9 ms·
Sam Altman Says OpenAI Will Leave the EU If There's Any Real AI Regulation
- henearkr 3y agoOne day he says AI is frightening and must be regulated, one other day he says I don't want AI regulations...
- jeroenhd 3y ago"It must be regulated according to my ethics" isn't a new stance in the tech world. It's also possible that any calls for reasonable regulation were just pandering towards investors. Key FTX people also called for regulation of the crypto market, after all. It projects a willingness to be a good and compliant company, even if they'd wish they themselves wouldn't have to comply.
- m3affan 3y agoExactly this. I am pretty sure he's bluffing, and even if not, by the time they decide to pull their operations, many alternative would be on the market (there are already many).
- 3np 3y agoAltman is the new BF
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoIt’s as if he wants AI regulations that only benefit OpenAI.
- bilbo0s 3y agoIf we can comply, we will, and if we can’t, we’ll cease operating… We will try. But there are technical limits to what’s possible. He didn't say he doesn't want them. He said AIs, for a lot of reasons, may not be able to operate within the confines of potential regulations. For a simple example, they may be trained on work that was not properly licensed in the EU. That's only one compliance challenge in one dimension, but there are a large number of dimensions in which AIs might fall outside the mandated parameters. Obviously people will try, but there are reality based technical limitations.
- mschuster91 3y agoThis reminds me strongly of the famous cartoon "A brief history of corporate whining" [1]. US companies said the same when the EU enacted the RoHS regulations, they said the same when the EU passed the GDPR, and it will be just the same with AI regulations: the European market is just too massive to ignore it. [1] https://leftycartoons.com/2009/09/04/a-brief-history-of-corporate-whining/ https://leftycartoons.com/2009/09/04/a-brief-history-of-corp...
- ilyt 3y agoEvery thread about GDPR have people (I assume from US, especially given it being HN) whining how "hard" it is to implement (just don't store user data by default, how hard is that?) and how "overbearing" it is. Then big surprise when another news about US spying on its citizens harder than people thought drops...
- scarface74 3y agoIf the law is that simple, then why did it take 11 chapters and 99 sections to say that?
- mschuster91 3y agoBecause European laws tend to be very precise and detailed, so that people can rely on them instead of a situation in the US where the effective boundaries of the law are only created in the subsequent years by the courts. It is easier to read the law and the cover text explaining the reasoning behind the regulations than to read a vague US/UK style law and then having to research court rulings, looking which of these conflict with each other or if they're even applicable (as I recently learned here, y'all's federal courts are organized in circuits and a ruling of a federal court is only binding for that circuit).
- scarface74 3y agoAnd yet small businesses in the EU are still getting caught up in it.
- simion314 3y agoYeah, sure. Like Microsoft does not like EU money. Though is funny he asks USA for regulation to regulate his competitors.
- sonotathrowaway 3y agoHe does not want the USA to regulate his company. He will lobby against every attempt to do so, he’s proposing a new agency specifically because it’s the most unwieldy proposal possible. This has been the tech playbook for close to two decades now, it’s time we stop participating in the charade.
- Veen 3y agoI get the impression Altman would like the US to regulate other AI companies, so that only the "responsible" ones can provide AI based services (i.e. OpenAI and Microsoft). It would take care of his moat problem.
- simion314 3y agoI think he will be happy to split the market with Google and Apple, but he probably is scared of Open Source, most server run Linux or BSD and open source programming languages, and most server stuff is based on open source libraries. Would be the same for LLM, you would have many small but very specific LLMs.
- jeroenhd 3y ago> If we can comply, we will, and if we can’t, we’ll cease operating… We will try. But there are technical limits to what’s possible. Isn't that what any normal company does? Comply until it's impossible to operate legally? They can choose between ceasing to operate or getting arrested. If the AI regulations are reasonable and AI companies can't operate, the technology just isn't ready for wide-spread adoption yet. See also: Tesla's Autopilot. I have to wonder what the investors over at Microsoft are thinking right now. I doubt they'll be happy with threats of leaving lucrative markets from a company so deeply integrated into their product suite.
- chii 3y agoBy proclaiming they'd leave if they can't comply, it might cause the EU regulators to "self-censor" the regulation such that it's "easy to comply". but tbh, i dont see what the regulations would be. I am a fan of no regulation unless actual harm has been shown first.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y ago> I am a fan of no regulation unless actual harm has been shown first. I used to be, but some of the modern crop of CEOs has taken the wind out of that. They have done tremendous damage, very quickly, and the regulation has been unable to keep up, until severe damage has already been done. Once the bullet has left the gun, it can't be stuffed back in.
