7 ms·
The newest college admissions ploy: paying to make your teen “peer-reviewed”
- vages 3y agoThis has been going on in South Korea for a while, but to the best of my knowledge, only as a service to your own children or relatives: https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20191023160207706 https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=201910231... Doing it in exchange for money may have been invented/popularized in the US.
- endisneigh 3y agoAs long as college is an acceptable, and legal signal to use in the hiring process nothing will ever change. It's prisoner's dilemma. The "better" schools will always incentivize more and more pathological behavior in order to get a competitive advantage. I propose that similar to age and gender, college name be no longer required as a criterion for job applications. If there is indeed an advantage of going to a better school than this will manifest itself in the actual interview process. If there is not, then it will be quickly realized that it doesn't make any sense to jump through these hoops to go to the better schools and thus the problem solved. It's unlikely to happen as most legislators in the USA went to the very same schools that one is attempting to gain admittance to - a clear conflict of interest.
- nordsieck 3y ago> I propose that similar to age and gender, college name be no longer required as a criterion for job applications. That's never going to work for specialized jobs. If you need a chemical engineer, than you need a chemical engineer. But I think this is a very good idea for all of those jobs that just say "4 year degree required" without any specialty. Honestly, I don't understand how such postings aren't already illegal under structural discrimination.
- endisneigh 3y agoNote: I said college name, not degree. You can and certainly should be able to say that you attained a Bachelor's of Science in Chemistry. Whether college is required at all is also an interesting discussion.
- joelfried 3y agoIt's a lot easier to lie about a degree if nobody knows where you got it. That seems like a fatal flaw to your plan.
- ceejayoz 3y agoTreat it like a drug test. Extend an offer contingent on degree verification.
- endisneigh 3y agoThat's already true of all criteria in your application. It would be handled during the background check.
- quadrifoliate 3y agoThis. We really don't need some complicated ZKP scheme. 10 minutes of an HR person's time is enough.
- adamsmith143 3y agoPlenty of jobs check your credentials before hiring already. It's not a significant burden.
- meowkit 3y agoZero Knowledge Proofs You get a degree. You can prove that you got the degree from an accredited university, if that university is providing some cryptographic form of that degree, without revealing the name of that university. This only works if multiple universities sign on to a ZKP scheme, because (obviously) if only a single university did this you would know which university it was. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-knowledge_proof# https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-knowledge_proof#
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoProblem is, that'll just shift competition somewhere else. This has already happened in Tech to some extent, where the interview process has gone exponential in just the last few years. We need to aim closer to the root, at the economic concentrations in society that all this competition is about trying to access. In a world of independent artisans, we wouldn't need to worry so much about all this status and hierarchy and gatekeeping. But there are a handful of FAANGs that reign unnaturally like giant totalitarian states. It's like we have Oceania, Eurasia, and Eastasia, when we're supposed to have The Netherlands, Italy, Thailand, Vietnam, and so on. Instead it's like some Tsar expanding over the whole of Eurasia. And you need to get into the bastard's court.
- endisneigh 3y agoThe shift is good. It is more meritocratic imo.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoI do see your point. But I feel we only need to look at, say, passing the exams to get into IIT, or at the South Korean school system, to see where this leads. At some point it's just too much, and it doesn't matter how fairly the Hunger Games are administered. Let me put it another way: It's extremely destructive to a society if too much effort is channeled into zero-sum competition within that society.
- thfuran 3y ago>This has already happened in Tech to some extent, where the interview process has gone exponential in just the last few years. What does that mean?
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoMostly rhetoric, but it gestured towards some mathematical/modeling intuition. I was picturing a graph with time on the x axis, difficulty on the y, and a fairly constant value until recently, at which point things began to increase rapidly. I had in mind instability and explosion, a mania like for tulips, and self-destructive involution, like a society locked in competition with itself to pass the Emperor's exams. Why an exponential? I know that, in contrast, finance people speak of things going "parabolic". But there may be reason for literal exponentials, for dx/dt = x. It's not that difficulty begets difficulty, but that difficulty arises from economic concentration and concentration of opportunities, and economic concentration begets economic concentration.
- CPLX 3y agoThis is stupid. We can just demand, or even mandate, that colleges not suck so hard. They've basically turned into hedge funds at this point, we have quite a bit of leverage as a society and we don't have to let all this stuff happen. I'm exhausted by the current narrative that says we can't demand excellence from public institutions. Like why not. Why can't universities, the police, the department of homeless services, or the guys who regulate airplane safety not be competently run and effective at improving society? Why can't we improve them?
- endisneigh 3y agoBy what criteria do they suck? Regardless, it doesn’t seem relevant to what I’m suggesting. Even if colleges were perfect there were still be disparities if only due to the student demographics and the problem in the OP would still exist.
- CPLX 3y agoThey hoard tens of billions of dollars tax free and use that money to fund private equity firms who buy and destroy American jobs, while becoming an increasingly bloated service firm for the richest American families, and are almost complexly divorced at this point from their original public purpose of academic progress and educating the next generation.
