7 ms·
No, fluoride must not be added to any food or beverage, because it provides no benefits whatsoever when ingested. Fluoride is beneficial only when applied exte
by adrian_b 3y ago
No, fluoride must not be added to any food or beverage, because it provides no benefits whatsoever when ingested.
Fluoride is beneficial only when applied externally on the dental enamel, so that the fluoride ions will passively substitute the hydroxide ions. There is no known biological process that uses actively fluoride in the human body and excessive ingested fluoride has bad effects, e.g. bone damage.
Therefore fluoride must be added only to tooth paste and mouth washes, which provides all the benefits and none of the risks.
Intentionally ingesting fluoride is incredibly stupid and it is beyond my power of understanding how this could be mandated by law in USA and in some other countries which imitated USA irrationally.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- levzettelin 3y agoSome people lack the self control to use toothpaste regularly. For those people it's beneficial adding flouride to water.
- oblak 3y agoThis has to be satire. What sort of incredible self control does something like this require? Where does it end?
- nwiswell 3y agoYou think it's satire that there are people that don't brush their teeth but do drink water?
- Moru 3y agoYou could give targeted help to the ones that needs it, it would be more efficient to help them brush their teeth than just adding fluoride to the water that everyone drinks.
- Timon3 3y agoHow would you target them, and what would make it more efficient?
- Moru 3y agoWe do it by noticing who needs help on the free dental checkups during the first years of life usually. If they have some sort of handicap, they can get help physically brushing or support to do it themselves every day. Helps a lot more than adding something that might work a little in everyones water.
- Timon3 3y agoOn what basis have you evaluated that it "helps a lot more"? What if your method doesn't lead to more people actively brushing their teeth, thus reducing the amount of people with properly protected teeth (since they are also missing fluoride now), increasing amount of dental healthcare required?
- elif 3y agoYou have to consider that these people have lost some cognitive faculty by ingested fluoride so they may not be capable of rational self interested decision-making.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoIt's not satire. It takes enough self-control/willpower that, for example, a lot of people suffering from ADHD have problems with it. There are a lot of people out there who just aren't capable of habituating the tasks of brushing their teeth to the point of being done on autopilot - they have to consciously make themselves do it every time. And that's after more than half a century of brushing teeth being a cultural expectation and something kids are taught in schools. And that's not counting people in dire economic conditions, where frequency of brushing teeth with fluoride toothpaste is something to trade off against e.g. eating. It's the 21st century. If we know anything about people, we know that self control and "free will" are overrated, and you can't rely on them at scale. On the contrary, you can rely on people having very predictable reactions to right nudges and incentives. It's the basis of modern economy and policymaking. It's the entire reason marketing and advertising are as big and well-paying jobs as they are. Etc.
- adrian_b 3y agoI can imagine that there might exist people who cannot brush their teeth. However, for such people the solution is not to drink fluoridated water, but to use fluoridated water to wash their mouth and then spit it. If they cannot take water in mouth and spit it, then they certainly cannot feed themselves and they need permanent care. Whoever does that should also take care of their teeth. Regarding money, I cannot believe that to be an obstacle. I eat relatively cheap food, because I buy only raw ingredients that I cook myself. Therefore in most days food costs me at most $5. I doubt that anyone who is really poor succeeds to spend much less for food. I wash my teeth after each meal with rather expensive tooth pastes from Colgate or Sensodyne. Even so, the daily cost for the tooth paste is at least 30 or 50 times less than the cost of food, so unless there is some remote place where the price of tooth paste is much more than 10 times more expensive than in Europe or North America, I cannot believe that being poor would prevent someone to brush their teeth. They would die of hunger much sooner than that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- triyambakam 3y agoThe parent stated clearly it doesn't work by ingestion.
- x-complexity 3y ago> Some people lack the self control to use toothpaste regularly. For those people it's beneficial adding flouride to water. At some point, we can't just replace individual personal responsibility with the State as a solution. This attitude just reeks of infantilization of the total populace just because a certain percentage of them lack such self control. If you still want to provide support to them, make it targeted towards those individuals in need of such help. Do not drag down the rest of the populace in order to make the lives of a few easier.
