8 ms·
School district sues Meta, Google, and TikTok over ‘mental health crisis’
- DueDilligence 3y ago.. 100% behind this long overdue action.
- unnamed76ri 3y agoI’m not a fan of any of the companies listed but I don’t necessarily like blaming them for things parents shouldn’t be giving their kids access to. But maybe these lawsuits will wake some parents up.
- mentos 3y agoWhat if you consider social media to be like cigarettes?
- veave 3y agoEven if you did, parents shouldn't allow their kids to get cigarettes. Parents trying to get out of parenting is getting old already.
- LightBug1 3y agoAnd if the cigarette companies advertise to the kids? And the second hand smoke is everywhere (everyone else using them) and are almost ubiquitous now? Such that the only way around that is to cut those kids off from society? I agree with you on parenting, but I won't, for a second, let these companies off the hook for the damage they cause. Give them an inch, they'll take your entire soul if they can and it will help their quarterly P&L. Don't forget it.
- throw_m239339 3y ago> And if the cigarette companies advertise to the kids? It's illegal. Tiktok, Facebook, ... nonsense on the other hand isn't, because these platforms aren't responsible for the content they broadcast, by regulation. So should these regulations change?
- LightBug1 3y agoOf course, I know it's illegal. I'm using the comparison to highlight it. It's as if we're allowing cigarette companies to be all pervasive through general access and direct advertising to our kids, and then saying: "but the parents shouldn't let them smoke, man, they're not responsible parents". I think that's unfair at this stage. Yes, perhaps regulation needs to change.
- probably_wrong 3y agoI think you're being too harsh on the parents. I don't know a single parent who allowed their kids to get cigarettes, but I also don't know a single teen who ever said "I'd like to smoke but my parents don't allow it so no, thanks". They just smoked behind their parents' backs. I feel the comparison to cigarettes is apt: I know of children who had an "official" Facebook account for their parents and a "real" one for their school friends. And while I'm not sure I 100% agree with the lawsuit, I think it's worth asking: given how much money these companies invested in hooking teens up and how much they profited from it, should they also be held accountable for the negative effects of said hooking up?
- cycomanic 3y agoAre you a parent? It certainly doesn't sound like it. While you might be able to keep a preteen away from things, once they are teenagers you can not prevent then from doing something they want to do. The amount of teenage pregnancies in states where they preach abstinence instead of doing sexual education is a pretty strong proof of that.
- joelegner 3y agoThe law has far more power over corporations than society has over parents and parents have over children. We are better off doing what is most effective: regulate the industry.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoI think you over-estimate how much control parents do have, or even should have, over their own children.
- throw_m239339 3y ago> What if you consider social media to be like cigarettes? Well, then people should show some ID before using the internet or something to prove they are adults? How do you enforce that? at the ISP level? at the device level? At the website level? Genuine question. Who's responsibility is that? In a society where nobody wants to be responsible for anything?
- geraldwhen 3y agoTo buy ammo online, you need to upload a photo of your drivers license. It’s much, much cheaper to buy ammo this way. So there are regulated industries where age restriction is already being handled.
- DirectorKrennic 3y agoI don't see regulators pushing for Meta and Google to be broken up, or for ISPs to nuke TikTok in the USA. It's been talked about for years but nothing ever happens.
- joelegner 3y agoI took it to mean the age restrictions and restrictions on advertising to kids, not an anti-trust action.
- maxbond 3y agoI don't think parents can just keep their kids off of social media, at least teens. How are they supposed to function socially if they're not even able to enter the spaces where a huge amount of the socializing is happening? What about during the pandemic, when it was virtually all online? If the goal is to promote their mental health and their growth, cutting them off from their peer group doesn't seem like a promising strategy. It seems silly to blame the parents when the world has shifted around them, outside of their control.
- geraldwhen 3y agoMany teens did not isolate. They had no reason to. Virtual relationships are low value, and I encourage my kids to do things in person.
