12 ms·
A mental health crisis in science
- mensetmanusman 3y agoHave been in research 20 years, and cultures vary dramatically by group. Scientists also seem to be more anxiety prone than the general population. Also, it doesn't help if you take your work too seriously.
- Lutger 3y agoI'm sorry to say it and you probably mean well, but your response sounds like the very kind of victim blaming that perpetuates and reinforces the abusive culture the article is talking about. Instead of the victims or the culture, I'd rather look at the systemic issues that scientific institutions struggle with: debt, lack of social mobility, being underpaid and overworked, etc.
- PaulHoule 3y agoI would point out this https://www.insidehighered.com/quicktakes/2022/08/31/22-tenure-track-professors-have-parent-phd https://www.insidehighered.com/quicktakes/2022/08/31/22-tenu... as one of the elephants in the room. It's particularly a problem for DEI because someone who diagnoses their problem as "I am a woman", "I am black", ... is missing the major factor that the people who seem to fit in just fine in academia just fine are working in the family business. That is, at best you can erase "black stigma" but the privilege you are looking for is not a "white privilege" shared by all whites but rather a much more specific privilege, and if we just got them to where the average white person is they'd still feel lost at sea.
- omginternets 3y agoWe can also look at main effects across populations.
- _fat_santa 3y agoIt seems like this is a symptom of a larger problem, rates of anxiety and depression have been going up in recent years in pretty much every facet. I always hear that social media is to blame, but I wonder if that is really the case? I feel like something else is going on, maybe it's just a totality of smaller issues rather than one big problem.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoSocial media does sound like a decent theory though. To your point, the issues plaguing the US ( and indeed the world ) have not changed that much over the past four decades. What did change is relative access to information, which exacerbated and maybe even hastened some trends. The small factors were always there, but were not as commonly seen for a variety of reasons ( social stigma, exposure to media, 'toughen up' message from society being but a few examples off the top of my ehad ). And even now, we only are aware of it as a potential trend due to social media exposure ( in this case, HN ). Would we be as aware of it even 10 years ago?
- cornercasechase 3y ago> To your point, the issues plaguing the US ( and indeed the world ) have not changed that much over the past four decades. Wealth inequality has an increased a lot in the last four decades. I’d start there when looking for a source for mental health issues. https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/01/09/trends-in-income-and-wealth-inequality/screen-shot-2020-01-08-at-5-06-47-pm/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2020/01/09/trends-...
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoMoney does buy certain level of comfort ( and help if needed ) so I am more than willing to consider it as a factor, but I am not sure it is THE answer to the source of mental health issues. Lack thereof may make things worse, but I am not sure it is the core issue. FWIW, I may well be wrong, but I don't think it is fair to assume it is X, when you see same health issues pop up in otherwise wealthy environments. Most interesting example of that being 'affluenza'.
- schnitzelstoat 3y agoLow pay and an insecure job. It's like a pyramid scheme and many end up either forced to leave science or remain an eternal postdoc, and in countries like Germany postdoc funding is restricted once you reach a certain career stage so even the eternal postdoc isn't an option.
- juujian 3y agoAnd graduate students will be the last ones to receive a "pay raise" or even cost-of-living adjustment, I am certain.
- gorjusborg 3y agoOthers are hinting at the same thing, but toxic culture (by itself) is probably only part of the problem. If a single research job is toxic, that's stressful in the short term, but will just motivate someone to leave eventually; stress relieved. If the entire 'industry' is toxic, there's no job change that can relieve the stress. Also, research jobs are attained after people make some hard-to-reverse decisions about money, time investment, and lifestyle. If someone is in loads of student debt, has spent a decade learning a very niche topic that can't be easily leveraged elsewhere and doesn't have enough money to just quit and be okay, it's easy to see where the stress comes from, and it doesn't seem easily resolved.
- tptacek 3y agoWhole research fields share this toxic culture; what people seem to do is leave their field entirely. Not to mention that, because of the way academic lab research works, people frequently take up jobs in locations where there is only one credible "employer" (there will of course be dozens of PIs, but it's institutional failures that allow abusive culture to take root).
