15 ms·
Ice loss from Greenland and Antarctica hits new record
- rybosworld 3y agoSaw this posted the other day, and it seems like a potential way to offset some of the ice melt: https://unchartedterritories.tomaspueyo.com/p/seaflooding https://unchartedterritories.tomaspueyo.com/p/seaflooding
- runsWphotons 3y agoYeah this is cool
- rektide 3y agoThe idea of flooding some desert at first seemed gobsmackingly useless to me. The article talks about a 6mm drop in ocean levels. The article does say it could potentially increase total water evaporation by up to 6% though, and that could be useful.
- regularfry 3y agoIf it's increasing local rainfall that means it's contributing a cooling effect via the albedo of the clouds, too. Don't know if it would be measurable other than locally, though.
- throwway120385 3y agoSomeone just posted an article above about how our climate models just got precise enough to model cloud layer changes as CO2 increases. Somehow I doubt we can model things effectively enough to really predict that more evaporation will make things better instead of worse. Moisture can also be effective at raising the wet bulb temperature above what we can survive if it hasn't condensed into clouds.
- vkou 3y agoIt will also contribute to a heating effect, because water vapor is itself a greenhouse gas.
- margalabargala 3y agoThe increased evaporation wouldn't really do that much re: sea levels. That water doesn't vanish, it falls as rain and goes back into the ocean, buffering a (relatively) miniscule additional amount of water in clouds. It would do tons for the local ecosystem, though. That evaporated water would fall as rain across eastern Egypt and the Middle East. Not to mention of course the truly incredible amount of hydropower.
- rektide 3y agoA lot falls on earth & is absorbed too, is my understanding. There's plenty of talk about farmers flooding fields & what not to restore groundwater. 100% I think the main benefit of this project would be to restore some ecology & create power. There may be some small benefit to the earth as a whole too, but it seems silly to make this effort for somewhat enhanced evaporation.
- hkwerf 3y agoIt's most interesting that the current sea level rise is mostly due to thermal expansion of the water, not the melting ice. When learning about sea level rise in school, the focus was definitely on the latter.
- mempko 3y agoAnd just think how big the oceans are! That's a lot of heat!
- fsflover 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32750935 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32750935
- shkkmo 3y agoThe proportion of sea level rise from melting ice is significantly increasing though. > In the early 1990s, ice sheet melting accounted for only a small fraction (5.6 %) of sea-level rise. However, there has been a fivefold increase in melting since then, and they are now responsible for more than a quarter (25.6 %) of all sea-level rise. It is a bit strange how much melting ice caps get attention more than the thermal expansion of water, but I expect that is because a melting ice cap is much more visceral and easily understood and explained than the thermal expansion of water.
- jvanderbot 3y agoI personally have zero hope that we'll succeed in mitigating "tipping point", irreversible climate change. I'm less doom-and-gloom about it than most, though, since I think we'll find ways to adapt, and a sort of apocalyptic human-ending scenario doesn't seem likely to me. Don't get me wrong, "adapt" is going to be painful. But I think it will be painful in the way the industrial revolution was painful: Lots and lots of cultural displacement, shifts in lifestyles, etc. But it'll also make some new billionaires and powerhouse industrial centers based around the need to fundamentally change our society to stop making it worse and to solve the problems a heating globe produces.
- lolive 3y agoBye bye Las Vegas…
- hkwerf 3y ago... and India: https://weatherspark.com/compare/y/109174~2228/Comparison-of-the-Average-Weather-in-New-Delhi-and-Las-Vegas https://weatherspark.com/compare/y/109174~2228/Comparison-of...
- davidw 3y agoI think that's a huge worry. There is a huge population there that as far as I can tell, can't just 'move a bit north' or something. Plenty of them are not very wealthy so don't have a lot of cash to spend on mitigation. It could get really ugly.
- agentultra 3y agoIt's a regular yearly event these days. How soon will the record ice loss be posted this year? Did we beat it last year? Some times it feels like we're re-arranging deck chairs. The US administration plans more drilling in Alaska, Russia continues to seek new natural gas and oil sources; human civilization continues on as if nothing is happening. I hope we can end all use of fossil fuels in the energy sector before 2030 but I remain doubtful. It seems like we may simply end up with no polar caps and have to survive the next few thousand years without them.
- slashdev 3y agoI wish we could end all fossil fuel use by 2050, but even that won't happen. I do think we'll be using substantially less than we are today by 2050 though, so that's something. 2030 is impossible. The ice in Antarctica won't completely melt, it's been there a very long time and it would take a very long time and a very dramatic change to cause that. If we manage to cause that we're really fucked, because the changes to everything else would be catastrophic. But Greenland could happen over the course of a millennia. That would have far reaching consequences, as it would likely disrupt the Gulf Stream (I know that's not the right name for it, but everyone knows it by that name).
