7 ms·
About Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library
- pyrelight 3y agoShe's able to do all this and still live comfortably and live her dreams. I wonder why more wealthy don't do things like this. It seems most just write a check to Charity X for the tax break and the ego boost. The things Dolly does seem to lend themselves to legacy, and what could a rich man/woman want more than their name immortalized in a social program that helps people.
- glass_of_water 3y agoIf you find the right organization that uses the funds effectively, what's with donating your wealth as opposed to creating your own charitable organization? Also, I'm sure the tax deduction for donations is exploited when the receiving organization is non-profit in name only, but if the receiving organization really is an effective charity, what's wrong with the donor getting a tax break? Or is the claim not that one approach is more effective than other in terms of positive impact, but that the wealthy, for their own sake, would be better off founding their own organizations?
- massysett 3y agoThis is Warren Buffet’s approach. He figured Bill Gates is better at giving away money than he ever would be, so he simply gives his money to the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mc32 3y agoAre there no profit charity organization where everyone is a volunteer and no one draws a salary? Lots of these orgs often seem like they exist to maintain the organization than benefit their cause.
- prroyston 3y agoI am a nonprofit CEO who’s worked in community, sport, educational and health charities. Organizations and causes require people who work full time to help organize the charitable work. It is very difficult to find people to volunteer at this level and typically if you do, they are independently wealthy. Retired people can do more but typically they do not want to give that much time and have other things they want to do. 4 hrs a week which is a typical volunteer shift at our hospital does not lend itself to pulling all the details together. Good people deserve to get paid to do good work. Just like in tech, you get what you pay for. And typically a nonprofit worker puts extra hours and time in as does their family members in support of the cause.
- marniewebb 3y agoThis.
- mc32 3y agoI understand the need for professionals, but what grates me is seeing the leaders of these organizations renting expensive venues to conduct some of their activities, sometimes display expensive art and so on. As if they need to impress their donors. No, donors already believe in the cause, they don't have to be plied, taken to expensive restaurants, served luxurious food, etc. in order to get their commitments. They should believe in the mission, run frugally and most of all divert the majority of the money to the cause. I often hear, well, if you don't pay them top salary you are not going to attract people from private enterprise. I don't think you want people whose main motivation to contribute is money.
- pyrelight 3y agoYeah, it's too late to shift it, but from everything I've seen when researching on Charity Navigator, leadership at non profits is viewed similarly as C-suite with regard to salary. I suspect it's probably because to be effective, it's much easier to just network at the level that C-suite professionals would, rather than the grassroots approach that requires raw labor, outreach, etc. It's probably easier to get that guy you know who is high-up at Kroger to get involved in your charity in a mutually-beneficial way. Or maybe I'm just really really over the edge jaded and cynical. It's probably that.
- avidphantasm 3y agoShe grew up very poor. I suspect many wealthy people didn’t. Also, she made her money working for a living, not through financial BS.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 082349872349872 3y agosee Coat of Many Colors
- pmorici 3y agoNot to detract anything from her contribution but she isn’t funding the whole thing. The way it works is a local nonprofit for a geographic area partners with the Imagination library and funds them to offer the program in that area. Their website explains how you can become a partner for your area and the costs involved. In some places it is government funded. The program in Baltimore City for example appears to be largely funded by Maryland State government via a yearly grant to a nonprofit. https://imaginationlibrary.com/usa/ https://imaginationlibrary.com/usa/ https://goccp.maryland.gov/the-governors-young-readers-program/ https://goccp.maryland.gov/the-governors-young-readers-progr...
- pbj1968 3y ago$2.20 per child, per month. That’s the partnership contribution. Please reconsider where you place your time and outrage.
- artificialLimbs 3y agoStating facts != outrage.
- radec 3y agooutrage?
- pmorici 3y agoZero outrage on my part. Just pointing out that the op’s view of how this works doesn’t jive with reality. There are a lot of people and governments putting money into this to make it work at the scale and scope that it does.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pbj1968 3y agoJibe
- LocalH 3y agoDolly Parton embodies everything good about the Southern US, in an age where there's not really much in this area that gets the public eye for being a good, wholesome thing. I have a lot of respect for her, quite honestly in my mind she's up there with people like Fred Rogers and Bob Ross.
- celticninja 3y agoDolly Parton embodies everything good about people.
- peterleiser 3y agoA big motivation was that her father was illiterate. We live in Tennessee and this program is amazing. Dolly Parton is great to Tennessee and her reputation here is stellar.
- harimau777 3y agoGood point. Even from a purely selfish perspective, I would think that being universally loved would have more utility than a few more millions in the bank.