- bionhoward 3y agoCan you be more specific, with examples? Who did what?
- themitigating 3y agoYou need an example of a bad thing happening because regulations didn't exist?
- orwin 3y ago
- shafyy 3y agoAh, so the regulator has become the regulatee.
- Fnoord 3y agoQuis custodiet ipsos custodes?
- blibble 3y agoany chance can they take Microsoft with them? and the Tesla self driving
- shafyy 3y agoEU market is too big to ignore. We have seen this with Meta and others play out multiple times since GDPR has been increasingly enforced in the past decade. That's why it's important the EU keeps pushing, hopefully mostly sensible, regulation. There is no other counterweight that's aligned with consumer interests rather than corporate interests. Sure, you can accuse EU of hidden protectionisms blabla, but for now, this is better than nothing.
- spacebanana7 3y ago> EU market is too big to ignore It's not what it used to be. The EU's makes up around 15-20% of world GDP depending on how you measure it, but that's subject to disproportionality high taxes and compliance costs. Meta only gets around 10% of its ad earnings from the EU [1]. I'm not aware of the figures for Google and Microsoft or whether such figures are even available. Many global banks left the US or reduced it to skeleton operations after the wave of regulation following '08. Unfriendly enough behaviour might cause a similar reaction from tech in the EU. [1] "What we do know is that roughly 10% of worldwide ad revenue comes from ads delivered to Facebook users in E.U. countries", Meta CFO Susan Li quoted on stratechery, https://stratechery.com/2023/metas-low-e-u-arpu-the-supreme-court-and-section-230/ https://stratechery.com/2023/metas-low-e-u-arpu-the-supreme-...
- ilyt 3y agoTell investors you're throwing away 10% of the market and they will fire you > The EU's makes up around 15-20% of world GDP depending on how you measure it, but that's subject to disproportionality high taxes and compliance costs. That would have to be corrected for tech spendings, for example the fact asia produces most of the electronics have zero effect on facebook's business profits.
- spacebanana7 3y agoGoogle search and many other big tech divisions already did that with China. When a country/region deviates from the rest of the world in a big way there comes a point at which you can't offer the same products and services as other markets.
- lemoncookiechip 3y agoSo, he wants regulation but only if it benefits him: https://www.reuters.com/technology/openai-chief-goes-before-us-congress-propose-licenses-building-ai-2023-05-16/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/openai-chief-goes-before-...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- micromacrofoot 3y agowhy else would anyone want it?
- stemlord 3y agoTo benefit everyone
- andrewstuart 3y agoCommunity?
- ohgodplsno 3y agoAnyone with an ounce of consideration for others will want regulation, on any sbuject. Otherwise, we'd be driving around doing 150 in cities.
- azangru 3y agoIs it up to car manufacturers to lobby legislators to regulate cars' top speed though?
- micromacrofoot 3y agospeed limits and seat belts didn't come from the auto industry, it came from people lobbying for regulation that benefited them
- jacknews 3y agolol, very true but a 'good' reason for legislation is if it benefits everyone, including you.
- Decabytes 3y agoI wouldn’t be surprised if Sam Altman calling for regulation were done for two reasons. 1. Make it harder for smaller LLM based companies to break into the space 2. Drum up interest in OpenAI by making it seem that they had or were close to having an ai worth regulating
- DanHulton 3y ago1000% this. He's looking for regulation in the US that will ultimately protect Open AI because he believes he can get it. He's opposing regulation in the EU because he knows he can't control it and it will almost certainly actually restrict him. It's so plainly obvious and obviously cynical, it's just gross. Especially when his calls for regulation in the US are supposedly based on trying to look out for humanity on a grand scale.
- cj 3y agoMy guess: 3) Get ahead of the attack on AI before the attack begins. Once LLMs start to make certain jobs obsolete, I predict one of the major US political parties will take a position against AI (as a job destroyer similar to outsourcing) and the other party will take the opposite side. No idea which party will take which side yet. Once it becomes an issue of this magnitude, it’s better optics to have went before the senate “asking” for regulation before they come to you demanding regulation.
- is_true 3y agoIt's the business jackass tactic, enter a market and then use the government puppets to raise the barriers to entry. I've seen a few times. It's one of the steps to create a government assisted monopoly
- washadjeffmad 3y agoI wrote my Senators after watching the recent subcommittee meeting. I think it was pretty transparent to everyone that it was largely optics, but privately reinforcing that OpenAI isn't and shouldn't be the sole spokesperson for all things AGI is still important. We're all already using AGI, but we're not using OpenAI's AGI, and we don't need their pre- and proscriptive alignment. It's starting a discussion, and more tacitly, a negotiation. We need to weigh in to the right people proactively if we want to be represented and start defining intelligent regulation.