- selectodude 3y agoWhat are we supposed to be calling the Gulf Stream nowadays?
- 3y ago
- LatteLazy 3y agoThe important thing is that we all keep telling ourselves how much progress we have made because emissions keep growing but by slightly less than before covid.
- hkwerf 3y agoDo not worry, we, the Germans, are finally starting to hold those responsible accountable: https://www.dw.com/en/german-police-swoop-on-last-generation-climate-activists/a-65715954 https://www.dw.com/en/german-police-swoop-on-last-generation... Oh, wait...
- CalRobert 3y agoGermany is such a bafflingly inconsistent country. Freiburg prides itself on reusable cups but they're very quick to replace nuclear with coal for no clear reason.
- nate_meurer 3y ago> Two of the suspects also allegedly planned to sabotage an oil pipeline linking the Bavarian city of Ingolstadt to the port of Trieste in Italy. Assuming this is a plausible threat, would you prefer the government to simply decriminalize vandalism?
- hkwerf 3y agoThat's beside the point: The German government did not act against those responsible for climate change, they acted against those protesting for laws that are slightly stricter than those we have right now. Whether the ends justify the means is a different question and maybe one reserved for more severe crimes? In another century, the relation whether blocking traffic for a protest is acceptable vs. 4 K increase in temperature will look quite differently than it does today. However, history will remember what we do now, not in ten years, as we have done far too little for decades and are now quickly approaching the tipping points our grandchildren will learn about in school.
- 3y ago
- zeitgeistcowboy 3y agoThe video and graphics presented with this are really well done. I think it helps educate people when you show them well-made visuals like this. It's a good way to show information in a short period of time without a lot reading required.
- deathgripsss 3y agoIs there anything to even be remotely positive about with regards to climate change? It's getting very depressing.
- gitanovic 3y agoPlants will grow more easily... due to increased temperature and CO2, just like in a greenhouse This in the long run will reverse the climate change, so after we go extinct, the remaining species will thrive :)
- padjo 3y agoYou’ll probably be dead before the worst of it so it’s not all bad.
- CalRobert 3y agoIn fairness this statement can also be true if you die from climate-induced causes....
- nervousvarun 3y agoSure but since we're using the word "probably" here... He (most probable pronoun) probably has kid(s) as well.
- zigzag312 3y agoIt'll drive us towards advancements in geoengineering.
- 3y ago
- tnel77 3y agoI don’t want this to happen, but I have a theory about how this is all going to play out over the coming decades. We are going to continue to see yearly records be set. Bigger fires, more ice melting, worse droughts, etc. Eventually, the global poor will be forced to relocate and even the leftest leaning countries will realize that it is infeasible to accept all these immigrants (looking at Europe in particular). Mass riots will occur along those borders, but eventually eco-immigrants will die off and the more wealthy countries will “just” adapt and move on. As we see mass casualties due to food shortages and violence, I’d imagine we will see a drop in greenhouse gases from those regions which, ironically, will help the climate change problem.
- CalRobert 3y agoWe're committing acts of war against those countries and leaving their people to die. If we were putting poison in their water, blowing up dams to flood valleys, or destroying their crops directly it would be an atrocity, but apparently doing it with a layer of indirection in the middle makes it OK.
- whyhellothere97 3y ago[flagged]
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoAny time you see a comment about over population, one must ask themselves, "who does this person want to see less of?". Eco-fascists are abound
- tnel77 3y agoI’d like to reiterate that I don’t want my prediction to happen. It’s just my guess as to how things will play out.
- flangola7 3y agoWealthy countries will not escape this. Europe will freeze over. The south and midwest US will turn to Sahara like desert. Printing money will not make crops grow, will not make rain fall.
- CalRobert 3y agoMeanwhile, Sea Surface Temperatures remain far, far, far above normal. The gap between this year and the second-hottest is striking. https://climatereanalyzer.org/clim/sst_daily/ https://climatereanalyzer.org/clim/sst_daily/
- lordnacho 3y agoAm I reading it wrong? We're 4 standard deviations away from the average?
- nomel 3y agoMax by year, since it's hard to see: https://imgur.com/a/YTiDmbc https://imgur.com/a/YTiDmbc edit: no idea why imgur thinks my plot is erotic. But, if anyone is too afraid to click, it's a linear looking increase, up to the right, from 20 to 21C.
- uncertainrhymes 3y agoThere are several comments about "oh well, whatever species replaces us will have a new chance". Unless the cockroaches want to wait 300 million years, they won't have the easy coal and oil reserves to jumpstart them to an 'advanced' civilization. Which might be a good thing? Maybe some future inhabitants will invent an oil-producing algae because they didn't have an easier option like we did.
