28 ms·
10 years after Snowden's first leak, what have we learned?
- MrYellowP 3y agoNothing. As nothing changed, nobody learned anything.
- rnd0 3y agoNothing -or at least that's what it feels like.
- dylan604 3y agowhat? we learned that digital privacy does not exist. anyone that can make a dollar for information that they can glean from their users via any mechanism they offer will sell that data. we've learned that there are more people doing that very thing than would seem obvious at first. we've also learned that if the product/service you are using is free means you are the product is no longer true as things like smart TVs and other items that you pay for are also data hoarders to the point they make more money of the analytics sales than they do the actual product they are known to sell. we've learned that the rules for thee but not for me is rule of the land for gov't TLAs. so, it seems to me that we've learned a lot, but the "nothing" you claim would be more appropriately describing the response from what was learned.
- conductr 3y agoWhat we knew already, if you were aware of conversations amongst datacenter employees et al, just got official names like Prism It's akin to how we seem to be getting more and more info about UFOs lately. When it's finally confirmed, we can't just act like we knew nothing about UFOs existing, we had a clue for a long while - just no official confirmations.
- dylan604 3y ago> What we knew already, if you were aware of conversations amongst datacenter employees et al, just got official names like Prism right, and for the 99.999% of the population that is NOT, we learned all about it. what a weird caveat you've added that assumes "we" are only HN readers that could have possibly have learned anything.
- conductr 3y agoIt was widely reported as well (I remember a video of some govt agency installing a device in an AT&T datacenter siphoning a huge amount of internet traffic, it should have incited outrage and gone viral), just not much interest without a smoking gun. The laypeople you speak of weren't interested, they were blissfully ignorant. I honestly still believe with a smoking gun and 10 years later many people just don't have much interest, they tend to abide by the "nothing to hide, nothing to fear" views of privacy (in US at least)
- dylan604 3y agoI think it is more of a Douglas Adams type of SEP. These are things that are too complex for the average person to understand, and they might actually know deep down that if they were to allow themselves to understand it that they might actually have to do something about it which would disrupt their lifestyles. So their brains make the situation out as Someone Else's Problem which allows them to stick their head back into the sand. It's much more nuanced than "nothing to hide, nothing to fear", as it's just wrong. Everyone does something that is against regulations every day. It's just a matter of time before that is truly enforced using this "nothing to hide" data, and then people will be "I guess I did need to hide that".
- conductr 3y agoI tend to think people do know or have some clues into these type of things, they just think their probability assigned to "just a matter of time before that is truly enforced" is so low, they don't want to waste energy on it. They also view the consequences as low, hence the erroneous "nothing to fear" part. A current thought experiment on this is, if Trump won 2024, it wouldn't be a surprise to anyone if he went off the rails and tried to punish anyone that spoke poorly of him. Citizens included. Meanwhile, half the country has been posting openly on social media about hating the guy for the past 8 years. Some of us, thinking we did so anonymously behind a @non account. We collectively just don't fathom the risk of that type of institutional upheaval. But, it's bound to happen at some point, in some way. An example with less consequences (perhaps?), everyone knows that something is listening to them even when they don't know what. We all have stories of something unusual coming up in conversation, then immediately you notice you're being targeted for those ads. Even though you never search for it, etc. it just came up at the watercooler in conversation with Bob in accounting or something. Everyone knows it's happenings, for years now, but nobody is really too concerned or asking for real answers about how this occurs. It might be a complex of an answer for the average joe, but he's not even asking the question because the consequences are perceived to be low.
- falcolas 3y agoIf we as a society have changed nothing in response to new knowledge, have we really learned anything? I'd agree with the parent that no, we haven't.
- dylan604 3y agoIf you want to be flippant about it, fine. Just because you know that other planets exist around stars outside of our solar system but you can't visit them, did we actually learn anything? Having knowledge of something does not immediately mean you are able to take action with that knowledge. Sure, the typical HN reader might have been able to take action with things like installing various extensions in their browsers, running PiHoles on their private networks, using VPNs when on public networks, etc, but we've also learned that these are not enough and avoiding the tracking that we've learned about is nigh impossible. We now know things about persistent tracking that was not shared by Snowden, but we only started looking because of the revelations from Snowden got the wheels turning.
