10 ms·
Jeff Bezos announces $3.4B NASA contract to land astronauts on lunar surface
- wpasc 3y agoBlue Origin hasn't been to orbit yet right? If that is still the case, pretty wild contract to land.
- verdverm 3y agoNone of the contracted next moon landers have been to space yet
- dmoy 3y agoI think the question is, "has Blue Origin gotten anything into orbit?" (I don't know the answer, I think as of a couple years ago it was still "no", but then I stopped paying attention)
- ta1243 3y agoLanding is easy, every BO rocket has landed
- qgin 3y ago> According to Blue Origin's lunar lander head John Couluris, Blue Origin privately contributed 'well north' of the contract's $3.4 billion payout. Seems like the NASA award is only is only paying for some minority of the total cost.
- idlewords 3y agoThey've been to orbit the same number of times as Starship
- mrguyorama 3y agoAnd hundreds of fewer times than SpaceX as a whole. Surely a group who has actually been in space has more experience than a team that has launched a small dick rocket 80 miles up?
- jjk166 3y agoThis is a contract for a lander, it gets into Earth orbit on someone else's rocket.
- panick21_ 3y agoPretty sure their concept depends on New Glenn.
- panick21_ 3y agoAs usual SpaceX gets less money for more effort. And the three companies known for performing badly get the second contract.
- giarc 3y ago[flagged]
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- yinser 3y agoDo you want to share some evidence that that has anything to do with the federal government's decision to choose Blue Origin? Or do you want to omit you're opining without any evidence?
- alistairSH 3y agoUh, SpaceX already has a contract. They weren't part of this.
- Robotbeat 3y agoExactly. So Blue Origin winning has nothing to do with Musk running his mouth.
- giarc 3y agoYou know there is no way to provide that evidence. And therefore I think it's obviously to any reasonable reader that it's an opinion.
- yinser 3y ago[flagged]
- tectonic 3y agoActual press release: https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-selects-blue-origin-as-second-artemis-lunar-lander-provider https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-selects-blue-origin-... NASA needs multiple lander options; putting all their cards on a lunar Starship landing was always a bit ridiculous, even if it seems reasonably likely to happen. So if you want the Artemis program to actually succeed, this is likely a good thing. However, with Congress in a deadlock around the debt ceiling, and SLS costing $4B per launch, this is only going to add to Artemis's serious funding challenges. If you're interested in the space industry in general, I'll cover this more next week in the weekly Orbital Index newsletter (https://orbitalindex.com https://orbitalindex.com) which I co-author with blach.
- samwillis 3y agoExactly, and if we (well you, I'm British) do get them on the moon with the intention of a permanent base, you absolutely want two landing options. If one is found to have a fatal flaw and people are stuck, you need an alternative. On top of that, this is about promoting investment into infrastructure and vehicles that may one day take us to Mars, you can't just encourage one company to develop that. There needs to be a whole ecosystem of competing companies, we don't want a SpaceX monopoly.
- eastbound 3y ago> On top of that, this is about promoting investment into infrastructure Gosh, I wish USA had access to potable tap water. Having less than 20 hours of electricity a day in winter is also a problem.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chrisco255 3y ago> If one is found to have a fatal flaw and people are stuck, you need an alternative. That's why you test the hell out of one good one before you ever put humans in one. We didn't have alternatives for the Apollo missions. Failure just wasn't an option.
- lreeves 3y agoHopefully to bring them back, too.
- krisroadruck 3y agoI mean they did say they were going to the moon to stay... maybe they meant it more literally than we're reading it ;-)
- oldstrangers 3y agoNASA handing out money the same way VCs do. No product or proven success, here's a billion.
- ProAm 3y agoWhen you are in an arms race with other countries it's okay to have more than one horse.
- wmf 3y agoNASA only received three bids and one failed to meet the requirements. They're in a "beggars can't be choosers" situation.
- jjk166 3y agoNASA's entire mandate is to develop new technologies and do things that haven't been done before. If you could just order a lunar lander off Amazon, what would be the point?
