11 ms·
YouTube removed dislike counts, so this guy made Rotten Tomatoes for YouTube
- gliixo 3y agoThere is a Firefox extension that brings it back...
- ruupesssh 3y ago[flagged]
- activiation 3y agoSmart idea... Hope it catches up
- andrewclunn 3y agoIf it does there will then be the "verified YouTube critic score" and the "audience score," where only the critic score is displayed at first glance. You know, because actual popular sentiment is the antithesis of advertising.
- devmunchies 3y agoEven Rotten Tomatoes has changed this recently to break the audience score into 2 new categories. "Verified Audience" and "General Audience". Disney was probably putting pressure on RT after years of putting out garbage and getting review bombed.
- watwut 3y agoThere would be no need for review bomb if they were widely disliked. The issue is that they were not widely disliked and certain groups are angry other people consume this content.
- devmunchies 3y agoDisney has been underperforming at the box office for a while now. Review bombs are a symptom of not focusing on the product (entertainment, story). And to my original point, if review bombs are a symptom, then "verified reviewers" is addressing the symptom, not the problem. Same reason YouTube took down dislikes. It was around the time the Rings of Power was getting wrecked by LoTR fans.
- mike741 3y ago> There would be no need for review bomb if they were widely disliked. This is circular reasoning. You're calling something a "review bomb" because you're assuming from the outset that its not widely disliked, despite the large amount of negative reviews suggesting it is in fact widely disliked.
- watwut 3y agoI did not called it "review bomb", the whole thread started with the "review bomb" promise. Review bomb is when whole group goes out of their way to seek content they disagree and then downvote it. There is zero reason to organize all of that for widely disliked content. However, especially right wing groups do it against mildly popular content they do not want other people to see.
- peoplefromibiza 3y ago> There would be no need for review bomb if they were widely disliked. What is a review bomb if not a symptom that something is widely disliked? There are no review bombs on stuff that is widely liked either.
- watwut 3y ago> There are no review bombs on stuff that is widely liked either. Typical review bombs go against liked content.
- lmm 3y agoOr maybe they were widely disliked, but this was not reflected in the critic score because certain groups were promoting the content.
- Scokee 3y agoWouldn't it make more sense to install an extension that shows the dislike count again? https://returnyoutubedislike.com/ https://returnyoutubedislike.com/ I've been using it since YouTube removed the dislikes and it's worked very well...
- NayamAmarshe 3y agoRemember that you can't use an extension on all browsers and on all platforms. So, having a common platform makes sense.
- gsich 3y agoThose should be called "crippled" platforms or browsers.
- qwytw 3y agoDesktop Safari has extensions yet that plugin does not support it. At some point developing for anything but Chromium ceases to make sense since your potential users can just install Chrome, so who cares..
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agoAnd then people say why is market share of Firefox decreasing. If extension developers spend just a little time porting their extension, then they can point either way. By forcing your customers to only support chrome, you are helping chrome build a monopoly overtye browser based internet where all extensions and work and play happens only on chrome. Please do better. And yes. I have an extension that is built for Firefox and chrome so I have some skin in the game
- rollcat 3y ago> Desktop Safari has extensions As a desktop Safari user: Safari theoretically has extensions. Apple made it painful and expensive for developers to publish, and so the ecosystem is in an abysmal state, with ultimately the users losing. I'm torn between paying for extensions (that are free for other browsers) as a way to say "sincerely thank you" to those developers who bother, and absolutely not paying - to send a message, that this system sucks.
- frou_dh 3y agoSomething else strange is that they removed the dropdown option to sort videos in a channel in chronological order ("oldest first").
- quaintdev 3y agoProbably assuming oldest one like archived data and storing them accordingly.
- Tokkemon 3y agoAre you sure this isn't just an option for some channels to decide if they want it? Some channels definitely still have this sort option available.
- doodlesdev 3y agoNo, they removed it. While I believe they haven't shared the reason they do it, I think it's probably due to backend changes to reduce costs of hosting older less popular videos (maybe moving them to nearline storage?). Some previous discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33559888 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33559888
- Lockal 3y agoYes/no, "Some channels definitely still have this sort option available". Many smaller (?) channels still have this button. Also sorting by date still works for all channels after editing URL. I don't know exactly, what is the criteria for hiding that button, but consider size/geography/political views/ability to inject ads/etc. YouTube shadowbanned comments, likes, videos for a long time; consider this as another technique of shadowbanning without explaining anything.
