9 ms·
30% of All Rural Hospitals in the US Are at Risk of Closing [pdf]
- rqtwteye 3y agoIt’s really interesting how the US has managed to get a health system that’s extremely expensive, doesn’t cover everybody, is highly bureaucratic and complex, delivers below average outcomes and has overworked hospital staff. And somehow people defend this system because it works fine for the top few percent (especially the people in Congress) and people who have Medicare or VA.
- adamwong246 3y agoNo comment, only a thought. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Devouring_His_Son https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Devouring_His_Son
- syntheticnature 3y agoFrom talking to veterans I know, "works for people who have VA" might be optimistic.
- hotpotamus 3y agoFrom my experience talking to veterans, they think the VA is bad until they experience the alternative. But medicine is just incredibly individualized, so it's natural that everyones' experience will be unique.
- explaininjs 3y agoIs there any country with a medical system that people don't complain about? For instance is there anyone in the world that would agree: "Gee, my healthcare is so cheap, it's surprising that it covers everything I want it to without me needing to go out of my way to justify my treatment options and I have so many medical professionals available to me at a moments notice!"
- carapace 3y agoCuba. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Cuba https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Cuba
- ethanbond 3y agoThe NHS is one of the most beloved institutions on the planet AFAICT. Of course everyone would prefer if everything were better all the time, but complaints about the US system and clearly not on the same plane as those about UK’s.
- sidr 3y agoIt used to be. https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/press/press-releases/british-social-attitudes-satisfaction-nhs-falls-lowest-level-ever-recorded https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/press/press-releases/british-so...
- explaininjs 3y agoI see sentiments like this echoed quite a lot regarding the NHS, similar for Canada's: https://www.reddit.com/r/unpopularopinion/comments/upoamh/the_nhs_is_utter_trash_and_im_tired_of_people/ https://www.reddit.com/r/unpopularopinion/comments/upoamh/th...
- ethanbond 3y ago/r/unpopularopinion seems like a great place to go for "what's the general attitude toward X"
- notho 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- searine 3y ago>It’s really interesting how the US has managed to get a health system that’s extremely expensive, doesn’t cover everybody, is highly bureaucratic and complex, delivers below average outcomes and has overworked hospital staff. Well, most of Europe' social welfare systems were wiped out by the end of 1945 and were then rebooted with forethought and precedent of what not to do. The US is an archaic hodgepodge of systems over a 100 years old and were created with no precedent to model from. People defend this system because their lives and livelihood are tied to it. It is dumb, but without a thing like a world war to wipe the slate clean it is what we have to work with.
- vel0city 3y agoEh, most of the current designs in the US healthcare industry has its roots with the move to employer-sponsored healthcare in the 1940s (see: 1942 Stabilization Act and it's consequences). Private health insurance was barely a thing in the 1920's and pretty much didn't exist before then.
- searine 3y agoI generally agree. As I said, it was a hodgepoge, with no one solution covering the nation. Lots of proposals for more comprehensive solutions but nothing ever with enough momentum to make it into law. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_health_care_reform_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_health_care_reform_... Or if that wiki is wrong, feel free to correct it.
- vel0city 3y agoI'm mostly just speaking of calling the US system archaic compared to Europe's post-WWII, because for the most part the US system wouldn't be how it is until 1943 which most would consider post WWII. In other words, I don't think it's the age that's the problem. It's that most European countries don't mind as much having their national government run things while the US tends to push more federalistic/distributed systems. In fact, I doubt most people in 1942 would have even thought about the federal government's ability to regulate healthcare. Wickard v. Filburn was decided in November, which is the case that really opened the interstate commerce clause. Heart of Atlanta Motel v. US wouldn't happen until 1964, only then finally allowing federal laws to prevent restaurants from discriminating racially. If the federal government can't even set standards for restaurants it's rather hard to argue they have the ability to regulate hospitals and healthcare that happens inside a state. Medicare wouldn't get founded until 1965, it's not a bit coincidence this happened after SC decisions widening the interstate commerce clause. The powers of the federal government looked extremely different in 1942 than they do today.