- grt_thr 3y agoWhen I was a post grad I could make less than I would at McDonalds for work I was volontold to do. I did the smart thing and quit. When you select for people who don't do the smart thing and want to be exploited in exchange for prestige they get exploited.
- marktangotango 3y agoWhenever these things come up, I'm always grateful toward my past self who opted out of academia and pursued industry. The entire system of placing your fate in the hands of disinterested, self motivated, senior faculty and researchers seemed very risky to me at the time. Plus the money has been nice. But I do feel like I missed out on some intellectual growth. YMMV.
- fullshark 3y agoIn grad school I learned a bunch of stuff and pushed forward a research topic that was outdated at the time but I just had no idea. Once I got into industry it was obvious and I had to catch up. The degree ended up providing nothing more than a signal for job interviews.
- generic92034 3y agoTrue. But please consider the difference the social background of the people makes. If you are financially secure due to parents (or whatever) you can easily accept positions with a low payment and do your best to get into a promising tenure track. So maybe it is only partly about exploitation, but also about applying a social filter.
- Hermitian909 3y agoI would describe the best "second-tier" academics I've encountered as mostly fitting the "parents money" archetype. They're not the uber geniuses who flit to the top, but since the toxic incentives aren't as important to them due to their financial independence they get to focus on the work which ultimately pays dividends in their career.
- 3y ago
- oaiey 3y agoWhat I found interesting of this article is that most of it is also applicable to a many tech sector jobs. High pressure to deliver something (because we squeeze the last of people), hire-and-fire practices everywhere, politics and toxic environments (because that is what people do and what is the current social perspective on what is okay). Developers, like scientists, are very outcome driven (number of lines, number of features, RoI, ...) The only - very big difference - is pay.
- fullshark 3y agoIt's what you get when you put intelligent, ambitious and arguably insecure people in a high pressure environment with status/economic rewards and punishments. Also yes you are judged based on output not how cordial you are in the workplace or whatever. Sales I guess would also qualify.
- PaulHoule 3y agoTech job hunts are easy in good times. (e.g. leave one employer, take a day off, interview at another employer the day after that, start working the week after) Academic jobs are nothing like that.
- mistrial9 3y agonotice that "leading" tech companies fixed this, with artificial hazing behavior in interviews, and changing the norms of hiring from two interviews to more than six, as widely reported.
- _Wintermute 3y agoThere's actually a huge shortage of postdocs at the moment, if you're remotely qualified and a somewhat normal human being you can easily get a job. The problem is that the job is awful, stressful, temporary, and poorly paid - hence the shortage of candidates willing to apply for them.
- tptacek 3y agoHaving now two lab scientists living under my roof, there is nothing even in the stories I've heard of the video game industry that compares to how toxic research culture is. It is next-level, as if being vexatious was a goal on its own --- which, given the culture generation after generation of PIs have come up through, might at this point actually be the case: students and employees are threatened, berated, harassed, and coerced into ludicrous hours as part of a dues-paying process.
- stochastimus 3y ago“Well-being and how to set healthy boundaries in your life and in your work is a fundamental skill,” says Sharon Milgram What is this “life” you speak of?
- trabant00 3y agoThe world is as good as it's ever has been in human history. Minorities, females, lgbtq members, etc, have more rights, are more protected and represented than ever. Extreme poverty is down, life expectancy is up. Human rights for any group are enforced as never before. But mental health issues are still going up at alarming rates. So it must be something else. I have various hypothesis as to what other causes may be but they're not worth very much. The problem is too complex for one head to understand it. It's like trying to determine the cluster health from one server. IT CAN NOT BE DONE. I don't care what your credentials are, if you're not a god you can't do it. I am willing to present this hypothesis in public: presenting the world in an idealized and false light, pretending that it should a safe space for everybody in which conflicts of interest and identities should not bother anybody is not helping. Generations are growing up expecting the world to embrace them, their identity, their ideas. This is causing fragility.
- tptacek 3y agoThis has nothing to do with the article.
- trabant00 3y agoThe article states multiple times that harassment, bullying, abuse and general toxicity is affecting science workers in general, but in particular women and minorities. My post states that said abuses are historically at a low point, especially for those groups, thus can not explain the rise in mental health issues. How exactly does this have "nothing to do with the article"?