- BlargMcLarg 3y agoThere is a humongous gap between stars we can't reach and not putting every little detail of your life on the internet for all to see. Keeping information to yourself isn't something locked away behind extensive technical prowess. Heck, if we are playing this game: most still make fun of their 'weird tech relative/friend' who can do this rather than ask them to help for what they will probably do for free. The people have spoken and continue to speak very clearly.
- dylan604 3y agoSure, not publicly listing every meal you have followed by every bowel movement would be a good start that is never going to happen because the world needs to know this information. However, that's not the only data that is gathered and sold. The information that is gathered passively from extensive efforts to track individuals across the internet is the elephant in the room that you seemingly want to ignore. These are direct attempts by companies to subvert individuals that might actually NOT be posting every little thing they do on social platforms. Things like tracking people as they move about brick & mortar stores or other types of beacons for whatever purposes they are being used for are examples. SmartTVs gather metrics, grocery stores gather metrics, and the million other "little" things that when gathered together all paint a very very detailed picture about someone without them necessarily knowing about. so you're "don't be so public on the internet" is not such a simple little thing
- raincole 3y agoWe learned that digital privacy doesnt exist and nobody cares about that. By nobody I meant the amount of people who care is rounding error.
- dylan604 3y agoBut isn't that pretty telling information to have learned? As evangelists against tracking, we hope that by spreading the gospel of evil tracking uses to those unaware might actually convert them into the flock and they would change their habits. instead, we learned we are outcasts in society, and that if we keep singing the hymns in places people are not interested in hearing them, that we will become (have become) a mocked group of society that becomes meme-worthy and never taken seriously. so, the Prophecies of Idiocracy are doomed to come true.
- sillystuff 3y agoCertainly not enough given the level of Snowden's sacrifice. The article mentions revelations of Verizon participating in illegal spying. It was also revealed ATT and others participated. This prompted congress to pass a retroactive law making the illegal telecom spying, during the Bush Jr. administration, legal. I guess the US hypocrisy is more plain now? The US is a nation of (retroactive) laws that protect powerful men. There were a few technical fixes. The NSA presentation slide that stated, OpenVPN and SSL were "not a problem" led to using stronger ciphers by default. Google reportedly encrypts its inter-DC links since the revelations that the US was tapping and spying on the communications. You are less likely to be treated as a tinfoil hat nutter if you talk about US spying on its own citizens and the rest of the world. The rest of the world's population stated the US as the greatest threat to freedom in the world today in polls across allied nations, so some who had prior, are no longer believing US propaganda. Although recent US illegal wars of aggression and revelations of torture and other war crimes, probably played a large part here too. The powerful have tried harder to ensure secrecy, and control over documentation of their misdeeds. It is highly likely that the powerful also are more careful now to ensure there is no record of their crimes. But, what should have happened was the displacing of all the federal prisoners convicted of non-violent drug offences to make room for all surviving politicians and surviving members of the NSA, CIA, FBI, federal courts, etc., who reasonably could be expected to have known of illegal behavior of those agencies, and who did not do everything within their abilities (including whistle blowing) to end it. There would have been a lot of powerful members of the corporate party's far-right wing (Republicans) and the corporate party's right wing (Democrats) being locked up, so of course, go after the messenger, sweep what you can under the rug, and as a last resort, pass retroactive laws to make the illegal, legal.
- 5350-uiop-1130 3y agoto assume that everything you write or say to or near an internet connected device is being recorded and linked to your real life identity. to assume that everything companies tell you about security and encryption is an intentional (legally bound) or unintentional lie. to realise that there are shadow laws that we are not aware of that govern these things.
- maerF0x0 3y agoTo realize that the real state acts "deep state" like without requiring nefarious or shadowy behavior. Simply make unelected people have lifelong careers within governmental organizations. Snowden talks about this in his book. Yeah a new ~puppet~ figure head gets elected every 4 years. But what about all the layers of folks who actually perform the "Government" actions? They are the same people for decades, they say yes or no to actions you can/cannot take, they influence in their every choice they true meaning of policies...
