11 ms·
This almost got me into a serious accident, twice. Definitely would not recommend and I switched cars because of it. The last thing I need is buggy software wit
by jacquesm 3y ago
This almost got me into a serious accident, twice. Definitely would not recommend and I switched cars because of it. The last thing I need is buggy software with the capability of instantly changing the trajectory of my vehicle (slippery surfaces, cornering). A brand car as well (MB) so really, really disappointed, what should have been a safety feature actually was the opposite. Dealer said everything was fine so that was the end of that car, if 'fine' means that you have a couple of close calls in the first few thousand km on account of a feature that can't even be properly disabled without sabotaging the electronics then that's just too bad.
Now I drive a 27 year old car that has none of these 'features'. It does what I tell it to and when I tell it to, it doesn't phone home, and has no touch screen, but old fashioned buttons.
If the government wants to immediately improve car safety they should outlaw touchscreens instead.
- jo6gwb 3y agoTouchscreens first, quickly followed by excessively bright, flickering, and aftermarket headlights.
- ddalcino 3y agoWould you care to elaborate on what went wrong? The other comments here make ‘automatic emergency braking’ sound like a really good idea, and it’s hard for me to imagine that this particular feature would be so problematic. If you’re talking about other automatic steering features, that’s very different, and your comment makes more sense to me.
- burgerzzz 3y agoI’ve had the automatic breaking in my Jeep take effect needlessly, which can be quite jarring
- lsaferite 3y agoMy Kia has AEB, Lane Keeping, and Adaptive Cruise Control. They have false positive type events from time to time, but generally you just know when it's going to happen. The first couple of times it was a shock, but I've never had it trigger in such a way that I felt like it would cause an accident. That being said, you can't just leave it un attended. You're still the PiC of the vehicle.
- karaterobot 3y agoNot the person you were responding to, but here's an anecdatum: One time I was driving behind someone under otherwise normal conditions, and they turned right into a parking lot. As they turned right, they obviously began exiting the road. The screen on my car screamed "BRAKE!" and then the braking system activated. They were about 60% of the way into the parking lot, and continuing to exit. I was at a normal following distance, going a normal speed, and they were just making a right into a parking lot. This was a very ordinary situation, and the emergency warning was unexpected. Now, technically, if that car had completely stopped for some reason instead of continuing to exit, I guess I could have hit the back corner of the bumper. That is, if I hadn't, you know, shifted a couple feet to the left to avoid it. Ironically, the emergency braking alarm was so distracting that it might have caused me to hit the car in front of me if the brakes hadn't activated, and if I had needed to steer to avoid an accident. And if the person behind me hadn't seen my brakes suddenly activate, they might have hit me. Or, if the person behind them hadn't seen their brakes activate, they might have hit them. And so on.
- bgentry 3y agoI've had this exact situation happen on numerous occasions. It's always people turning into a parking lot ahead of me, in a situation where they will absolutely be out of the way long before I reach them, but also I'm actively shifting to the side to go clearly around them anyway. In none of the situations was there any chance of an accident even if the turning car stopped suddenly instead of completing its turn. And this has happened to me on multiple different vehicles. Each time it happens my immediate reaction is "what the hell is wrong with my car" before I see the "BRAKE" on the dash or heads up display and realize this happened yet again. I'm surprised I haven't been rear ended on account of it yet.
- lsaferite 3y agoI fully understand that frustration, but I would point out that continuing through the departure zone like that at full speed is prone to accidents with another car entering the road in that blind spot and you should adjust accordingly. Additionally, following the car in front of you so close that you hit them if they brake suddenly is inherently dangerous and a bad habit as well. Interestingly enough, a universal AEB requirement on all vehicles would help in that scenario.
