6 ms·
Why labor shortages could be here to stay
- jleyank 3y agoFolks wanted boomers to get out of the way. Many of us have or will soon. This opens up positions at the top end and starts returning the savings to the general economy.
- nradov 3y agoSavings from what? Boomers will still be consuming a lot of resources for a couple decades yet. But they won't be productive or paying much in the way of taxes anymore, which means that younger generations will have to endure higher taxes and/or inflation to support the Boomers. Someone has to pay those assisted living facility bills. (And to be clear, I am not arguing for abandoning the Boomers or anything like that.)
- patmorgan23 3y agoSocial Security, pensions, and traditional IRA/401k withdrawals are all taxable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- datavirtue 3y agoSo weird.
- deprecative 3y agoAnd all of these will be gone when Millennials retire. I'll retire when I die. Social Security? Gone. Pensions? Don't exist. 401k? Pennies. So, there's not going to be much there for us.
- jleyank 3y agoDump on boomers if you’d like but we didn’t create social media. The pipes, yeah, but the kids and grandkids created the environment we live in. Boomer hackers made tools. Their descendants sold ads and collected data.
- laratied 3y agoThis is delusional. The boomers voted themselves entitlements that is going to practically break the system. I am GenX and don't have social media but this is such standard Boomer thought. Just no idea how much you are fucking everyone over. Niall Ferguson even mentions how the boomers have basically broken the generational social contract. Previous generations never borrowed everything they possibly could from their grandkids and the unborn. Generation Me.
- jleyank 3y agoNot me mate, sorry. Spent 40+ years working for the man paying my taxes. Didn’t vote for the monied party, so lost a whole lot of elections. Given the view of techbros here we’re both posting in the wrong place. Get involved. Vote. Change things (back).
- mensetmanusman 3y agoWork to live. I hope you have an enjoyable retirement :)
- adammarples 3y agoThis is not useful. Boomers transitioning from helping generate supply, ie. Working, to generating demand, ie spending their savings - all that does is increase the money in circulation while decreasing the stuff. Inflation is not going anywhere for some time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- renewedrebecca 3y agoIt's not a "labor shortage." It's a "companies don't want to pay people what they're worth" problem. Throw wads of cash on the table. There will be no "shortage."
- alexandre_m 3y agoOr it's really a shortage, and when you're the highest bider for a talent pool on the market what really happens is that a person who's employed will leave their current employer to work for you, therefore just creating a shortage of employees for the competitors. The validation of "shortage" is really simple. If every employer pays the same high-end market salary, is every open position filled?
- kelseyfrog 3y agoIf their business depended on it, I'm sure we would see no shortage of creative solutions like funding education or training needed to do the job. If the pool is too small, then the problem switches to growing the pool.
- vuln 3y agoThen you have Congress artificially restraining the pool knowing full well there is a dire shortage. https://www.openhealthpolicy.com/p/medical-residency-slots-congress https://www.openhealthpolicy.com/p/medical-residency-slots-c...
- kelseyfrog 3y agoThat's funny. You now have the AMA lobbying against the caps they originally lobbied for.
- massysett 3y agoSaw a great video about the Army doing this. Youth are too fat to qualify for the Army. The brass stopped complaining about it and started a “fat camp” to train recruits into shape. https://youtu.be/P-n7wXqMorU https://youtu.be/P-n7wXqMorU
- diordiderot 3y agoWhen are they going to end the Lambo and Caviar shortages?
- gumby 3y agoImmigration is the easy fix for this.
- linksnapzz 3y ago...sorta like putting a penny in a fuse box.
- i2cmaster 3y ago[flagged]
- gumby 3y agoAs the article makes clear up front, the number of people in the USA of working age is diminishing faster than the rate of overall population is growing. Yes, raising pay will bring some retirees into the workforce (is that good or bad for those people?) but won’t materially increase the size of the pool. If your country’s population is growing you are “giving away” the land to other people, and of course different people have different attitudes…what is considered “culture” changes regardless.
- i2cmaster 3y agoThis only makes sense if you think of people as fungible. Also one of the main drivers of the low birth rate in the US is the housing/land shortage. Recovery depends on the population shrinking.