- vkou 3y agoIt doesn't work very well for people going through VA. Source: MIL is a former nurse, former-VA claims processor. She found both the level of coverage, and the rules she had to follow to deny it, and the hoops her patients had to jump through to get treatment were utterly insane. Everyone here likes starting wars. We're very good at starting wars. Starting wars, and support-the-troops pins are cheap. We really don't like paying for the cost of war, though. That's expensive.
- hospitalJail 3y ago> And somehow people defend this system The defenders of the system are entirely medical workers and owners. The various medical lobbies/cartels are incredibly strong.
- zamnos 3y agoAre medical workers even that loud a defender of the system? A lot of providers are burnt out and leaving the profession due to being overworked.
- jjav 3y ago> The defenders of the system are entirely medical workers No, that's not correct. Doctors and nurses largely despise the US system. They are incredibly overworked and streched too thin to provide great care (and most of them are in it at least partially because they enjoy caring for people). The US system only benefits the middlemen who provide no healtcare value: insurance companies and hospita/clinic adminitrators.
- hospitalJail 3y agoDoctors like it enough to spend 490 million dollars to keep it in place https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-spenders?cycle=a https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/top-spenders?cy...
- gs17 3y agoMy opinion of VA healthcare dropped a lot living next to a VA hospital. There were a lot of homeless nearby who seemed to be veterans who had come for the hospital.
- dragonwriter 3y agoSeems to me that the problem there is the non-healthcare part of how America provides for veterans (and citizens in general). If the same veterans with the same healthcare weren't homeless...
- akuchling 3y agoI don't see how this is the hospital's fault: they can't keep patients indefinitely. Today's Washington Post has an article on the increasing number of homeless seniors https://wapo.st/3q8Gzeb https://wapo.st/3q8Gzeb which includes this passage: "After treatment for an acute illness, hospitals often discharge homeless patients, who wind up back in shelters or even back into their sidewalk tents and makeshift lean-tos, in what health practitioners in Phoenix ruefully call “treat-and-street.” ... A pinball effect takes hold, said health-care providers, shelter operators and advocates. Homeless people bounce from homeless shelter to hospital, then to a nursing home for a short-term recuperation stay. Once that short-term stay ends, nursing homes must decide if the person is infirm enough to qualify for long-term care. If the answer is no, they must leave the nursing home, starting the cycle over again."
- gs17 3y agoI would consider it VA not being an example of "it works fine" if they can sometimes get some help after waiting a long time, then get dumped out in the street to rot. Maybe the specific hospital itself isn't at fault, but the program in general is contributing to the exact issue you're quoting, which is more or less what I'm talking about.
- dragonwriter 3y agoSeems to me it is a poverty support/housing problem, not a healthcare problem (which, sure, impacts healthcare, in the same sense that poverty/housing issues impact education and pretty much every other aspect of society.)
- 0000011111 3y agoIt is broken for sure.
- oatmeal1 3y agoVA works for those not on the secret waiting lists, at least.
- oatmeal1 3y agoIt's the most obvious case of regulatory capture but also the market with the most calls for further regulation. That further regulation could be a good thing, but it would have to be substantially different from the way things are currently regulated.
- jjav 3y ago> It’s really interesting how the US has managed to get a health system that’s extremely expensive, doesn’t cover everybody, is highly bureaucratic and complex, delivers below average outcomes and has overworked hospital staff. The healthcare industry (it should not be an "industry") in the US is all about extracting maximum profit for the benefit of middlemen. In a rational system, the only people who should be involved in health care are the patients and the providers (doctors, nurses, technicians, etc) who actually provide health care. Nobody else should be involved, let alone skimming profits from the care. In the US both the providers and the patients are just an afterthought, the whole system is set up to extract maximum profit to the hospital and clinic administrators and, most and worst of all, to the insurance industry. The latter of course contributes nothing at all in therms of actual health care, it's pure profiteering. The solutions are quite simple, but they don't maximize the share price and CxO bonuses at insurance companies so it's not possible to implement them in the US.