- jacquesm 3y agoI've detailed this in older comments, in a nutshell the first time was on a wet bridge where the car mistook the return of the bridge supports for an imminent crash causing the car to go into a spin (and on a narrow bridge that could have ended really badly, especially because of those supports). I had the car checked out and it was declared healthy, and that it must have been something spurious. A short while later it did it again, this time in a corner where an advertising sign was placed such that oncoming traffic could read it, again the car braked violently resulting causing some loss of control so it swerved into the oncoming lane. Fortunately no traffic there. I sold it right after and won't be buying another MB, ever. They've really lost the plot if they believe that this sort of thing is acceptable in a production vehicle for their regular clientele.
- r00t4ccess 3y agoNot the poster Vw golf r 2016 the sensor was low to the ground and it would randomly brake for stuff it thought was a threat like a cardboard box. Subaru crosstrek 2018 - would brake for no reason, cars turning up ahead of me, etc. VW atlas 2019 - brake for no reason would also scream at me and show a red symbol on the hud when nothing was in the road in front of me. Subaru impreza 2023 - brakes for turning vehicles up the road, had it brake in a car wash. On my vw vehicles i bought a can bus programmer so i could turn off as much if the safety stuff as possible because it made the car less safe to drive. In the impreza (current car) turning off the eyesight features is part of the pre-drive ritual. I also had the lane assist on the crosstrek almost cause an accident on the highway at speed. Roads here are inconsistent and it was violently jerking the wheel trying to stay between lines.
- jacquesm 3y agoWhy not get a car without that stuff?
- r00t4ccess 3y agoI got what was available at the time. The golf r is low production car finding one to buy was hard enough. The crosstrek the only orange one available had eyesight. The atlas was used so there was only 1 option locally The impreza its standard on anything over base, and the base was missing other things i wanted.
- jacquesm 3y agoOk, that makes sense. I just bought a 1997 car and had it rebuilt, about 30% of the price of a new one and none of the crap, roughly just as safe as the current ones and much less likely to be stolen. Not the most economical decision because of course it is still a 1997 car but it will hold its value well enough that I'm not worried about it and I'm not really planning on selling it anyway. But if I ever do crash it then I'll probably lose a bunch of money because the present day value is less than what I put into it. Otoh just the write-off on a new one would have been roughly the total invested. It's very frustrating how tech can be mis-applied. But I also see the regulators point of applied statistics and that even if these systems cause the occasional crash they prevent a much larger number from ever happening.
- pdonis 3y ago> The other comments here make ‘automatic emergency braking’ sound like a really good idea That's because those other comments all assume that "automatic emergency braking" will only do exactly what it's supposed to do and will never make a mistake. But any sensible person knows that's not going to happen. These systems will make mistakes, and some of those mistakes will cause harm. So you can't just make a blanket claim that such systems are good. You have to actually look at the data and balance the harm they avoid by doing what they're supposed to do when they're supposed to do it, against the harm they cause when they make mistakes. The obvious next question is, does the proposed rulemaking here consider the consequences of the system making mistakes? As far as I can tell, the answer is no, with just one qualifier. The claims about crashes prevented and lives saved are not net savings, accounting for harm done by the system making mistakes; those claimed numbers assume the systems will always perform perfectly and will never cause any harm, only prevent it. The one qualifier is that the proposal does include two "false positive" tests to try to spot systems that brake when they're not supposed to. But there is no analysis given to show why those particular false positive tests were picked or why they would justify the extremely high level of confidence in the systems not making errors that the rest of the proposal shows.
- hnick 3y agoI think there is one other aspect to consider. Over here at least, generally if someone rear ends you it's always their fault. The law says they were not maintaining a safe following distance. So from the perspective of the manufacturer they would probably say such mistakes should not by themselves cause problems unless someone else is breaking the law, no different to a human tapping the brakes because they thought they saw a kid about to run on the road but it was just a jacket stuck on a tree. You should be safe and free to brake without deep introspective thought, without fear of causing an accident. The real world is not that simple but that's how the law is generally setup. And as a further point they'd probably say that if that person following had such a system, there's also less chance they'd rear-end you in turn. I was wary of the systems in my own car, but after 6 months of driving they are far more reliable than I'd feared and I'm quite impressed.