- maxbond 3y agoWell those are certainly views you're entitled to. Many of my most meaningful friendships have been with people I've never met in person. Teens are/were able both to contract and to spread COVID, which are two excellent reasons they might have isolated during the stay at home/shelter in place advisories. That said, encouraging your kids to interact in person seems reasonable to me.
- gitowiec 3y agoThe space you call social media, is not a space where children learn social behaviours.
- maxbond 3y agoWhy do you say that? I'm part of one of the earlier cohorts (I assume) to go through high school on Facebook, and absolutely a huge part of my social life was on Facebook. I organized our senior ditch day on Facebook. My awkward first attempts at flirting were on Facebook. I'm not saying it's a good or healthy space for teens to socialize, but I do contend it's an important one.
- brightball 3y agoMy kids are in middle school. Almost all of their friends have no restrictions at all on phone use, electronics, video streaming, etc. A few have been on TikTok and Instagram since they were in 5th grade. The amount of pressure I hear to let them have Snapchat is constant. Regardless, we maintained the restrictions. Apple Family makes it fairly easy to manage. Xbox controls are a little more of a pain but they work too to moderate. I’ve talked to my kids about the addictive and psychological elements of how certain games work or videos. They listened but didn’t understand. Last week, they started talking to me about how a lot of their friends have a phone in front of their face all the time and they see what we’ve been trying to warn them about. It was a struggle to get there but seeing that they finally really understood was big. The flip side though, the reason they understand is because they see people who have fallen victim to it. It’s like understanding why your parents warned you about drugs because you see what happened to your friend who fell into it. We know the consequences. At this point, parents shouldn’t have to spend so much time worrying about this. It’s not easy but it should be.
- mattgreenrocks 3y agoI am with you. I will die on this hill. Social media is toxic: it’s not real, it’s a waste of life when there’s tons of other awesome things you can do. And the legitimization of chasing Internet Points is truly sad.
- boppo1 3y agoI'm an illustrator/painter and instagram has been a MASSIVE net positive on my life. I have come across extremely useful products (allaprima pochade) and artists who provide unparalleled education. I have learned WAY more from artists I have found on instagram, and for a paltry $600 compared to the thousands I absolutely wasted on university classes led by professors who I discovered too late were incompetent.
- micromacrofoot 3y agothe sad thing is that in a lot of professions like this you need social media to promote your work
- TheAceOfHearts 3y agoOn one side parents who are likely overworked, on the other a group of corporation filled with some of the top minds of our era focused on building the most addictive product imaginable. The deck is stacked very strongly against parents and it's completely unreasonable to not hold greater accountability towards these massive corporations.
- wiseowise 3y agoHave you ever been a child? Kids don’t live in isolation.
- hnlmorg 3y agoAs a parent I can assure you that both things need to happen. It’s like how cigarettes weren’t allowed to be advertised to children. Sure, parents were responsible for teaching kids not to smoke but companies need to also be held accountable for the well-being of their product and it’s users too. It’s not an either / or. There is enough responsibility for all parties to be accountable.
- xg15 3y agoI think you can reformulate the old "bank debt" adage for social media and still have it hold true: If 10% of your users are using your product wrong, the users are at fault. If 90% are using it wrong, it's your fault.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rvz 3y agoFinally. Some action against the biggest tech companies of some sort, especially both Meta and TikTok the usual suspects. Also an unrelated note, do NOT browse this site without an ad-blocker. Just realized that The Verge has regressed in quality and is riddled with ads just like the Daily Mail.
- throw_m239339 3y ago> Finally. Some action against the biggest tech companies of some sort, especially both Meta and TikTok the usual suspects. Section 230. These lawsuits have zero merit until regulations change.
- baby-yoda 3y agoSection 230 protects against liability from user generated content. My understanding is the school is alleging the platforms operate in purposefully addictive and damaging behavior. IANAL of course but it sounds like the actions of the platform itself would be clearly outside of S230.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Hamuko 3y agoI feel like other countries might try to tackle these kinds of issues with legislation instead.