- BeFlatXIII 3y agoIt's nothing to do with the article because general societal trends may not be relevant within a specific industry.
- pelasaco 3y agoBut exactly the "general societal trends" are used to make a point, so how it's not related?
- taylodl 3y agoWelcome to late stage capitalism. Our blue collar brethren have been put through the grinder for decades. Now it's our turn. In the end the majority of the population will be simply burnt out - and to what end? To support the lavish lifestyle of a select few.
- dbcooper 3y agoA part of this is that in academia there are often few positive career rewards. You're under pressure to publish frequently, in high impact factor journals, and that is to keep your job. You don't get pay rises or bonuses, or any other career improvements, and job security can be until your next contract, at best. If you don't make it to tenured professor, and have good grant funding, then you are staring down the barrel of starting a new career at an older age and with few contacts. The place to start is by having far fewer PhD students, but more masters students and technicians. A 60% reduction in PhD student numbers would reflect job opportunities, and student aptitude, more accurately.
- currymj 3y agoThis would help on some level, although it would definitely make the stress on applicants much higher. E.g. there’s increasingly an expectation that students should come into a PhD program with one or more publications already under their belt. For top programs ideally these should be first author (not yet an absolute requirement but it’s more important each year). So you better get a good research assistant job as an undergrad so you can do that. It has to be early enough in undergrad that you have time to get the paper out before applying to grad school. So you need to be prepared to get a professor to work with you freshman/sophomore year… So you have to have evidence of skills basically coming in to undergrad. Either be really brilliant and stand out in class, or, better, have some experience in high school to make you credible… These pressures would only increase with fewer PhD slots. Maybe that’s fine long term but it does have a distorting effect on people’s lives if you have to make high stakes decisions that early.
- xhkkffbf 3y agoWould you rather be told you're not going to get a stable job as a researcher when you're 21 and first applying to grad school or at 28-35 when you're finally told you didn't get any interviews for a tenure track job?
- dbcooper 3y agoExactly. It's far better to get rejected early from the PhD track, for not being a high achiever, than to muddle through unable to secure a job. You would still be able to prove yourself in a masters degree.
- cush 3y agoI've seen this toxic culture tear people apart first hand. 80+hr weeks, 52 weeks a year, barely enough pay to make rent, while being berated by emails at 3am by the PI for poor data. It's sickening.
- abhayhegde 3y agoAcademia places unrealistic goals on brilliant people and pays them so meagerly that they have to often find other sources of income. On top of this, some of the advisors are outright unbearable with their demands and work expectations, the world seems bleak for even a motivated researcher. Amidst the scarcity of grants, measly pay, extremely competitive environment, uncertainties tied with job market, failures in experimental methods, intractable theoretical adventures, publish-or-perish culture, and the better alternatives available for someone with a skill-set enough to pursue grad school, it's hardly any surprise grad students have mental health issues.
- fatnoah 3y ago> Academia places unrealistic goals on brilliant people and pays them so meagerly that they have to often find other sources of income Early in my career, I considered (with an MS in Electrical Engineering, but with 4 years of professional programming experience) a switch into law. Big firms hire (or did in the past) people with tech degrees to do patent work and will pay a salary plus pay for law school. When I joined the big firm, there were about 25 people in my role. I was the only with with an EE or CS degree/background, the only one without a PhD, and the only one with actual post-academic work experience. For me, it was a 10% pay cut before accounting for law school tuition, similar benefits, and an small increase in hours. For all of the PhDs, it was essentially a 100% raise, substantially less work, and superior benefits.
- jebarker 3y ago> Big firms hire (or did in the past) people with tech degrees to do patent work and will pay a salary plus pay for law school. I've never heard this before. What job title would you search for?
