11 ms·
US lawmakers urge PayPal to end ban on Palestinians in Occupied Territories
- RobotToaster 3y ago>lawmakers urge Shouldn't lawmakers, um, make laws? Instead of asking nicely?
- bushbaba 3y agoBecause this is a minority opinion speaking.
- boomboomsubban 3y agoYes, but I wouldn't be surprised if signing a meaningless letter an aide wrote gives better PR than pushing for a failed bill. And it's hard to imagine a pro-Palestine bill actually passing.
- mikece 3y agoThey don't have a majority sufficient to make such a law (or a super-majority to override a veto).
- q1w2 3y agoCorrect - the letter was signed by 11 out of 535 members of congress. ...and it was the very vocal anti-Israeli ones, such as Rashida Tlaib
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- flagrant_taco 3y agoWhat would that law look like exactly? It couldn't single or PayPal and likely shouldn't single or Palestine to be sorry all the time and effort to get it passed.
- fsflover 3y ago"A company with <revenue/number of users/...> larger than <number> may not freeze your account without giving any reason and without any recourse.
- flagrant_taco 3y agoThat's a pretty serious step with the federal government directly limiting what every business can do. I'm not actually sure if that would even be constitutional given that it severely limits how potentially privately owned businesses set their own terms of use. Defining what those limits are is entirely arbitrary, how do we pick a number that makes sense universally? Is that number adjusted for inflation, population size, business market share, etc? Does this only apply to financial service businesses, regulated financial institutions, or any business? What's the legal definition here for freezing an account? Writing clear laws isn't an easy or fast process, especially when you're talking about a government regulation 300M+ citizens spread across 50 different states with their own laws.
- polski-g 3y ago> That's a pretty serious step with the federal government directly limiting what every business can do. I'm not actually sure if that would even be constitutional given that it severely limits how potentially privately owned businesses set their own terms of use. See: https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/civil-rights-act https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/civil-rights-ac...
- flagrant_taco 3y agoI never said there isn't precedent for the government seeing some limits on what companies can do. It's important to note, though, that this is a constitutional amendment rather than a law and had a much higher requirement to pass. This precedent would also be equating the civil rights protections within American borders with the rights of non-US citizens to use a company's payment service in a foreign territory. Not sure that is be comfortable comparing those two issues.
- somebody78978 3y agoI don't think the U.S. government has the right to force a company to operate in another country.
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y agoHowever they do have the power to end a boycott, either directly or indirectly (see the laws passed by various states regarding refusing to do business with Israel).
- giraffe_lady 3y agoThe ones that criminalize participating in a boycott? A fourth grader can identity those as flatly unconstitutional.
- user982 3y agoAnd yet: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-BDS_laws#Anti-BDS_laws_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-BDS_laws#Anti-BDS_laws_in...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- giraffe_lady 3y agoYeah the immediately following "public opinion" section is particularly interesting. really makes u think.
- user982 3y agoI do wonder how Pew got such drastically different results from every other poll.
- giraffe_lady 3y ago
- mikece 3y agoI wish lawmakers would urge (or force?) PayPal to actually give you a detailed reason when they freeze your account and effectively confiscate your money. I still have hundreds of dollars tied up in the limbo of "your account is frozen but we won't tell you why."
- zerr 3y agoTry withdrawing again. They unblock it without any notification while keeping the account limited.
- KptMarchewa 3y agoIt's the other way around. If you're flagged for AML investigation, telling you it would be tipping off and explicitely illegal.
- Detrytus 3y agoIf you are engaged in money laundering then the very fact that your funds were frozen is enough of the tip-off. If you’re not then they might as well tell you about their suspicions. If you were mixed up in some money laundering scheme involuntarily you might even be willing to help the investigation
- antihero 3y agoMaybe, but not legally.
- KMag 3y agoExactly. I spent 11+ years in a Fortune 500 financial services company, and my annual anti-money laundering training always stressed (and included one quiz question) that if you saw something fishy, escalate to Compliance, and UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES share suspicions with clients. Even if some aspect of the regulation doesn't make much sense, you do not cross the regulators.
- bee_rider 3y ago
- stevespang 3y ago[dead]
- mschuster91 3y agoThe only thing this will result in is even more funding for Hamas, and possibly even money laundering for Iran.
- petesergeant 3y agoWhat should ordinary people in the territories do?
