4 ms·
> COLUMBUS, Ohio (WCMH) — Viral researchers believe someone in central Ohio has been infected with COVID-19 for at least two years, and they want to find that p
by londons_explore 3y ago
> COLUMBUS, Ohio (WCMH) — Viral researchers believe someone in central Ohio has been infected with COVID-19 for at least two years, and they want to find that person.
I believe this is why various lockdown strategies didn't work to eliminate COVID, even in very authoritarian places which can effectively enforce the lockdowns.
All it takes is one person to have a persistent 'forever infection' like this, and you will never eliminate the disease from your country. Even if you lock down with no person to person contact for months, as soon as you end the lockdown the disease will appear.
The only way to eliminate the disease would have been to lockdown for a while, identify all 'forever infected' people and imprison them for life, and close your borders to outsiders forever.
- perihelions 3y ago[vouch] Why even was this flagged? It's a perfectly good curious comment. - "The only way to eliminate the disease would have been to lockdown for a while, identify all 'forever infected' people and imprison them for life," Not a hypothetical. That was the initial reaction of several countries to HIV/AIDS, and Cuba actually implemented it [0]. [0] https://www.tampabay.com/opinion/2019/11/29/are-public-health-quarantines-in-our-future-column/ https://www.tampabay.com/opinion/2019/11/29/are-public-healt...
- jvanderbot 3y agoI'm always amazed at the diversity of opinions about lockdowns. In this case, I'm flabbergasted anyone ever thought that lockdowns alone would eliminate the disease, or that elimination was the goal of lockdowns. Are either of these common beliefs? Let alone that that lockdowns + prison + tracking those with persistent infections was the next logical step in the case of TFA
- RandallBrown 3y agoI was unaware that forever infections existed. I was definitely of the opinion that if we all locked down for 2 weeks and made no contact with anyone, this would all go away because the disease would be dead. I of course also realized that it's impossible for everyone to actually be locked down with no contact.
- Scoundreller 3y agoYeah, the definition of “lockdown” varied wildly. In many parts, any employer could make the case that an employee was “essential” if they had a job worth paying for. Recreational activities (even solo ones) faced the harshest enforcement.
- saiya-jin 3y ago> Recreational activities (even solo ones) faced the harshest enforcement. The least functional restrictions, the harshest on mental health of those impacted, on top of severe isolation issues that many faced. Luckily I can handle isolation quite well contrary to most folks I know, and I had 1 and then 2 babies to consume all attention but few were so lucky. Also Switzerland where I live didn't enforce basically any hard restriction on movement, just asked politely to stay home if you can, so whoever wanted to do sport outside just did it. Unlike say neighboring France which went batshit crazy with 1km-around-your-home one (so much for 'liberte', I find the more politicians talk about some catch word the less they actually mean to adhere to it when it matters).
- lIl-IIIl 3y agoWhy isn't that a reasonable thought? If the virus was less contagious (e.g. SARS) it would have worked, no?
- klyrs 3y agoThe stated goal of lockdowns was to "flatten the curve." The working assumption was that the virus would become endemic no matter what we tried, but by limiting interpersonal contact, we could decrease the rate of hospitalization to a manageable level. It is not reasonable to declare the lockdowns a total failure because they didn't achieve a goal they weren't intended to solve.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoSure, and it would have worked with COVID as well IF there was close to 100% compliance AND you could sustain that for 2 to 4 weeks. The only place that had real lockdowns where they actually welded the doors of people's apartments was China and they did effectively stop the spread of COVID until the much more contagious omicron came along. By then people were weary of lockdowns and the protests started threatening the government.
- com2kid 3y ago> In this case, I'm flabbergasted anyone ever thought that lockdowns alone would eliminate the disease, or that elimination was the goal of lockdowns. Are either of these common beliefs? Quarantines and lockdowns work really well for less communicable diseases. Given we didn't know how communicable COVID was early on, or that the absurdly easy to spread omicron variant would come along, assuming proper lockdowns could contain COVID wasn't unreasonable. Also, prior to omicron, some countries (Vietnam, China are the two I know of) did manage to completely stop COVID with targeted lockdowns and quarantines.
- justrealist 3y agoWhat China was doing before Omicron was still unsustainable. It was crushing exports and demographics.
- _delirium 3y ago> work really well for less communicable diseases In particular, SARS was successfully contained and then eliminated using similar measures in 2002–2004, so it was not totally absurd to think in the initial phases that it might work again for SARS 2.
- mrtesthah 3y ago>Also, prior to omicron, some countries (Vietnam, China are the two I know of) did manage to completely stop COVID with targeted lockdowns and quarantines. Ironically Omicron was exactly one such "cryptic lineage" that effectively descended from alpha and incubated in a presumed immuno-compromised and/or AIDS patient in South Africa while delta was already dominant. So any potential for global elimination was already foiled by exactly the sort of thing discussed in the article.
- yieldcrv 3y agoPeople don’t have an understanding and trusted health officials and politicians who all absolutely communicated poorly, lied, said ambiguous and conflicting things. And then those people made it their whole identity till this very day. So phrases like “stop the spread” was taken literally by both proponents and opponents. And “mitigate the spread while we increase treatment capacity but then don’t” Was far too complicated for the population
- jvanderbot 3y agoFlatten the curve was pretty straightforward, I thought.