- oldstrangers 3y agoJust a little humor.
- panick21_ 3y agoThis is a fixed cost payment based on milestones. Maybe next time actually inform yourself before spouting nonsense.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoGiven the context, either Bezos must have given some pretty amazing guaranty, like killer late fees and refund if you don't get to the moon, or and offered something politically important outside of this deal entirely.
- wmf 3y agoNah, NASA wants two landers and very few companies are willing to build them.
- danielbln 3y ago$3.4B seems.. cheap, considering they don't even have a proper launch vehicle yet? What's the catch?
- wmf 3y agoThe actual cost is $7B or more but NASA isn't paying for it.
- bell-cot 3y agoAny informed guesses as to how much NASA money Jeff would actually net if he fails to deliver?
- lesuorac 3y ago> The SEP also reviewed Blue Origin’s pricing for advance payments and concluded that it did not propose any advance payments. I'm guessing none. Unless NASA has a creative definition for advance payments.
- Robotbeat 3y agoNegative. It’s pay for performance, and Blue is already pitching in more money to help fund it than the contract is worth. So negative money. That’s the advantage of commercial contracting as opposed to cost-plus contracting. A lot of idiotic takes on private spaceflight have this completely backwards.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThere are milestone payments. So even if they fail to get to the moon, if they meet some of the other milestones they'll get some of the money from the contract. But not enough to turn a profit either way.
- lenova 3y agoSounds like Bezos just finished season 1 of For All Mankind...
- lesuorac 3y agoThe "Source Selection Statement" from the May 19th entry has NASA opinion. https://www.nasa.gov/nextstep/humanlander4 https://www.nasa.gov/nextstep/humanlander4
- kennywinker 3y agoOh great - more private space exploration funding by public money. Instead of the people owning the tech at the end of spending 3.4bil, jeff owns it. Boo.
- ivalm 3y agoPublic funding of space flight led to mediocre results. And the tech still subcontracted/built/owned by Boeing/ULA folks.
- mmanfrin 3y ago> Public funding of space flight led to mediocre results Is this bait? Public funding of space flight lead to spaceflight and landing on the moon.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoAnd then stagnated for decades when an administration with no interest beyond LEO came into power, which was exacerbated further by each following administration changing NASA's direction, preventing any kind of sustained focus. That's the problem with publicly funded spaceflight: it's subject to the whims of both politicians and public favor, meaning that if it doesn't happen within the span of a single favorable administration it's probably not going to happen. That's extremely limiting, because spaceflight (especially the crewed variety) is extremely difficult and operates on decadal timelines.
- dubcanada 3y agoI mean the same thing can be said about private companies being publicly funded?
- chasd00 3y agoin a way i suppose. Tesla being public almost killed teh entire company when the shorts came after them. SpaceX being (and remaining) private is probably 25% of the reason they're able to accomplish what they can accomplish. Imagine the stock price hit after the starship test, that would take so much time and effort to repair. Also, there's probably 100s of live cams all around Boca Chica spying and watching on every single test and weld. The stock price would fluctuate wildly based on what's happening on those cams. SpaceX remaining private is probably priority 1 on the financial side of things.
- samwillis 3y agoNASAs press release: https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-selects-blue-origin-as-second-artemis-lunar-lander-provider https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-selects-blue-origin-... Blue Origin press release: https://www.blueorigin.com/news/nasa-selects-blue-origin-for-mission-to-moon/ https://www.blueorigin.com/news/nasa-selects-blue-origin-for... Of all four submissions, it's the one from the Daily Mail that we vote to the homepage, how? https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=last24h&page=0&prefix=false&query=blue%20origin&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=last24h&page=0&prefix=fals...
- totallyagr33 3y agoMusk should launch from other countries. The world needs more competition, the US Government can't have the monopoly on decision making.