- lesuorac 3y agoI mean per the article, Palastine has banks with corresponding US banks to handle transfers. So, ordinary people of those territories can use their banks.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoWhat kind of hurdles does someone need to overcome to transfer money to a Palestinian through the bank? Banks deal with the same OFAC requirements that PayPal does.
- gl-prod 3y agoIf they can just use their banks, why was PayPal created?
- lesuorac 3y agoWhy stop there, if they could use Bank A why does Bank B exist? PayPal does not uniquely solve any problem.
- mschuster91 3y agoGet rid of Hamas instead of shooting rockets at Israel?
- Somatochlora 3y agoYou do not believe that there are any Palestinians who might have legitimate uses for PayPal?
- annoyingnoob 3y agoOr just don't use PayPal. There is nothing necessary about PayPal.
- jb12 3y agoGiven the recent seizure of crypto accounts funnelling money to Hamas and Iran[0], this seems pretty sensible, to funnel more financial activity in the region onto platforms that have good AML/ATF processes. [0]: https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-seizes-30-crypto-wallets-allegedly-used-to-fund-hamas https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-seizes-30-crypto-wallet...
- f6v 3y agoIt might as well be that the only reason why Iran and others are active in Palestine is because it’s blockaded.
- vxNsr 3y agoBefore all this they had legal and fair election where they elected a terrorist org: Hamas. Stop infantilizing an entire people. They are adults with their own agency. They are responsible for the decisions they make. The reason a terrorist group runs things there is because they want it to. In fact, if elections were held today, Hamas would lose… to Islamic Jihad because they’re more radical. Support for Hamas has been waning in recent years not because they’re a failed government but because they’ve failed to deliver serious harm to Israelis. The reason Iran is active there is because their interests are aligned (destroy Israel). The reason PayPal doesn’t operate there is because the AML/KYC would be much too expensive for the amount of money they could possibly make on entering that market. The reason these “lawmakers” are agitating for this is because they hate the state of Israel.
- f6v 3y agoWell, I support neither Islamists, nor Israel. And I can see how Palestinians look like terrorist to someone from Israel. But I can understand that IDF looks like a terrorist organization when they drop bombs on your head. Point is, both sides take extremely violent actions which affect non-combatants, at least from time to time. It’s hypocritical to take a side. They all suck, but the UN is too dysfunctional to change anything.
- yieldcrv 3y agoit sounds like we need an anti-OFAC law. Instead of only telling companies who they can't transact with, tell them who they can't arbitrarily not transact with. We need a financial bill of rights. Custody and payment rails should be like public utilities where everyone can use them regardless of your opinions about them.
- edgyquant 3y agoAny financial bill of rights passed would not apply to Palestinians
- yieldcrv 3y agoIt would apply to the companies located elsewhere who would now be forced not to be exclusionary
- from 3y agoI think Republicans tried something like this in the aftermath of Choke Point, it didn't go anywhere: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/house-republicans-money-laundering_n_5717877 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/house-republicans-money-laund....
- droopyEyelids 3y agoI'm curious why PayPal bans Palestinians. It's not like they want to limit their addressable market. Seems likely related to OFAC, which is tough to google casually https://ofac.treasury.gov/sanctions-programs-and-country-information https://ofac.treasury.gov/sanctions-programs-and-country-inf... Nothing specific to Palestine on the country programs, but OFAC explains further that our sanctions are much more complicated than country-by-country here: https://ofac.treasury.gov/sanctions-programs-and-country-information/where-is-ofacs-country-list-what-countries-do-i-need-to-worry-about-in-terms-of-us-sanctions https://ofac.treasury.gov/sanctions-programs-and-country-inf...
- bushbaba 3y ago[flagged]
- willcipriano 3y ago> Palestinian government does pay its citizens if they kill an Israel in a suicide attack I assume Israel dosent provide any survivor benefits for it's soldiers?
- gadders 3y agoI don't think it's contingent on them killing someone else.
- bushbaba 3y agothese aren’t solders on either end. If a Palestinian non combatant resident kills an Israeli child. The Palestinian or their surviving family will get a payment. And yes, many Israeli children have been killed through such programs.
- willcipriano 3y agoIf a Israeli kills a Palestinian child (like this [0]) and is later killed himself, would his family receive survivorship benefits? If Palestinian fighting men aren't soldiers does that mean Israel is killing non combatants? [0]https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/eight-palestinian-children-killed-gaza-strip-last-night https://www.unicef.org/press-releases/eight-palestinian-chil...