- endisneigh 3y agothis seems completely irrelevant to the article, and still has nothing to do with school quality. what you're saying could be true and still be an academic powerhouse.
- CPLX 3y agoI was responding to this: > college name be no longer required as a criterion for job applications By saying maybe we could, instead, try to improve the reputations of our best colleges so the signal would be valid.
- dfadsadsf 3y agoI think this is already happening, to some extent. Back in the day, all the smart folks would flock to a handful of top universities. But now, things are changing. The reliance on SAT and merit is decreasing, and universities are focusing more on DEI when admitting students. This means that the cream of the crop won't be concentrated in just a few elite schools anymore. As a result, companies will start looking beyond the usual suspects and consider a broader range of candidates when hiring.
- jacknews 3y agoSeems ridiculous to me, why would teens even have peer-reviewed papers, or even papers, to their name? Pretty much only because of this scam - so an automatic 'fraud' signal IMHO.
- dangwhy 3y agosame reason teens "volunteer" in local hospital around their application time . Incentives.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Seems ridiculous to me, why would teens even have peer-reviewed papers, or even papers, to their name? The same reason they'd have any number of other (real, non-scam) competitive advantages in applications, a combination of aptitude and privilege allowing it to be recognized and to have the opportunity to exploit it.
- adamsmith143 3y agoPlenty of teens have legitimate papers. Probably not first author but it's not hard to believe that an IOM Medalist could contribute to a Mathematics paper or an Intel Science winner would contribute to a Biology paper e.g.
- AlanYx 3y agoThe tragedy here is that widespread abuses will water down the signal for those few high school students who do legitimately contribute to research. My wife worked in an academic hospital affiliated lab during her PhD, and every summer they had several of these children of lab friends "volunteering" as research assistants. Some were so colossally incompetent, messing up equipment or never showing up, etc. it was a net productivity loss.
- parpfish 3y agoThe "i have to volunteer so i can get into med school" crowd was the worst
- 3y ago
- jqpabc123 3y agoLooks like something that could be easily addressed by colleges if they chose to. Simply ignore publications for the obvious reason --- they are easily faked and authorship is suspect. Problem solved.
- dragonwriter 3y agoColleges have an incentive not to promote the idea that publications are irrelevant because they are easily faked and authorship is suspect, though. And the better a college is perceived to be in the current higher ed environment, the stronger that incentive is.
- bell-cot 3y agoWhat "problem"? The applicants with papers are demonstrating that their families have plenty of money, that they are eager to game the college admissions system, and that they're happy to genuflect before the alter of academic elitism. What better signals could there be, for the sort of applicants who colleges actually want to admit? Edit: Okay, if a kid's family bought him an Axiom Space ticket or few, that'd clearly be better.
- rayiner 3y agoHaving reviewed articles can be a legitimate signal. My brother started working in high school on research that was ultimately published in a peer reviewed physics journal. (Maybe if he’d gotten that article out before graduation he wouldn’t have gotten dinged at MIT.) But he only had that opportunity because he went to an elite public school in Virginia that had a program to get students internships with the dozens of defense industry research labs in the area. Not exactly something that’s available to folks in Iowa, where my wife went to high school. And getting published in a non-science journal probably provides a much weaker signal. For cultural reasons, lots of families wouldn’t even think it would be worthwhile to have their kid published in say a social science journal. (My dad, who has a sociology degree, told me in no uncertain terms that I wasn’t allowed to major in the subject.) Really it’s another reason that college admissions should just be based on test scores and grades. If the kids are poor—give them an $1,000 scholarship to take an PowerScore class. (That’s just a fraction of what even poor school districts spend on each student annually.) Everything else is so wildly subjective or unevenly available to kids around the country.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoThis is why I'm so skeptical that de-prioritizing SAT/ACT scores will make college admissions more equitable. Yes, the SAT favors rich applicants who can afford to pay for (and spend time on) test prep. Unfortunately, rich applicants can also pay to boost whatever other signal is used by the admissions committee. Extracurriculars? Those violin lessons didn't pay for themselves! High School internship? Consider which families have the connections to find those opportunities. And now research papers... I actually think standardized test scores are considerably less subject to bias than anything else! IMO, the only actual solution is to specifically consider socioeconomic background as part of the admissions process. But everyone hates that because it feels unfair. And it is unfair, but that's the point—any system we come up with will be unfair, so we have to find the least-unfair one.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> High School internship? Which families have the connections necessary to find those opportunities? Less connections than being able to get to and from a non-paying internship.
- atdrummond 3y agoThe good news is that test prep seems to have a very small effect: https://nepc.colorado.edu/sites/default/files/Briggs_Theeffectofadmissionstestpreparation.pdf https://nepc.colorado.edu/sites/default/files/Briggs_Theeffe...
- andrewprock 3y agoThere are a number of papers making related claims. The typical conclusion is: test prep helps, but paying for test prep is only marginally better than self study. For some strange reason they are often summarized as "test prep had no effect".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 3y ago
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoHuh, the rage was filing for patents when I was in school. Surprisingly, it still looks like a niche and thus advantageous tactic.