- wnkrshm 3y agoGood, space for better gardening of the technology.
- classified 3y ago[flagged]
- courseofaction 3y ago[flagged]
- teekert 3y agoHmm, for a moment I thought there must be an error in the title and it should be "Sam Altman Says OpenAI Will Leave the EU If There's ISN'T Any Real AI Regulation" But no, He is in front of US congress arguing for regulation, he is in the EU arguing against regulation. It's pretty obvious he's after whatever (de)regulation supports his business model. But I guess that's just his job. Let's hope regulators don't forget it is their job to represent the people's interests... I mean, whatever those may be in this case, I'm not claiming it's easy, I'm just claiming that Sam may not be the person to have the people's interests at the top of his list.
- newshorts 3y agoThe real take away is that he’s out front shaping regulation before it impacts him. In the US he knows it’s easy to manipulate our policy with a little song and dance because our policy makers don’t understand what they are looking at. It’s a different story in the EU where you have competent leaders. That seems to be the reason for the inverse approach. US: “let me help you write the regulations ;)” EU: “you’re gonna be behind it you regulate me :0”
- toth 3y agoAs a EU citizen, I really wish we had competent leaders, particularly in Brussels. Have never seen any evidence that is the case, specially with regards to tech. The last EU initiative at sweeping regulation in the tech space (GDPR) was disastrous. It imposed huge compliance costs for all entities, from large multinationals to small startups and business and even some individuals and nonprofits. For the multinationals that is totally fine with me, they can afford it, but for the other ones it is far from clear that the benefits outweigh the costs. They could have just made it not apply to small entities (either in revenue, number of users or some other metric) and it would have been arguably great. The way they did it they just gave a big advantage to large incumbents and put a strong handicap on EU based tech start ups (as well as other businesses to a lesser extent). Years after the roll out, I still occasionally come across international websites that have opted to ban European visitors than figure out how to comply with GDPR. Don't get me wrong, the GDPR was meant to address real on going abuses of personal data, and did some things right, but it could have easily had most of the benefits for a fraction of the cost if they did things right. Unfortunately, like all almost all regulators, Brussels tends to pay a lot more attention to hypothetical benefits of regulation than its predictable costs.
- SanderNL 3y agoI don't know how AI regulation will work, but wouldn't it be feasible to restrict regulation to usage in specific domains? Like how you can regulate software used in finance, health care and others but you can't just restrict "software" in the general case. You can't prevent me from making a good health care suite, it's just that I might not be able to operate it for profit and thus not expose the general public to it - which I find sensible. I would find it amazingly depressing if capable AI like GPT4(+) in general was blocked to the public, like it were heavy assault vehicles or nuclear devices. Just block specific instances of it. Just block WhateverShadyStartupDecidingIfYouGetAJob using GPT for example, I'm fine with that. If I can replicate their work at home, leave me be. Regarding this tech as if it were explosive devices is way too heavy handed for my taste.
- naillo 3y agoPaulg complaining about the EU regulations while ignoring Sams congress hearing is just a crazy contrast and hypocricy to me.
- nrtlal 3y agoI like paulg, but in one of his essays he complained about jocks stealing the Nerds' lunch money and that software engineering was a way to avoid the jocks. Now, his protege is attempting to steal the Nerds' lunch money with CoPilot.
- sokoloff 3y agoWhat do Sam or pg have to do with CoPilot?
- matthewmacleod 3y agoCopilot is powered by OpenAI Codex
- sokoloff 3y agoThank you; TIL! I assumed without checking that Microsoft would have their own competitive offering in the space.
- ChatGTP 3y agoI've always felt like AI is the ultimate nerd revenge. I still kind of do. Except I like this framing, the nerds are trying to take each others lunch money now too :)
- rvz 3y agoOh no! This time we really have to be 'Open AI' and actually be 'open' and 'transparent' about our models and training methods this time? More regulations for thee, but not for me (O̶p̶e̶n̶AI.com). But little do the regulators know that the majority owner (Microsoft) will lobby and bribe them a little to have regulations to benefit both O̶p̶e̶n̶AI.com and Microsoft, etc over everyone else.
- dijit 3y agoI've spoken to many people in the USA that are anti-union and anti-regulation. The impression they have is that regulation is used to stomp out small businesses (and unions have some propensity for corruption). The EU regulation does not come with the same feelings, aside from the very aggressive FUD around GDPR. EU regulation is typically seen as something for the consumer/public good and not intended to stifle competition. With that in mind, it's interesting to see him arguing for regulation in the US, yet against regulation in the EU.
