4 ms·
It is remarkable to see (in this age of the internet) the huge gap between what the media believes about the present vs. what is more likely based on the far de
by roenxi 3y ago
It is remarkable to see (in this age of the internet) the huge gap between what the media believes about the present vs. what is more likely based on the far deeper amount of information made available on the internet.
Society is made up of many parallel subcultures, and only a very small group of them keep journals, write, or otherwise record history. That group appears to be mostly disconnected from the nuts and bolts of what is actually going on technologically, politically and economically.
It has always been understood that history was unreliable, but the collapse of media credibility as we gain access to primary sources stands as a stark warning of just how little we really know about the past.
- revskill 3y agoHistory is written by not the winner, but those who accuire power.
- macrolime 3y agoOr by those who make the headlines that get the most clicks. Often stories are exaggerated or twisted, not for any particular side, but for attention and clicks.
- 77pt77 3y agoPotato, potato.
- visarga 3y agoHistory is written by those who know how to write. For a long time they were a small minority. Even poor monks could leave manuscripts. Not necessarily the "winners".
- nicbou 3y agoAlthough certain writing has a greater chance of being considered important, and of surviving through time.
- echelon 3y agoIs this why "defeatist" narratives feel so much more prevalent lately? Those at the bottom are sharing their pain and suffering more widely on social media? Not that their experiences aren't valid, but that there is an overwhelming feeling that "America sucks and is failing" when this isn't a true assessment. Not for the middle class and above, and especially not relative to the rest of the world on average. Social media lumps all voices in together and tends to amplify strong feelings. But if you zoomed out, you'd see a very different picture of what constitutes this collective voice.
- mxkopy 3y ago...is your solution to have those sharing their pain and suffering made to stop? I seriously don't understand your point, nor the level of mental gymnastics it takes to see a trend of independently dissatisfied people and say - oh, my neighborhood is doing fine, you're just being defeatist. I'd wager that if you "zoom out" what you see is a dangerously reckless societal experiment for some, and a life of modern amenities for others. Both can be true at the same time.
- echelon 3y agoGood news is seldom shared or amplified. It's also seldom relevant, but I'd argue the same is true of the negativity. Online content is overwhelmingly negative. Bad things happen, but in reality the proportionality is much smaller than you encounter online. But negativity is what gets amplified, since that drives engagement. The smallest grievances become threads that take up disproportional space in the attention feed and crowd out the rest. I guess I'm wondering if this isn't just the algorithm, but also an amplification of certain subpopulations over others. The ones that tend to be angry. > ...is your solution to have those sharing their pain and suffering made to stop? I want a mute button. Or a threshold that caps it past a certain point. Or, if this is just some people contributing to most of the problem, maybe just a way to opt out of their noisiest signals. People can say all they want, but it doesn't mean they deserve a place in my limited attention and emotional energy feed. Emotion is contagious. I want my media use to drop to only the most salient bits. And I want it to be more positive.
- ramblenode 3y agoMost records don't survive. Over any considerable timespan, the ones that do have been copied and rewritten dozens or hundreds of times (with the exception of a few archeological gems). Every generation is curating the past based on what they think is important.
- Mezzie 3y ago> It has always been understood that history was unreliable, but the collapse of media credibility as we gain access to primary sources stands as a stark warning of just how little we really know about the past. Establishing provenance and reliability post 2020 is going to be...interesting...
- anamexis 3y agoWhy 2020 specifically?
- tarkin2 3y agoGenerative AI
- Mezzie 3y agoSpecifically the combination of generative AI and the lack of current understanding of it by the history-making professions (archivists and historians). Historians and archivists rely a lot on primary sources and right now digital provenance is already a dumpster fire - I don't even want to think of what generative AI is going to do. A lot of the methods traditionally used for identifying an authentic primary source aren't going to work with generative AI.
- kiba 3y agoIt isn't particularly new, given that most of our media are either doctored, touched up, or manipulated in some ways. Most of us don't have VFX knowledge or the ability to detect minute flaws in Deepfake works. We do it through by filtering and selecting sources of information.
- HellDunkel 3y ago> It is remarkable to see (in this age of the internet) the huge gap between what the media believes about the present vs. what is more likely based on the far deeper amount of information made available on the internet. So "the media" has no internet? > Society is made up of many parallel subcultures, and only a very small group of them keep journals, write, or otherwise record history. That group appears to be mostly disconnected from the nuts and bolts of what is actually going on technologically, politically and economically. Is the fact they write or record history stopping them from digging out those real deep youtube videos about the truth behind everything? > It has always been understood that history was unreliable, but the collapse of media credibility as we gain access to primary sources stands as a stark warning of just how little we really know about the past. Did "the media credibility" collapse in that very moment when you found out that the pentagon was behind 9/11?
- marcosdumay 3y ago> Did "the media credibility" collapse in that very moment when you found out that the pentagon was behind 9/11? That's a funny question to ask, because a huge amount of people on the US lost confidence on the media exactly because most of them conspired to lie to the public about Iraq's WMDs shortly after 9/11.
- HellDunkel 3y agoEven funnier: most US citizen were pro Iraq war first, then embarrassed, then looking for someone else to blame...
- esafak 3y agoI don't remember the embarrassment stage. I think it went from pro-war to forgetting about it. President Obama said it himself: "we need to look forward as opposed to looking backwards".
- joenot443 3y agoI’m curious, are you deliberately avoiding the very obvious implication that “most US citizen” only felt that way because of CNN/Fox messaging? I feel like you’re remembering this timeline pretty poorly. Were you living in the US at the time?
- omgwtfbyobbq 3y agoThis reminds me of old shows about Big Foot, Yeti, the Loch Ness Monster, etc... Now that many people can easily take videos/photos on there phones, it turns out there's a lot of official and police misconduct, bigotry, and people acting like dilholes in general, and not many monsters. At least not yet.
- sbuk 3y ago> …it turns out there's a lot of official and police misconduct, bigotry, and people acting like dilholes in general, and not many monsters. One can argue they are the monsters
- bigmattystyles 3y agoSimilarly, miracles and credible supernatural events have all but stopped. Odd.
- signalToNose 3y agoDidn’t they just release a lot of military ufo videos. Most of them already debunked by several YouTubeers
- imtringued 3y agoThe end result of analyzing the UFO videos just ends up publicizing more and more details of military technology that should be kept secret. By that I don't mean that aliens are real, I mean the far more mundane implications of military espionage such as your enemy having extensive knowledge about your sensor capabilities because that is what most of these UFO sightings are, they are sensor artifacts.
- dustymcp 3y agoyet the earth is more flat it is remarkable..
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoThere have been far more sightings and phone recordings of the LNM than there used to be. They just don't make the headlines any more. I'm agnostic about the LNM and don't lean either way. And of course this is now History Channel click-tainment, so it's not a serious topic. Even so - it's not factually correct to suggest there are no recent photos or videos of surface phenomena that seem to match the profile.
- _8j50 3y agoI disagree. Historically, having a lot of subcultures wasn't a thing in any society I've heard about. Even in the west today, what people call a subculture is just people doing stuff that is conformant with the dominant culture (mostly individualism and progressivism, what indivduality or direction of progress might change and people think that's a subculture). History looks at all available sources not just popular ones. Merely surviving up to the present age is a huge feat for any historical evidence. I am constantly seeing disputed history when I look into historical events or figures. I only agree with your last sentence because much of history was oral and like the game of telephone it has gotten distorted or just lost.