8 ms·
401(k) Hardship Withdrawals Tick Up as Inflation Stays High
- sokoloff 3y agohttps://archive.is/pYTXo https://archive.is/pYTXo
- sokoloff 3y ago> an information technology worker in New York City, has taken money out of retirement accounts three times since the 2008 recession. He withdrew more than $50,000 to pay credit card debts, tuition for his six children to attend a religious school and, most recently, an overdue mortgage. “It was really a choice of saving the present versus securing the future,” he said. “My situation wasn’t someone who’s frivolous. Expenses were just more than I was making.” Raiding retirement accounts to pay for private school seems like a terrible idea. Credit card debt and overdue mortgage payments might be somewhat more understandable as reflecting a pinch of mandatory expenses growing faster than income, but I'm pretty sure that NYC public schools would provide an adequate enough education to not be worth the risk of having insufficient savings for retirement. If you can't pay your mortgage and credit cards, I'd consider private school to be an extravagant luxury that you literally can't afford at this time.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoHaving six kids does not help your finances living in a Tier 1 city (assuming you need at least a three bedroom for that sized family). Each one costs $250k-$300k to raise 0-18 (per Brookings) without accounting for daycare, private school, or college. Hard to have sympathy for the financially irresponsible. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2022/08/30/its-getting-more-expensive-to-raise-children-and-government-isnt-doing-much-to-help/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2022/08/30/its-getti... (2022) https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2017/01/13/cost-raising-child https://www.usda.gov/media/blog/2017/01/13/cost-raising-chil... (2017) https://gothamist.com/news/it-could-cost-you-500k-to-raise-a-child-in-nyc https://gothamist.com/news/it-could-cost-you-500k-to-raise-a... (2014) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33991744 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33991744 (additional citations from a previous comment)
- rootusrootus 3y agoThere's a lot of variability in those costs. A third of the estimate is just housing. It's not quite as simple as saying that each kid will cost you another $1400 out of pocket each month.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- svnt 3y agoThey easily will for the first six years of their lives in NYC, assuming both parents work.
- xenospn 3y agoFor a religious family with six children that is probably not the case.
- rootusrootus 3y agoOn what, though? Well over a thousand bucks a month per kid? The dollar figure specifically excluded daycare.
- pc86 3y agoNot trying to dispute anything here, as I don't think anyone sane would suggest it isn't expensive to have kids, but the Brookings article in particular is kind of hard to parse. $310k for kid #2 born in 2015 to a middle-income family. What's middle-income in this case? How does that change for higher income which would be more representative of HN readers? How does that change if it's kid #1 instead of 2? They also say "adjusted for higher expected future inflation" but don't say what numbers they're using. Elsewhere they say that inflation is increasing the cost by about $26k overall. Over 18 years that's $120/mo which for a $300k expense is pretty insignificant overall. And in general, I don't think people take cost into account for children this granularly. Who is looking at $290k over 18 years and thinks "yeah let's do it" then balks at $310k? Nobody.
- csomar 3y agoReligion, huh?
- 2023throwawayy 3y ago> “My situation wasn’t someone who’s frivolous.“ Sending 6 kids to a private religious school sounds extremely frivolous to me.
- pb7 3y ago>someone who is good at the economy please help budget this. my family is dying[0] [0]https://dril.fandom.com/wiki/Candles https://dril.fandom.com/wiki/Candles
- hobo_in_library 3y ago[flagged]
- axus 3y agoI'd say it depends on the quality relative to the other options. In some areas near me, people will choose a Catholic school even when they aren't Catholic. My own experience with a public vs religious elementary school was much better at the public school.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whimsicalism 3y agoI went to an inner city urban high school and anyone suggesting that you must withdraw from your 401k to send your kids to private school if you live in NYC is out of touch.
- MobiusHorizons 3y agoFrivolous would suggest the decision is not weighty. Religious schooling is considered very important to many people. It may not be the choice you or I would make, but I have a hard time imagining it as a casual choice.
- fundad 3y agoWhat do you think money is for?
- svnt 3y agoIf your social support depends on your membership in that community, which depends on your kids attending a similar school, you’ll dig deep to preserve it.
- whimsicalism 3y agoUh, no - there is no way paying for an urban day school through 401k withdrawals makes any financial sense.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoRight I think they're saying that someone's social/family/community life is more complex than a financial calculation. It's not about making this "make sense" in terms of endorsing it as an outsider, but about understanding what circumstances would lead to someone feeling like this makes sense for them.
- whimsicalism 3y agoI don't disagree that the person feels that this makes sense for them, but I am not confusing how this person feels with what they ought to be doing. At the limit case (and withdrawing from your 401k to support your 6 children going to private school is definitely a limit case), you can absolutely reason about what 'makes sense' and this simply is not it.