- chasd00 3y agoit would be funny to see a SpaceX flag planted on the moon first. SpaceX needs the FAA to launch but do they need anything else once in space? afaik anyone can do anything they want once up high enough. If it's SpaceX astronauts would they control their own human rating process too? If SpaceX has the money and tech SpaceX should just goto the moon themselves first.
- totallyagr33 3y agoThe reduced circle of Washington bureaucrats have too much control over the world. It's time to diversify. Using less the dollar, paying taxes in other jurisdictions, ignoring their sanctions, etc. Specially Europe should realize that hinging on the US at every step is not a realistic plan.
- idlewords 3y agoIt always seemed bonkers to me that Starship was selected as the moon lander when the first lunar mission will require five fuel transfers in orbit, a technology that has never been demonstrated, along with the ability to land a tall rocket vertically on lunar terrain. What was so terrible about the 1960's mission architecture? The chief goal of the Artemis program is to solve difficult bureaucratic problems at NASA. As an engineering or exploration program it makes no sense on the merits, and the sooner it dies the better.
- Robotbeat 3y agoThe 1960s architecture was not sustainable. Artemis is supposed to be sustainable, was supposed to have reusable landers, which implies refueling. So refueling as a technology was already something NASA desired. Starship is also about 50 times more capable than the Apollo LM. Artemis is also supposed to be preparing for Mars, which Apollo didn’t do. Artemis is also less well funded than Apollo. I’m not sure why Starship HLS gets the hate it does. It’s by far the best choice NASA could’ve made, and it’s cheap enough that NASA can select a second lander provider, allowing redundancy.
- idlewords 3y ago"Sustainability" is a bureaucratic requirement, not a technical requirement. The reason the mission architecture has been stuffed full of reusable components like Orion, Starship and the Gateway is to make one-off capital expenses into long-term operational expenses that are difficult to cut. This is the same reason important parts of the whole program are being farmed out to ESA. Starship gets hated on because it's vaporware being promoted by someone with a long track record of creative promise making across multiple fields of endeavor.
- Robotbeat 3y ago“Idlewords” indeed. No one with actual deep knowledge of the space industry thinks Starship is vaporware. SpaceX has been launching more stuff to orbit on Falcon than the rest of the planet combined, and virtually all on a mostly-reusable orbital rocket, the only one that is in operation today. They also have been the sole domestic provider for orbital crew launch in the US since Shuttle retired. This is not “empty promises.” Compare that to New Glenn, for instance, which is years behind schedule. The first orbital rocket from a company that was started before SpaceX.
- runesofdoom 3y agoTo stay on brand for Bezos, will be an exact copy of the SpaceX lander made in China?
- moffkalast 3y agoAmazonBasics Lander, overnight delivery
- putzdown 3y agoQuestion: what’s the financial endgame for these ventures? Is there some financial benefit (other than government spending) for going to the moon?
- bryanlarsen 3y agoBezos & Blue Origin's end game is to try and set up an industrial economy in space. It's a long game, Bezos does not expect to live long enough to see it. Bezos was heavily influenced by the work of Gerard O'Neill while at Princeton. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerard_K._O%27Neill#Space_colonization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerard_K._O%27Neill#Space_colo...
- shmde 3y agoI really hope the earth gets obliterated before any of that happens.
- shadowfox 3y agoCurious, what about that triggers your wish for mass extinction events?
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoSocialized suicidality
- photochemsyn 3y agoThis seems a bit odd in comparison to how the Apollo program worked with private contractors - each contractor was assigned a specific task, e.g. "Boeing was responsible for designing and producing the Command and Service Module", etc. https://apollo11space.com/apollo-program-and-private-companies/ https://apollo11space.com/apollo-program-and-private-compani... Generally the competition and the bid takes place before the awarding of the government contract, doesn't it? This is rather like having two companies build competing bridges and then deciding which one to use after both are built, or am I missing something? I suspect the Bezos lobbying machine had a hand in this decision: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/king-hill-how-amazon-jeff-bezos-made-washington-second-home-n1033296 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/king-hill-how... > "There are a lot of opportunities for influence once you get your own people insinuated into the elite clubs, schools, and other social venues in D.C."