- flagrant_taco 3y agoI've had absolutely terrible experiences with Palpal. Lawmakers should be urging everyone to use a better service, forget worrying about PayPal's ban. The last straw for me was when they blocked a transaction of a few hundred dollars without any explaination. I was talking to a support rep for well over an hour, repeatedly being told that there is no security team at PayPal that can see why a transaction was blocked override the block. I was told the security system was a black box, they wouldn't transferred me to a supervisor, and the end result was a recommendation to try a different payment system like bank transfer. This happened to be on the day we were selling our house. The buyer came in with a cash offer and a 7-day close. The inspection results came back after the paperwork was already drawn up, when they asked for a few hundred for electrical repairs it should have been easier to do that as an addendum rather that completely redoing the closing settlement sheet. I guess PayPal had better ideas.
- miroljub 3y ago> I've had absolutely terrible experiences with Palpal. Lawmakers should be urging everyone to use a better service, forget worrying about PayPal's ban. I'd rather have the government enforce something like user-friendly free globally available instant payment and settlement system. Then none of these shady services would be required. Fox example, a version of SWIFT, but instant, free and distributed.
- mschuster91 3y agoThat's not going to be possible, alone because there are countries like Iran or North Korea or maybe-countries like Palestine which are sanctioned for good reasons.
- rightbyte 3y agoWhat good reasons? Kim Jung Un can send boats with gold bars. Meanwhile I can't send money without the bank asking me 'what ya gonna do with "your" money little friend?' Just have the money in escrow for 30 days or whatever if fraud is a concern. It is all about messing with us and showing who is in charge.
- propogandist 3y ago[flagged]
- giraffe_lady 3y ago> It’s antisemitic to even suggest there’s an occupied Palestine. How?
- joshenberg 3y agoPeople with loooong memories will say that Islamic Palestine arose after the forcible removal of Jewish culture from the area after the Jewish wars against Rome, at which point the Romans relabelled the area from Judea to Syria Palestina. Therefore the idea that Palestinians are 'indigenous' is in contention, since the diasporic Jewish people retained their language and customs in the interim, and then sought refuge in their land of origin throughout the early 20th century and beyond. Even the word 'semitic' describes a cultural (language) origin in the Middle East, so to describe Palestine as occupied (and therefore the Jews as being interlopers) is technically "antisemitic". I don't think these things excuse the human rights abuses caused by the current state, but its opponents often call for its dissolution based on their 'rightful' ownership of the land which is a gray area.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoOK thanks for the answer I guess. That seems like a lot of technical scaffolding to disqualify the use of a common, useful, and mostly accurate shorthand description of the current political arrangement there. I will continue to call it an occupation and continue to get called antisemitic for that probably.
- z3c0 3y agoSadly, its use in politics has shifted the term from referring to a brand of hatred to simply meaning that you do not agree with Israel's claims of victimhood.
- throwawaaarrgh 3y ago[flagged]
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoThat will never happen though. Israel would become a minority Jewish nation. On the other hand, if they just took the land and expelled the people, everybody would see it as genocide.
- red_trumpet 3y ago> That will never happen though. Israel would become a minority Jewish nation. Do you have a good overview source how many arabs/jews live in the occupied regions?
- HDMI_Cable 3y agoThe State of Israel (including Area C under the Oslo Accords) had a population of ~9,650,000, of which ~7,100,600 are Jewish (for reference, about 600,000 are settlers in Area C, 250,000 of whom are in East Jerusalem). ~3,990,000 Palestinians (Muslim & Christian) live in Areas A and B. If Israel were to annex Areas A, B, and C, the total population would be ~13,650,000, with 7,100,000 Jewish people and ~6,550,000 Muslim + Christian + Druze people [1]. So, a slight majority would still be Jewish, but that would completely change the demographics of the nation. --- [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Israel#Definition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Israel#Definit...
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoIn addition, the Muslim population have more children than the Jewish population. so that slight majority wouldn't last.
- js212 3y agoBeing a Zionist and supporting settlers are not mutual. Being a Zionist is simply supporting a Jewish state not everything the government does.
- hospitalJail 3y agoIsnt this what Bitcoin is for? Use Bitcoin. There are services that will convert bitcoin to other currencies and vice versa. We don't need paypal.