- dahwolf 3y agoMy take is that advanced civilization isn't an evolutionary inevitability nor is it of any objectively higher value or importance. Imagine a planet with just grass. One species. It's thriving. Highly successful. Who needs "intelligence"?
- iconjack 3y agoI'm old enough to remember when Antarctic sea ice extent set a record high in 2014. The cause? Probably global warming. "So as counterintuitive as expanding winter Antarctic sea ice may appear on a warming planet, it may actually be a manifestation of recent warming." [1] https://www.climate.gov/news-features/featured-images/antarctic-winter-sea-ice-extent-sets-new-record-2014 https://www.climate.gov/news-features/featured-images/antarc...
- magicalist 3y ago> Antarctic sea ice extent This article is about loss of ice mass.
- alex_young 3y agoOn the other pole.
- olddustytrail 3y agoOn both.
- shkkmo 3y agoRight, as that article explains: The increasing melting of the antarctic ice cap makes it easier for the sea ice to expand because it leads to more fresh water (with a higher freezing point) on the surface of the ocean. > How does the melting of land ice matter to sea ice formation? The resulting meltwater is fresher than the seawater. As it mixes with the seawater, the meltwater makes the nearby seawater slightly less dense, and slightly closer to the freezing point than the ocean water below. This less dense seawater spreads out across the ocean surface surrounding the continent, forming a stable pool of surface water that is close to the freezing point, and close to the ice onto which it could freeze.
- wpm 3y agoFunny that I don't see any of the commenters who wax poetic about their wonderful convenient car centric lifestyle in every post about the costs of car infrastructure in here telling us how great it is they can drive to their sprawl-town's Costco once a week.
- gavaw 3y ago[flagged]
- CacheRules 3y agoI like Costco.
- scoofy 3y agoI primarily ride a bike and have been low-car since college in the early 2000's... hell, I've been a mod on /r/bicycling since around 2010. I took some Earth Sciences back when the professors just assumed people would act rationally and care about their climate impact. That seems adorably naive in retrospect. I think one of the biggest issues... as is always... is the housing shortage. I'm currently trying to find new housing that is low-car friendly (my lifestyle), and also dog-friendly (my gf's lifestyle). Yes, we live in the bay area, but this applies to every single major tech hub in America. If we want to get a two bedroom unit, that's both safely bikeable to central SF, but also a few blocks from a dog park, we're going to probably need to pay about $4000 per month. That's about $50,000 per year; it's about 40% of the SF median household income. As much as I hate the way our sprawl is infecting climate change... the real reason sprawl has taken over is that we've blocked urban housing construction for 70 years. I hardly blame younger folks for their exurban lifestyles at this point. I can barely afford being an urbanist, over 40, without having roommates... and I consider myself fairly well off. And I'm counting down the days until I say 'fuck it' and just move to Milwaukee or Pittsburgh where I could basically retire (not at all a slight, just the extremely rare affordable urbanist cities). I can't imagine what it would be like with kids. If you pretend to care about the environment, you need to be at your city council meetings demanding high-density, mixed-use, housing in your neighborhood.
- 3y ago
- orwin 3y agoGHG do not have any impact on the temperature until they reach the high troposphere (the way GHG work is nothing like a greenhouse btw). C02 surplus at ground level takes 20 years to reach the level it has an impact on, and have a 'half life' there of almost ten thousand years. Today, the climate is impacted by emissions made in 2003. Emissions from today won't have an impact before 2043 (on the climate. Still have an impact right this moment on the oceans acidity btw). I'm not doom and gloom though. Your kids will suffer, but I'll probably make it just fine. Still, I'm making all I can to preserve future humans some pain, but I feel like I'll stop making efforts soon.
- akomtu 3y ago"hits new record" is a cheap headline that people have learned to ignore. It's far better to say "25% of ice cover lost in 10 years" and show two satellite images.
- Lolaccount 3y agoLet's just admit it. We're f@cked. If we can convince governments and corporations to step up, that's something. But there's such a huge percentage of people who either couldn't give af, or if there is even the smallest disturbance to their daily life will resort to conspiracy theory. People would rather lie to themselves than face a minor inconvenience or change to to their lives for the greater good. Where are all the heroes? Are they just p!ssing around on Tiktok?
- timeon 3y ago> But there's such a huge percentage of people who either couldn't give af, or if there is even the smallest disturbance to their daily life will resort to conspiracy theory. Or think that it will just solve itself.
- kzrdude 3y agoI'm not depressed about the changing climate. We could adapt to changing conditions. But I'm depressed about the lack of will and capacity. We don't manage to come together and decide what to do or to deliberatey control our behaviour. (I.e help ourselves avoid climate change.) So we are in general not very sophisticated as a civilization, this whole thing is just going to happen to us. A trancendentally smart organism would understand and avoid the crisis before it hits, but we will hit the resource usage ceiling knowingly.