- melling 3y ago“I wonder why more wealthy don't do things…” I wonder why so many people want the wealthy to do more things to make the world a better place when the United States has a GDP of $23 trillion dollars. Everyone wants to pay little taxes, have a cheap gallon of gas, and tax the rich to solve our problems, while kicking the can as far down the road as possible. How many problems could have been solved with $32 trillion https://www.forbes.com/sites/mikepatton/2023/04/25/the-national-debt-approaches-32-trillion-will-it-bankrupt-america/?sh=25c72a5f5a4e https://www.forbes.com/sites/mikepatton/2023/04/25/the-natio...
- croes 3y agoWhat do you think why the rich are so rich? How much of the tax money lands in their pockets because they don't pay their employees good enough?
- harimau777 3y agoCan you explain what you are advocating? It's not clear to me what connection you are making between America's GDP and wanting the wealthy to do more. The wealthy capture the largest portion of the GDP, so America's high GDP would seem to support the idea that the wealthy can do more. It seems like you are criticizing tax rates but then you talk about how much can be done with the money that makes up the national debt. Are you advocating more or less government spending? Are you advocating more or less taxes?
- melling 3y agoNo, if you can’t figure it out then you deserve the world that you get. Saying rich people should solve the problems is the lazy answer. US consumer spending is 70% of GDP.
- blep_ 3y agoYou are not obligated to explain yourself, but you also don't get to complain when nobody knows what you're talking about.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- Wiki39366 3y ago[flagged]
- nickweb 3y agoIt’s comments like this where I wish I wasn’t so much of a lurker to get the karma required to downvote you. These are age appropriate books being sent to families of all incomes to promote good education. Let people have nice things.
- Wiki39366 3y ago[flagged]
- jjgreen 3y ago...I wish I wasn’t so much of a lurker to get the karma required to downvote you. I did that for you.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoThis is another new troll account, noticed them in the snowden thread.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoIt's actually so much that I can only imagine it's someone trying to make the right look bad with a false flag.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoThe comments are plausible sounding on the surface but obviously ridiculous if you know a bit about the subject. I didn’t know that they are exclusively right-wing oriented, but will keep an eye out.
- dredmorbius 3y agoThere are plenty of us who do. You can also emails HN mods directly at hn@ycombinator.com for specific unaddressed issues, including newly-created troll accounts. That's strongly encouraged over replying to trolls themselves: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35547193 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35547193>
- mberning 3y agoIt’s a great program. My son loves the books and I have to admit I look forward to taking him to the mailbox to check and see if one came. Many of the books are printed in a lower cost format specifically for the program. These editions have a back inside leaf that contains a blurb about the program and a picture of Dolly holding a book. My son knows her by sight and says “Thanks Dolly” when he sees her on that leaf.
- diego898 3y agoI really underestimated the program when the hospital asked if we wanted to sign up for a free book program. But my son is now three with a little library made up mostly of these books. He also loves checking the mailbox for a new book! This is such a wonderful program and I am so grateful for it. I wish/hope it becomes global.
- aperrien 3y agoIs there a way to find the list of books available in the Imagination Library?
- jffry 3y agoYes. https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=dolly+parton+imagination+library+book+list&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=dolly+parton+imagination+li...
- Tempest1981 3y agoGlad she included a book om LLMs for the kiddos: > Group 2 (Children born in 2022) > Llama Llama Red Pajama
- aperrien 3y agoFound it at: https://imaginationlibrary.com/usa/book-list/ https://imaginationlibrary.com/usa/book-list/. Really nice, there's even a pdf of the contents.
- hylaride 3y agoI hate, hate, hate country music, but I have an enormous amount of respect for Dolly Parton. She's just a plain old good person, and also extremely savvy from a business and money point of view (while having to plough through patriarchal barriers both emotionally and financially): https://www.joshuakennon.com/dolly-parton/ https://www.joshuakennon.com/dolly-parton/
- dcdc123 3y agoShe’s about to release a rock album, maybe now is your chance :D
- samstave 3y agoDolly Parton is the most wholesome and sexiest person alive. There was an interview with her just after she turned 70, and the question was something along the lines of "Do you argue with your husband (shes been married to the same man for 50+ years)" and her response was "no, if I need to win an argument, I just have sex with him to get my way"
- Jun8 3y agoI find your comment interesting and would like to understand why you hate a large genre of music. Is it the message in the songs, the people, Nashville? My taste in music is questionable (I still listen to Yaz and even Modern Talking occasionally, mixed with 80s disco, which I believe was the epitome of popular music) but I do like many Country songs: putting aside Dolly’s favorites like 9 to 5 (great lyrics and music if you haven’t listened to it), I also like many Kenny Rogers songs (guilty pleasure here is Scarlet Fever). Expanding, Folk and Bluegrass are also great.