- roywiggins 3y agoThe modern civil service is still better than the old "spoils system." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spoils_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spoils_system It was reformed for a reason! Putting politicians in charge of all hiring and firing turned out to be bad for everyone.
- artificial 3y agoThere have been no reforms. Business as usual.
- fsflover 3y agoRelated recent discussions: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastYear&page=0&prefix=false&query=snowden%20ten&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastYear&page=0&prefix=fal...
- zingababba 3y agoWho is 'we' in this? If 'we' is U.S. citizen I think it's something along the lines of the typical trope 'if I don't have anything to hide then I don't have anything to worry about' with the unspoken piece of the formula being '...so I should censor myself to ensure...' etc.
- actionfromafar 3y ago"We need to ensure the TLA is run by people sharing our values, so they will only spy, frame and kill our enemies in the culture war." (Too dark?)
- nunobrito 3y agoOnly criminals have something to hide, right? I love that saying. But if it would be true, then why do people lock their bathroom doors?
- fsflover 3y agoThis is completely missing the point of why one needs privacy. Lack of it harms journalism and activism, making the government too powerful and not accountable. If only activists and journalists will try to have the privacy, it will be much easier to target them. Everyone should have privacy to protect them. It’s sort of like freedom of speech is necessary not just for journalists, but for everyone, even if you have nothing to say.
- nunobrito 3y agoIt was sarcasm, friend. Apologies if it seemed otherwise. I'm on the side of privacy, decentralization and offline technology that is free from modern shackles.
- colpabar 3y agoThat mainstream media outlets filled with "former" intelligence agents completely control american discourse.
- drewcoo 3y agoThis times a big number. And because of the increased saturation of the MSM with "former" three letter agency staff, we also see today's liberals as staunch defenders of the same agencies they used to harshly question. That's a huge shift and I think it's attributable mostly to needing to do damage control post-Snowden.
- actionfromafar 3y agoEven if there was a "cabal" of string pullers, don't you think there are more direct reasons in that case? Such secret networks, to the extent they exist, generally value stability. Chaos is dangerous to the powers that be. If these groups felt threatened by leftists and liberals rocking the boat, don't you make the mistake of what they feel threatened of. It's not primarily the ideology, it's the rocking of the boat. If the right is now rocking the status quo, don't you think that is also threatening? Somewhere mixed in here are also (probably a huge majority) of bureaucrats, for better or worse, just doing their jobs.
- whimsicalism 3y agoI think it is more attributable to reformed alliances in the wake of Trump and conservative populism. Neocon figures realized they couldn’t rely on popular Republican support for intervention, so they started making alliances with liberals who had shown willingness to be swayed.
- skilled 3y agoI hate when journalists steal headlines and don't add any meaning/life to a story. The actual piece is from Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jun/07/edward-snowden-10-years-surveillance-revelations https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jun/07/edward-snowd...
- drewcoo 3y agoI'm pretty sure it was 10 years since Snowden's reveal both for El Reg and for the Guardian. El Reg did not steal the time period from the Guardian.
- LatteLazy 3y agoThat nationalism beats knowledge and people really cannot cope with ideas that don't fit into tweets. Sorry this is so "edgy" but I cannot find a better way to sum it up. This whole thing is just like the end of the Roman Republic only with less class.
- whimsicalism 3y agoThe elites are much better at managing public opinion in the modern West than they ever were in the Roman Republic. We would never see something even remotely similar to the Gracchi in the US today.
- markus_zhang 3y agoLearned that we are more or less naked when surfing the web, which is beyond any individual's effort unless one literally lives in a cave.
- dralley 3y ago[flagged]
- actionfromafar 3y agoI have this same impression but I can't remember how I got to this conclusion. This scares me a little bit.
