3 ms·
Can't we have a constitutional law that always invalidates any law that is implemented in a way that goes against democratic principles?
by amelius 4y ago
Can't we have a constitutional law that always invalidates any law that is implemented in a way that goes against democratic principles?
- pjc50 4y agoThere's a very real problem that "make binding agreement with another country" and "total independence of the legislature" are incompatible. The most obvious one is external debt - see what happened when Argentina tried to legislate theirs away. If your country agrees not to make a law that has a certain effect, and then makes that law, it's breached international law. And for countries other than America that has negative consequences imposed by America.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoWhat is the proper way to handle a future legislature saying "who cares what our predecessors ratified? The populace changed its mind. Isn't democracy grand?"
- chii 4y ago> What is the proper way to handle a future legislature by force (ala an invasion), or by not ever dealing with said country again. A populous wanting to change their mind is not a reason to invalidate a treaty unilaterally - this sort of behaviour should be frowned upon. The process should be to renegotiate a new treaty that all parties to the treaty agree to.
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoThen it's a behavior that can only be gotten away with if said populace also has a stockpile of W80s and other H-bombs (and is flooded with guns and wannabe domestic terrorists)
- gostsamo 4y agoIf you define the democratic principals in the constitution, and define them as fundamental, then the constitutional court would consider any lesser law as unconstitutional.
- amelius 4y agoYes, but the people in favor of the law will just say that the senate approved of the law, and since they are democratically installed ...
- gostsamo 4y agoIt does not matter, it is the constitutional court who decides if the law is compatible with the constitution, not the senate. E.g. if in the constitution it is written that judges must be elected with a popular vote, the senate cannot adopt a law saying that it is a president's prerogative. The fact that both senate and president are democratically elected does not matter, because their legitimacy is given by the constitution and therefore they cannot override it. So, the constitution is a protection, however, you should define well what a "democratic principal" is and how to recognize if something is not part of it. The best way is to assert a list of unalienable rights like right of property, access to information, and right of privacy, such that no law could be adopted which goes against them. The government being democratic is only a secondary defense, and not very reliable should add. * fictional example
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoCuriously there was vehement argument at the time of the Bill of Rights, that enshrining a fixed list of rights might mean that no other rights could exist. Which is actually pretty close to what happened. E.g. the right to freedom of speech is generally not enforced except as the government itself will not enact laws to restrict it. Individuals, corporations are still free to censure other individuals. So we don't have freedom of speech in that sense. Thanks, Bill of Rights! So maybe not the 'best way' of ensuring rights.
- 4y ago