- 3y ago
- marklubi 3y agoAnecdotal, but I was riding with my friend on the highway (~70 mph) with absolutely nobody in front of us, and the automatic braking kicked in out of nowhere. Thankfully the one other person on the road that was a bit behind us swerved and avoided rear ending us. After that experience, I don't want a vehicle with that functionality in it, and don't want other cars on the road having it. It's half-baked at best. It had happened enough times to him, and he complained to the dealership enough, that they bought the vehicle back from him. Who knows if these incidents were ever reported to the NHTSA since no physical collisions with other cars occurred.
- jacquesm 3y agoMake and model?
- marklubi 3y agoI know what it was, but I won’t participate in naming and shaming. The dealership tried to fix it several times, and I don’t know if this is a systemic problem, or a single vehicle issue. Either way, I don’t trust the tech. It can be developed and tested against plenty of different scenarios, but we live in a very uncontrolled and fluctuating environment.
- mattmcknight 3y agoWhat it keeps doing to my wife is stopping the car (Audi) in oncoming traffic when she is making a left turn from a median across a road that is two lanes in each direction. She is basically jamming the accelerator to go, and so it applies the brakes for a very hard stop, which once resulted in the car behind her not being able to stop.
- karaterobot 3y agoMost people I know buy older cars now. They're more fun, less cluttered with dumb features and technology. I get it. When I was shopping for a new car recently, all the salesmen talked about was how big the touch screens were. Cool, the manufacturer placed an order for a panel of a certain size, very impressive engineering there.
- nradov 3y agoThere appear to be major variations between manufacturers. I've driven many miles on a wide variety of roads in a Subaru and haven't experienced any false positive automatic braking incidents. However, the system does automatically disable itself (and warns the driver accordingly) in heavy precipitation so there is still significant room for improvement.
- jacquesm 3y ago> the system does automatically disable itself (and warns the driver accordingly) in heavy precipitation That would have saved me one of two incidents so Subaru may well be the one doing this right.
- pbnjeh 3y agoMy parents have a couple of newer Outbacks. My father, who's rather technical and pays close attention to these things, had commented repeatedly that he likes how Subaru appears to be more conservative in deploying new technology, but what they do deploy seems to be functionally solid and correct. (His opinion; YMMV.) Also, they still provide physical knobs and switches for the important things; that includes climate controls and, I believe, the stereo. I'm driving an 11 year old Forester and just as happy not to be dealing with all this crap quite yet. And the various satellite connectivity options on it have been left never activated.
- hnick 3y agoWhen shopping for a new car Subaru was very proud of its dual-camera setup, I don't know if it's actually better but they make a lot of noise about it. Maybe there is some truth to it.
- tacticalturtle 3y agoAnecdotally, I’ve been driving a 2019 Forester for the past few years, and every year or so - I’ve had an experience where taking an exit off the highway, it detects an object that isn’t there, and starts beeping and throwing up red warnings. From what I can recall, it’s never gotten to the point of engaging the brake, but it’s super unsettling every time it happens.
- nzrf 3y agoFully agree. As it is fine most the time it comes back to the other part where it is wrong. Example: living in cold weather climate my outback just stops cuts the engine when exhaust from the car leaves car in front of me on cold day( large cloud of vapor). The visual collision avoidance detects this as car and cuts the engine. This is not the place you want to be leaving an intersection with people accelerating behind you. Unless this backed by lidar / radar or combination that is more accurate I don’t see this as pro. Top reason I can’t stand my outback is the decisions it makes incorrectly. Of course there is no way to get any of this fixed in my outback other than selling it. Consumers are getting the shaft on technology in their cars imo and are being treated as test pilots.
