5 ms·
Exercise Has Many Health Benefits. Weight Loss Isn't One of Them
- bigyikes 3y agoLosing weight is easy: just do nothing! Haha, only kidding. But really, it often is easier to reduce calorie intake than it is to increase calorie expenditure. Sure, you can burn hundreds or thousands of calories a day by riding your bike. But if you’re worried about losing that much weight, are you in good enough shape to do that much exercise reliably anyway? I’m not. (I should ride my bike more…)
- swagasaurus-rex 3y agoYou can't outrun a bad diet
- krageon 3y agoYou can outrun a bad diet, you just need to run a lot more.
- canofvents 3y agoThere are ~6500kcal in a kilogram of nuts, very easy to consume throughout the day with minimal effort. Running 6500kcal on the other hand seems infeasible for the sturdiest athlete
- GeoAtreides 3y agoIt's very hard to eat a kilo of nuts, because of their strong satiety effects. And yes, 100gr of nuts is about 650 of calories, but that doesn't mean the body will actually "access" all those 650 calories. For example: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2161831323002752 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S216183132... "The metabolizable energy (ME) of nuts was consistently lower than that predicted by Atwater factors for investigated nut types" "The lower-than-expected ME may explain a lack of association between nut intake and body weight observed in the literature" A search on google scholar for: peanuts lipid bioaccessibility digestibility might bring more studies on this topic
- jdechko 3y ago6500 calories of nuts is a lot. It would also be terrible for quick energy because most of the calories are from fat and protein.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- storkhm 3y agoThis is simply wrong. None of this stuff is even complicated.
- musicale 3y agoThat explains why athletes tend to be obese.
- testhest 3y agoCorrelation does not imply causation.
- tailspin2019 3y agoI find this article extremely annoying and low quality. It’s difficult to get past the clickbait title for a start. The analysis here is far too simplistic for any useful purpose. Regular exercise also has many indirect but well-studied psychological effects which may also aid in weight loss. It’s not just about the raw calories burned off by the activity itself. But if those calories happen to tip you into a calorific deficit then that exercise absolutely WILL help weight loss - so you cant just make misleading blanket statements about this. There are plenty of cherry-pickable studies to support both sides of this argument, for example: > The 15-week exercise training appeared to motivate young adults to pursue healthier dietary preferences and to regulate their food intake. [0] [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41366-018-0299-3.epdf https://www.nature.com/articles/s41366-018-0299-3.epdf
- AtlasBarfed 3y ago"working your butt off" Really? A pound of fat is 3500 calories. To work off a thousand calories requires swimming 4000-5000 yards, biking 25-30 miles on a road bike, or running 7-10 miles. People need to understand what working your butt off is. High school practice for major sports will burn that for every single practice. That's working your butt off. Now go to a gym and tell me if you see most people doing that. They aren't. Add to that you need intensity to cause physiology adaptation which forces more calories in tissue building. People aren't working their butt off. For the vast majority of people starting an exercise routine it will be hard to burn even 600 calories in an hour of exercise. So that means six days of one hour of exercise a day will burn 1 pound of fat ... If you controlled calories intake. Big if. Ten pounds of fat is: 35000 calories 140,000 yards of swimming (180 lbs person) or about 80 miles of swimming 233 miles of running (180 lb person) 875 miles of biking. And I may be underestimating.
- elmolino89 3y agoWhile we do burn some extra calories rebuilding muscles after say long session of cardio your numbers (at least for running) for 70kg person are OK. There may be also an appetite suppressing effect of exhausting training sessions. There is no way that not even overweight but a middle aged mostly, sedentary person can do 10 miles runs 6x a week. IMHO one should start with biking and walking which are way easier on the joins and start running after getting to the level when 50km rides are not causing you any problems. This assuming your BMI is not way above 25.
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoSo sixty pounds of fat in one year.
- storkhm 3y agoAs if your body is in the same state after working out than if you had sat on the couch doing nothing. As if the only change happens during the time you are actually working out. As if no calories are being spent recovering from a brutal workout for the next day vs sitting on the couch playing video games. I just don't get it. This stuff is just not that complicated. Just constant wrong information over and over and over.
- testhest 3y agoThis has been known for decades. It's hard to resell a weight loss program that works so the marketing budget is quite low.
- phendrenad2 3y agoExercise just adds muscle, and maintaining muscle makes you hungrier. You aren't suddenly hungry for healthier food, which actually leads to weight loss.