- throwway120385 3y agoIn my understanding at the time the lockdowns were strictly for reducing the spread of the virus to the point that the hospitalization rate didn't exceed our hospital beds. The lockdowns in Washington State were very effective at limiting the pressure on hospital resources early in the pandemic to the degree that the Army withdrew their temporary field hospital in Seattle and the hospital ship the Navy had originally stationed in Seattle was moved to California where the lockdowns weren't as widely followed. The two hospitals were stationed in March and withdrawn by May or June as I recall. And we wouldn't see any further backup in Washington for the rest of the pandemic. Another thing that gets missed in these discussions is that Washington State was following the best data that they had, and you could watch it on the Department of Health's website. When cases started trending upwards they would wait for the hospitalization rate to trend upward and the bed count to reach a certain point and then ratchet down on the controls. When the trends reversed and fell below a certain point they would loosen the controls. It was very predictable what would happen next if you watched the DOH's website. There was also a very gradual decoupling of the hospitalization rate from the case rate the first summer vaccinations were widespread, and that seemed to demonstrate that as a public health measure vaccination was very effective.
- Buttons840 3y agoA seldom expressed idea is that maybe we acted close to optimally throughout this whole thing. I hesitated to write that, because I know someone will bring up a case where an official lied or there was widespread corruption (and I still welcome such arguments)... But, some mistakes pushed us towards too much lock-down, and some mistakes pushed us towards too little lock-down, and perhaps they balanced out to something close to optimal. Not only in the case of lock-downs, but in other things too: surely some executive acted with primary concern for profits, and surely some others spread baseless anti-vax conspiracies. Maybe they balance out? Maybe society is like a huge machine learning model. It has many errors, sometimes it estimates too high, sometimes it estimates too low. We are always striving to correct both types of errors, but the errors do not stop us from finding an approximate middle path which is often good enough.
- 6502nerdface 3y ago
- autoexec 3y agoThey're infected, but are they contagious? How contagious? > The only way to eliminate the disease would have been to lockdown for a while, identify all 'forever infected' people and imprison them for life, and close your borders to outsiders forever. It seems like you could identify them and then treat them so they wouldn't need to be locked up forever, but there'd be no reason to close your borders as long as you quarantined and tested everyone on entry.
- sokoloff 3y agoGiven that, over a long period, this has shown up in two but hasn’t shown up in other sewer systems that are also being tested, I think we have strong (albeit indirect) evidence of the contagiousness.
- cma 3y agoCouldn't you instead test outsiders, and cure 'forever infected' people probably sometime within their life? The tradeoffs aren't worth it with effective vaccines, but if it was something as deadly as the original SARS with a long incubation time I'm sure we'd still be doing strict measures like that.
- derefr 3y ago> identify all 'forever infected' people and imprison them for life Presumably this "forever infection" is due to the person lacking an immune response to overcome the disease. You probably just need to treat their HIV or whatever it is that's causing that, and they'll stop having COVID.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoSome folks may remember the saga of the TB-infected woman in Tacoma[0]. This is a difficult tightrope to walk. In her case, I suspect she's mentally ill, which is a very real problem. The issue is that there's a "slippery slope," where all kinds of conditions could become used as excuses to lock people up. Those of us "of a certain age," will remember that the Soviet Union routinely declared dissidents as "mentally ill," and threw them in gulags. The CIA and NSA also generally call whistleblowers and rouge agents "mentally ill," in order to discredit them. If we can be locked up, because someone has decided that some characteristic, or chronic condition, warrants lifelong lockup, what will the world look like? [0] https://arstechnica.com/health/2023/06/woman-with-untreated-tb-finally-in-custody-held-in-negative-pressure-room/ https://arstechnica.com/health/2023/06/woman-with-untreated-...
- throwway120385 3y agoSlippery Slope is a fallacy unless you can also demonstrate that the people in power genuinely want to throw us in gulags but are slowly rolling out their gulag policies to keep it on the down-low.
- sokoloff 3y agoWe shouldn’t discuss possible excesses of policy framework just because we can’t demonstrate that there’s genuine intent? If I look out at the current incarceration rate and the loosening of marijuana policy, I can see a projected drop in future incarceration. (I’m all for releasing everyone whose only crime is non-violent drug possession or sales.) But we have all these prisons and all these people whose income depends on them being fairly full. That’s a lot of pressure to find other what the private sector would call revenue streams. Pharma companies created a great fairly novel technique to target specific viruses. You don’t think it’s likely that they’ll create pressure for governments to use that capability to encourage at first and later to force multiple annual flu/other shots? That there won’t be sanctions for non-compliance as there are today for existing inoculations? (I say this as someone who took a handful of C19 vaccines and gets a flu shot most years. This isn’t an anti-vax rant, but rather exploring the pressures that allowing government too much leeway to restrict individual freedom and violate bodily autonomy has. I don’t want to allow the burden of proof to shift to the individuals to prove the government has ill intent or else submit to a novel, restrictive policy.)
- Imnimo 3y agoIf this person is an ongoing source for infections, why doesn't this lineage show up anywhere else?
- netsharc 3y ago> If it were spreading it would not remain precisely restricted to 2 sewersheds for almost a year. Source: [1] The person has an ongoing infection in their body, but seemingly not infecting anyone else, i.e. not infectious. Looking forward to hearing about the "Ohio variant"... /s [1] https://twitter.com/SolidEvidence/status/1665498960063078401 https://twitter.com/SolidEvidence/status/1665498960063078401
- ssnistfajen 3y agoYou are a prime example of why Hacker News should stick to strictly programming/startup stuff. Read the thread. This lineage is not showing signs of community spread.