- tstrimple 3y ago> In a rational system, the only people who should be involved in health care are the patients and the providers (doctors, nurses, technicians, etc) who actually provide health care. Nobody else should be involved, let alone skimming profits from the care. While I agree with the sentiment, hospitals require management to run well. They certainly don't need the amount of overhead they have, but it can't just be doctors, nurses and patients. Maybe in very small hospitals you could actually have doctors manage schedules and things like that, but once you reach a few dozen people you'll want to have someone coordinating availability and to deal with scheduling at the very least.
- jjav 3y agoI did not mean to imply there should be a place for office admins to do scheduling, facilities people to keep the building running, etc. They are needed, and should be paid a fair living wage for their work. What should be eliminated is the very highly paid class of middlemen who provide no value and just skim profits from the labor of health care providers.
- nradov 3y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI don't know how you can realistically look at this without thinking of the "I never thought leopards would eat MY face!!" meme. Politics matters. Voters in rural areas (generally, of course) have consistently voted against policies that would help support health care in these rural locations, such voting in politicians who are staunchly against Obamacare, who refuse any expansion or even adequate support for Medicaid, and who enact policies that put doctors at risk of prison for doing their jobs. Just look at all the recent news coverage of all the maternity wards in Idaho that are closing because Obgyns don't want to work there anymore. Sorry, my empathy at this point is fully tapped out for people who delight in cutting off their nose to spite their face.
- swader999 3y agoYet in Canada we have this same issue.
- notho 3y ago[dead]
- bombcar 3y agoCanada did not vote for Obamacare, so they get what they deserve. (Sarcasm, of course, every single problem in the USA comes neatly down on political lines and one side is perfectly good and the other objectively evil).
- rayiner 3y agoAnd in blue states in America that voted for Medicaid expansion we have the same issue. It’s almost as if the problem is escalating costs for skilled workers, lack of economies of scale in rural areas, and wealth/job flight to urban areas.
- kevingadd 3y agoYeah, but it's not as if all the people who live in these areas voted to shut down the hospitals. There's still a sizable portion of the electorate that wants good things and they get to suffer now. Not great.
- logdap 3y ago[dead]
- jeron 3y agoThere was a Reddit post that these rulers[0] were $80 from a medical supplier when they could be purchased for $6 on eBay, which is an easy explanation why healthcare here is ridiculously priced [0]: https://imgur.com/a/BSPRh https://imgur.com/a/BSPRh
- jbm 3y agoUm, wasn't that 100 for 80 dollars? That's how I read the imgur link.
- dilyevsky 3y agoIn the original post[0] it was $6 for 100 pack too. And someone pointed out that msrp is $70 so it’s not that bad and ebay was probably either a scam or surplus. Most things on reddit is bs for votes or straight up astroturfing. [0] https://old.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/1jiczi/i_work_in_a_hospital_laboratory_i_ordered_a_pack/ https://old.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/1jiczi/i_work_in_a_ho...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jorblumesea 3y agoCan we please just implement some level of universal healthcare. The fact that healthcare is tied directly to payers, who fight over how to much to pay, is ridiculous. Imagine your local hospital shutting down because the hospital charged $50 for aspirin but the insurer wanted $40.
- tristanb 3y agoIts also incredibly expensive (500k) to become a doctor.
- bombcar 3y agoMaybe we need something like the Army, where you can join up, qualify, get trained to be a doctor for free, and all you have to do is serve out your term at army wages until you're 45, then you're retired and free to do whatever doctoring you want wherever. It's how we get a lot of our airline pilots, after all.
- lelanthran 3y ago> Its also incredibly expensive (500k) to become a doctor. That's a large number. I thought it was less. In any case, in most countries, the number of doctors created is artificially limited (by the professional medical society, by lack of lecturers, artificially small classes, etc). You want to double the number of doctors? Make each doctor serve (after internship) for at least one year as a fulltime lecturer in medicine. That'll more than quadruple the intake in the first year. The professional health organisation that registers doctors can enforce this. In fact, they can enforce lots of things, and the question you should be asking is not "Why are the greedy corps taking all the money", but "why is the artificial limit on doctors so low?".