- halfjoking 3y agoThis article describes a problem but gives no solution. It mentions caloric restriction but nothing about fasting. And fasting is a form of caloric restriction but it’s not really the same - see this video: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2iCVKRxsgE0&pp=ygUldGhvbWFzIGRlZmxldXIgZmFzdGluZyBvciByZXN0cmljdGlvbg%3D%3D https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2iCVKRxsgE0&pp=ygUldGhvbWFzIGR... The 36 hour fasts I do are so much easier than trying to eat small portions consistently it’s absurd. I lost all my extra weight and didn’t even eat as healthy as I was prior to fasting. Serious fasting is like hard exercise for your metabolism. When you exercise, would you rather go hard and push yourself or would you rather go through the motions and not work up a sweat? I think of real fasting (24 hr plus) as intense workout for your metabolism. And it’s much easier than I thought if you know the tricks… mainly take prebiotic fiber to stop insane hunger. Drink lots of tea. And take pink/mineral salt if you get a fasting headache. If you want to know more of the science why it works watch the YouTube vid I linked. That guy has like 5000 videos about fasting, it’s so much he should probably do a fast of making YouTube vids about fasting.
- throwawayadvsec 3y agodid you measure how much muscle you lost?
- lapcat 3y ago> Serious fasting is like hard exercise for your metabolism. For additional context on this commenter's health perspective: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36068156 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36068156
- halfjoking 3y agoAll modern medical science is fraudulent. If you believe otherwise you haven’t been paying attention. Read some arkmedic https://arkmedic.substack.com/ https://arkmedic.substack.com/ I may rant off the cuff like I did in that comment, but the evidence is there you should not trust anything in a medical journal.
- xupybd 3y agoI find I lose weight with diet alone but slightly faster with diet and exercise. I don't seem to lose weight with exercise alone.
- yodelshady 3y agoI've recently come off a 10 week pause in any significant exercise due to injury (and still can't do many strength exercises, though I was already mostly cardio). I made zero effort to change my eating habits, since I still have a job, and doing it is much easier - debatably only possible - if not distracted by hunger. My weight went down and is skyrocketing now that normal service is resumed. Maybe I break the laws of physics, maybe my brain is lying to me about how much I ate, or maybe my endocrine system is doing things to maintain a setpoint, like it does with temperature, hydrostatic balance, CO2 levels, Na/K balance, anything else I've missed? Given the above, how the ** do you suggest that CICO works as a predictive model over long terms? I don't know the first number, really don't know the second, and the second changes in response to the first.
- incrudible 3y agoCICO is one of these things that are technically true, but useless in practice. What does the O mean here, exactly? It depends on metabolism. Some (few) people struggle to gain weight, some people struggle to not gain weight, consuming the same amount of calories. The former burn far more calories at rest than the latter. Some studies even show that caloric restriction slows down metabolism. This a survival feature of the body. The benefit of exercise is that it may(!) increase your metabolic rate so that you burn more calories at rest, but that's not something that will show up in some brief interventional study like the ones presented here.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 3y ago> What does the O mean here, exactly? Doesn't matter. Ignore the O, focus on the I. If you want to weigh a certain amount, look up what the sedentary metabolic estimate is for that weight and consume that number that despite any additional exercise you are doing. The hard part is dealing with being hungry all the time, and despite the promises of fad diets everywhere, there is no solution to that that I have found that doesn't involve stimulants.
- incrudible 3y ago
- ofslidingfeet 3y agoThis is just prima facie untrue, and sure enough, even the article plainly states that 30 minutes of daily exercise will "probably" lead to 12 lbs of weight loss in a year.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 3y agoIff your diet doesn't change, which it often does because people often reward themselves after a workout, or a week of working out, or whatever. They tell themselves "I can eat this entire pizza, I've earned it", and the math gets fucked because of it.
- david-gpu 3y agoAnd yet amateur endurance athletes are skinny while stuffing their face constantly with sugar and other refined carbohydrates. Correlation does not guarantee causation, but it sure hints there may be something connecting the two variables.
- canofvents 3y agoSports drinks and recovery snacks aren't that high in energy, and they likely forgo gallon of sugar-coke, donuts, cake, bars of chocolate, extra trips to mcD from their diet
- david-gpu 3y agoTypically an amateur athlete will go for something like 60g of sugar or other rapidly-absorbed carbohydrate per hour of training. In coke terms, that is a 600ml (20 fl oz) bottle per hour. They are very much outliers in terms of what their body composition compared to people of the same age who don't do endurance sports, especially when you look at their diet.
