4 ms·
The drop in 2020 seems to corralate with the Visa Renewal backlog that began during the pandemic. I know a lot of very technically adept Chinese+Indian research
by alephnerd 4y ago
The drop in 2020 seems to corralate with the Visa Renewal backlog that began during the pandemic. I know a lot of very technically adept Chinese+Indian researchers who ended up taking positions back in top Chinese and Indian Universities+Companies+Govt Labs due to this.
Edit:
Digging deeper, it looks like Nature treats the Chinese Academy of Sciences (the Chinese version of US DoE National Labs) as a single institution.
I'd be curious how the US stacks up if National Lab affiliation was included in the same manner. Lots of R&D done by National Lab researchers are affiliated only with their Lab, not a university.
Also a lot of naturalized American academics can also get Chinese Academy of Sciences affiliation due to the murkiness of Chinese nationality renunciation, so that might muddy it further (eg. If I'm an academic at Harvard University with an affiliation to the CAS, which relationship does the Nature Index treat as the primary?)
Edit 2: from the Nature Index itself
"For authors who are affiliated with more than one institution, the author’s Share is split equally between each institution. The total Share for an institution is calculated by summing the Share for individual affiliated authors."
So, if a researcher at Harvard or MIT or Cal is also cross affiliated with the CAS or Tsinghua, their research output would be split equally, even if the relationship is an adjunct one with one or the other.
This sounds like the same kind of statistical gaming NUS and NTU in Singapore and KAUST in Saudi Arabia are famous for to climb up global university rankings.
- nine_zeros 4y agoOnce we step out of the American bubble, it is very clear that American research is top notch, but other countries have basically caught up. America just doesn't attract (or retain) the best. Opportunities are quite high in other countries for them to consider American immigration nonsense.
- alephnerd 4y ago> it is very clear that American research is top notch, but other countries have basically caught up. I agree. The last time we've seen a similar parity in R&D capacity was probably the 1950s-1960s. That said, a lot of discourse around geopolitical rivalries is kind of stuck in a pre-1990s mindset. Even at its worst, countries with actual military disputes continue to be closely economically connected and (excluding Russia over the past year) we haven't seen the kind of economic decoupling that we saw in the 1970s-90s globally. So long as nations globally maintain diplomatic contact and continue to be connected via diasporas and economic relations, there is always an off-ramp for political disputes. P.S. Do NOT quote Russia as a counter example to my final example. Russia has been under severe EU+USA sanctions since 2014. The only difference is that these sanctions did not extend to Belarus until 2022, which was used as a backdoor to maintain EU-Russia economic relations.
- coliveira 4y agoI would say that the decoupling has been more from the side of US/Europe than the rest of the world. Asia, Africa and South America are becoming more strongly connected. That's why the Russian sanction didn't work (and won't work in the future).
- warning26 4y ago> Opportunities are quite high in other countries for them to consider American immigration nonsense. I find it utterly baffling that the US is in a position to easily absorb the best and brightest from other countries, and yet shoots itself in the foot with ridiculously restrictive immigration policies.
- alephnerd 4y agoI agree as well. Sadly, neither side wants to negotiate. On the Federal Dems side reform on skilled immigration needs to also be lumped with undocumented immigrant reform, and on the Federal GOP side due to some semblance of racism plus opposition to negotiating over undocumented immigration. I sadly speak from experience working on this. Silver lining, just about every other country sucks as skilled immigration as well. But on the negative side, skilled professionals in Israel+India+PRC+SK+ASEAN increasingly prefer to stay put over being in immigration limbo. [0] - https://www.politico.com/story/2013/12/nancy-pelosi-immigration-reform-101014 https://www.politico.com/story/2013/12/nancy-pelosi-immigrat...
- nine_zeros 4y agoIt is so strange. The decline in competitiveness is so obvious. American cars can't compete with Asian or German cars. No engineers. American homes aren't built for efficiency. No engineers. American semiconductor and hardware tech is powered by immigrants. If/When they leave because of backlogged immigration, the companies will see more competition. Already America is resorting to sanctioning Chinese semi companies because American companies can't compete. American software industry is powered by h1b slaves who can get deported by BS American laws themselves. America is out of doctors and nurses too. The only thing America succeeds at is financial engineering and management enriching itself. Baffling!