- iancmceachern 3y agoI'm not the parent poster, but I believe they are generally called patent agents
- fnord77 3y agoThere's toxic culture in a lot of fields and there's one common denominator. Can't wait for AI to take over every field it can and push out the corrupting factor - humans
- imranq 3y agoMaybe this is the answer...when humans are no longer required for a field to move forward, prestige becomes meaningless and everything becomes a means toward self-fulfillment not competition
- stainablesteel 3y agoscience boasts empiricism but the institutions who 'teach' science don't have any empirical basis on how to do so efficiently yeah, its outdated, has been for a while
- bioemerl 3y agoScience as a whole has died a hard death. All reward and prestige of being a researcher has been lost and the people in the study have a slim chance of being able to work with their degree. Which I understand is about the opposite of what this article wants, but you shouldn't trust the people who have broken science to fix it. Research itself gets locked behind tightly walled journals and are written with obscure and difficult language laymen can't understand, peer review has become a hoop jumping scam that let's bad research through. Medical review and other ethics boards are suffocating the ability for researchers to actually do things in a massive overcorrection from the early days of research. Media is in a continuous game of misrepresentation of everything researchers say and trust in scientific truth had lead to instructional actors getting their fingers in the process and corrupting it to suit their ends. ARXIV and the likes are the future of science. Where literal discord servers are getting together to publish studies. Yeah. Bunk gets published all the time, but peer review can just happen dynamically through good old regular unchecked skepticism. I would never in a billion years engage in the academic side of research. If I wanted to be a scientist I'd do it as a hobby, buying the tools to do it in my garage and publishing to open journals where ethics boards and bureaucrats cannot touch me beyond the reach of actual law. In all hopes, academia will start to crumble and this sort of garage philosophy will grow into a network of people that replaces it with a fresher and more dynamic outlook.
- tptacek 3y agoI've heard a lot of complaints from a lot of different people working in lab science (in my case, my interest was in bio & chem) and none of them were about "tightly walled journals" (working academic researchers generally have institutional access, and when the logins are annoying to manage they just sci-hub like everyone else) or IRBs. Rather, it was very basic stuff, like being told to come in at 5:30AM to feed a cell line only to have the PI show up at 2PM, throw the experiment in the garbage, threaten the student's livelihood, and then demand they stay until 11:30PM redoing the experiment. Over and over again, at random intervals. I asked around about this stuff because a family member now works in the field and had some startling experiences, only to find that this is apparently almost universal, and that what I'm describing is on the lighter end of it. There are stories about labs at elite universities where the grad students have set up secluded spaces to go hide from their PIs and cry. It's everything you've heard about working as a developer at a video game company, dialed up to 11.
- ProjectArcturis 3y agoFundamentally, the research industry requires continuous exponential growth to accommodate everyone working there. Each PI trains 10+ grad students in their career. Where do those students go? They all want to become PIs themselves. Otherwise why would they get a PhD? Ultimately the majority must be disappointed and leave for positions outside academia. But leaving academia is a process that takes some time. First cognitively as you give up on your dreams and decide to leave. Then as you search for a new job with no real-world experience and few or no connections. In the mean time, the pipeline between grad school and professorship gets longer and fuller. Postdocs were once extremely prestigious positions, a sort of "finishing school" for the elite. Now they're standard, and most people need to do more than 1. In practice it's a holding pattern, giving PhDs something to do while they try to struggle to the top of the heap and find an assistant professorship. And the actual experience of a postdoc! Leave all your friends and move to a new city. Work 60 hours a week for $45k a year. Have the rest of your career controlled by your PI, who you maybe met a few times before you decided to work for them, who has never had any kind of management training, and is under their own severe pressure to publish and bring in new grants. Compete against other brilliant, driven people, many of whom are abusing stimulants, and/or are immigrants with no safety net and willing to work 80+ hours. How could this system NOT create a mental health crisis?
- tptacek 3y agoIn biochem, the norm is for people who intend to work seriously in the industry to go to grad school; that is, academic research in that field is not a competition for a tiny number of academic jobs. But bio and chem have two of the worst reputations for academic research culture.
- dv_dt 3y agoI wonder if there is a filtering effect here where people who have relatively better soft skills and technical knowledge move into industry, and what we are seeing in academic circles is biased to what the industry declined.
- 3y ago
- mtriassi 3y agoThis makes me wonder how much of this is because research typically happens in an academic setting versus this just being the nature of research. I wonder if researches from private companies feel the same woes. If so, its probably just the nature of, like others have mentioned, a deliverable / outcome based jobs. I'd imagine (and hope), that at the very least they're paid better and have more resources available to them.