- fragmede 3y agoIf it leads to your kids into an upper echelon college like Harvard, which then sets up their trajectory for a very lucrative career, it seems entirely sane to me. The lifetime earning potential of a Harvard grad and chance of being the President is so much higher than someone who dropped out and maybe managed to get a GED later on in lift that it's not even funny.
- jknz 3y agoMillions of families make this reasoning and spend $30k or more per year and per kid from age 2. Very few of these kids make it to Harvard or other top 4 colleges, maybe 1 will become president. Sane Western countries have free and decent public education; and parents can't withdraw their future retirement early to fund dreams.
- whimsicalism 3y agoWow, what poor financial decision making. It's literally the dril candles joke but with religious private school instead of candles.
- fundad 3y agoI love how everyone assumes that man left $0 in retirement savings: "Now working in the public sector and paying into a pension..."
- whimsicalism 3y agoHe paid penalty on 401k withdrawals. I made no assumption that he left $0, but it is a stupid decision to pay 401k penalty in almost all situations.
- sokoloff 3y agoThe words immediately following your ellipsis are: "...Mr. Scharf, 55, calculates that if he retires at 70, he can draw 40 percent of his former salary." Working until 70 and even at that having only 40% of his former salary sounds like a pretty bad financial planning outcome, especially if you voluntarily put yourself into that situation.
- yardie 3y agoGetting a gauge on private schools in my experience is difficult because each family's situation is different. There are the typical non-denom prep schools which cost a car payment every year. And then there the private religious schools which are more of a sliding scale. Prices go down further if you have scholarships, being a member of their church, parent volunteer, etc.
- yamtaddle 3y agoI've seen $15k up to ~$50k /yr (non-boarding—I've seen boarding as high as $70k) The ~$15k ones tend to be Catholic or otherwise religious, and quality varies from "worse than the local public schools, actually" up to "notably better than the local public schools, though not as good as a really good private school". Some cheap secular schools are only a little more expensive than the bottom end of the religious ones, but they don't tend to be much better than average public-school quality (nb. that may still be a lot better than some particular public school district)
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoAlways take the opportunity to note that public schools cannot refuse anyone. Private schools can kick out low performers if it could help raise the average student performance on standardized tests.
- yamtaddle 3y agoYes, of course, they benefit hugely from the ability to select students. They're also less answerable to parents or the public than public schools, in many way, which can free them up to ignore stupid demands from parents (they select families, as much as they select students)—or free them up to maintain stupid policies or approaches that could never fly in public schools, which is sometimes exactly what their customers want (as in the case of e.g. fundamentalist religious schools). They're more answerable to the set of expectations they've created for their families, than to the particular whims or desires of any given family, or any constituency present in the broader public. ... which doesn't necessarily mean preferring a better school that's only better due to selection bias (and knock-on effects from being able to remove very-disruptive or low performing students) is a bad way to go, at the individual level, if one has that option. The observation's more relevant to policy-making, than to the relative merits of those options to any given family.
- youreincorrect 3y agoAgreed. I would add that he probably shouldn't be budgeting to have that money go into his 401k in the first place. He's paying more in tax + penalty to do this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pcurve 3y ago"Fidelity found that 2.4 percent of 22 million people with retirement accounts in its system took hardship withdrawals in the final quarter of 2022" That's a lot... over half a million people dipping into the account in a single quarter. :-/
- lotsofpulp 3y agoHow many normally take hardship withdrawals?
- pcurve 3y agoCompared to prior year same period, it's 28-33% jump for both Fidelity and Vanguard.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoPercentage changes of a percent are not a very good signal. If a 33% increase in the percent of hardship withdrawals means the proportion of people doing hardship withdrawals went from 1.8% to 2.4% of people doing a hardship withdrawal, an increase of 0.6%, then I do not know if that is significant enough to be newsworthy. What is the volatility or standard deviation? Are these just normal fluctuations? I am just trying to figure out if this is clickbait or not. Frequently, sources of data will withhold data regarding the distribution to obfuscate the fact that there has not been a material change.
- pcurve 3y agoThe trend has been going on for couple years. It's not a clickbait. Hardship withdrawal is up by 3x fold looking at 20 year chart. https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/107162765-1670436208538-J6qLY-the-share-of-401-k-savers-who-withdraw-cash-for-a-hardship-is-at-an-all-time-high.png?v=1670436215 https://image.cnbcfm.com/api/v1/image/107162765-167043620853...
- mywittyname 3y ago
- 29_29 3y agoI recently raided my retirement accounts because we are at the end of a long term debt cycle and I do not believe in the future of the United States (government), the West or the dollar. I own gold, a farm and I raided the retirement accounts to buy a home. The only way out of 130% debt to GDP is default through inflation, high taxes, and bail ins.
- pb7 3y agoAre you planning on working (your farm) into your 80s?
- pstuart 3y agoThat's what the kids are for.
- tartuffe78 3y agoAssuming your kids enjoy living this exact lifestyle, and don't end up leaving, big assumption.