- jvanderbot 3y agoOh now that SpaceX won we're back to asking for old school single-performer contracts and redundancy is bad?
- appointment 3y agoHaving two suppliers for critical services has been common practice where possible for NASA and USSF for quite some time now. Commercial Resupply (SpaceX and OSC/NG), Commercial Crew (SpaceX and Boeing), National Security Space Launch (SpaceX and ULA),
- ren_engineer 3y ago>quite some time not exactly an endorsement for NASA considering how little they've accomplished in recent decades. To me it makes sense to focus on funding the R/D "primitives" for space technology rather than funding essentially duplicate projects reinventing the wheel. That's what worked for Apollo, the new strategy has been a colossal failure and SpaceX alone has hiding a lot of NASA's flaws
- wmf 3y agoThis is rather like having two companies build competing bridges and then deciding which one to use after both are built, or am I missing something? If the bridges have a high chance of multi-year delays (ahem Starliner), that's exactly what you should do.
- MuffinFlavored 3y agoWhy are Elon Musk + Jeff Bezos + Richard Branson (billionaires) so fascinated with space?
- remir 3y agoSpace is going to be industrialized, sooner or later. Since it takes massive amount of capital to do so, you can pretty much limit this kind of thing to wealthy nations or multi-billionaires such as Musk, Bezos and Branson.
- MuffinFlavored 3y agoI think this is absolutely part of it, I was just trying to separate whether the correlation between being a billionaire and enjoying space for non-industrialization reasons is correlated
- anonporridge 3y agoBecause people who have successfully acquired massive amounts of wealth and power know full well that opening up access to space will yield more material and energy wealth than any previous leap human civilization has ever made. Small thinkers are satisfied keeping their imagination on Earth alone, but small thinkers don't lead massive leaps of prosperity.
- panick21_ 3y agoMusk: Inspired by having a backup for humanity on Mars, and an aspirational goal to motivate everybody Bezos: Space will be industrialized and earth will remain some kind of national park Richard Branson: He doesn't give a shit other then to self aggrandize himself further as far as I can tell.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThe coolest thing about this proposal IMO is that they plan on being able to keep the lander on the moon for a full lunar day/night cycle (aka, a month). That means extreme heat and extreme cold. Which is extremely difficult when you rely on liquid hydrogen which boils at -250C.
- sdfghswe 3y agoWell I would hope that NASA wouldn't trust their astronauts to someone as sloppy as Elon Musk. Hopefully they looked at how his self-driving statements compared vs reality, and noped outta there really fast.
- hersko 3y ago> Well I would hope that NASA wouldn't trust their astronauts to someone as sloppy as Elon Musk. They already do? SpaceX has been flying NASA astronauts for awhile already...
- sdfghswe 3y agoNo it hasn't?
- atonse 3y agoNot sure if you're actually trolling but will leave this here: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/spacex-dragon-launches-arrivals-and-departures/ https://www.nasa.gov/feature/spacex-dragon-launches-arrivals... It's so common, it's not even newsworthy anymore.
- sdfghswe 3y agoOh my, NASA is getting sloppy again :-( In the 80s standards declined and astronauts ended up dying. Afterwards NASA tightened up again. What you go a long time without accidents you forget the benefit of being meticulous with safety. I believe there's a name for this. You'll see, SpaceX is gonna get people killed, NASA is gonna commission an investigation, and find that NASA was sloppy by accepting SpaceX's sloppiness.
- panick21_ 3y agoIts pretty funny how you didn't know even the most basic thing about NASA. And then when somebody gave the most basic information you instantly jump to 'i know all about this and why it is bad'. Given that you didn't know SpaceX flew astronauts, it clearly you don't have the slightest clue about the standard for safety applied by NASA, how and why they work with SpaceX. You heard 'Musk' and jump to 'oh NASA is bad'.
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoDoes he even have a functioning rocket?
- krapp 3y agoLand a man on the moon? Preposterous, they'd sink right through the moon-dust!