- tristanb 3y agoThat number comes from my wife, who's a double board certified surgeon. We're still paying it off and will be for some time. That said, we'd both vote for universal healthcare, even if it bankrupted us.
- mikem170 3y agoHow much do we want to subsidize people who choose to live in less populated areas? This will probably come up with roads and utilities at some point, also. Did we build a lot of infrastructure in less dense areas during boom times, similar to how China was recently building, with little regard for the long term sustainability costs? One day some of those currently paved roads in the country may need to be allowed to revert to dirt. If only a few people live on a long road they obviously can't pay for it themselves. The article does mention things like farming and mining that take place in rural areas, where workers may want nearby health care. Perhaps the companies profiting from these activities should pay these costs? There's also the idea of subsidizing elderly people who choose to live in the middle of nowhere. I'm not sure how many people would be in favor of that. It's been over a hundred years since we lived in a small town farming economy. These places have been emptying out for a long time.
- zokier 3y ago> Perhaps the companies profiting from these activities should pay? This is how you get company towns, and they don't have exactly stellar history.
- mikem170 3y agoI wasn't thinking of normal towns with a variety of people, but instead something more like oil rigs, or Alaska oil fields, or some military bases, where pretty much only workers are present, and they rotate in and out on a schedule. Farming for example has already become quite automated, not so many actual people are needed. Same for mining. Should everyone who chooses to move to the middle of get a paved road and emergency room subsidized by others? Or just the people who are grandfathered in? Wouldn't it make more sense for these people to move if their needs are not being met, as so many already have?
- tboyd47 3y agoThis is "too big to fail" logic applied to hospitals. How do our basic life services always become captured by huge organizations that are poorly run and require bailouts by the government? Or is "too big to fail" just a ploy by those organizations to entrench themselves even further in our lives?
- yifanl 3y agoPutting on my economist's hat for a second: Services like healthcare inherently have extremely inelastic demand, and are difficult to serve to a large number of people without a large number of resources, which makes it naturally easy to build a monopoly. A monopolicist is incentivized to increase fees and/or reduce spending on the quality of service as long as the demand is inelastic... and here we are. Admittedly, I never got past ECON 201, so I'm probably wrong on something here.
- lelanthran 3y ago> Admittedly, I never got past ECON 201, so I'm probably wrong on something here. I wouldn't worry about it (myself, only ECON 101); after all the people opining the loudest are the ones who have even less ECON than me, nevermind you. I think one of the largest mistakes made with medical insurance is removing the price visibility. The hospital cannot tell you how much a procedure will cost until after it is done. They can tell you how much it will cost if you pay in cash, so they have a good ballpark figure. So the consumer buys something without knowing how much it will cost, and is then legally on the hook for paying whatever the cost is. This is broken. Maybe it's unavoidable in this particular field (medical care), but the one thing you can be sure of when the consumer buys something without knowing how much it costs (and only paying the cost later) is that the price of that thing is going to skyrocket.
- pingpongchef 3y agoRegulation increases the barrier to entry, making competition more difficult to start
- DevX101 3y agoOne other factor triggering closures in the article: private equity companies have been on a buying spree for hospitals. The strategy is to buy the hospital, sell the land to a real estate co, and have the hospital pay exorbitant rates to lease the land. After they’ve extracted maximal value, the hospitals that can’t afford the lease are forced to close. Hospital execs get paid large bonuses for agreeing to deals like this.
- Eisenstein 3y ago> Hospital execs get paid large bonuses By whom?
- zamnos 3y agoBy hospitals who "can't afford" to pay their nurses more.
- jeffbee 3y agoI'm not 100% sure about the conclusion, in which we force private insurers to cover the cost for rural services. I suggest there is a middle ground where rural life is reformed slightly to become economically sustainable. Rural America is in many ways ridiculously expensive to serve, and not just for health care. Consolidating populations into compact towns that have several thousand people fixes a lot of those cost issues, and it also goes a long way toward preventing the need for the hospitals in the first place, which for rural ER departments comes from car crash injuries.