- gitowiec 3y agoI'm very happy that USA schools are trying to fight unsocial media. This is an example the world should take. For example, there is such a thing as parenting burnout. I as a father of 6 yo child which uses smartphone very rarely just to play two games we approved, am thinking too much about moment my child will start school. The moment where she will see most children have smartphones, use them without supervision and watch stupid videos. Support from schools would help me to worry less and allow me to feel that my child is safe.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoAnti-social media? When I was raising my daughters the smart phones didn't come until their peers hit middle school (their teens). They did the odd web-surfing (desktop) thing while in elementary school though. Are smart phones really in the elementary schools now?
- Lacerda69 3y ago[flagged]
- jdthedisciple 3y agoSmartphones are most definitely in elementary schools by now, correct. What's more, most of them will have TikTok and/or SnapChat installed.
- unnamed76ri 3y agoThey definitely are. What’s more, elementary kids already know what porn is and how to find it. My son was exposed to porn by other kids in 4th grade!
- Apfel 3y agoThis is probably a very european viewpoint, but I find it amazing how shocked people are by children seeing porn, but don't bat an eyelid when kids are exposed to violence on television or in movies. The biggest example from my own childhood was WWE (WWF at the time). The simplicity of the scripts etc seemed to be explicitly targeted towards kids who would then, predictably, try to copy the wrestling moves on their friends. It's a million times more harmful than seeing the human body sans garments. Obviously there are specific types of porn that I'd be mildly concerned by my child being exposed to, but generally speaking it's the violence and inherently problematic power structures within that are the fundamental issue, not the nudity.
- gsatic 3y agoHere is the latest UN economist network report on the Attention Economy - https://www.un.org/sites/un2.un.org/files/attention_economy_feb.pdf https://www.un.org/sites/un2.un.org/files/attention_economy_... Its not enough to sue them. They need to be drastically rearchitected.
- endisneigh 3y agoThese lawsuits make no sense. The schools can already ban phone usage and have no authority to dictate things outside classrooms. 1st amendment will squash these (and if they didn’t you should be concerned at the implication). But since we are filing ridiculous suits they should sue fast food companies and junk food ones as well. It’s already well established that poor nutrition affects student outcomes significantly. They should also sue state governments for blocking housing too since student homeless is a problem.
- xg15 3y agoThat might actually be a good idea, considering the obesity crisis is well-known.
- llamaimperative 3y agoWhat legal theory is that? The whole point of lawsuits is to exercise power over things you don’t have direct control over. And that’s a good thing.
- kristiandupont 3y ago>These lawsuits make no sense Do you mean legally? Because ethically, I think they make perfect sense. And I would think similar about going after fast food companies and possibly other industries.
- ifdefdebug 3y agoSince it's a lawsuit, there is unfortunately only one way for it to make sense: legally.
- kristiandupont 3y agoI guess you and I disagree on what "make sense" entails.
- bthrn 3y agoThe first amendment only applies to state actors. I’m not sure why it’s so frequently used broadly as a blanket for free speech in any context.
- wiseowise 3y agoLong overdue.
- paganel 3y ago[flagged]
- woodruffw 3y agoNot to spoil the good time here, but where’s the standing? I don’t think the courts have ever broadly recognized schools’ standing with respect to things that can harm students outside of the school’s walls. I would think that the appropriate regulatory tool here is having each school (or district) institute bans on device use during school hours, not suing random companies.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoNot a lawyer, but I think you are right that the case will end up hinging on this; my guess is that the argument will be that having a whole bunch of messed up social-media addicts at school is disruptive to the educational environment, preventing them from fulfilling their mission.
- woodruffw 3y ago> my guess is that the argument will be that having a whole bunch of messed up social-media addicts at school is disruptive to the educational environment, preventing them from fulfilling their mission. I don't think this is wrong per se, but it's hard to see a court accepting that broad environmental concerns of this sort fall under schools' purviews. Put another way: if schools can sue social media companies for disrupting the educational environment, what stops them from suing oil companies for making the world uninhabitable for their students? The problem isn't factuality (the school is arguably correct in both cases!), but scope.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoI would venture to guess they are suing BECAUSE they can’t do anything else I’ll tell you that for the schools that my kids go to, parents would most likely throw a massive tantrum if they banned phones. Beyond that…it wouldn’t work and would either be ignored and just another mis-applied or selectively punished thing or further turn every school into prison-lite. In reality the entire school system is a sham intended to be public day care so that parents don’t have any reason they can’t go to work. So anything that would functionally work to improve education is orthogonal at best.