- touisteur 3y agoVery important to keep in mind that a large part of European regulations are meant to encourage competition within the EU. I'm not clear on the results but the goals are very often clear. There are also moral and ecological stances, but still trying to impose them in a way that doesn't stiffle competition within the EU.
- Tangurena2 3y agoThe difference in philosophy is part of the issue. The EU leans towards the precautionary principle (first, show us that it is safe). The US leans towards reactionary regulation (something terrible happened, let's make sure it doesn't happen again). There is also a large difference in practice. In the US, it is possible to get rid of regulations via lawsuits or "lobbying". It is also possible to corrupt public discourse with large amounts of advertising (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36067401 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36067401). It is much harder to apply US-style lobbying to EU regulators (one of the motivations for Brexit was to get away from EU regulators), so American companies will try very hard to get out from the regulations while making money from EU customers. What he wants is toothless & after-the-fact regulation that will not reduce his income.
- revelio 3y agoFeelings from whom? Because for sure that's a very common feeling in Europe about EU regulations. It was a big part of the political campaigning around Brexit, even. You even admit this - nobody feels this way, except for the people who very strongly feel that way but their feelings are "FUD" so don't count?
- meindnoch 3y agoNo no no! Sammy totally wants regulation. He just wants to help wording it ;)
- lokimedes 3y agoSo will I.
- skull723 3y agoGood. Piss off then.
- simonster 3y agoI know that there are many people at OpenAI who worry about the risks posed by AI and support real regulation to mitigate these risks. That said, given that Sam Altman’s position on climate change is something along the lines of “we shouldn’t reduce emissions now because we can develop tech to fix whatever we’ve done later” (e.g. https://twitter.com/sama/status/1445059564114563080 https://twitter.com/sama/status/1445059564114563080), I’m skeptical that he personally sees AI regulation as anything other than a means to regulatory capture.
- ilyt 3y ago[flagged]
- Fnoord 3y agoYep, though I wouldn't call him names. Stay civil; its not needed to call names to make your point. In a nutshell: he asks for it to please those who are concerned yet on the fence. Whereas he won't give up in EU without a fight. Also, he's American, not European. His interest could very well lie in whatever benefits the American people primarily, instead of whatever benefits the rest of the world. As long as he gets away with it. I mean, Facebook and Google are getting away spying on users all over the world.
- SilverBirch 3y agoThis is where the rubber hits the road. In the US you can walk around and sagely tell everyone how concerned you are and how you'd support thoughtful regulation safe in the knowledge that a few million on good lobbyists will completely derail any attempt at regulation. In the EU regulation will actually happen and the US CEOs still really haven't figured out a way of guiding this how they like. Threats like "If you do that we'll leave" just don't work on EU regulators, and US tech is a fantastically easy target for EU regulators.
- moffkalast 3y agoAltmann schreit eine Wolke (old man yells at cloud)
- Barrin92 3y agoHe knows perfectly well that the EU is able to pass regulation that will sting whereas the American federal government is never going to pass any meaningful tech regulations. We've seen it with social media. The EU has GDPR, California has CCPA, Montana has banned TikTok yet after two decades there's still not even a national privacy framework in the US.
- christkv 3y agoThis ironically might be a boon for the open source models. The problem seems to be privacy related so companies will be forced to run their own models instead of OpenAI, Google and Microsoft owning all the AI apis.
- jcfrei 3y agoIn traditional European fashion the EU is again likely to crush any emerging European AI venture with overburdening regulation while companies in the US flourish. For decades now the American approach of wait and see has proven superior (with few exceptions for sectors like pharmaceuticals). When the government waits with regulation until more clarity has been established to what the actual business models are going to be like then you give companies a chance to establish themselves versus the old ones. The European approach just scares new companies off and they'll try out their new ventures in different jurisdictions.
- surgical_fire 3y agoEh, I'm not convinced. I do pay for ChatGPT, but I'm not onboard with corporate whining by spoiled CEOs from across the pond. I certainly am not a fan of US lax regulatory approach that only seem to ever favor corporations in detriment of the population with this lame excuse of not scaring away poor corporations. If adjusting to regulation is impossible, don't do business here. It's alright.
- maxehmookau 3y agoSo, he wants regulation unless it hurts OpenAI's bottom line? So he doesn't really want any regulation at all.
- whywhywhydude 3y agoI can see them mandating another GDPR like popup saying that the content is AI created. Europeans have the right to know if they are being bamboozled by AI created content.