- smileysteve 3y agoThis, especially for aging populations (who may lack reliable transportation) and have higher needs
- hospitalJail 3y agoThe medical cartels caused this. Their greed has made it impossible to afford healthcare.
- HEmanZ 3y agoPeople here seem to go straight to politics on US healthcare, but does anyone ever stop to consider that this really is a complicated problem? I’ll look at two political extremes: - in a pure-market healthcare situation, these hospitals likely wouldn’t exist in the first place. Health services would be worse than they are now in rural areas, to the point that many probably wouldn’t have “real” health services at all because there’s not enough of a market to support it. You can say “well that’s my choice to live somewhere I can’t pay for healthcare” and that’s a different discussion, but free market wouldn’t get good healthcare in rural places. - you could have a single payer system, at which point providing good healthcare to rural areas would be a “net drain” on everyone else. Basically people in dense areas would be subsidizing people in rural areas REGARDLESS of those people’s incomes or wealth (this is a similar problem to many ex-urbs in America where we basically subsidize the infrastructure of rich people who live there). Neither of these seems to work out well, and I worry neither I politically sustainable. It doesn’t strike me as an easy problem…
- bombcar 3y agoI'm not exactly sure what would drive rural hospitals to be a net drain unless they are "built too large" for the population, or are usually empty. Most of the rural hospitals I know will send you "to the big city" anyway for specialized procedures.
- tstrimple 3y agoThe same reason rural areas are a net drain in other ways. They have no efficiencies of scale and since everything is spread apart, providing services becomes more expensive and difficult. https://www.brookings.edu/research/why-rural-america-needs-cities/ https://www.brookings.edu/research/why-rural-america-needs-c... > "This pattern holds for state government spending, too. Studies in Minnesota, Georgia, and Wisconsin reveal that metropolitan areas contribute more to state coffers than they receive in education, infrastructure, and other public services investments. In Georgia, for instance, metropolitan Atlanta provides 61 percent of state revenue but receives just 46 percent of state investment. State spending on roads, broadband networks, schools, and other public services in small town America is funded, in part, by the economic prosperity of cities." There's no way the majority of rural communities in this country could cover their own infrastructure costs. Those are heavily subsidized by the state. In the state I live in, Iowa, there are nearly 100k miles of rural roads to support a population of roughly 1 million rural residents. Meanwhile there are about 16k miles of road to support the other 2 million urban and suburban residents. Roughly 1/3rd of those rural roads are considered to be "farm to market" roads which facilitate delivery of farming goods to markets. The other 70k miles of roads are just to support rural residents. And while there's an argument that rural gravel roads are cheaper to build, that ignores the total cost of ownership as those roads need annual maintenance. Even things like electricity are heavily subsidized because residents pay a similar rate regardless of where they live, and rural residents require substantially more infrastructure to get the power to them in the first place. Those additional costs are borne by all residents. At least part of that "cheap rural lifestyle" is paid for by folks living in cities.