- ics 3y agoI wrote up a long comment that got scrapped by my focus filter but I feel the need to voice strong agreement here. I have a recent Mazda which in almost all ways is my perfect car except for the newfangled safety features all new cars seem to have. Lane correction and emergency braking, even set to the lowest sensitivity levels, are bad to outright dangerous in city (and some country) driving. In NYC it's common to have multiple road lines crossing during construction which by default has lead my car to try steering into cyclists or barriers. It can't read the lane because the lane is not properly marked but that's typical. So I disabled it. Emergency braking is a bit harder for me to understand when it kicks in but I've done whatever I can to keep it off. Twice it caused a hard brake in the middle of traffic with my newborn in the back and almost got me rear-ended. Another time it detected another car ahead of me but technically in the next lane and warned that it was about to hard brake in the rain on the Williamsburg Bridge inner roadway which is... tight to say the least. If there's a future where these features are rigorously tested for worst case scenarios in different driving environments and somehow universally implemented across manufacturers... maybe.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> I wrote up a long comment that got scrapped by my focus filter I've been making productive use of the "textarea cache" extension lately. Sites and browsers lose text a lot more often than they should.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat sounds like there is a lot of commonality between the two cases that I had and the ones that you have experienced. My car was a Mercedes Benz C class July 2014 issue. The AEB relies on a lot of gear supplied by Bosch (I dug into it a bit to see if it could be disabled without surgery but that wasn't possible). Maybe Mazda has the same unit? (it sits behind the front license plate and there is a camera behind the windscreen).
- ics 3y agoI'm not sure of the exact sensor. There is a little more info on it here for example (https://www.mazdausa.com/static/manuals/2021/mazda3/contents/05200101.html https://www.mazdausa.com/static/manuals/2021/mazda3/contents...) but I can confirm the sensor placement is the same behind the windscreen, the lower one I think is by the badge. I wish they'd just made dashcam a standard feature instead and forget about trying to throw me through the windshield for shits and giggles.
- brookst 3y agoI had an Audi that would emergency brake on the freeway if it was raining and there was a semi in the next lane. Terrifying. Now I drive another car that will hit the brakes in parking garages when going around corners if cars have backed in and I am going 5mph or more. I've learned to drive 4mph in parking garages.
- Eumenes 3y agoI had a very similar problem - a mouse ate through my wiring harness and it was tripping my brakes lights out, which the ECU thought I was braking, and I couldn't accelerate. Took the dealer like 5 trips to figure it out. Insurance covered it. Btw, where'd you find that old car? Locally or get it shipped to you?
- jacquesm 3y agoLocally.
- dmead 3y agoI just had to junk my 18 year old Buick sedan. Everything sucks now. Even mid range cars reek of the electronics being obsolete or broken in 5 years.
- notatoad 3y agothis seems like the sort of thing that would be better measured with actual numbers, not just anecdotes from people on the internet. the NHTSA is a pretty cautious organization, and they like numbers. if they've studied it and found that automatic braking will prevent 24000 crashes and 360 deaths per year, i'd be inclined to believe them. having the car brake for me when i'm not expecting it sounds kind of scary to me too, but i'd rather experience that than let 360 people die every year.
- JohnFen 3y agoI agree. I also agree with this: > If the government wants to immediately improve car safety they should outlaw touchscreens instead.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoThe problem with numbers is that they don't tell the whole story. I can easily imagine a scenario where it might prevent 25000 crashes a year that are caused because 5% of drivers are staring at their phones, have a high chance of rear-ending someone, and this software makes that far less likely. While also containing bugs causing 1000 crashes a year for the larger number of non-distracted drivers, resulting in a net change of 24000. This would mean that adding the software would be better for society, while making the majority of drivers slightly more likely to crash into someone.
- ak217 3y agoI've driven hundreds of thousands of miles in cars of 3 makes (Mazda, Subaru, Nissan) with AEB systems and they never once had a false activation, while the feature did save me from several serious accidents. The Nissan is also nice enough to warn early so I can react before the AEB kicks in. Properly implemented AEB is an essential safety feature that saves lives.
- dorfsmay 3y agoAre you talking about emergency braking or lane assist? We've disabled lane assist on our car as it seems to always take the wrong action, but we've never had an issue with the emergency brake which is the subject of the article.
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoAlso the damn side collision avoidance which is active for way too long post-overtake.
- jquery 3y agoI have an MB and AEB has been nothing if not extremely useful. It saved me from hitting a pedestrian who I didn't see, thank god.