- CogitoCogito 3y ago> At some point, we can't just replace individual personal responsibility with the State as a solution. Have we reached that point? If so, why?
- levzettelin 3y agoI don't think I was expressing much of an attitude in my comment. Just a factual statement that seeks to explain why the intervention is successful even though better alternatives clearly exist. I don't think water should be flouridated and I don't think we should provide support for people lacking self control.
- blackhaz 3y agoWouldn't some part of toothpaste end up ingested? With strong fluoride pastes (like those 5000 ppm specialized ones) could there also be a risk?
- adrian_b 3y agoObviously a little fluoride will be ingested. However it is doubtful that this would increase much the total amount of fluoride that is ingested daily, mainly from the plants that you eat and from the natural water that you drink. When you brush your teeth with fluoridated paste or you wash your mouth with a fluoride solution and you spit it, most of the fluoride acts against the tooth enamel to harden it and only a little is ingested. On the other hand, when you drink fluoridated water, only very little of the fluoride acts against the tooth enamel to harden it and most of it is ingested, which will provide no further benefits, but which might have bad effects. How there is even a discussion about which choice is better, beats me.
- threeseed 3y ago> which will provide no further benefits Source please.
- jtbayly 3y agoI’d say anybody claiming the opposite would need to provide a source. Or even just a theoretical reason to think it could be beneficial. All I’ve ever heard is that the benefit is in tooth contact.
- webworker 3y agoThat's before even considering topical application through the gums
- hgsgm 3y agoWhen you assume the reality that many people don't brush, the benefits of brushing have no impact.
- 3y ago
- thrashh 3y agoWell it halved childhood cavities in the 50s. It did its job and I don’t think it’s hard to understand why it was done. Same reason why they stared iodine to salt… because people were having mental development issues. Now is it still necessary? That’s a different question but let’s not pretend that we don’t know why it was done.
- KETpXDDzR 3y agoCorrelation doesn't yield causation! The whole fluoride in drinking water only came up based on a study from abroad. There, they noticed an improvement of dental health over time after they introduced fluoride in their water. However, this study and the same for the 50th ignore the fact that dental hygiene and awareness dramatically improved during this time. Thus, the better dental health is more likely from better topical application of fluoride and more regular brushing/flossing. I'm concerned that we have all the scientific facts and keep ignoring them. Fun fact: Dentists recommend flossing before brushing. Edit: "For example, in Finland and Germany, tooth decay rates remained stable or continued to decline after water fluoridation stopped in communities with widespread fluoride exposure from other sources." - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_fluoridation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_fluoridation
- koboll 3y agoI think there might be some confounders at play here. Consider this excerpt from Wikipedia's article on 'Tooth brushing': > In the United States, although toothbrushes were available at the end of the 19th century, the practice did not become widespread until after the Second World War, when US soldiers continued the tooth brushing that had been required during their military service.[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tooth_brushing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tooth_brushing
- Retric 3y agoDifferent communities added fluoride at different times, it’s not hard to adjust for other factors when you’re drowning in such data.
- dash2 3y agoGiven that the health bureaucracies of many countries seem to disagree with you, you need to cite more evidence and sources to support this claim. You can't just do it by strong assertion.
- tnel77 3y ago>>You can't just do it by strong assertion. Sir, this is the internet. Sources are for the weak. Just type your response so it’s passionate and angry and people will believe you!
- Consultant32452 3y agoHaving the health bureaucracies in many countries all agreeing on something would have been convincing enough for me three years ago. Now, it means nothing.