- jdechko 3y agoFor the most part, I agree. We aren't all super skinny. Since Jan 1, I’m down about 20 pounds with another 10-15 to go. But endurance athletes are quite different to just “regular” athletes. Someone who does a < 60 minute workout will likely not burn off all the glycogen stored in their muscles. Around 60 minutes your body will have to switch to burning fat or you start having to add calories. And “eating healthy” during exercise takes a backseat to fast calories due to GI issues and the much slower breakdown of more complex carbohydrates. The difference is what you eat when you’re not training. I try to eat healthy during the day, but for long workouts, it’s high-carb sports drinks, gels, and peanut butter M&Ms. Gustav Iden, the current IRONMAN champion, eats around 8000 calories on intense training days. https://youtu.be/GrzDoSwg198 https://youtu.be/GrzDoSwg198 I’m not Gustav, and I don’t work out as much or as hard as he does, but sometimes I need 3000-4000 calories just so I don’t feel like * before, during or after training
- phil21 3y ago
- lapcat 3y agoIn my opinion, and in my experience, it's a mistake to aim for short-term goals such as losing X pounds. Indeed, I think it's a mistake to even measure your weight, because weight measures good muscle too. Once you "accomplish" your short-term goal, after intense short-term effort, the natural tendency is to begin to slack off, and the fat comes back. The key is to make permanent, maintainable lifestyle changes to become healthier, including diet and exercise — cut down on sodium and added sugars too — and eventually your body will look and feel better. The fat will come off and stay off, but you don't need to measure to tell that, you can just see the changes in your body. The thing about exercise is, the more exercise you do, the more exercise you're capable of doing in the future. Sedentary people aren't capable of exercising with the intensity to burn off a ton of calories, whereas athletes burn off so many calories that they have to eat a ton just to compensate. Short-term, exercise may not do a lot of good, but long-term, it adds up. You have to "invest" in exercise, and the payoff will come, slowly but surely. Admittedly, there's one downside to this gradual approach, which is that you may have to keep buying new clothes that fit right, until you eventually stabilize.
- chrsw 3y agoFor me it’s always been: Want to lose weight? Eat less. Want to feel better? Exercise more.
- TomMasz 3y agoI got back on a bicycle when I ruptured a disc in my lumbar spine and had to stop running. My only intention was to stay in decent shape. I've lost 40 lbs. since 2019. Weight loss was not a goal but it still happened. If you expend more calories than you take in, you will lose weight, but probably not at a rate like you see advertised.
- BJBBB 3y agoNot quite anecdotal, but a very narrow range of subjects. Sample of 19, all male, between 19 and 26, medium age 21. Approximately half were smokers. All had scored a class I or II PFT prior to deployment, had passed a physical, and were in good to excellent health. Environment and Conditions = Aircraft carrier on gonzo station in the Indian Ocean. Period = 4.5 months. Working temperature range 24 to 35C, 50 to 100%RH. IMA mostly sedentary, sitting at avionics bench in air conditioned space. OMA mostly active, on flight deck or on hanger deck Work level = 12 to 24 hr/day for OMA(this includes chow breaks). 10 to 20 hr/day for IMA. Both worked 7 days/week. Food Intake - OMA people ate 3x to 5x per day where range of consumption not less than 3400 cal/day. High end of consumption range indeterminate, probably over 5700 cal/day. IMA people ate 3x/day, unless standing a mid-watch, where range of consumption was 3100 to 4200 cal/day. About 30% of OMA subject did weights 3x to 5x per week. Essentially all IMA lifted 2x to 6x per week. Results - all OMA people lost between 5% and 20% body mass by end of cruise. I lost approx 9%, but may not be representative because I spent approx 30% of time working in IMA. IMA people weight gains ranged from 0% to 10%. Source = Senior Chief Corpsman (paygrade E-8) that was collecting performance data on aviation maintenance personnel for unknown reasons. Based on this small sample, I could conclude that both caloric intake and activity level are among the principle things that effect a weight loss or gain.
- sw104 3y agoIf somebody exercises hard and sufficiently, of course it can lead to (a boost in) weight loss. It's just difficult and requires a lot of willpower. Provided you actually worked (didn't sit on a machine at the gym on your phone), burned a decent amount (typically cardio works best), and don't replace the extra calories you burned out with more food, it's all helping you achieve a CICO deficit. 9 times out of 10, it is all CICO.