- zachlatta 3y agoI run a nonprofit for teenagers called Hack Club (https://hackclub.com https://hackclub.com). We often get groups like this trying to sponsor our events and buy emails of our students. It's disgusting. We also sometimes get their counselors trying to "collaborate" with us to get one of their projects published. The competitive college application process and supporting industry of consultants is creating a generation of sociopaths. We are teaching young people that the way to get ahead in life is to lie, cheat, steal, exaggerate, and hire consultants to help you do it with class. Over the past few months, I have spoken with some of the admissions leaders behind "top" institutions. They say that in many cases, it's hard for them to tell the difference between these applicants and "real" applicants. Most CS programs still don't even look at the GitHubs of applicants!
- Ekaros 3y agoI don't see how github would be good indicator of anything. One could buy one when they come popular. Maybe even let it run for year or two with regular automated commits to make it look reasonable. With AI generating content would be simpler than ever...
- 11101010001100 3y agoAs a prof, I'll be adding my 3 year old as co-author to a few of my papers. No shame in my game.
- dangwhy 3y agoAll the names in the linked papers are Indian ( and Chinese) . My boy is half indian and we are thinking of moving to school dist with 90% indian Americans. I have this gnawing feeling that he might face brutal pressure to compete,strive and could make him a less happy child. I don't know what to make of it.
- questime 3y agoJust make your kid identify as hispanic/black/native american and take it easy. This is what more and more people are doing - look at Census data.
- Barrin92 3y agoA year ago or so when China did a major crackdown on ed-tech and the private tutoring and education sector I read a lot of outraged stuff about it, but this kind of thing is the logical end result. A 17 year old writing a fake paper on chick-fil-A, 'peer-reviewed' by some non-existent degree mill to get a leg up on completely opaque college admissions. Just make it simple. Stick with the SAT tests. There is nothing more equitable than standardized, rigorous testing. It will not be perfectly equitable because people do differ in their abilities, but they do differ less on that front than their parents wallets do. Which is of course why it's the more privileged households that love lobbying for these bogus qualifications instead of just doing merit based tests. Just remember a simple fact, intellect is distributed on a Bell curve, money follows a power law distribution. Whenever you're concerned that merit based processes may have unequal results, anything that can be turned into pay-to-win is going to be worse.
- Ekaros 3y agoAnd if SAT is a bad test. Come up with better one. Just need to get enough schools to sing up for one at same time. Then just run same test in multiple locations at one time and allow using the results everywhere.
- dfadsadsf 3y ago> 'peer-reviewed' by some non-existent degree mill That's what poor people will do and it is easy to filter for degree mills. Upper middle class people will pay PhD students to add their kid name to decent papers as second author. Rich people will pay PhD post doc to put their kid as first or sole author. Billionaires will sponsor Nobel laureate lab and have kid as co-author on ground breaking paper that will get 1000+ citations in first year.
- parpfish 3y agoFrom time to time the media will release puff pieces about a "genius" high school student that discovered something/invented something/won some national science fair "with the help of a local university lab/professor". I used to think that these actually were genius kids that spent their free time pursuing scholarly pursuits and somehow befriending professors. But what I've seen happen (multiple times) is that a lab PI convinces one of their grad-students/post-docs that "it would be a great mentorship opportunity for you to have <highshool student that just so happens to be my friend's kid> finish up that project you've been working on". The end result is that some well-connected kid gets credit for the whole project on their applications, but the grad-student/post-doc that has already done 95% of the work just has to hand it over and can't use/publish their own experiment
- philipkglass 3y agoMy personal anecdotes: I came to know some of these "genius" kids from a forum I used to run. They really were quite bright and had unusual interests on top of that. Of course they also came from financially comfortable families that could afford to build a home laboratory. Their financial peers had parents who would give children international vacations or horse riding lessons; their parents bought them used industrial/scientific equipment from eBay. They exited high school early and went on to R1 research universities.
- zwieback 3y agoPut yourself in the position of an elite school and it makes a lot more sense: who would you rather get, the student who gets decent grades and worked a part time job during high school or the kid of parents who can afford these signaling activities? To pay off all the fancy amenities I would go with the kid with the rich parents 100% of the time.
- sliken 3y agoThere does seem to be a general misunderstanding of what Peer-Reviewed means among the public. At my kids highschool there was an AIM program for harder classes for the academically inclined. A parent's kid didn't get in, they decided to write up a piece on how AIM should be killed. They showed it to another parent, called it peered reviewed, and submitted it to the school. The school at a meeting after they turned off the cameras decided to fire the lead teach and kill the program. All without any discussion, because it was a "peer reviewed" "paper".
- xg15 3y ago> The first reader “is very young and in almost all cases majored in humanities or social sciences,” said Jon Reider, a former admissions officer at Stanford. “They can’t tell if a paper in the sciences means anything or is new at all.” Ouch.