the community, discussion, and value (the reason people show up in the first place, randomly or via seach).
- realusername 3y agoThey can do that but that will accelerate the titanic effect of those subs, moderation is already the weakest point of Reddit.
- archerx 3y agoMaybe it could have a good effect ironically, the problem with Reddit's moderation is the actual moderators. They mostly seem to be self righteous narcissists and have been the cancer killing reddit for the past decade. Purging them all and starting over with a clean slate could bring new life and freshness to the septic tank of a community it has become. I don't care about the reddit API but I am enjoying watching the this dumpster fire burn. Popcorn sure does taste good indeed.
- andybak 3y agoMost "bad" moderators I've encountered could easily be explained by potentially being a stressed, overworked volunteer who takes a lot of shit from assholes all the time. I think my explanation is at least as plausible as yours with the added benefit of not denigrating an entire group.
- Amezarak 3y agoIt’s a generalization, but it holds true on Internet communities in general that the most dedicated people who want and obtain mod power start out beforehand with less than ideal mental health, which is often a contributing factor as to why they have the enormous amounts of free time to moderate communities for free in the first place. Obviously there’s exceptions, but it is a really common phenomenon. They found communities or get modded simply because they spend the most time and hang out in the right chats, not because they’re objectively great neutral moderators. They are very frequently people with very strong personalities, and are often in the long-term have a more destructive influence on communities than any short-lived comment troll, especially wrt to the effect on newcomers as they tend to make communities increasingly insular.
- smolder 3y ago
- agilob 3y agoThere are subreddits where mods meet in person a few times per year. Replace that commitment.
- gpm 3y agoEasy if you pay the new ones really.
- csomar 3y agoTheir whole business model is that you have free labor to moderate the subs. They can't afford to pay for all subs and will become centralized in a few subs only.
- reilly3000 3y agoAs the front page of the Internet, I would hope someone there has enough imagination to find a way to pay the people that do the work. If not, do we really have an Internet?
- ghaff 3y agoFront page of the internet? Please. It's not that important.
- oefrha 3y agoGood. I’ve never been an active Redditor, but there are people discussing my open source software on Reddit, so I’ve answered questions there on a good number of occasions. That my informative and completely rule-abiding posts can be made unavailable at the whim of some community mods while the site is still alive feels like a betrayal. These mods don’t own my posts. No complaint if Reddit goes the way of Digg and takes everything with it.
- Macha 3y agoYou think that people Reddit would have to appoint on such short notice with no experience of the prior community will be _less_ likely to go on power trips?
- nkuttler 3y agoThat sounds naive. Your contributions were only needed and possible because of the volunteers that built the community you participated in. These mode don't own your posts, you can publish them anywhere you like after the community is gone. If you rely on an unpaid commercial entity to preserve your content forever I have bad news for you.
- oefrha 3y agoMy contributions were possible because I and a bunch of other non-mods contributed. As I said, I expect the commercial entity to preserve my content until the entity decides not to, not some random third party. My prior experience moderating other forums tells me the contribution of these community moderators are often way exaggerated and usually easily replaceable. Some form personality cults and periodic rotation would actually be a good thing.
- citizenkeen 3y agoThat entity delegated responsibility before you ever posted. That you didn't care back then doesn't matter: it's always been this way.
- that_guy_iain 3y agoI think most subs that are a few hundred thousand won't really notice the difference. The big subs that they would 100% do it on that are a few million plus, you would never really notice. /r/pics, /r/gaming, etc who even pays attention to who the mods are. The mods aren't the community. If Reddit replaces volunteer mods with paid mods we would get a more consistent moderation and almost certainly a more professional experience. People getting banned for disagreeing with a mod would stop for example. You wouldn't have to guess what the mods mean by their rules. For example, on /r/startups replying to people giving them an answer and saying if you have any more questions I'm free is called an unauthorised ask me anything. Which is crazy. There are many subs where it's anyone's guess what the rules are. And it can literally depend on the mood of the moderator. There are some subreddits that automatically ban people who have posted in certain subreddits. Moderation is an important job. It's needed. But I can't think of any other social site that has such a bad rep for moderation.
