6 ms·
‘Massive’ Tesla leak reveals data breaches, thousands of safety complaints
- wahnfrieden 3y agoThe deregulation that enables this kind of public beta testing only works if we also don’t accept commanders with the individual power to make trade off decisions like this for thousands of workers to follow. Time and again workers show more humane decision making given the agency in events like these or the train operators who raised warnings ahead of recent disasters etc. And we see the state siding their support with those owners over the powerless operators, which I point out to show there is value in deregulation regardless. Workers often show pride in what they do, can enjoy the productivity and value what they achieve as a group, but their limited agency at the altar of command prevents common humane reasonableness day to day and in bigger ways.
- cryptonector 3y agoAnd the Morton-Thiokol Challenger shuttle case.
- ndsipa_pomu 3y agoAlso an article on ArsTechnica https://arstechnica.com/cars/2023/05/massive-trove-of-tesla-files-contains-thousands-of-safety-complaints/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2023/05/massive-trove-of-tesla-... > For each incident there are key points for the "technical review". The employees who enter this review into the system regularly make it clear that the report is intended for "internal use only". Each entry also contains the note in bold type that information, if at all, may only be passed on "VERBALLY to the customer". > "Do not copy the report below into an email, text message or leave it in a voicemail to the customer," it continues. Vehicle data should also not be released without permission. If, despite the advice, "a legal involvement cannot be prevented", this must be recorded. > Customers that Handelsblatt spoke to have the impression that Tesla employees avoid written communication. "They never sent emails, everything was always oral," says the doctor from California, whose Tesla said it accelerated on its own in the fall of 2021 and crashed into two concrete pillars.
- wjnc 3y agoThose Tesla's can’t keep their mouth shut (“whose Tesla said it accelerated…”)
- SoftTalker 3y ago> They never sent emails, everything was always oral I work with a guy like that. Send him an email, and if he replies at all it will be with a phone call.
- meinheld111 3y agoMaybe he is just fond of instant organic feedback
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoEven in a work setting it prevents accountability. That's why I send a follow up email immediately after the discussion with the points and commitments. "Please let me know if any of these action items are incorrect..."
- gtirloni 3y agoWorked at a fully-remote company that was like that. Anything barely controversial was moved to Zoom for fear of recording incriminating data (which could used by authorities but also by CEO in regular witch hunt). We weren't discussing anything illegal but it had the side effect of discouraging any disagreements in writing.
- dspillett 3y agoOnce worked with someone like that too. And he was terrible at keeping to things agreed on such calls, and would in fact later claim that we'd agreed things which we had not. I started following every call with a short email listing, for the avoidance of doubt, everything agreed in the call, with a note that if I've missed anything he should let me know ASAP, and explicitly mentioning anything that didn't have a satisfactory conclusion during the call. Never felt the need to CC in others, unless they were specifically relevant, though that would have been a further step if needed (if he claimed to have never seen an mail etc.).
- izacus 3y agoMost sold car model and highest stock value. Capitalism approves of this approach and has rewarded the decision makers.
- yellow_lead 3y agoThere's been a few stories over the years that show Tesla is a bit "laissez faire" with their security and data protection. A recap from my own memory: 1. Engineer sharing how they SSH into moving cars in order to apply updates and troubleshoot (several years back) 2. Recent leaks of customer recordings. The whole autopilot situation is concerning too.
- waihtis 3y agoThe good old Ford Pinto playbook
- kramerger 3y agoI guess Elon will handle this by tweeting something really crazy to shift focus from the real problem, and as usual we will fall for it. On the other hand, he is running out of crazy things to say. The only remaining thing I can think of is he coming out in support for cannibalism
- zeristor 3y agoIf things get tight in his Martian kingdom they may well have to invent the Donner Pass kebab.
- tiffanyg 3y agoAh yes, reminds me of one reason I don't mind waiting so much for a table these days. Just list the family name as "Donner" - hearing the maître d' call out "Donner, party of 4, your table's ready" really makes up for the wait! ;)
- capableweb 3y agoCannibalism is crazy now? Think of all the advantages: - Cannibalism is a way to maximize the use of available resources - If regulated in a certain way, cannibalism could serve as a form of population control - With a balanced diet and careful preparation, human meat could be a source of protein and other nutrients - Cannibalism could be seen as a means of waste reduction. Instead of bodies taking up space in graveyards or being cremated, they're consumed - Cannibalism could be used as a symbol of dominance or power. Consuming another person might be a demonstration of absolute control or superiority. Of course, this is all fictional, and I just thought it would be fun to try to think positively about a somewhat controversial topic. But still...
- imranhou 3y agoTeslas are great cars that just make driving a pleasure. I’m sure for every large sample of any item, there will be some problem ones. It is specifically in these cases, a non trivial number of them are not being handled with more care, more like google customer service. I’m sure a significant part of this is growing pains, scheduling delays in service. I would love for a singular place on the internet where people can start reporting public data about their experiences, in hopes to get more attention to these problems, at least the more common ones.
- teslashill 3y ago[flagged]
- sebzim4500 3y agoAs compared to yours, which adds a huge amount to the discussion. Or mine I guess.