- dharma1 3y agoI’ve been thinking about this recently - fluorapatite is stronger than hydroxyapatite when it bonds to enamel, and less soluble by acid. But fluoride doesn’t occur in any natural processes in the body - while hydroxyapatite is a perfect biomimetic - very safe, you can swallow it safely - and also works great in toothpaste to remineralise teeth. Currently using BioMin F (fluorapatite - very little fluoride due to a novel delivery mechanism but still) but considering switching to BioMin C (nanohydroxyapatite)
- opan 3y agoI've used both apagard and boka toothpastes with nanohydroxyapatite and I've enjoyed them, though my tooth sensitivity is not totally cured. I still get a jolt of pain from sweet things on certain teeth occasionally. These n-Ha toothpastes seem at least equal to if not greater than high-fluoride options (in effectiveness) I tried previously like sensodyne and prevident (prescription-strength). I would say the boka mint toothpaste tastes better also, and as a bonus their electric toothbrush is much nicer than the old one I'd used a few years ago. I still drink water with fluoride in it as well, mostly because it's the best tasting water I've come across. (From a city I grew up in, and I still fill jugs full to drink at home) I have well water at my house, which is safe as far as I know, but I still feel hesitant to swallow it.
- krackers 3y agoBoka only has 2% nHAP, compared to the 7% of apagard premio or 10% of apagard royal.
- gregwebs 3y agoAnother option is just hydroxyapatite without the nano (sometimes nano particles end up having their own safety issues). A higher hydroxyapatite concentration might work almost as well. Kinder Karex is such a toothpaste. https://www.consumerlab.com/answers/finding-the-best-toothpaste/toothpaste-ingredients/ https://www.consumerlab.com/answers/finding-the-best-toothpa...
- jjcon 3y ago> it is beyond my power of understanding how this could be mandated by law in USA It isn't mandated by law in the USA. All water contains some naturally occurring fluoride, some localities choose to add additional fluoride to their water in the USA but certainly not all. I'm pretty sure it is added in something like 60% of city water supplies.
- elif 3y ago> beyond my power of understanding how this could be mandated There is of course the "that was the plan all along" hypothesis, that mild cognitive decay on a large scale is a useful outcome for control purposes.
- concordDance 3y agoIt really isn't. Lower cognition is strongly associated with dissatisfaction and violence, not to mention much lower economic productivity (less taxes!).
- elif 3y agoIt's only a hypothesis and all cognitive impairment is not uniform.
- 8note 3y agoYou might prefer the term "conspiracy theory"
- drekipus 3y ago> strongly associated with dissatisfaction and violence, dissatisfaction and violence are the easiest problems for a state to deal with.
- xtian 3y agoWho cares about taxes when you can print money?
- concordDance 3y agoMoney has value because of what it buys. If a society is making 400 widgets it doesn't matter whether each is priced at $2 or $999, the government will only be able to get 400 widgets. A stupider population makes much less widgets.
- 3y ago
- mihaaly 3y agoadrian_b vs. health scientists throughout the world and history, ca. 1:1e10 Who to believe here, who should we believe here, hm, very difficult problem, adrian_b's passionate statements or practically all the professionals of the world. I go and contemplate over this for a while now. : )
- jstanley 3y ago1e10 people is about 10% of everyone who has ever lived. It's more than the current global population.
- mihaaly 3y agoOne can score multiple times! : )
- adrian_b 3y agoIf you judge the truth of the information you receive based on the claimed authority of those who provide it, instead of using your own mind to discern whether that information is logically consistent or inconsistent, that is sad and I believe that this should be a cause of concern for you. Consider the following facts, which can be easily be verified in countless sources, e.g. in books written by real chemists or "health scientists": The mineral component of the teeth and bones grown by a human body is made of hydroxylapatite. When a hydroxylapatite crystal is immersed in a water solution of fluoride ions, in the superficial layer of the crystal, which is in contact with the fluoride solution, some of the hydroxide anions from the crystal are dissolved in the water and they are substituted by fluoride anions, thus converting the superficial layer of the hydroxylapatite into fluorapatite. The fluoride ions bond more strongly to apatite than the hydroxide ions, so once formed the fluorapatite layer is more resistant to dissolution than the parent hydroxylapatite. In the conversion of hydroxylapatite into fluorapatite, like in any other chemical reaction, the converted amount increases with the concentration of the reactant, i.e. of fluoride and with the time of contact between hydroxylapatite and solution. All of the above explain how the contact between the tooth enamel and a fluoride solution creates