- ggm 3y agoThe implicit threat is fascinating. He clearly believes in a higher authority around what is or is not acceptable regulation. From whence comes this magical source of authority and reason? I mean sure, arbitrary law is bad. But does he truly ideate the EU like that? I wonder what jurisdiction he winds up in and why?
- holografix 3y agoPathetic mixed messaging from a hypocritical CEO. Releases the most powerful LLM the world has seen pretty much publicly and next to free. However now that he has the lead wants everyone to be regulated and now allowed to open source it. Tells the US gov, where his competition is mostly likely to come from that they need regulation. Tells the EU, where the actual enforcement of privacy and legislation happens via billion dollars fines, that he doesn’t want regulation. Comical display.
- catchnear4321 3y agosama showing musk there’s a new dr. evil in town. nothing more than an oligarch dancing with government structures in an effort to prevent more equality. surprise.
- vlovich123 3y agoWhile I agree with other commenters that this is kind of hypocritical on its face, there is a strongman interpretation that’s more generous. It would probably go something more like this: The US crafts regulations that work with businesses while the EU crafts them and is OK to sacrifice businesses. Additionally, the EU crafts regulations that can accomplish nothing but increase costs and reduce quality without helping the end goal. For example, all the cookie banners that have pervaded the internet. They don’t actually help reduce tracking, they make the web less usable, and they’ve made compliance more complicated, and building a website is more expensive as you have to add these banners. Sure GDPR has strengths but the cookie aspect is a miss. In fact, the EU is as easily bamboozled as the US considering that Google had a huge hand in shaping GDPR legislation.
- vlovich123 3y agoAnother strong man. The US hasn’t started considering how to regulate so Sam is saying “great, here’s how you regulate” in the EU they’ve already outlined principles (proposed regulations? Can’t recall) and maybe he sees those as problematic and that his discussions with them haven’t yielded improvements. Of course even the strongman interpretations are problematic here but just saying. I think there may be more nuance here than the hot take based on the headlines alone. > …he was miffed by the way the European body defined “high-risk” systems.. > According to Time, the OpenAI CEO said “If we can comply, we will, and if we can’t, we’ll cease operating… We will try. But there are technical limits to what’s possible.” > He called for some regulation “between the traditional European approach and the traditional U.S. approach,” whatever that means. It’s important to catch the author’s non-neutral tone here. They’ve clearly staked out a position and it’s worthwhile to keep that in mind.
- TradingPlaces 3y agoRegulation that puts up a barrier to entry that prevents competition: good All other regulation: bad
- nologic01 3y agoFeels like a first step in a long dance performance. Good that EU regulators are already looking at this space (given that nobody else does). The main risk for them is that the actual risks from use and abuse of AI in various domains will only start showing up later. So early regulatory work might appear silly or misplaced. But that is not a reason to adopt a "wait-and-see" attitude. There is so much recent precedence in the software domain: the privacy disaster from targeted adtech and the speculative manias of crypto. Once large numbers of users are lulled into certain behaviors under false pretenses it becomes much harder to reverse the social damage. While privacy is a connected risk here too, there are much wider possibilities for abuse once algorithms are on the loose, processing and influencing without any transparency or accountability. We know that people will try anything that is not explicitly illegal if it gives them financial or political leverage. Gray areas of missing regulation are an open invitation for "creative" thinking and regulatory arbitrage. The noise "not to suppress innovation" will be enormous. But the concepts and tools for sandboxing and keeping a close eye on developments are there. The idea that the only way to innovate is to move fast and break things is just a transparently self-serving dictum that should be put to rest. They should keep an eye for oligopolies too. There is no reason to endure more decades of gratuitous "winner-takes-all" dynamics. The technologies are exciting, there are clearly positive scenarios. Let us hope we are smart enough to properly regulate smart algorithms.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- southernplaces7 3y agoSo to be sure of the basics: Altman goes before the U.S. congress to promote AI regulation, and than at the same time makes arguments that imply not wanting regulation for the EU market? Cute little double standard... Not in the least related to him selectively changing postures because he worries about a real threat of upstart competitors forming in the highly dynamic U.S. market, while also worrying about a loss of manipulable customers in the much more passive and non-competitive EU market.. Couldn't be something like that.
- detaro 3y agoProbably also because he doesn't expect any strong regulation to come from congress regardless of how much he talks about it.
- simaltwman 3y agoClickbait title that leads to an inflammatory, divisive article which doesn't explain much.
- fabiofzero 3y agoSam: "Please regulate AI" EU: "Ok then" Sam: "No, not like that"
- i2cmaster 3y ago[flagged]
- dinvlad 3y agoI’ll be glad if EU regulates the sh* out of this. Companies like OpenAI should not have a reason to exist in today’s world.