- teslashill 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- imranhou 3y ago[flagged]
- teslashill 3y ago[flagged]
- troupo 3y ago[dead]
- TekMol 3y agoWhat keeps me bullish about Tesla is that when I put "self driving" into YouTube, I see an endless stream of videos made by normal people, filming their own Teslas actually doing self driving. No other manufacturer has gotten there yet. The cars are either geofenced or there are only marketing videos available. So I take it, that Tesla does have a technical advantage of some sorts. Considering how big the market for self driving is, I think the advantage in this field is worth the $500B market cap they have.
- wahnfrieden 3y agotheir technical advantage is measured in comparison to tests, not production consumer rollout which is confounded by risk appetite
- kramerger 3y agoThe only company that has a level 3 self driving car is Mercedes-Benz. Besides, if you measure success by the number of YouTube videos then feel free to search for "Tesla self driving accident" and "Tesla quality issue" on YT
- TekMol 3y agoI don't see any Mercedes self driving videos on youtube by regular people. If that tech existed and was in customers hands, Im sure there were many such videos?
- ChuckNorris89 3y ago>I don't see any mercedes self driving videos on youtube by regular people What a weird metric to have, "videos on youtube of X". Has it occurred to you that more people post videos on youtube because they're influencers or just regular attention seekers cashing in for views because Tesla is overhyped and is the kind of thing that generates traction on social media? Maybe Mercedes owners, or those of any other brand, buy their car to drive it first, not show it off on youtube. For my next job, I'll work only at the company with the most videos on TikTok.
- JoshTko 3y agoEvaluating Tesla's situation is difficult without context. With 3 million cars on the road, about 0.1% of owners have lodged complaints, which doesn't seem alarming initially. Unintended acceleration issues, typically attributed to user error barring some floormat incidents, are common across the industry. Without comparison to the overall auto industry's complaint rate, Tesla's situation isn't notably concerning.
- bandyaboot 3y agoI find it notably concerning that they seem to want to avoid creating a record of customer complaint interactions.
- beerpls 3y agoI don’t. If you’ve ever worked in customer service you realize majority of issues are user error where the user isn’t bright enough to see their obvious error. Combine that with the hate cult that follows musk around and such a database would just be kindling… like how this report is kindling for the hate. It’s not surprising musks corporations act like any other corporation to me. But to each his own.
- fgsfds028374 3y ago[dead]
- minusf 3y ago"your call can be recorded for training purposes"
- throwaway892238 3y agoLiterally every company in the world wants to avoid creating a record of defects. It opens them up to litigation and bad PR. That would put their shareholders at risk, which would effectively be negligence. Have you never heard of a data retention policy? Every company has them. They exist to delete records that could be used in a lawsuit or by a whistleblower. They tend to find whatever the regulatory maximum is and put their limit at a little past that.
- paul7986 3y agoI assume all Tesla drivers who are frequent road trippers have a gas car too? There are 1800 Tesla chargers in the US vs. 145,000 gas stations. Also it takes less than three minutes to fill a gas car and gas cars are less expensive. I don't get the appeal for all their disadvantages unless your Tesla is your 2nd or 3rd car? Also Elon Musk's behavior....
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoIt is usually not true. Tesla drivers often live in cities with limited parking. They can afford more than one car sure, but perhaps their $1 million town home only has one parking spot. So they can only park one car. And why have sucky acceleration ICE when you can have an EV instead? You have to choose, why not go with the better daily drive rather than the occasional long range driver? You can always rent if the trip doesn’t make sense in an EV.
- SoftTalker 3y agoWhy does anyone need the kind of acceleration that Tesla offers. You can really only fully exploit it on the track. Driving around town it's totally unnecessary. Even on a highway, as long as you can keep up with traffic that's all you need.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoYou can exploit the acceleration in city driving. It’s like every stop light is a chance to cut loose from 0 to 35. Have you test driven one yet? It’s just a fun drive.
- SoftTalker 3y agoAnd what about the pedestrian trying to judge whether he can cross the road, who may not be expecting a car to be leaping from stoplight to stoplight, but accelerating at the normal pace that most other cars do?
- nkotov 3y agoI can't be the only one who is tired of seeing news media digging at Tesla constantly. No other car manufacture is treated the same way.
- sidibe 3y agoMaybe because no other car manufacturer is managed the same way.
- switchbak 3y agoVW’s management isn’t exactly stellar either, and they’re the ones who got caught.
- JamesUtah07 3y agoSame with Elon. News sites know articles about him bring views so there is a new article edit him every other day. At this point I just don’t care what stupid thing he’s done this week.
- hef19898 3y agoA lot of hype, and a very public CEO intentionally driving said hype, can have that side effect. In a sense so, I know at least one former POTUS who was also treated worst of all other throughoit history. Both claims have equal merit to them.
- throwaway173738 3y agoNo other manufacturer went out of their way to put cameras everywhere and to record from them to employee chats where they make memes and share videos of peoples “intimate moments.” If GM got caught doing that I’d be ragging on them too. Tesla is an inanimate object, not some person with feelings that need to be protected.