- jamesash 3y agoAn early stage lab has a lot in common with a startup. The PI is given seed money to validate an ambitious idea and has limited time and resources to do it. The work is extremely labor intensive and in the early stages the PI will be in the trenches with the early employees working in the lab and setting an example for them to follow. Fast failure and pivots are extremely common. Furthermore, at any time the research idea could get scooped by another hard-working research lab, resulting in publication in a lower-tier journal. The PI must get early results that can be used to obtain further research grants. A good PI in this situation will set expectations accordingly that 60+ hour weeks will be required and hopefully those who are not willing to do so will self-deselect. From their perspective I completely not understand not wanting to invest $50k/year of their startup funds in a graduate student who is not putting in the necessary time to succeed. The prospective graduate student's maximum power is at the time when they are choosing a research advisor. Choose wisely, and remember you are always free to choose not to go if you don't see a good situation. I advise that people think long and hard about whether or not they truly want to do graduate school. There are far better ways to spend your 20's than in a lab. I had two great experiences in "intense" labs in my field (organic chemistry) after a very poor experience with a prestigious but absentee graduate advisor in another field - but it is definitely not for everyone.
- BeetleB 3y ago> An early stage lab has a lot in common with a startup. The problem is you also see this behavior in well established lab, where the PI has very little to lose if he quits research altogether. In my experience, the correlation with whether the professor was an assistant professor seeking tenure vs a well established full professor and the amount of work they make PhD students do is almost nil. It's mostly purely driven by the will of the PI, not the demands of the funding situation. A lot of professors choose to have few graduate students so they don't have to stress too much about funding. Remember: Once you get tenure, your job is not at risk if your research output is low (although it does affect compensation). If you get a $1M grant and end up with no research papers out of it, there is no accountability - except the granting agency will deprioritize you in the future (if even that). If you're seeking an advisor, ask his/her current students what life is like. Also find people who graduated under him/her and ask them.
- whatever31337 3y ago[flagged]
- xbar 3y agoScience is hard, viciously competitive, and deeply cruel in all ways in order for some to win. Cheating, plagiarism, racism, sexual harassment, theft of ideas, publishing spam, .... Everything is in play in this game. Calling it "culture" and laying some "blame" is a convenient "we're the worst off subset of victims; it's not us, it's them" perspective but it will neither solve the problem nor address the actual condition--science is not a utopian island that is separate from big business economics, university branding and wealth, nor from geopolitics. Scientists have not figured out how to organize as well as any of those entities and will continue to be subjugated to their game and their system. When that is solved, the tools that abusers within the scientific community use against each other are more easily addressed. Perhaps in the meantime we can pass some more laws that that make it seem like we care, but the existing regulations that make racism/ageism/sexism/abuse illegal are not currently effective. But to be clear: we don't care. We fought as hard as we could to win at that game and we raise our kids to try to win at that game. MIT, Stanford, Harvard, Cal, Michigan, Texas, Wisconsin, <insert your personal alma mater for which you have pride in its research capabilities>: you wanted to get in; maybe you did; you will desire for your kids to get in; they probably won't. The patents and rights of science and research are in the hands of someone who is not doing the work.
- pelasaco 3y agoyay more laws!
- nr2x 3y agoIt won’t change until people quit. I did, I’m making way more money, way less stress, and I have no regrets.
- AlbertCory 3y agoRather than focusing on research, we should look at "careers that are considered prestigious or rewarding in themselves" : fashion, entertainment, sports, medicine, tenured teaching. In all of those, there are more applicants than there are jobs. Hence, lousy salaries and poor treatment. On the other hand, jobs that won't impress anyone you meet tend to have fewer applicants and much better treatment, because they can't afford to drive people away.
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoI know a very intelligent woman: graduated in 4 years having a 4.0 with a double major in CS and Chemistry. She was extremely gung-ho about going to university and achieving her PhD, and I naively believed at the time that she'd have no trouble accomplishing her goals. Enter competitive research academia. She felt constantly defeated by classmates and advisors who seemed to be working against her at every turn. One advisor, whom she trusted, moved to take a job with another university. She followed in the hope that she could shed the toxicity of the current working environment. Turns out that the new place was just as toxic. She finished with a 4.0 through grad school but never defended the dissertation due to burnout, tired of the constant struggle for resources, attention, and just plain basic humanity. She now has a subservient role to PhDs she could run circles around intellectually.