- topper-123 3y agoIMO social media should age check by law. The problem with parental control is that it’s very difficult to say no, if the child’s friends are on socal media. Let the social media do age controls, by law.
- ValleZ 3y agoHow?
- jdthedisciple 3y agoAnd as a result have everyone upload their personal identification to some untrustworthy corporate database? Thanks but no thanks. There ought to be better solutions. My view is that it's a question of culture. In particular, the eradication of any sort of authority (parents, teachers) and the worshipping of "I want, therefore it's good and my right" are among the root causes for this epidemic.
- filmor 3y agoHave age checking done by a trusted third party that only certifies the age check on the spot without storing any information (post office or sth like that?)?
- iakov 3y agoA government API / website to do the verification can work similar to OpenID - the end application doesn't know any PII, receiving a JWT with some basic info (name, age email) instead. Just something on top of my head, I'm sure that there are solutions to this. It's the political will and balls that are nowhere to be found...
- uncletammy 3y agoSorry, no. I don't trust a government API/website with my personal information. They collect and abuse the private data that I DON'T willingly give them access to. Imagine what they'd do with the data I do.
- ahahahahah 3y agoIt's crazy to me that people can't accept that most things have both positive and negative effects. Facebook was absolutely hated on for doing research into understanding and minimizing those possible negative effects. I mean, for fucks sake, attending schools themselves has been directly linked to increased suicides (https://fee.org/articles/new-study-shows-the-striking-correlation-between-school-attendance-and-youth-suicides/ https://fee.org/articles/new-study-shows-the-striking-correl... and https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/childrens-risk-of-suicide-increases-on-school-days/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/childrens-risk-of..., for example).
- vharuck 3y ago>Facebook was absolutely hated on for doing research into understanding and minimizing those possible negative effects. IIRC, the outcry was because Facebook was performing a psychological experiment without subjects' consent. That's considered unethical.
- jonnycomputer 3y agoNot just considered. Is.
- klysm 3y agoI agree, but the question of ethics is always predicated on whatever basis you are using to evaluate
- perihelions 3y agoAm I alone in thinking this is batshit crazy on a multidimensional fractal of levels? What possible standing does a school have in the relation between students and a third-party website? What possible resolution could one ask for, that doesn't trod all over the First Amendment like a rabid horse with muddy hooves? Also, how is "internet causes mental health issues" even an acceptable cause of action? It's just people speaking freely with each other. To say that's a "crisis" is to utterly reject the free-society value that people speak freely with each other, that that's everyone's inalienable, unquestionable right. It's unvarnished authoritarianism. (And yet again, if people are contemplating this direction of authoritarian control, it's simply because they perceive a small crisis, and don't know how else to answer it besides brute force. (But all of civilization is a series of little emergencies; if you start thinking in policy in terms of emergency measures, you'll never have normality again)).
- paulcole 3y agoit’s political grandstanding by someone who wants to run for office
- ineedausername 3y agoWere do you draw the line? What if social media design is malicious intentionaly and kids are so messed up that x school can't function anymore (hypothetically).
- ethanbond 3y agoWe have concepts like “the First Amendment” and “standing” and so on exclusively to build and maintain a strong society. All of these things are subject, at the end of the day, to the assessment of whether they are effective at preventing bad things and preserving good things. If, for example, 100% of people under the age of 18 commit suicide within one month of being on Instagram, these arguments correctly would not prevent action against Instagram. We’d simply find a way to prevent kids from going on IG while weakening as little as possible the First Amendment’s protections of things that are good for our society. The only point of debate here is where each individual draws the line. From my observation, it seems people who are close to children a lot (parents, teachers, medical professionals) have been screaming their fucking brains out about this problem in ever-increasing intensity for years and years. People who are not close to children (20-something year old tech workers and HN browsers) think it’s all made up.