- jmoak3 3y agoThe US is freakishly large. I've lived all over it and driven across it from west to east several times. I grew up 2 hours outside of Appalachia, and couple that with the other places I've seen I feel safe in my belief that the US has large swaths of sparsely populated regions. Here's some fun maps if you don't believe me: https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/l4zr10/red_areas_in_map_are_a_bit_over_1_of_us_land_area/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/l4zr10/red_areas_i... If you don't like reddit, feel free to reference this night map: https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2021/geo/population-distribution-2020.html https://www.census.gov/library/visualizations/2021/geo/popul... It's no surprise that these hospitals are at risk of closing. There are few people there and fewer new people coming in, causing the cost of labor to explode. For example, there's a shortage of new blood entering the workforce compared to retiring boomers: https://www.populationpyramid.net/united-states-of-america/2023/ https://www.populationpyramid.net/united-states-of-america/2... This leads to labor shortages especially in rural areas because the few young people are fleeing to urban environments to find work and a not-shrinking economy a la Japan & Tokyo. Here's a document referring specifically to some east coast regions, but there is likely one for your local region out there somewhere: https://www.richmondfed.org/publications/research/econ_focus/2020/q1/district_digest https://www.richmondfed.org/publications/research/econ_focus... Here's a document on Japan and Tokyo's situation: https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/04/business/japan-pay-families-relocate-tokyo-intl-hnk/index.html#:~:text=But%20this%20migration,a%20national%20census https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/04/business/japan-pay-families-r.... It sucks that these hospitals are closing but this is what the decline of a region looks like. The labor costs are only going to get worse as time goes on because if you want nice things you have to convince people to hang out there and make it nice. The growing costs of labor will shut down hospitals and prevent the opening of new ones. It was easy to justify the construction of such things when the population of the USA almost doubled between 1970 and today. Now? Not so much: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/POPTOTUSA647NWDB https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/POPTOTUSA647NWDB Widespread immigration into these areas would help alleviate these issues, as would policy decisions that favor the industries that used to exist in them that drew people there in the first place.
- duffpkg 3y agoI'm sorry to say but there is a lot of nonsense in the other comments here. I wrote Hacking Healthcare for O'Reilly, created the ClearHealth/HealthCloud Open Source EMR system, and most importantly I have, amongst other things, actually managed dozens of rural hospitals and clinics. First for context, the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform (CHQPR) is an advocacy organization for the types of institutions this report discusses. I think that is important context. Second, what is rural? From a healthcare standpoint rural typically refers to area of populations centers of 50,000 people or less. Examples in California that might be familiar to people living in the San Francisco bay area would be Humbolt and Mendocino counties. This report includes some semi-rural areas, places similar to something like Yuba City, CA, a population center of about 160,000. Thirdly, the main point is that what "rural" hospitals get paid for services from insurance companies and what it actually costs to provide those services, continues to get further and further apart. In my first hand experience, this is true. Number one amongst those is staffing, today staffing costs have risen dramatically faster in rural areas than in urban and semi-urban areas -- though they have risen their as well. The staffing levels and types of personell at what is legally called a hospital are heavily regulated and have continued to to expand. Medicare in particular is pretty "unfair" in its latest fee structures regarding these issues though HHS does provide other types of subsidy to rural areas. The meat of the report is that if that continues unabated, one hundred or more hospitals will likely "close". Closing may mean to completely cease operation or in other cases mean to continue to operate but as something which cannot legally be called a "hospital". Finally, as a report which is not really in-depth, not really independant of the organizations it is advocating for, provides little in the way of citations and data, I am somewhat dubious of its value being posted to HN at all, other than to act as a punching bag around which everyone can throw the usual jabs at the US healthcare system as a whole.
- MichaelZuo 3y ago> Finally, as a report which is not really in-depth, not really independant of the organizations it is advocating for, provides little in the way of citations and data, I am somewhat dubious of its value being posted to HN at all, other than to act as a punching bag around which everyone can throw the usual jabs at the US healthcare system as a whole. Nowadays a large fraction of upvoted HN posts don't contain much genuinely substantive discussion at all. The farther away the post is from a purely technical topic, the higher the likelihood of this. Instead they are often filled with what I call pseudo-substantive discussion, meaningful superficially, but that don't make much sense, or based on faulty assumptions, once anyone tries to investigate or question a bit.
- notacoward 3y agoThe main reason seems to be that it costs more for them to deliver services than they're getting paid by insurers (especially Medicaid). I'd love to see a fuller breakdown of how those costs compare to those for urban hospitals. How much is demographics, such as serving a generally older population more prone to "deaths of despair" because rural living is hard? How much is demand, because of different eating/exercise habits or the uneven distribution of addiction to different drugs? How much is logistics, delivering care over a wider area? How much is other factors I haven't even thought of? The question of why rural hospitals don't get paid as much as it costs them to provide care doesn't have to be a political one. It just has to be asked.