- pstuart 3y agoI omitted the '/s'. In all seriousness, I could see the value of that in some idyllic context of a family farm but the days of having children for the sake of cheap labor are over (in the US at least).
- baremetal 3y agoThe way things are going, its possible that the farmstead lifestyle will be one of the highest standards of living available to the common man. The alternative might be living in 800sf apartments in a 15 minute city eating whatever food is on offer. Living through screens all day. Perhaps their kids will enjoy that way of life more than the sun on their face on a May afternoon with birds chirping in a field of grass wet with dew petting their livestock.
- tivert 3y ago
- vldmrs 3y agoIMHO this article, and any resource behind a paywall shouldn’t be here
- tracerbulletx 3y agoEvery time you see one of these articles it's like "but taking money out is a bad idea that can be bad for your retirement" It's so patronizing, if you are eligible for a hardship withdraw you are about to miss a house payment or something, they're not doing it for funsies.
- whimsicalism 3y agoOr to pay for their six private schools tuition.
- gabereiser 3y agoThe implications of this will be felt in 20 years when all those who faced hardships will be unable to retire. Living off social security alone is not enough for the vast majority of Americans.
- dangwhy 3y agodreading having to support 2 pairs of retirees on my income in a few years. my wife's and my parents. Neither of them have any savings and are counting on their only child to come through. I've been maxing out my 401k last decade but we don't own any assets rent our home ( We entered our 40s :/ ).
- adamwong246 3y agoTheres a terrible damn mess coming in a few years. It's easy to crap on millennials but what's going to happen when those kids retire WHILE their parents are still on life support? Those same millennials who spent their whole lives without saving? Those same millennials who never produced the children needed to keep this whole enterprise going?
- reactordev 3y agoThose same millennials that were preyed upon by poor financial programs pushed by their parents generation. The same millennials who suffered financial setback after financial setback all while the X’ers and Boomers got richer. Yeah, it’s going to be a bitch.
- adamwong246 3y agoMy Mom: Why aren't you making me any grandkids?! Me: Because you voted for Ronald Reagan.
- dangwhy 3y agoWe live in a Hispanic neighborhood in Chicago ( we are hispanic) . All the families here have 3 kids each and i see pregnant ladies all around me. I feel a surge of anxiety that window is closing for me and that i might be overthinking this.
- wwweston 3y agoInflation is staying high because we're not taming housing costs: https://www.marketplace.org/2023/03/14/housing-costs-are-a-main-reason-inflation-is-still-high/ https://www.marketplace.org/2023/03/14/housing-costs-are-a-m... Higher borrowing costs have slowed the meteoric rise of a bunch of markets, there's some sign of sale prices dropping, but monthly costs stayed the same or increased with mortgage rates; they're apparently not a tool that can pop that side of the bubble. This is usually where the chorus of "just let people build" comes in, and decreasing barriers to adding new stock is a good start, but I've come to believe it's simply unlikely that market incentives will ever make housing more affordable. As far as I can tell, housing costs do not drop unless demand significantly drops. And even theoretically from a pure incentives POV you can see why developers would prefer to chase markets with rising prices and watch production/building to avoid the point of diminishing marginal returns and maximize income. I don't know exactly what the solution is. Maybe it's something like Singapore Housing and Development Board (probably untenable in the US). Maybe it's using an array of higher taxes against supply-constricting or price-inflating behavior (vacancy taxes, short-term rental taxes, property taxes that increase with regional ownership volume or rental prices above standard deviation) to fund development grants. Maybe it's something else. But the market is not going to lead the way out alone.
- Workaccount2 3y agoIf the government wanted to set off some fireworks they could tax homeowners with <4% mortgages such that it makes their "effective mortgage" somewhere around 4% (2019 rates). This would effectively undue the "gift" of the magical 2% mortgage and crush those who chased the low rates during 2021. If they really wanted to rub salt in the wound, they could use the proceeds to fund a home builder subsidy program, giving home builders access to special low interest loans. And if they went full masochist, they could use eminent domain to seize vacant commercial proprieties and build high density housing on it, regardless of local zoning. All this would never happen though. So rest easy homeowner. Just a mental exercise in how the government could use the tools it has to unstick the housing market.
- mdorazio 3y ago
- aynyc 3y agoAm I missing something? None of the example is about inflation. Even with low inflation, I don't see how sending 6 kids to religious school or borrowing from 401k to renovate the house is considered financially prudent.
- mywittyname 3y agoCongress has been increasing the number of ways which you can qualify for a hardship withdrawal. The Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018 made a lot of changes to the rules around hardship withdrawals making it easier than ever to use them as savings accounts instead. This is why self-funded retirement is bad. It really only benefits wealthy people (who don't need the money), since regular people are going to see that balance and get the urge to spend it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- RickJWagner 3y ago1. Remember all the cries for $15 fast food workers, back when $15 meant a lot more? 2. Recall who exactly it was that was saying inflation was 'transitory'. This matters because those who forget history are doomed to repeat it.