- autokad 3y agoI worked in a research lab at a university for 10 years. It was grant funded, so my position could get canceled at any time, but so is working at at a private company. While the pay was about half of what I made a year after leaving and working at private companies, working in the research lab was WAAAAAAY easier.
- contemporary343 3y agoSpeaking as a tenured PI in the (applied) physical sciences, everything here is true but a lot of it boils down to a lack of perspective and imagination by many faculty running labs. There are many positive examples out there of ensuring student career success in a supportive lab environment while also producing good research. These need to be amplified as role models.
- Balgair 3y agoCare to share some of those examples?
- golemotron 3y agoIf true, the terrible thing is that it is traumatic to even study this. There's no winning this one.
- LetThereBeLight 3y agoA large issue is that PIs have no training on how to manage people nor is there much protection for grad students (and practically none for postdocs). It is surprisingly common to hear stories of sexual harassment, or international researchers essentially being held captive by their advisors. The universities are motivated to maintain their public appearance, and so cases of harassment and mistreatment are either entirely ignored or dealt with quietly. This, in addition to pay issues, is also playing a significant role in the unionization efforts that are taking place across US universities.
- pfdietz 3y agoScientists are exploited the same way game developers are exploited: their love for the area, and the intangible rewards they get from working in it, are used to depress wages and benefits.
- dbcooper 3y agoThis song sums up how awful most lab careers are better than any articles that I am aware of: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q_bB3LBYG6E&list=RDQ_bB3LBYG6E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q_bB3LBYG6E&list=RDQ_bB3LBYG... "You halted the march of progress."
- tourgen 3y ago[dead]
- jdlyga 3y agoI grew up in a family of scientists and professors. It's really disheartening to see how much trouble it is to make a living nowadays. My grandfather was an entomology professor, and was able to support a wife, 3 kids, and a nice house though they were no means wealthy. If you can't support yourself or a family in 2023 working in academia, why would anyone pursue it as a career?
- baja_blast 3y agoAnd this will lead to the a stagnation of science if the best and brightest disincentivized from participating.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoNo, the science will take place in private companies, and the result is they will have even more control over society than before. Think of all the psychology employed at social media companies to get people hooked on social media, whatever the cost - even if the cost was functioning society itself.
- syngrog66 3y agoMy understanding is that there's been a big rise in mental illness, anxiety and stress in general, over the last 10 yeats or so. And its true across professions, ages, race, gender or sexuality. A lot of factors pushing for it: 1. the general madness and chaos of the Trump presidency ("When I wake up in the morning will I learn Trump has launched nukes at North Korea? Or vice versa?" etc etc, ad nauseum for 4 years) 2. COVID lockdowns and economic swings 3. apparent explosive rise in gun mass shootings -- "Will I or my loved ones be next?" 4. social media's toxic effect on peace of mind, in general 5. active efforts by various actors to spread lies, sow tensions and trigger violence (eg. stochastic terrorism) 6. carbon climate crisis... a biggie Therefore I've been building a sci-fi post-apoc, educational game lately [SB: see below] which happens to take as its premises that: 7. humanity (or at least the US) fails to save democracy 8. humanity fails to act boldly enough or fast enough to save us from the worst of climate change's most dystopic effects 9. and therefore, due to all of above, there's a yet further MASSIVE rise in mental health disorders (all the way up to full blown de facto "insanity") -- eg. like many of the survivors you see in the Mad Max films From a purely entertainment standpoint I loved watching films like Idiocracy and Mad Max Fury Road. As a person in the real world and a patriotic citizen I don't want to see us descend to that level of insanity, struggle and suffering. Our existing mental health systems are already inadequate today. If we start losing more doctors, nurses & therapists to anxiety/depression or over-work fatigue (speaking in broad terms), and also scientists, engineers, teachers, etc, then it will get MUCH worse. ---- [SB] - https://synystrongames.itch.io/slartboz https://synystrongames.itch.io/slartboz
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoPeople who understand that collapse is inevitable are generally more depressed, yes.