- squeaky-clean 3y agoAny examples? I just checked about 20 channels I'm subscribed to that have between 1k-15k subs and there's no Sort By Oldest button.
- bitwize 3y agoIs it going to put its thumb on the scales to counteract "review bombing/troll campaigns" for widely disliked but powerfully backed YouTube videos the way RT does?
- minimaxir 3y agoIt's impossible to feasibly counteract review bombing. It's even worse when you have to release a non-native extension, as that introduces a selection bias among people who want to review bomb on the main site but can't.
- watwut 3y agoYeah, cause they are not that much widely disliked, it is just an attempt at political pressure and attempt to make them see widely disliked.
- mike741 3y agoif its "not that much" and creates deception then why make site-wide changes that make it even less transparent? If a video had 4k dislikes and 46k likes then you knew that 4k accounts disliked it. There's little room for speculation there. Now you have to go to the comment section to get an idea of public opinion, where the theorized vocal minority have far more potential influence (because they can leave multiple comments, but only one thumbs down)
- qwertox 3y agoI think they didn't just remove dislike counts, but are actively suppressing negative comments. If I watch a speech of someone from the German (right-wing) AfD party, which I very rarely do and start reading the comments, I feel like I'm visiting an echo chamber. Zero negative comments which simply can't be the truth.
- bspammer 3y agoThey are, but indirectly via the video recommendation algorithm.
- kmeisthax 3y agoI don't think YouTube themselves are doing that. As the uploader, AfD can absolutely just remove all negative comments they don't like. And they've been able to do that since YouTube started.
- mardifoufs 3y agoCan they filter out words automatically? Like I know that tons of people seemingly love to be moderators (for free) so maybe some channels just have enough mods to delete stuff very fast, but sometimes the whole comment section is just too clean. Do YouTube channels have more advanced moderator tools now? The funny thing is that I started to get that impression on videos of Moroccan politics of all things. Not some western culture war topic haha.
- whamlastxmas 3y ago
- hinata08 3y agoI don't get why the Reddit crowd cares so much about disliking... Mostly without even a comment or something. Everytime on groups that share a userbase with Reddit, and on YouTube, you get haters. You don't know who, you don't know why, they just downvotes and burry your comment and they're not able to comment back. It kills online discussions, make an echo chamber for the leading opinion, and kills any content that's a bit different. For exemple, some awesome song about Assassin's creed was featured on YouTube, a few years ago, next to related content. (Assassin des templiers) The quality and the realisation were sublime. But it got tons of thumbs down because it was in French, and haters only want content in English (filtering your exposition to international content was not the point of upvotes and downvotes!) So downvotes are pointless imo. It's great they get rid of it (and HN should do the same for the quality of the discussion)
- AlbertCory 3y agoHear, hear. Another term for downvotes is: casual meanness. If HN isn't willing to get rid of them, then they should at least cost you something: 10 karma points, maybe.
- Fauntleroy 3y agoDislikes were a fantastic way to determine if a video had a misleading thumbnail or title at a glance. Now you have to waste time determining if the contents of the video are factual or not, which can become infuriating, especially for technical work that demands accurate information.
- kortilla 3y agoIt has nothing to do with meanness. It’s community curation. Upvotes provide you a signal that some people like it. Downvotes provide you a signal that some people dislike it. They are completely different. Downvotes prevent unpopular things that have a fervent user-base from sitting on top.
- hinata08 3y ago> Downvotes prevent unpopular things that have a fervent user-base from sitting on top It's the definition of an echo chamber, isn't it ?
- diimdeep 3y agoYouTube monopoly is really hurting internet and the world. YouTube at this point is globalized TV controlled by one country: U.S. It got so bad that for countries that do not have their own platforms, YouTube become as worse as adversarial subversive NGO that dictates one narrative and suppresses other narratives. i have seen in recent years countless examples of channels wiped from platform for holding opinionated views not aligned with Neo-liberal west. Removing features so that you watch what they want you to watch.