- whimsicalism 3y agoit should. i will be the first to say he is pretty obnoxious, but i think people also underestimate the degree to which they are influenced by targeted social media campaigns
- dbspin 3y agoThe Intercept's treatment of Reality Winner under his editorship, and his refusal to take the blame for it is one good reason - https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/reality-winner-interview-prison-nsa-1261844/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/real... His embrace (and defence) of right wing ideologues like Tucker Carlson is another https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QN1bp7jSBY0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QN1bp7jSBY0 His embrace of politicised conspiracy theories is another https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/media/greenwald-intercept-feud/2021/05/20/34732c92-b727-11eb-a5fe-bb49dc89a248_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/media/greenwald-int... His leaking of Chelsea Mannings private chat logs is another https://www.salon.com/2022/08/08/what-happened-to-glenn-greenwald-the-former-trans-ally-now-sides-with-right-wing-transphobia/ https://www.salon.com/2022/08/08/what-happened-to-glenn-gree... The guy seems to have moved from a progressive, anti-authoritarian civil rights campaigner, to a populist self promoting zealot.
- whimsicalism 3y agoGlenn Greenwald was always aligned with the libertarian right, the progressive gloss was one imposed by people reporting on his actions. He has definitely moved into Right wing circles after the Democratic backlash to Snowden/wikileaks/etc. in the aftermath of the Podesra, etc. leaks. The reality winner stuff is disingenuous, most of this was messed up by the people who pushed Greenwald out, you can read more about this elsewhere. Look, the guy is complicated, but he has made valuable contributions. He exposes corruption & public-private collusion. There is clearly a lot of smoke around the Hunter Biden stuff. I don’t agree that it is the biggest deal, but I can see why that level of governmental intervention into the private matters of presidential family might interest civil liberties reporters and that does not make it a “conspiracy” (the WaPo has a 7 year old history of calling inconvenient truths conspiracy at this point).
- rib3ye 3y ago[flagged]
- rat9988 3y agoHe should have stayed in a democratic country friendly to the US? He didn't have many choices here.
- myko 3y agoHe could have faced trial, which was the right thing to do
- whimsicalism 3y agoIt seems reasonable to me to not want to go to jail over what I view as a heroic act and Russia is realistically one of the only places he could have fled. You are playing into exactly the narrative the Western intelligence community is trying to propagate by saying he is somehow blameworthy for not wanting to spend the rest of his life in jail (and no, Snowden would not get pardoned like Manning was, the leaks are too great, the ire is too great).
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agohttps://intelligence.house.gov/uploadedfiles/snowden_report_highlights.pdf https://intelligence.house.gov/uploadedfiles/snowden_report_... > “The Committee further found no evidence that Snowden attempted to communicate concerns about the legality or morality of intelligence activities to any officials, senior or otherwise, during his time at either CIA or NSA.” > “The vast majority of documents Snowden removed were unrelated to electronic surveillance or any issues associated with privacy and civil liberties.” (p. 22) > “Since Snowden’s arrival in Moscow, he has had, and continues to have, contact with Russian intelligence services.” > “Some of the personal network drives Snowden searched belonged to individuals involved in the hiring decision for a job for which Snowden had applied. On these individuals’ network drives, Snowden searched for human resources files and files related to the promotion and hiring decisions.”
- wunderland 3y agoThe House Intelligence Committee has every reason to discredit Snowden. Why should we believe this?
- scottiebarnes 3y agoEven if it were true, one should see it as an attempt to distract from the leaked documents themselves.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWhich claims in the document are inaccurate?
- MisterBastahrd 3y ago[flagged]
- wunderland 3y agoMaybe I don’t have a lick of intelligence but it’s documented that Snowden tried to go through official channels to report illegal surveillance first.
- RomanPushkin 3y ago> what have we learned? Julian Assange should have come to Russia, not Sweden
- tpmx 3y ago[flagged]
- JPws_Prntr_Fngr 3y ago[flagged]
- tpmx 3y agoYou seem to have accidentally switched HN accounts when replying. Oh dear. You're at the very least not supposed to use multiple accounts in the same thread.
- JPws_Prntr_Fngr 3y ago“No ur a Russian putinbot!!” Hahah we’re so fucked
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fallingfrog 3y agoWell, we've learned that the people in power are immune to criticism and that the democratic process has no ability to constrain them whatsoever.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoPeople blew the whistle on a sitting President just a few years ago and they're practically heroes today (Alexander Vindman, Bill Taylor, etc.).