a superficial tooth layer that is more resistant to dissolution, which decreases the likelihood of tooth cavities. The dependences of the conversion efficacy on fluoride concentration and on contact time explain why tooth brushing or mouth washing are far more effective in enamel hardening than drinking fluoridated water, when the fluoride concentration is low and the contact time is very short and most of the fluoride never enters in contact with the tooth enamel to have a chance to harden it. After the fluoride is ingested, it never comes again in contact with the tooth enamel, so there is no way for it to harden the enamel. Please tell us how your "1E10 health scientists throughout the world and history" have told you that ingested fluoride from inside your body can harden the tooth enamel from outside your body. Perhaps the fluoride ions use The Force to harden the enamel from a distance? The fluoride ions are carried by blood in most parts of the body, but the tooth enamel does not contain blood vessels. Even if it had blood vessels, they would have been buried in it and they would not have reached the external surface of the teeth, which is where the fluoride is needed for protection against dissolution. Moreover, the fluoride ions spread uniformly in the entire blood volume. Only a small part of the ions pass close to the teeth, most of them pass through the bigger organs, including through the bigger bones, which, unlike the tooth enamel, contain numerous blood vessels. Because the fluoride ions have high affinity for apatite, many of those passing through the bones stop there and remain incorporated in the mineral part of the bones. While at the surface of the teeth fluoride is desirable, in bones it is harmful because it makes the bones more fragile, increasing the likelihood of fractures. In conclusion, when drinking fluoridated water, only very little fluoride is retained in the tooth enamel, but most ends in the bones, so this method is much more effective in making the bones fragile than in hardening the tooth enamel. There are only 3 ways in which the ingested fluoride could protect against tooth cavities: eating one's own excrement, washing the mouth with one's own urine or biting one's own body and drinking one's own blood or washing the mouth with it. Whoever does not have such habits will not receive dental health benefits from ingested fluoride. I look forward to see how "all the professionals of the world" can explain the magical ingested fluoride effect claimed to exist by the proponents of drinking water fluoridation.
- elif 3y ago>it is beyond my power of understanding how this could be mandated by law in USA Consider that fluoride ingestion has been linked with increased anxiety and depression[*]. Depending upon one's political objectives, this could be a desirable outcome. For instance, the "anti-terror" decades of invasion would be easier to accept for an anxious public. Or depression may lead to more consumer activity. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258252498_Fluoride_exposure_during_development_affects_both_cognition_and_emotion_in_mice https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258252498_Fluoride_...
- drewcon 3y agoOr, hear me out, watching terrorists kamikaze a few commercial airliners into a couple of buildings in downtown Manhattan and the Pentagon live on TV was actually kind of a nerve racking on its own irrespective of what the dissolved minerals in our tap water might have told us.
- elif 3y agoYet we didn't question the non-involvement of the 7 nations we invaded, nor question the lack of invasion of the responsible nation. Society comforted themselves with the official narrative while branding whistleblowers conspiracy theorists.
- elif 3y agoAlso calling it a "dissolved mineral" is pointlessly euphemistic. Fluoride is sold as a poison. You may as well call the following "dissolved minerals": lead, arsenic, uranium, mercury, asbestos
- hgsgm 3y agoTable salt kills slugs.
- kodah 3y agoAt the time Republicans reported much better mental health than Democrats [1]. iirc, this study was reproduced with children as well (in terms of kids raised under a political ideology). Moreover, as someone else pointed out, watching commercial airliners fly into skyscrapers and having our world upended with military guards at airports and new governmental snooping powers that we just had to accept is all pretty much enough for the things you mentioned. 1: https://news.gallup.com/poll/102943/republicans-report-much-better-mental-health-than-others.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/102943/republicans-report-much-...
- aatd86 3y agoThey give that to babies in France... I have swallowed my fair share of fluoride pills. Are you to tell me that I should have been a galaxy brain but am now a smooth brain? Fvck!
- rjzzleep 3y agoWow WTF I've found french baby products to be quite nice but somehow child birth it's a weird industry there. I remember there was heavy lobbying to increase people's wishes for c sections there.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoC sections are more profitable!