- llsf 3y agoI think we are to some extent. But it cannot be a reason for inaction. Because the extent on how we are f*cked can go from collapse of the economy to mass extension, from in 10 years or in 50 years. Governments only act on pressure from the base, especially when it is take difficult decisions that would most likely impact in the short term the economy (e.g. diverting $B to new energy sources, optimization for homes, transportation, etc.). It is an investment for the next decades.
- syngrog66 3y agoSpeaking of collapsing ice sheets and this comically, tragically obvious oncoming train of utter climate doom heading mankind's way I've been building an educational, comedy adventure game [SB] about it. Set a mere 80 years in our fictional future, it assumes as a core premise that we failed to take the kind of big bold sustained collective action necessary to prevent it from happening. ---- [SB] - https://synystrongames.itch.io/slartboz https://synystrongames.itch.io/slartboz
- temptemptemp111 3y ago[dead]
- x3874 3y ago[flagged]
- x3874 3y ago[flagged]
- deanCommie 3y agoI'm horrified by the negativity and fatalism in this thread. Do things seem dire? Yes. Is this the time to give up? No! We all already know what needs to be done. What we lack is the political will to do so because 50% of our political leadership has refused to acknowledge any necessary action and instead keeping everyone busy with distractions like threatening trans people and re-banning medical procedures. There is an appalling lack of focus on the big picture from the percentage of the population that, let's face it, is motivated by religion and nothing else. We have a rising threat of authoritarian fascism worldwide, and it's NOT in order to save humanity by enacting sweeping societal change to address our warming planet, but is instead to reintroduce hierarchical societal roles based on gender, race, and sexuality, and give those at the top of the food chain another generation of blissful prosperity while the planet burns. Our ancestors overthrew governments, assassinated leaders, and uprooted whole societies over far less. I realize a community of technologists and startup enthusiasts benefit from capitalism, but it needs to be asked whether the system that brought so much prosperity to humanity over the last 100 years will be the same that brings us atrocities and gloom in the next 100. Painful revolution must not be considered off the table.
- llsf 3y agoNot time to give up, for sure. But brace for impact, probably. The impact on the global economy could be severe, and we might all have to rethink our lives and our plans. The concern to me is that if we manage to break the current stable climate, the impact could be extreme. It looks tens of thousands of years to get the extra 5 degrees to make earth livable, and now we might add an extra 5 degrees in the coming decades. It will be very hard to rollback. And we might extinct so many species in the process, that will not come back.
- cibie 3y ago> Painful revolution must not be considered off the table. Enjoy presiding over the rubble of civilisation. Any mass revolution is going to end with destruction of humanity as the nukes go off.
- corey_moncure 3y agoKnow what happens to your drink when it runs out of ice? I wonder what happens to the oceans?
- dahwolf 3y agoEarlier this week there was a shareholders meeting at Shell. They'll continue to heavily invest in fossil fuel exploitation including finding new wells. No sense of urgency or even the slightest hint of a correction. As expected, activists disrupted the protest. Intensely. The meeting concluded with 80% of shareholders signing and approving Shell's plans. Dutch politicians confronted Shell's leadership: What you're doing directly opposes what should happen and even accelerates the climate issue. It's highly immoral. Shell: well, that's just your opinion, dude. Either we all don't care or we wake up: self-regulation will not happen. Stop being so naive about it.
- bokohut 3y agoAll else being equal, and no large external cooling events occur as mentioned in the comments, in time we will witness a change in what seasons the majority of people look forward to. I recall over my duration of time to date that in the heart of winter the majority of people hating the cold have stated "I cannot wait for Summer to be here" however my recollection of the inverse memory from the heart of Summer with people stating "I cannot wait for Winter to be here" is slim at best yet YMWV. Consider in the last few years the large number of Americans which have relocated to Florida - why not Alaska which also has no State income tax? One thing I learned growing up as a country boy hunting game in those Winters to put food on the table is one can always put on more clothes to warm up but the inverse is certainly not true in the Summer. We only need to look at existing cultures that have evolved through millennia of evolution to realize how temperature impacts chosen residency and the Inuit's are the defining example. They have evolved to survive in extremely cold environments by using available resources to keep warm, referencing 'one can always put on more clothes', however where are the mass population of cultures that live off the land as the Inuit's do but solely in the extreme desert? Yes, they do exist but are they as prosperous as those groups living in the extreme cold? The majority of society resists change as this is just a fact of life however when that change is forced that resistance often surfaces in negative ways and here we are in 2023 with so much 'change' beyond that of just the climate.