- mmh0000 3y agoWhat have we learned? * That the U.S. Government is above the law and no one will ever be held to account. * Privacy in the U.S. for citizens is dead, but alive and well for corporations and government. * That 50% of Americans would glady kill the other 50% so that they can be little racist Nazi shitheads. * That things will get much worse before they get better.
- titzer 3y agoThe lengths that the "good guys" will go to in order to spy on the "bad guys" and how they'll be lying into their graves about it. You can't trust a single word intelligence agencies say. We have no idea what they are collecting, how it is stored, indexed, searched, or used, or how long. They actively deny operations they are currently engaged in, i.e. they lie, at the highest levels. There are only technical limitations imposed by computational resources. Which aren't really limitations when they have effectively infinite funding at this point. They've infiltrated hardware; inserted backdoors, not just at telcos, but into privately-developed and owned locations. They consider encryption to be a stumbling block and are willing to intervene to weaken it to serve their purposes. Absolutely shitbirds, all. I don't care what their ends are, their means are to create a digital dystopia that simply cannot be trusted. They basically broke tech; usurped it to serve the power structure. And so many people and companies went along with, are going along with, and are enriching themselves by doing so. This future sucks. I hate my own devices.
- digging 3y ago> This future sucks. I hate my own devices. Installing GrapheneOS on my Pixel was the closest I'm come to feeling like having an actual PDA I could trust and living in a cool future. But of course it's still on Google hardware, so it's not trustworthy. And it still requires apps, some of which are not trustworthy. And, worst of all, I still have to communicate with other people on their phones, which voids most privacy efforts. I don't even give new friends my real phone number because I can't trust their contacts list not to be shared with everybody who wants to buy it.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoIt also, no doubt, relies on a Google-signed blob to enforce Secure Boot that is signed by Google. Where do you think that "This device has secure boot disabled" or "This device is running a custom image..." (can't remember exact terminology) warning comes from... So, in theory, Google could make a signed blob that unlocked secure boot if the government really wanted it anyway.
- 3y ago
- reducesuffering 3y ago[flagged]
- GVRV 3y agoPersonally, I have learnt I do not have a moral compass strong enough to outweigh the consequences that come with being a whistleblower. I'm very grateful such people exist, though.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoWhat are the consequences? Legal protection from retaliation? https://www.dodig.mil/Resources/FAQs/#whistleblowerFAQs https://www.dodig.mil/Resources/FAQs/#whistleblowerFAQs
- sigzero 3y agoThat is only for "legal" whistleblowers though. Snowden was not.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThat was his choice. He could have chosen the legal avenue and would have been afforded whistleblower protections. Fleeing the country with classified material doesn't afford you protection.
- kenicctwd 3y agoCopying from another comment, to prove how stupid is to expect that a secret service will pet you on the head for talking out against them: "Thomas Drake did everything you say is the right, he paid the price: | The first is Thomas Drake, who blew the whistle on the | very same NSA activities 10 years before Snowden did. | Drake was a much higher-ranking NSA official than | Snowden, and he obeyed US whistleblower laws, raising | his concerns through official channels. And he got | crushed. | Drake was fired, arrested at dawn by gun-wielding FBI | agents, stripped of his security clearance, charged | with crimes that could have sent him to prison for | the rest of his life, and all but ruined financially | and professionally. The only job he could find | afterwards was working in an Apple store in suburban | Washington, where he remains today. Adding insult to | injury, his warnings about the dangers of the NSA’s | surveillance programme were largely ignored. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon... "
- dionidium 3y agoThe real lesson of Snowden's revelations is that almost nobody actually cares that they're being spied on. (I certainly don't.) Edit: OK, here's some actual data on this and a little less hyperbole. "Almost nobody" is wrong. But it's not obvious that most Americans care. * On most questions about surveillance Americans are pretty evenly divided (it's about 50/50 for/against government surveillance and wiretapping) * On the question of monitoring non-citizens Americans are broadly supportive (80% in favor) * When you ask people about their own data they actually turn out to be less concerned than if you ask them about surveillance in the abstract (a majority are "unconcerned" about surveillance in that context) Source: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2018/06/04/how-americans-have-viewed-government-surveillance-and-privacy-since-snowden-leaks/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2018/06/04/how-ameri...