- crazygringo 3y agoOK, I'll ask -- can you give some specific examples of wiped channels? What is an example of an NGO promoting one narrative and what are the other narratives being suppressed? What are countries this is happening in? I'm genuinely interested in the specifics here. I always want to be knowledgeable about different narratives. Because my impression was that YouTube will serve you up recommendations on any topic you watch, because its goal is to serve ads, not to further a neoliberal narrative over others. But if YouTube is hiding certain narratives, I definitely want to be aware, to understand what kinds of categories they fall into. Can you share what you've observed? Edit: best I can tell (looking through comment history) is that the commenter is upset specifically with YouTube banning content and channels that "denies or trivializes" Russia's invasion of Ukraine: > YouTube has also been able to operate in Russia despite cracking down on pro-Kremlin content that has broken guidelines including its major violent events policy, which prohibits denying or trivialising the invasion. Since the conflict began in February, YouTube has taken down channels including that of the pro-Kremlin journalist Vladimir Solovyov. Channels associated with Russia’s Ministries of Defence and Foreign Affairs have also been temporarily suspended from uploading videos in recent months for describing the war as a “liberation mission”. YouTube’s chief product officer, Neal Mohan, said: “We have a major violent events policy and that applies to things like denial of major violent events: everything from the Holocaust to Sandy Hook. And of course, what’s happening in Ukraine is a major violent event. And so we’ve used that policy to take unprecedented action.” [1] [1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/may/22/youtube-ukraine-invasion-russia-video-removals https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/may/22/youtube-u...
- nativeit 3y agoHonestly, it isn’t hard to justify Youtube’s choices on this very specific issue. The dislike button presumably has a function beyond public shaming. I expect it’s primarily for tailoring recommendations and tuning their algorithms, but in any case it was clearly being abused by troll hordes. If Youtube devs could see that significant amounts of dislikes were coming from users who hadn’t watched the video, or could identify other statistical aberrations, it stands to reason that such abuse would actively interfere with the legitimate functionality it was intended for and/or work against the interests of YouTube, advertisers, as well as authors and viewers. I personally think that removing the public counter was an elegant solution in this case, as it suppresses the worst excesses of trolling while maintaining the original intent of the dislike feature, which should improve the overall experience for most users, generally speaking.
- NigelThornberry 3y ago[dead]
- matteoraso 3y ago>If Youtube devs could see that significant amounts of dislikes were coming from users who hadn’t watched the video, or could identify other statistical aberrations, it stands to reason that such abuse would actively interfere with the legitimate functionality it was intended for and/or work against the interests of YouTube, advertisers, as well as authors and viewers. But if you can see that these dislikes were from trolls, then you can account for that and not have the algorithm register them.
- hnarn 3y ago> then you can account for that and not have the algorithm register them It’s an unsolvable problem which is why they disabled it entirely. If you “account” for “bad” input the only consequence is that those responsible for that bad input figure out how to get it classified as good input.
- s3p 3y ago
- mr-pink 3y agosomebody should take youtube private and get rid of all the shit videos
- sacnoradhq 3y agoDid you forget Alphabet (Google) owns YT?
- dbhalla4 3y ago[flagged]
- SN76477 3y agoThey made a mistake by removing the star rating system.
- Mobes 3y agoWebsites or services that act as personalized recommendation middle-men with a less "trashy" presentation for the recommendations themselves are a great idea. Essentially, I'd like "Rate Your Music" for all sorts of things. There's a reason why a handful few are trying to get those "Action Button" Youtube videos submitted to Letterboxd. I guess I also believe that plenty of platforms with user-generated content have boundless stuff to see, and making the platforms themselves responsible for recommendations gives them almost too much responsibility. I understand it's part of the business plan, but recommendations would become less toxic of a phenomenon if they weren't forced onto your regular user experience as you engaged with the platform.. and better if they were more individual and something you'd have to access separately. Like movie reviews in the paper!
- Nextgrid 3y ago> Websites or services that act as personalized recommendation middle-men These are impossible without a legal precedent to make adversarial interoperability legal again. While it was never explicitly made illegal, copyright law and the CFAA have successfully been used to curtail it. Software that wraps common services such as YouTube/Facebook/Twitter/etc and added its own features on top (such as custom recommendations, etc) is routinely attacked and taken down. That's why there are no mainstream alternative clients for any of those services.
- katamarimambo 3y agoDidn't click surely LGBT people have less than 10% approval on this unless its a pre-misstep Milo Yannopoulos type
- jdthedisciple 3y agoInnovative Idea: Instead of a single dislike button, force the user to select a dislike reason, with choices such as: - title doesn't match content - content is in unexpected language - content is in low visual quality etc.
- Nifty3929 3y agoUnfortunately, exactly the people who abuse the dislike button are the ones who won't care which reason they pick - they will just pick one.
- evandale 3y agoAll Youtube has to do is review one of the dislike reasons and if it's not true ignore the rest of the dislikes for that reason. If a bunch of people dislike it because the title doesn't match the content, but it does match, ignore other dislikes for that cite that reason.