- datavirtue 3y agoMaybe, but if you aren't begging immigrants to come to America in the next ten years I'll eat my hat. We should be competing for immigrants right now. Unless you like economic stagnation (save for a possible AI productivity revolution).
- i2cmaster 3y ago[flagged]
- nradov 3y agoAnalyst Peter Zeihan has been pointing out for a while that the number of highly productive skilled workers in the labor pool is going to decline temporarily just due to demographics. The Baby Boom generation is rapidly retiring, the Millennials are still too young to reach peak productivity (on average for most industries), and Generation X in the middle is relatively small. This means a period of high inflation. https://zeihan.com/demographics-part-3-the-xer-cut/ https://zeihan.com/demographics-part-3-the-xer-cut/
- tuatoru 3y agoThe economist Charles Goodhart has been beating this drum for a couple of decades and more. The great thing about demographics is it's about the only area in which we can make predictions about the (near) future with any degree of precision (or accuracy). However pointing out these looming problems and advocating family-friendly and child-bearing-friendly polices just got Goodhart labeled as a right-wing anti-gay nutjob back in the '00s and '10s. 1. Goodhart has finally (2020) written a book after decades of writing pieces on Project Syndicate and VoxEU: https://www.amazon.com/Great-Demographic-Reversal-Societies-Inequality/dp/3030426564 https://www.amazon.com/Great-Demographic-Reversal-Societies-...
- than3 3y agoI really hate people that idolize other people that get it wrong just as much as they get it right. The baby boom generation isn't retiring, they are rapidly dying because they are now in their 70s/80s and that's what happens when old age takes you. When there were downturns, the experienced workers crowded out the entry level positions normally used to build job experience. This has set back and snowballed every generation after the baby-boom generation. This lack of experienced labor, coupled with the massive amount of currency debasement means we are going into a period of high inflation and low production but its more about the currency debasement than anything else with regards to inflation. You can't print money to pay debts owed indefinitely. Like any ponzi it eventually has consequences. Many generations starting with Gen-X were hobbled at vulnerable times in their financial life. There is no predicting what is coming aside from the generalization that there will be lower birth rates because people are less financially secure, and have no say because representatives are only responsive to campaign contributions (see tweedism larry lessig). There are times in our lives where if we don't have children, then it doesn't happen for a large majority. You need to be debt free and have a downpayment of a house by 30, and children no later than 35 for women. Mortality, complications, and birth defects kicks in after that. Children are expensive and the cost is borne by the parents. Simple economics, if the cost of labor goes below what is needed by a family unit to support the mother and father 2 children to 18 then it doesn't happen. This was well known in 1776 only back then it was 4 children because of mortality. Something so widely and commonly known being so completely ignored by the people who are supposed to know best, really goes to show how bad things are going to get.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoCountries get old fast, here is a fertility rate of 1 (higher than South Korea): Year 0: 100 newborns Year 20: 100 twenties, 50 newborns Year 40: 100 forties, 50 twenties, 25 newborns Year 60: 100 sixties, 50 forties, 25 twenties, 12 newborns Year 80: 50 sixties, 25 forties, 12 twenties, 6 newborns Year 100: 25 sixties, 12 forties, 6 twenties, 3 newborns Year 120: 12 sixties, 6 forties, 3 twenties, 1 newborn We are nearing the midpoint of this in many parts of the world. Labor and GDP be gone.
- than3 3y agoGDP was never an accurate measure of national production. It makes no distinction between the number of people its concentrated in. You can't really claim its national production if only one person controls it, as in some countries is done...
- maerF0x0 3y agoAnd that's why replacement rate (including immigration) is important to the stability of society. With a dynamic value (exponential growth or decay) we struggle to properly predict the future needs. But with a stablish pattern we can mostly maintain, with little adaptations along the way.
- pg_1234 3y agoActually you achieve a kind of financial stability in the above example if each older generation relinquishes their accumulated wealth to the younger generation as a 2 to 1 rate. i.e. 2 Boomers give up their wealth to 1 Millennial for services rendered. The "haves" just don't like how the supply and demand equation is swinging back in favor of the "have not but can still work". As for the services rendered in return, well, supply side constraints dictate you settle for what's available ... that's all there is.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThere is much less to buy or afford when there is so much competition for the small workforce providing services or labor.