- wat_do_phd_923 3y agoThis isn't even remotely surprising. I'm a current PhD student in a coveted top-3 program. We have one of the better stipends in the country, and I've been fully funded by fellowships. My advisor thinks highly of me and isn't abusive. I have a perfect GPA (not that that matters), some publications, and pretty broad technical skills in "hot" area(s). Nevertheless, graduation feels hopelessly out of reach, and I'm getting closer and closer to dropping out. Academia is full of cronyism, perverse incentives, idea theft. Never mind work-life balance, there is no distinction whatsoever between work and life. There's no "out" if you're in a bad situation; you can't just change jobs like in the real world; your advisor is your "third parent". The incentive structures make it nearly impossible to meaningfully collaborate without some petty authorship conflict arising. It's isolating and seemingly designed to create unhappy, atomized, paranoid, jealous, mean-competitive people. At the end, there is ultimately no reward, materially speaking: all but the very tippy-top academic job tracks are no better. Academia's clerical heritage is not its only monastic quality. I'm on the wrong side of my 20s and still living in a tiny, crappy apartment with a roommate. At this point I implicitly believe I will never get close to owning a home. That a family is out of the question. That the future is always worse than the present. I've gradually turned into a learned-helplessness "sorry I exist" person, without ever noticing. Suddenly I see how pathetic that is. I'm ready to change back. I'm ready to be optimistic and ambitious and self-confident again. I'm ready to live a life of improvement, not stagnation. I'm ready to build something meaningful. Not to mention, my eyes are finally opening to how much I could be making in industry if only I hadn't been so proud/idealistic/willfully ignorant... And how much better that kind of salary can make your life. For the right offer, I am so ready to break free (DMs open (just kidding (but actually though))).
- naijaboiler 3y agotake your masters and run. go into the real world and get a job. your paycheck, mental health, future family will all thank you
- xupybd 3y agoI've noticed that the smarter and more academic people in my life are more prone to anxiety and depression. I've often wondered if there is a cause behind that correlation or just a random coincidence amongst the people I know. I guess this could account for some of that.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoHigh school-to-college pipelines need to be improved in many areas. The undergraduate pipeline is failing in gender overall: ~60% women + ~40% men. Universities that gender rebalance effectively make it harder for women to get in and easier for men. STEM (except biology and nursing) is bad at attracting women, with computer science and electrical engineering being possibly the most imbalanced fields compared to psychology and nursing at the other extremes. There's nothing wrong with individual major overall preferences but there is a problem when 2x the number of women are being educated than men. That's a strategic human capital loss and likely signals future underemployment. Phil Zimbardo (Stanford Prison Experiment and community college lecturer by telecourses broadcasted by KCSM) wrote a number of books and gives a TED talk on this subject. Prescriptive formulas at the point of college entrance isn't the correct place to apply pressures. Mentoring, programs, resources, and subject public relations need to happen where there is great need and especially in areas with fewer resources.
- a_bonobo 3y agoI quit my research career for exactly this; I was close to burnout. I left the academic sector because I realised it's internationally toxic; there's no solidarity among academics. They'll can your grant application, they'll trash your paper during peer review, for absolutely zero personal gain. Every aspect of research work is awful: ridiculously little funding, a parasitic publishing system outsourcing all of its labor to us (unpaid), overloaded teaching, universities' ballooning middle management inventing new hoops every week, endless unpaid labor in the name of 'academic service', low salary, endless pressure. Burn it all down.
- winderxxx 3y agoI know and can recommend a very efficient and trustworthy hacker. I got his email address on Quora, he is very nice and he has helped me a couple of times even helped clear some discrepancies in my account at a very affordable price. he offers a top notch service and I am really glad I contacted him. He's the right person you need to talk to if you want to retrieve your deleted/old texts, call logs, emails, photos and also hack any of your spouse's social network account facebook,instagram, telegram, tiktok,messenger chat, snapchat and whatsapp, He offers a legit and wide range of hacking services. His charges are affordable and reliable, This is my way of showing appreciation for a job well done. contact him for help via address below.. Email : cybermeniac @ gmail com