- ZooCow 3y agoThe article is light on the actual allegations, but at least they link to the complaint [1] (so few articles do). The claims are: Public Nuisance, Negligence, and Gross Negligence. The special damage they claim to have suffered seems to primarily relate to expanding and diverting resources to deal with mental health issues of students. The table of contents of the complaint is a good summary of their assertions, including: Defendants’ apps have created a youth mental health crisis. Defendants target children as a core market, hooking kids on their addictive social media platforms. Children are uniquely susceptible to Defendants’ addictive apps. Defendants design their apps to attract and addict youth. Millions of kids use Defendants’ products compulsively. Defendants' defective products encourage dangerous "challenges." Defendants' defective social media apps facilitate and contribute to the sexual exploitation and sextortion of children, and the ongoing production and spread of child sex abuse material online. [1] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23832853-maryland-school-district-lawsuit?responsive=1&title=1 https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23832853-maryland-sc...
- isitmadeofglass 3y ago[dead]
- jonnycomputer 3y ago- Defendants’ apps have created a youth mental health crisis. Causality is really hard to establish, possibly impossible in this case. Nonetheless, there does appear to be a youth mental health crisis, and it arose around the time of the smart phone. https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/honestly-its-probably-the-phones https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/honestly-its-probably-the-phon... - Defendants target children as a core market, hooking kids on their addictive social media platforms. It certainly appears that way to me; but it would help to get actual documentation of intent. - Children are uniquely susceptible to Defendants’ addictive apps. There is a lot of science that says that teens are vulnerable to addiction; the dual systems view, a pretty influential perspective, is that sensitivity to reward (particularly social rewards) increases dramatically in adolescence, but cognitive control lags; this leads to an increase in exploration vs exploitation, which is adaptive, but risky. I think they are on strong ground here. - Defendants design their apps to attract and addict youth. Like the last, documentation of intent would be the best thing for the case. - Millions of kids use Defendants’ products compulsively. This is probably true. Adults too. Defense is going to say that its up to parents and guardians to police the use of these apps. That argument didn't work with cigarettes and alcohol, so I'm guessing won't work here eitehr. - Defendants' defective products encourage dangerous "challenges." This is true - Defendants' defective social media apps (a) facilitate and contribute to the sexual exploitation and sextortion of children, (b) and the ongoing production and spread of child sex abuse material online. I've denoted one as (a) and one as (b). (b) is undoubtedly the case. (a) is more culture-war-y, but its hard to argue that a lot of the viral video content is not sexxed up* * I'm no prude, but find it annoying that 90% of the reels that Facebook suggest to me are sexual in nature, and that the sexually arousing nature of the suggested videos grabs my eyeballs. I mean, it works. But, I don't want those kind of distractions when I'm scrolling to see what friends and family are up to. Oh look, my sister took her kids to the beach. Oh look, that couple is simulating sex on a picnic table! Oh look, Mom got her first ripe tomatoes!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tincanner 3y agoIt's absolutely beyond me that you can't block a YouTube channel.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tssva 3y agoThey are suing Google while also using Google for Education and issuing Chromebooks to students.
- Eumenes 3y agoSchool should be suing the FCC or congress for lack of action around social media ... This isn't about change though, its about $$, so yes, go after the companies to "do better"™
- jscipione 3y agoSocial media is not to blame here, HCPSS is to blame for for promoting homosexuality, sexual degeneracy, and radical gender ideology on its students. It is expected that students are angry, violent, and suicidal given the abuse they have experienced at the hands of the leftist authoritarians running this “school” and to a larger extent the whole country. https://www.hcpss.org/supports/lgbtqia-youth/ https://www.hcpss.org/supports/lgbtqia-youth/
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]
- JopV 3y ago“School district creates mental health crisis, shifts blame to Meta, Google and TikTok”