- celdon25 3y agoThere are browser extensions that get you the dislike counts, and they are accurate.
- poorUs 3y ago[dead]
- zelphirkalt 3y agoFunny idea: What would happen, if a bunch of relatively well known Youtubers made it their mission to say at every video ending, that one should upvote for disliking a video and that they consider upvotes to be dislikes? If it became big enough of a movement, would upvoting also be removed?
- friend_and_foe 3y agoHow long before youtube removes everything but "what's next" and turns into a TV channel?
- usernew 3y agohonestly I hope not long. I could not care less about what random people like or dislike, what they comment on videos, or anything else. what's next is a great feature since I put on a song and it plays something similar next. a TV channel is the perfect use case for youtube, where instead of selecting a channel like on TV, you select a channel by type of video you first play. sidenote: I had no idea youtube had likes or dislikes until I read this post. I have however, used youtube to, you know, play a video and look at that video. I have zero idea about other components of the site, outside of the video playing, and a list of what's next. I've used youtube since before it was owned by google. now I don't know if I'm the target demographic, but it seems to me like youtube is doing the right thing and focusing on it's core feature while removing screen spam. and w/ ublock, I haven't seen an ad on there in a decade.
- dbeley 3y agoI also started working on a similar website several weeks ago. It's called tuberank, feel free to check it out! https://tuberank.org/en https://tuberank.org/en
- zX41ZdbW 3y agoYou can download the dataset of dislikes and analyze it in ClickHouse: https://clickhouse.com/docs/en/getting-started/example-datasets/youtube-dislikes https://clickhouse.com/docs/en/getting-started/example-datas...
- jaimex2 3y agoYoutube is bracing itself for Twitter's land grab. Personally I think Youtube is screwed.
- nojs 3y agoThe other thing they seem to have done around the same time is heavily bias towards showing only positive comments. This is quite damaging when searching for, for example, medical content. At first when I found a video where every visible comment was “Omg! I’ve tried everything for years, and this is the first thing that worked. You’ve changed my life”, I was excited! Now, I realise that almost every physical therapy video contains the exact same comments. Presumably because they are the ones the algorithm pushes to the top. This means it’s really hard to know which content is actually trustworthy, especially when there’s also no downvotes. And for a lot of thing this is really important. It’s as if Amazon showed only the glowing five star reviews - suddenly you don’t know what the common problems are with the product you’re about to buy.
- sn_master 3y agoCouldn't it be also because of bots/paid-humans writing the same kind of comments and liking them to make them bubble to the top?
- seoulmetro 3y agoNo. Because it does the same thing for comments by normal people. It's an actual feature of YouTube now. YouTube has been censored for a while. Writing anything even remotely critical is weighted down. You can only critically write good things about something, but that's not very easy to do. There's a reason why youtube comments are echo chambers of "happiness for the video". It's like Reddit, where you are writing comments to pass the hive mind filter. Welcome to modern communal interactions, where having a valid or invalid opinion is bad only because it is different.
- jakear 3y agoHN is no different. For a handful of select hot-button topics, any deviation from toeing the party line will result in near immediate downvote barrage and eventual [flagged][dead]. On the flip side, for some (usually the same) topics it’s easy to write banal karma-fishing comments sure to rise to the top of the thread. At least HN has a time-decay aspect on those.
- Ahmad498 3y agoThis just shows how little power we have over corporations, and how they can just get away with the stupidest things because "people will just forget about it." It's honestly sad.
- dancemethis 3y agoUnfortunate to be called something like that instead of an alternative for IMDB's ratings or something. Rotten Tomatoes is clearly meant to be just a parody website. Look at its name. It can't be taken seriously.
- boomboomsubban 3y agoHuh? Rotten Tomatoes isn't a parody, it aggregates "critic" scores for movies.
- rvba 3y agoIa there a way to search for youtube comments? I watched over 200 videos from some series and remember a particular comment under one of those videos.. but it seems those are not indexed by google, so you cannot search for youtube comments
- zenobic 3y agoI understand that not everyone will appreciate or connect with crafted and dedicated videos, and respect the diversity of opinions. However, given the rarity of positive feedback in a niche, the negative ratings without constructive criticis felt particularly impactful.
- BuzzDegen 3y agoWell why we don't have a review platform for YouTubers? Because it's free
- author-victor 3y ago[dead]
- throwaway77384 3y agoGetting a TypeError: Le.find(...) is undefined when going to https://www.favoree.io/search https://www.favoree.io/search needs a bit more work :)