- solfox 3y agoMy MB van also has similar serious issues with buggy auto-braking. Once, while driving head-on into a bright sun, it decided it was time to apply full brakes while driving highway speeds on a busy highway, in a vehicle with a GVWR of around 9,500 lbs. That wasn't fun and could have easily caused an accident involving multiple cars. My Tesla, which is probably the leader here, regularly makes mistakes - though never really to the point of forcing braking. Often it will warn me on my narrow street of objects like parked cars it thinks I will hit, but it seems a little more polished than MB. If regulators want to force this on all car manufacturers, they really need to also mandate certain tests and features - plus OTA updates to recall any bugs... My guess is that most car makers just don't have the workforce to develop these features, so forcing them to roll them out will mean even worse bugs!
- midoridensha 3y ago>they really need to also mandate certain tests and features - plus OTA updates to recall any bugs OTA updates for braking systems will result in hackers wreaking havoc. The security implications of this are enormous; it's like putting your country's nuclear reactors on the internet. Updates should only be done in-person at the dealership, for free.
- HPsquared 3y agoThey would need to mandate certain security requirements then. So the rule needs a rule to fix it, which needs another rule to fix that, and so on.
- tempestn 3y agoAgreed here too. Pretty much all my experiences with these kinds of features have been poor. I turned off the emergency breaking on our Tesla after it slammed on the brakes for no reason on the highway a couple of times. Could easily cause someone to rear-end you. I also recall a Kia I rented once that had automatic lane keep assist and blind spot warnings. The blind spot warning was so sensitive that it would loudly beep at you if there was another vehicle anywhere near you in the other lane when you put your turn signal on. Not helpful, and quite distracting. The lane keep assist was worse, because the way it pulled on the wheel any time you approached the edge of a lane (which it turns out you do often in the course of regular driving for all kinds of reasons - another car crowding you, giving room to a cyclist, taking a smoother line through a corner, etc.) felt very much like losing traction. It was quite disconcerting, and I could see it causing someone to overcorrect and lose control. And to paraphrase Matt Farah, if you need assistance to keep in your lane, you shouldn't be driving. All that said, I do like the autosteer on the Tesla, with the caveat that you need to treat it like cruise control, NOT like "autopilot". And I'll pretty much only use it on divided highways. In other situations its insistence in sticking to the dead center of the lane can be disconcerting at times (like the ones I listed above!)
- eternityforest 3y agoDo you have experience with non-tesla autobrake? Doesn't Tesla have a bunch of "We don't need radars, cameras only" stuff holding back their capability?
- toweriu34234 3y ago[flagged]
- jojobas 3y agoAdd to that the ability to stop and rob cars with a roll of foil. Thanks, but no thanks.
- autoexec 3y agoHow would you stop a car with a roll of foil?
- panny 3y agoI'm so glad this is the top comment. Ghost braking is a far worse problem.
- graycat 3y ago> Now I drive a 27 year old car that has none of these 'features'. It does what I tell it to and when I tell it to, it doesn't phone home, and has no touch screen, but old fashioned buttons. I second your motion!!!! I was happy with my 1986 Chevy S-10 Blazer until it was badly rusted out by winter road salt. Now I have a 2001 GMC Yukon. I prefer the Blazer since the Yukon has too many attempts at automation and is too big. But apparently the new cars have so much in automation that they are to be avoided, and cars of the future promise to be worse still.
- jaredhallen 3y agoThere are good points here on both sides. I'm in your camp, personally. I'll probably always drive older cars, because that's just my preference, for many reasons. Maybe the answer is to require the feature on new vehicles, but also have the option to disable it. Most drivers probably wouldn't, but those that feel strongly about it would have the choice.
- 2h 3y ago> MB https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercedes-Benz https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercedes-Benz
- elif 3y agoIf suddenly braking causes an accident it's because someone was not following at an appropriate distance. You should always allow space for unforseen hazards. It's actually the law. If both cars have AEB even that unsafe condition becomes a non-issue. Just because humans have adjusted to regularly driving in an unsafe and illegal manner does not make it the safest way to use roads.