- bllguo 3y agothat Americans are impotent, unwilling, incapable - take your pick - to effect any meaningful changes within their system. despite loudly proclaiming the virtues of liberal democracy and even being willing to violently force it onto others.
- smash666 3y agoit’s a damn shame snowden and assange are not consistently cited for the revealing the insane violence against us all. we are 20 years in the dark. we are 20 fucking years, in the dark. we shine the light on the present and they hang us by the balls.
- _yb2s 3y agoI still can't wrap my head around the widespread dislike/hatred of Snowden, and politicians still labeling him as a degenerate or criminal that should be brought to justice, while ignoring the crimes and abuse he revealed. Seems very 1984-esque. My own friends and family don't really remember what he did, but remember him vaguely as some sort of criminal that somehow hurt the USA or sold us out. There's also a narrative that he somehow "defected" to Russia, despite the fact that the U.S. government trapped him there during a flight layover, and he never wanted to go there at all. When I first heard his story I expected him to be hailed as a hero, and thought we might even have a holiday to celebrate him for risking his life, freedom, and career to inform us that our government is doing something deeply unethical in secret with our own money, that violates our basic freedoms. Thank you Snowden.
- joemazerino 3y agoAre you American? Snowden released unredacted classified documents that lead to real-world damage and potentially casualties. Compare that to wikileaks which redacted locations, IP addresses and other sensitive information. He wasn't a hacker by any means. He was a lowly SharePoint admin that was rumoured to have been coerced remotely by the Russians. He was angry with the NSA for being denied a promotion for TAO which drove him over the edge. It isn't hard to theorize that Russian and Chinese assets lurk the corners of chatrooms, looking for depressed/vulnerable US assets to coerce and corrupt. Money well spent for the West's enemies. If a single American intelligence asset lost their life because of Snowden's leaks would your opinion change?
- dTal 3y agoSnowden released his intel to a single journalist each from two highly respected publications, The Washington Post and The Guardian. Releases to the general public were made in those publications only, according to the judgement and discretion of those journalists. It was the model of responsible disclosure. Can you point to a specific article in the Washington Post or The Guardian which you believe lead to casualties? (The rest of your comment is rumor, wild speculation, and in the case of 'lowly sharepoint admin', outright misrepresentation)
- neilv 3y agoI get the impression that the intelligence communities (IC) have a lot of people who have a constant sense of it being their job to help avert national existential threats. I imagine they attract lots of smart and noble people, and that the nature of immersion in the work is going to affect a person's perspective. People I've met who might've been involved in IC don't talk about it, at least not with me (and I assume it's improper to ask), but I did once meet someone peripheral to that, who vocalized one kind of thinking about it. Years prior to the meeting, around the time of the Snowden thing, in a private research forum, I said something like: one of the IC orgs did important work, etc., but seemed to need guidance on Constitutional balance. It was a random comment, and I forgot about it. Years later, I was meeting with someone from that forum, about a (non-IC) job, and their attention was divided with laptop while they talked with me, like they were also reviewing my resume or something. Suddenly, they were agitated, and seemed to be referencing -- not our conversation, nor my resume -- but my forum comment from years earlier, as they angrily started saying how people at such-and-such org "know the Constitution better than anyone", etc. Then angry impromptu speech about (public) information about threats, and (public) information about a claim of why such-and-such org had done certain things. I'm somewhat sympathetic to that, and I also realized that I needed to get the interview-gone-sideways back on track, so the discussion recovered after that. But at the end of the interview, there was obvious (renewed) irritation in their voice and manner. (And that's not my worst interview ever. :) I realized that the person's work had probably led them interact with IC orgs before, the person had been impressed by the orgs, was very concerned about threats, and was offended on behalf of the org by armchair critics like me. I imagine that person is not the only one with strong feelings like that, but that people actually at the org, and who had similar feelings, wouldn't speak with an outsider about it.
- spirit557 3y ago[flagged]
- blipvert 3y agoAmerican patriots are loyal to Russia. Plot twist!
- NoZZz 3y agoThat anything that can be done will be done to push the narrative that will enrich the few.
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoWe've learned that we learn virtually nothing if the intelligence community says we don't.