- MoSattler 3y agoAre people familiar with Modern Talking outside of Germany?
- Jun8 3y agoAre you kidding? I grew up in Turkey and they were big there, as well as in Europe (another now forgotten blast from the past is C C Catch). I bought their In the Middle of Nowhere album, that was the year I graduated from HS. We followed them closely, eg Thomas’s Nora necklace, the weird guitar/synth thing or that Dieter played, the fact that Nora’s jealousy came in between them, etc. Looking at Spotify their top songs have robust play numbers. On a related note, in case the younger crowd here is interested: Animotion is also an interesting group, watching their Obsession clip on YouTube tells you what those times were about. Sadly none of these groups were/are known in the US. One of my “if I were a rich man” projects is to open a nightclub that only plays 80s, including these synth gems.
- nickpeterson 3y agoIt is a wonderful program. I wish more billionaires were trying to leave a legacy where their name stands for something more admirable. Will anyone know who Zuckerberg is in 100 years? Probably not.
- toochietoo 3y agoWill anyone know who one of the most influential founders in technology in history is in 100 years? I think yes…
- harimau777 3y agoThis isn't necessarily an exact comparison, but looking at the list of 1934 robber barons on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robber_baron_(industrialist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robber_baron_(industrialist) I only recognized a three of them: J. P. Morgan, John D. Rockefeller, and Andrew Carnegie. Three more I recognized universities named after them: James Duke (Duke University), Andrew Mellon (Carnegie Mellon University), Cornelius Vanderbilt (Vanderbilt University). To the degree that I have a positive opinion of Rockefeller and Carnegie, it's because of their philanthropy rather than their industrialism or politics.
- sillystuff 3y ago> To the degree that I have a positive opinion of Rockefeller and Carnegie, it's because of their philanthropy rather than their industrialism or politics. I've a friend who's grandparents, in Vietnam, were quite ruthless and accumulated sizable wealth. Now, they sponsor Buddhist monks in an effort to avoid being reincarnated as cockroaches. I suspect analogous motivations for people like Rockefeller, Carnegie, or modern equivalents like Gates and Zuckerberg (even if simply a secular motivation to rehabilitate their poor reputations). Parton just seems to be a genuinely kind human being.
- quesera 3y agoI wouldn't assume that at all. One hundred years is a long time. If people in 2123 are still talking about early social media companies, I'll be shocked. Actually I'll be dead, but I would be shocked. Zuckerberg and Facebook are relevant in the here and now, but they are not obviously Edison/Bell/Ford-level relevant in the long term. Unless either he, or his company, does something of lasting significance. Maybe Meta will have a next act. Maybe through his charitable foundation. Very much TBD.
- atan2 3y agoI was surprised to see Dolly Parton's initiative here in the UK. I just had my first newborn and the health visitors told me about Dolly Parton's Imagination Library in one of our visits. Great stuff!
- johnnylambada 3y agoI just looked up the cost to sponsor a smallish zip code in the US and it’s surprisingly inexpensive even if you’re not a millionaire or billionaire.
- germinalphrase 3y agohttps://www.imaginationlibrarywashington.org/become_an_affiliate https://www.imaginationlibrarywashington.org/become_an_affil... Relevant link (I think)
- Guidii 3y agoHow much is "surprisingly inexpensive"?
- adventured 3y agoA few dollars per child per year.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoI think it's closer to $40-$50/year. The way it works in CA is that every book costs around $4 and the cost is equally split by the state, local gov, and the Imagination Library
- johnnylambada 3y agoZip code 90740 has <800 under 5 yo kids. Total cost year 5 was something like $11k for the year.
- ksherlock 3y agoThis FAQ (via the neighboring comment) says the average rate is $2.10 per kid/month, so $25.20 per kid/year. https://assets.nationbuilder.com/uwpnw/pages/2189/attachments/original/1657642980/Affiliate_Interest_FAQ's.pdf https://assets.nationbuilder.com/uwpnw/pages/2189/attachment...
- vivegi 3y agoThis I learnt today about Dolly Parton! Very impressed with this work.
- syngrog66 3y agoI like that its blind to anything else other than if the household has kids under 5 in it. Doesn't matter their ethnicity/color, gender, income, doc status, etc. imo more government aid programs and charities should be like that. give to anyone in need or who would otherwise benefit from the given thing unfortunately I've seen way too many special carve-outs and "allowed" discrimination to happen. which just further fuels political grievances.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- virgulino 3y ago"UK PhD Research: Books Babies and Bonding - The impact of Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library on parental engagement in book-sharing and on child development from 0-5 years old." https://youtu.be/pKU5kqKypY4 https://youtu.be/pKU5kqKypY4