- ryandvm 3y agoEh, that's great for you (according to you), but for the millions of folks that are driving around staring at their phones, I am beyond thankful for this technology. I've been driving a Honda with the all the safety assists for several years and while it does do the occasional erroneous "you need to brake" pre-warning, I've never had it brake unnecessarily. Anecdotes aside, I'm fairly certain automatic braking is a net reducer of accidents.
- aio2 3y agoMay I ask why the respnsibility falls on the car instead of the driver on the phone in the first paragraph? Just like you are responsible if you used a gun, you are responsible on how you drive a car.
- ryandvm 3y agoBecause, like guns, it's obvious that the despite the fact that the actor _should_ be responsible, the consequences for failure to do so fall on everyone else. If my car has been destroyed by the driver behind me because they were looking at their phone, it's little consolation that they shouldn't have.
- alvah 3y agoSame here, in the last 18 months 2 different VAG cars have hauled the anchors on for no reason at all with me driving. Fortunately, I wasn't in traffic, but both cases would absoulutely have caused an unnecessary crash if there had been a car behind me. This technology will be great when it's ready, but the false positive detection rate is massively higher than would be acceptable.
- fennecfoxy 3y agoAutomakers are also terrible at writing software. But I do think these safety features are important if implemented correctly. I think the crux of the issue is: when someone _is_ paying attention, safety measures feel like they overreact and get in the way of subtle human reactions to things happening. If the driver is _not_ paying proper attention, then the safety systems are the only thing that react in time. I feel like this requirement is important, but requires better software, including lessening the impact of safety systems engaging when the drive has been actively steering/accelerating/braking during a period of time, making it obvious that they are indeed paying attention. But there are plenty of drivers who pay almost no attention at all, many people go into auto-mode when driving and aren't ashamed of it. I've almost been run over by drivers who have been directly looking at me before, then sudden braking when their eyes have stopped glazing over.
- nvarsj 3y agoOh yes, I tried a Honda E for a few months and the emergency brake system was incredibly liberal. I live in a city with lots of parked cars and unusual road dips/bumps. There was a turn into my kid's school road that would emergency brake about 20% of the time whenever I entered it. I almost got rear ended a couple times and it scared the crap out of me. On the other hand, maybe the benefits outweigh this drawback? Pedestrians get hit all the times by cars where drivers aren't paying attention (looking at their phone, etc.). So for the general population, it is probably a net positive.
- williamcotton 3y agoI want measurements like fatalities per 100 million miles driven to guide this conversation because there are so many emotionally driven reactions to Elon Musk and AI/ML that I can’t help but think that comments are motivated by things other than human safety! That being said, I do think that touch screens are a terrible design decision on almost all devices.
- _trampeltier 3y ago2 years ago, a brand new Audi (rental) tryed tro chrash me several times into tunnel walls. The car suddenly tryed always a hard right turn.
- Perepiska 3y agoMy wife owns a Nissan Qashqai. One day she complained that car started to brake on doing zip merge and this is dangerous on highways. The root of problem was combined back light with stop signal and blinker. Wires to stop signal and blinker suddenly soldered together and there was some current on stop signal wire on turning blinker on. Car's computer decided that brake switch near braking pedal is broken and started to brake. Fixed by cutting one of wires and using new wire around spoiled point.
- albrewer 3y agoI had mine (2018 VW Golf GTI) trigger when driving really fast on a very hilly road. Headed into a dip, the braking triggered at 70mph. Nearly gave me a heart attack.
- PaulHoule 3y agoMy son just got a job outside the house. He hated the looks of newer cars and with the current market a Honda Fit with 100,000 miles cost about as much as spent our current fit which was 30,000 when we got it. (Dealer had excuse why they didn’t have any new ones.) We found a 1996 Buick Park Avenue for less than $5k and keeping it running might be an adventure in maintaining American cars but boy is it a sweet car and it gets 29 mpg on the highway which is not bad at all for a large car.