- TimJRobinson 3y agoWhy would people use Bitcoin over sending USDC or other USD stablecoins directly on any other chain?
- dogman144 3y agoBecause that new boss is same as the old boss ``` /* * @title Blacklistable Token * @dev Allows accounts to be blacklisted by a "blacklister" role */ contract Blacklistable is Ownable { ``` [0] https://etherscan[.]io/address/0xa2327a938febf5fec13bacfb16ae10ecbc4cbdcf#code https://etherscan[.]io/address/0xa2327a938febf5fec13bacfb16a...
- TimJRobinson 3y agoI doubt Palestinians are worried about being blacklisted considering the only people that have been blacklisted are hackers and North Korea. And anyone that is worried can use LUSD/DAI/GRAI or a myriad of other fully decentralized USD stablecoins.
- dogman144 3y agoI doubt (choose a figure at this point: Snowden, Assange, Palestinians, OnlyFans) needs to get worried about getting blacklisted financially because (choose a reason how they wouldn’t get financially blacklisted based on precedent, and then were blacklisted). Specific payment rails behavior has never mattered with this, it’s always about the ability existing as people jump across payment options.
- hk1337 3y agoPaypal is trash, everyone should use something else anyways. Venmo is trash and sketchy AF (also part of PayPal).
- Eumenes 3y ago100%. I don't use any payment/money apps and my life hasn't skipped a beat. If friends complain, I tell them to write me a check or give me cash. Works just fine.
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- hersko 3y agoThis[1] interview gave me more of a nuanced understanding of the whole situation. Highly recommend it. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wv8F4NLr4E0&t=194s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wv8F4NLr4E0&t=194s
- upofadown 3y agoDoes US law have anything to say about private companies supporting human rights abuse in other countries through their policies?
- capableweb 3y agoIf it did, almost none of the top companies in the US would exists anymore. Of course it doesn't.
- dathinab 3y agothe US often doesn't even have to say anything about human right abuse _in_ the US
- bhouston 3y agoI think it doesn't because it wants to control what is polices, rather than relying on third parties like human rights groups to decide that.
- droptablemain 3y agoThe U.S. doesn't care about "human rights" if the supposed perpetrator supports U.S. hegemony.
- user982 3y agoYes, US law in 35 states does have something to say: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-BDS_laws#Anti-BDS_laws_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-BDS_laws#Anti-BDS_laws_in... Namely, if you do not support the human rights abuses of one particular country, action will be taken against you.
- causi 3y agoPeople forget that just because a payment services is so entrenched and powerful that many people think of it more like a public utility doesn't mean it isn't just as amoral as any other company. Visa has shattered entire industries on a whim by deciding it was simply more profitable not to service certain classes of people or professions. Somehow they're allowed to do that. We need common-carrier rules for payment processors.
- johngladtj 3y agoHave you considered that regulation is what causes those issues?
- ausbah 3y agostuff like processing sex industry related payments isn't illegal but isn't supported by big payment processors so it's defacto illegal. govt indecision to regulate here allows them to make shots of how economy operates via monopoly power
- from 3y agoThe sad reality is that Paypal doesn't serve these territories because they are "high risk" and also low income which means the amount of compliance officers they would have to employ to watch people in these territories and the regulatory penalties for accidentally letting a Hamas transaction slip through (these aren't easy to detect either as the government emphasizes that "terrorist financing" can be as little as a few hundred dollars at a time, in fact most terrorist financing prosecutions involve amounts < $10000) probably does not exceed the amount of fees they would earn.
- belter 3y agoFunny...PayPal is available to Israeli settlers residing in illegal settlements in the occupied West Bank. So it seems it is not the region...Western Union seems to be able to manage fine there: https://location.westernunion.com/ps?page=2&country=PS&q=Palestine https://location.westernunion.com/ps?page=2&country=PS&q=Pal...
- q1w2 3y agoThis is also why they don't serve Haiti, for example. It's also not coincidental that this letter was just written, since only a couple months ago Hamas was forced to stop accepting Bitcoin donations because a number of their donators in the US were arrested after their contributions were arrested for sponsoring the terrorist group. In fact it's such an unlikely coincidence, that some of the 11 US legislators that signed this letter are associated with non-profits who's donations seem to trickle into Hamas bank accounts... Source: https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/house/ilhan-omar-rashida-tlaib-democrats-hamas-american-muslims-palestine https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/house/ilhan-omar-ras...