- MarcoZavala 3y ago[dead]
- 3y ago
- gordian-not 3y agoWonder if there are any groups out there that steal data from these kinds of companies, and then short the stock and leak it
- baremetal 3y agoSizeable trades face scrutiny especially in light of leaks. Would be pretty obvious if someone bought a lot of puts right before a leak. And that is just a singular event. If they had a habit of doing that...
- adra 3y agoSure, you just leak it to some "public web site" for a few days then do your big splash trades in and around the time you leak it to aggregators. It feels easily muddled with insider trading vs opportunistic trading on breaking news.
- gordian-not 3y agoI was thinking more North Korea style rather than a single person, as in multiple shorts bought over a long period. Can’t say I really know how practical this is versus SEC
- mnd999 3y agoIf everything was above board this wouldn’t work would it?
- sebzim4500 3y agoI don't think it is really possible for everything to be 'above board'. I'm sure Ford receives plenty of complaints that they don't want published even if they are all baseless. When you have millions of cars on the road that is the reality.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoIn GTA 5, if you buy the right stocks before doing the heist missions, you can make a profit off the fallout. If you do it in all the right spots and invest all the winnings each time you can easily make $INT32_MAX.
- fgsfds028374 3y ago[dead]
- kazinator 3y agoThe time has come for a self-referential leak: a file which says that a confidential file F belonging to such and such a company, detailing a secret data leak, has been leaked on date D. What is the secret data leak being detailed? The leak of file F on date D.
- siliconc0w 3y agoIt's pretty expensive to properly invest in data access controls. You need to basically prevent anyone from unilaterally touching customer data without an assigned ticket (from an customer, alert system, or another employee) or another employee agreeing the access is justified. For very important customers you might want multiple or manager/director level agreement. This can add a lot of friction to normal business-as-usual tasks - if you just grant giant groups of people this access (which is pretty much SOP since so many roles occasionally do need it) then you invariably get this kind of misuse (and leaks).
- inkcapmushroom 3y agoEmployee training and a company culture of treating customer data respectfully are not that expensive.
- throwaway892238 3y agoMost car manufacturers have hundreds to thousands of safety complaints. They settle and include non-disclosures so you can't hear about them. If the cost of settling a class-action is more than the cost of a recall, they'll do a recall.
- hef19898 3y agoUsually it is regulatory bodies calling for recalls, if OEMs are not doing it themselves first. OEMs do not have a lot of say in these matters. That is why all recalls are public record as well.
- xyst 3y agoTime and time again, Tesla is proving to just be a meme company. I wouldn’t touch their products even if they gave it to me for free. I’ll stick with my “dumb” car (manual transmission) for as long as possible, reduce my dependency on cars in general (reducing carbon footprint of car usage and gas consumption). Maybe the true players in the EV industry will rise. Too many fly by night companies right now with minimal reputation; and first generation models from more known companies. Plus I’m still holding out for 500+ mi ranges on a single charge with a fully loaded vehicle. Hopefully some innovations in battery tech will make that a possibility.
- speg 3y agoHow often do you drive 500 miles in day?
- dclowd9901 3y agoI’m so tired of this argument. Any amount more than 0 precipitates a need for a vehicle with that range.
- gtirloni 3y agoYou mean even if I drive, say, 10 miles per day, I need a car that does 500+ miles on a single tank?
- falcolas 3y agoIn clear conditions on well traveled roads, nah. But I also just watched a video where a bridge closure turned a 7 minute drive into a 4.5 hour drive one way. And I’ve been stuck behind a winter road closure that lasted several hours (after being several hours into our trip).
- gtirloni 3y agoGot it. So much more extreme situations than "anything above 0".
- InTheArena 3y agoThis is the 10th time this has been posted - almost all posts have had double-digit comments, four of which reached the front page (from memory). It's getting very annoying. At the risk of spitting into the wind - yes, Tesla is treated differently. That is by both actual Tesla owners, who love their cars and autopilot (Tesla has the highest brand and highest satisfaction score from owners) and are mad at the media drivel that has poured out since day 1 (see #TSLAQ and Niedermeyer). They get irrationally defensive due to the flame wars, but also because they also believe that this is just the latest version of the attacks on Tesla and SpaceX that were just as vitriolic but more out of the public limelight before those companies "steamrolled" their competition. But then there are also the critics, who think little of what SpaceX and Tesla have done, make up shit (again, see #TSLAQ and Niedermeyer, as well as Biden's "GM is leading the EV revolution" comments), but also have legitimate concerns about Elon.
- JumpinJack_Cash 3y ago> > But then there are also the critics, who think little of what SpaceX and Tesla have done What have they done? Asking because after all the fanfare I set foot in one and it's the same experience you had getting in a 2003 Mercedes E-Klasse. If anything the 2003 E-Klasse makes you feel like you are surrounded by opulence during your ride, while Teslas are empty inside and the materials are so crooked and cheap. Can't comment on the space thing because it's so far removed from the daily use of everyday people that it's basically entertainment for nerds, like Chess or Bridge.
- dang 3y agoRecent and related: Whistleblower drops 100 GB of Tesla secrets to German news site - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36075886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36075886 - May 2023 (591 comments)