- SilverBirch 3y agoI'm not so sure, yes the mods are pretty anonymous on the bigger subs, but they do a tonne of work and have a tonne of experience on how to actually moderate the subs. There's a whole host of rules that have grown up around each of these communities that have been learned through bitter experience. So sure, you might not notice tomorrow if /r/pics moderators all got replaced, but I guarantee you over the next 6 months the sub-reddit would change in character significantly. You can employ paid moderators, I don't think it's a terrible idea from a quality of user experience perspective. It's an awful idea from a "We're desperately trying to get this fucking company to IPO".
- l-p 3y ago> If Reddit replaces volunteer mods with paid mods we would get a more > consistent moderation and almost certainly a more professional experience. I can guarantee you the opposite. You'll have a site-wide abusable Scunthorpe-incompatible report-based automated moderation with no proper appeal mechanism in place because half a dozen underpaid interns/offshored employees will be responsible for taking over the work of hundreds of moderators. It's already happening in some cases. There's ways to make reports go directly to the so-called Anti-Evil Operations team who will irrevocably override any moderation decision and enforce abusive reports. It's easy to get people banned, post some hateful content, wait for reports, and then report the reports for report abuse. > But I can't think of any other social site that has such a bad rep for moderation. There are some legitimate cases of poorly moderated subreddits and mod abuse (and the whole powermod issue), but beware, most of the time people complaining about power-tripping mods and "not being able to say anything anymore" have been banned for very good reasons (those reasons being straight-up hate speech most of the time).
- VectorLock 3y agoPeople seem to forget that the subreddits they create or moderate don't actually belong to them, they belong to Reddit Inc.
- Q6T46nT668w6i3m 3y agoNo. That’s the issue. Without moderators and posters, there’s no subreddits. Without Reddit, Inc., there’s no subreddits. In my experience, when trapped in a causality dilemma, it’s preferable to be thankful for both the chicken and the egg and not ask too many questions.
- jabradoodle 3y agoAnd without active users they are worthless.
- bardfinn 3y agoIf they pick moderators, those moderators are no longer volunteers, but employees & agents of Reddit, Inc. — and because of legal precedents with how moderators were engaged with AOL & LiveJournal, anything those technically-employee-agents of Reddit, Inc do wrong with respect to criminal activity and torts, Reddit Inc is on the hook for. That’s why they use the volunteer mod model, and why they keep us at arm’s-length, and mandate that we cannot receive any compensation of any kind from anyone for moderating. That said — The mod code of conduct gives them avenues for removing mods that violate it; there’s also neutral admin-developed tools that identify users who are already active in helping the community out as potential moderator recruits. So mods that close subreddits maliciously — with an intent to damage Reddit or to demand that they disburse money to a third party — could be removed from mod privileges, and replacements found.
- ipython 3y agoI'm pretty sure that's not what Section 230 says - in fact, the opposite, which is that reddit cannot be held responsible for the content on the site, even if reddit employees are moderating content. Sounds to me more like reddit trying to spin a false narrative (if that in fact is what they've said) to take advantage of free labor.
- subsistence234 3y agothat bike chain logic reminded me of "freeman on the land" lawyering.
- justcool393 3y agoi mean also given that reddit has actually picked moderators on subs that need it in the past (like /r/redditrequest exists), i'm pretty sure this is just made up
- humanistbot 3y agoNo, no, no, no, no. This is one of those Section 230 myths that somehow keeps circulating. It does not matter if moderators are paid or volunteer. Section 230 says nothing about this. AOL won all those lawsuits -- Zeran v AOL (1997), Blumenthal v. Drudge (1998), Doe v AOL (2001), Green V. AOL (2003). Now, reddit may SAY that this is the case as an excuse, but it isn't the truth.