- SoftTalker 4y agoAmerican cars were never that good, always built to a price. Nothing to do with engineering competency.
- 4y ago
- TMWNN 4y ago>America just doesn't attract (or retain) the best. Opportunities are quite high in other countries for them to consider American immigration nonsense. In a survey of scientists from 16 countries <http://spectrum.ieee.org/at-work/tech-careers/the-global-brain-trade http://spectrum.ieee.org/at-work/tech-careers/the-global-bra...>, the US is the top destination from 13 of the 15 others and the #2 choice from the other two. If you are a Canadian scientist, there is a 16% chance <https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/37lgxg/the_global_brain_trade/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/37lgxg/the...> that you will move to the US. That's not "16% of all Canadian scientists that move out of the country move to the US". Let me repeat: 16% of all Canadian scientists move to the US. They're also likely to be among the top Canadian scientists, too.
- dirtyid 4y agoAmerica still brain drains best, issue is really PRC talent production so great post academic reforms that limits of US immigration / global brain drain efforts is losing competitiveness to sheer numbers that stay in PRC.
- lo_zamoyski 4y agoWhile Visa renewal and the others mentioned may have been an immediate cause, I wouldn't be surprised by a general downward trend in observed American dominance (all other things remaining the same). The incentives to leave China and come to the US must be shrinking.
- throwaway2990 4y agoThere’s prob more people leaving China or trying to now than ever before.
- coliveira 4y agoNot true, lots of talented people are going to China, specially the young. They're doing a good job of attracting people from the global south. This happens while the USA is making immigration more difficult.
- throwaway2990 4y agoThen why is there an exodus of people immigrating to Canada uk Australia. Increase in purchases of homes in other parts of Asia. Increase in visa applications for America well over pre pandemic levels?
- dirtyid 4y agoWhose leaving? Folks with black money trying to park abroad because they know CCP can crack down vs safety of parking wealth in western housing where dysfunctional politics and entrenched interests won't go after real estate. Meanwhile actual top tier talent being retained and even returning because more opportunities in PRC than ever. They're the ones pushing PRC up these indexes. Even PRC students who go abroad aren't cream of crop anymore, many just have wealthy enough parents who know their kids won't make it in PRC, aka the bench team. Who still do good enough work to fill up space in US / western institutions.
- 4y ago
- bigcat12345678 4y agoAcademy of science is not doe labs Chinese gov have affiliated labs like doe national labs Academy of science has its own graduate school and professor ranks
- alephnerd 4y agoUSTC and UCAS are treated as separate entities in the Nature Index
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoUCAS ranks just behind Qinghua and PKU, but has 54k post graduates compared to around 18-28K in each of the former. So it is really a lot farther behind those two top institutions than it appears on paper, not as impressive when you realize how much staff they have.
- alephnerd 3y agoUCAS and USTC are holdovers from the Communist era, when a nation's Academy of Sciences would also include graduate education (eg. In the former Soviet Union). In the present day, the CAS includes national labs (to use a CN to US comparison), USTC, and UCAS. Being affiliated to CAS doesn't necessarily mean affiliation to UCAS or USTC, hence why you will see researchers from Tsinghua or SJTU affiliated with CAS.
- eunos 4y agoSeems "Academy of Sciences" is a legacy of communist country. IIRC lots of Warsaw pact scientists did their grad program at their respective Academy of Science.
- yeknoda 4y agowhatever you need to cope
- throwawayfd 4y agoI know people who don't want to pray for their kids safety in school. Violence isn't gonna come down unless mental health problem and fun couture changed which is very unlikely to happen.
- coliveira 4y agoNo, this is just expected, China has many more researchers (and will have even more in the future) than the US. Also, US is imposing visa restrictions, while China is attracting talent from other countries. Finally, US is investing only a fraction of what it should do in applied research.
- vkou 4y agoFollow the money, and the prestige. There's no money or prestige for going into academia in the US - quite the opposite, in fact. Unsurprisingly, this is not a winning formula for getting research done.
- eunos 4y agoSimilar practice to CNRS and Max Planck Institute.